News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by Apofis on Thursday November 18, 2021 @02:47PM (#29269553)
Just getting rid of first-past-the-post would do wonders for our country and by the looks of it approval voting is inferior to run-off voting by a mile.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:04PM (#29269757)
> by the looks of it approval voting is inferior to run-off voting by a mile.

I'm curious why you think this? I think exactly the opposite. RCV/IRV has major problems, especially for strong spoilers. They are also more difficult to tabulate and with the recent events of the last election the importance of ease to tabulate went up in my priority list (making me even question my preference of score over approval). In fact, IRV also favors extremists, which is something I really don't want.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by noahtallen on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:11PM (#29270626)
For more context, this post has some cool interactive features to explain the voting types: https://ncase.me/ballot/

Another problem with RCV is that it’s difficult to understand, at least when you get into the runoffs. That makes it harder for people to understand and trust the election system, which is also very important.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:22PM (#29270742)
I'm not too big of a fan of this site but it is nice. One thing I wanted to point out is the spoiler effect. Often we talk about it but similarly we generally only talk about a weak spoiler. So I wanted to show an example of a strong spoiler[0]. In this example Hexagon splits Triangles votes just by a little, but the sum of Triangle and Hex are larger than Square. But here IRV has Square winning but Approval has Hex winning.

This is one big issue for me with IRV vs Cardinal systems. Both handle _weak_ spoilers but IRV doesn't handle ''strong,, spoilers. Understanding that these are two different types of spoilers is really important. It is "Bernie vs Hillary" and "Cruz vs Trump." Even with IRV we'd still see the parties trying to prevent strong primary candidates from running independently because they could spoil the election. With cardinal methods (approval, score, star) this is far less of a concern and thus I think more democratic of an election. I honestly think we should be much more concerned with strong spoilers than weak spoilers (weak spoilers don't affect elections much anyways).

[0] https://imgur.com/a/vV15A7Z

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by noahtallen on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:31PM (#29270867)
I completely agree; I tend to like approval voting just because it is nearly as good as the other scoring methods while being very simple.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:08PM (#29271260)
Exactly. I say

STAR: 5, Score 4, approval 4, IRV 1, FPTP 1

It would be ranked in this order too, but there's more expressivity here than an ordinal system can provide.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by Apofis on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:12PM (#29271302)
Considering our present division, I have a big "spider-sense" tingle that approval voting will simply result in everyone just voting all blue or all red, that sounds like a bad deal to me. Run off voting would give moderates a good chance of putting the country right side up again.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Friday November 19, 2021 @02:10AM (#29274597)
> everyone just voting all blue or all red

FWIW, this already happens. That will also happen under any system. I'm not sure why you think IRV encourages moderates. It actually encourages extremist candidates which is why I'm particularly against it.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by madeofmeat on Saturday November 20, 2021 @12:09AM (#29285743)
"Everyone" doesn't vote all-red or all-blue. 30% vote all red, 30% all blue, and 40% stay home because there is never a sensible centrist candidate. Each of the 30% active voters then get mistaken for 50% of citizens.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by r00fus on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:40PM (#29270958)
All your assertions are actually complaints about our existing plurality voting system.

IRV/Approval/Borda/Condorcet voting systems all improve those factors. That they have some edge conditions that could be theoretically exploited belies that fact that plurality voting (ie, FPTP / one person one vote) is a complete train wreck for spoilers and favoring extreme voting.

No voting system is perfect (Arrow's impossibility theorem) but some are harder to exploit than others. Staying with a broken system because the proposed replacement isn't perfect is a poor justification.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by nitrogen on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:13PM (#29271313)
It looks like nobody's linked to this older visualization yet, so I will: http://zesty.ca/voting/sim/

The non-monotonicity shown there for instant runoff voting seems to be more undesirable than any downsides of approval voting.

IMO the point of elected representation is to be representative, not to elect specific people, so the possibility of a lesser known candidate winning over a major party's favorite candidate isn't a problem.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by clolege on Thursday November 18, 2021 @06:35PM (#29272004)
> No voting system is perfect (Arrow's impossibility theorem)

Arrow's impossibility theorem only says that no _ranked_ voting system is perfect, so it doesn't apply to cardinal methods such as Approval or Score.

> That they have some edge conditions that could be theoretically exploited belies that fact that plurality voting (ie, FPTP / one person one vote) is a complete train wreck for spoilers and favoring extreme voting.

I agree, but I think the nature of the exploitation should still be considered. For IRV, we would be introducing a dependence on unauditable voting machines to tabulate votes, which would make it harder to verify the integrity of future elections.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Friday November 19, 2021 @02:12AM (#29274612)
> Arrow's impossibility theorem only says that no _ranked_ voting system is perfect

I tend to not get into this fight because 1) it extends to cardinal systems with Gibbard's and 2) Arrow's is more about social choice than voting.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:04PM (#29271213)
Down below I actually give an example of IRV/RCV not solving a strong spoiler case. Clay has also written extensively on the subject matter so I'll defer to him. I'll especially defer to him on explaining how IRV actually encourages extremists.

I think the problem here is that people get caught up in VSE. I get it, that's what I was caught up in when I first started learning about this stuff. Then I had to really dig through strategic voting and spoilage. The nuance of the systems actually do make a very big difference in the outcomes.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by r00fus on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:10PM (#29271276)
I'd love to hear how our current electoral system is in any way preferable to RCV (or Star Voting for example).

Because for many municipalities, it's not whether they move to Approval vs. RCV or IRV or Star, etc - it's moving away from the dumpster fire of plurality voting.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by nitrogen on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:15PM (#29271338)
It seems likely that a given municipality will only have the political energy to change voting systems once. Given that, it would be preferable to move to something that isn't RCV/IRV in the first place.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Thursday November 18, 2021 @06:58PM (#29272196)
This is what we see historically
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by pxx on Thursday November 18, 2021 @03:38PM (#29270205)
I'd argue that instant-runoff is _worse than plurality_. It complicates the voting system, makes the wrong tradeoffs (lack of monotonicity is a very serious one), and I'd really like to hear more about why you think approval voting is worse than runoff (instant or otherwise).
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by cpeterso on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:14PM (#29270664)
IRV is also very hard to explain to average voters. Approval voting is easy to explain: you get to give a thumbs up or down to every candidate.

In a local mayoral election that used IRV, I've seen some candidates tell their supporters to vote for them in every slot. Either those candidates didn't understand IRV themselves, or they didn't want to try to explain IRV to their supporters.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by mjevans on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:30PM (#29270854)
I prefer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schulze_method

Though with a candidate modification: add 'none of them / no confidence' as a virtual candidate that can never be removed by the runoff processes. If 'NoT' is the winner then the entire election is thrown out and all of the candidates are banned from the re-run.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:06PM (#29271239)
Condorcet methods are also hard to explain to voters. The tabulation is rather complicated. At least in comparison to something like cardinal methods. In light of recent recounts I think this is a really important factor to consider. While Condorcet methods have the best VSE, they aren't winning by a huge margin. Besides, VSE isn't everything.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by ClayShentrup on Thursday November 25, 2021 @12:55PM (#29343404)
Condorcet methods perform, at best, only a little better than approval voting in computer simulations. And they have only ever been used in one US city (Marquette, MI) which shortly thereafter repealed it. And they are radically more complicated and unlikely to ever see the light of day.

https://electionscience.github.io/vse-sim/vse.html

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by dragonwriter on Thursday November 25, 2021 @01:07PM (#29343505)
> Condorcet methods perform, at best, only a little better than approval voting in computer simulations

Computer simulations pretty universally paper over the main problem with approval compared to any ranked-ballot (whether forced or unforced preference) methods by pretending that “approval” has a consistent, cross-voter meaning. (This is an even bigger problem with score-based methods than approval.)

Personally, for simplicity and good enough single winner methods, I prefer Bucklin which is both better than and simpler to explain than IRV, but more critically I prefer minimizing single-winner elections. 5-member legislative districts using a candidate-centric proportional method like STV or the method that has the same relationship to it as Bucklin as to IRV, which AFAIK isn't a named method, would be far superior to any possible system with single-member districts, and basically neutralize districting as a lever for partisan advantage.

Paramount executive elections with a parallel successor (e.g., US Presidential tickets, if they were directly elected, or state Gov/LtGov pairs) can even be made into phased single-winner systems to get some of the advantages of multiwinner systems (not proportionality, but you do get some ability to separate partisan and personal preference in the general election, and to thereby weaken incumbency advantage: basically, use any ranked ballots [0] single winner election for the top spot, eliminate the winner, and rerun the election on the same ballots with the same method for the constitutional successor.)

[0] while I am not partial to them, approval or score systems could be used to; simple FPTP fails because it mean those who voted for the top winner have no voice in the designated successor.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Friday November 19, 2021 @02:15AM (#29274633)
People are actually very familiar with cardinal systems. You have your 5 star ratings (score) for restaurants, apps, etc. You have your thumbs up/down on Netflix. "On a scale from 1 to 10 how do you feel about x" etc. I always see people say that cardinal systems are hard to explain but the fact is that we use systems similar to them on almost a daily basis. (At least the front end is the same)
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by Apofis on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:13PM (#29271316)
But I don't support every candidate I would vote for equally.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by Apofis on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:14PM (#29271328)
I don't support every candidate on the ballot equally because I believe every candidate's abilities to do the job vary. First choice, second choice, third choice is not hard to explain and I do not understand why some people think Americans have been lobotimized. NYC now has run off voting and it turned out marvelously, with Eric Adams being elected.

https://vote.nyc/page/ranked-choice-voting

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by troydavis on Friday November 19, 2021 @09:45AM (#29277667)
You might be interested in my answer in another thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29266519#29277580

I give an example from this year's Seattle primaries where RCV/IRV would have eliminated the candidate that most accurately reflects the electorate but Approval Voting would not have. That's not a trivial or rare situation, either, it's just such a simple race that it's easy to spot.