Re:Is it stealing to read by the light of your neighbour’s l...
by akomtu on Saturday November 20, 2021 @06:47PM
(#29292862)
Not giving back when you can is greed, not theft. But these days we encourage greed, so copyright owners had to frame greed as thef to make it punishable.
Re:Is it stealing to read by the light of your neighbour’s l...
by shukantpal on Sunday November 21, 2021 @10:47AM
(#29297025)
That's not the definition of greed.
Re:Is it stealing to read by the light of your neighbour’s l...
by onethought on Saturday November 20, 2021 @05:02PM
(#29292259)
But intellectual property isn’t a thing then.
Re:Is it stealing to read by the light of your neighbour’s l...
by akomtu on Saturday November 20, 2021 @06:45PM
(#29292848)
Using one metaphor, IP is not a thing, it's a fire: by its nature, when it creates more fire, the original fire does not diminish.
Re:Is it stealing to read by the light of your neighbour’s l...
by BeFlatXIII on Saturday November 20, 2021 @09:18PM
(#29293606)
I'm fine with that outcome.
Re:Is it stealing to read by the light of your neighbour’s l...
by onethought on Saturday November 20, 2021 @10:02PM
(#29293815)
Me too, but completely unwinds the software economic model. Licenses are meaningless, as would more broadly copyright.
Re:Is it stealing to read by the light of your neighbour’s l...
by Dylan16807 on Saturday November 20, 2021 @10:14PM
(#29293876)
A lot less than 'completely'. A big chunk of software is commissioned, and another big chunk of software is open source.
Re:Is it stealing to read by the light of your neighbour’s l...
by onethought on Sunday November 21, 2021 @05:55AM
(#29295407)
… a tiny chunk (by value).
Commissioned software Is a fraction of product/services protected by IP law.
Open source doesn’t really have an effective business model (and it doesn’t need one!)
Re:Is it stealing to read by the light of your neighbour’s l...
by Dylan16807 on Sunday November 21, 2021 @12:35PM
(#29298034)
So much software is in-house, and that's only part of commissioned software, are you sure it's a tiny chunk?
Re:Is it stealing to read by the light of your neighbour’s l...
by onethought on Sunday November 21, 2021 @04:20PM
(#29299848)
In house Software still rely on ip law. Try stealing Facebook’s source code and see what happens.
This applies to lamplight, and interestingly, can be applied to piracy as well: if you can honestly say you wouldn't have purchased the movie/software/music anyway, downloading it is not stealing.
As others have mentioned in the comments, this idea doesn't work for wifi: performance is inversely correlated with connected devices, making using your neighbor's wifi a case of "this one is benefitting and this one is losing".