News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:22PM (#29270742)
I'm not too big of a fan of this site but it is nice. One thing I wanted to point out is the spoiler effect. Often we talk about it but similarly we generally only talk about a weak spoiler. So I wanted to show an example of a strong spoiler[0]. In this example Hexagon splits Triangles votes just by a little, but the sum of Triangle and Hex are larger than Square. But here IRV has Square winning but Approval has Hex winning.

This is one big issue for me with IRV vs Cardinal systems. Both handle _weak_ spoilers but IRV doesn't handle ''strong,, spoilers. Understanding that these are two different types of spoilers is really important. It is "Bernie vs Hillary" and "Cruz vs Trump." Even with IRV we'd still see the parties trying to prevent strong primary candidates from running independently because they could spoil the election. With cardinal methods (approval, score, star) this is far less of a concern and thus I think more democratic of an election. I honestly think we should be much more concerned with strong spoilers than weak spoilers (weak spoilers don't affect elections much anyways).

[0] https://imgur.com/a/vV15A7Z

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by noahtallen on Thursday November 18, 2021 @04:31PM (#29270867)
I completely agree; I tend to like approval voting just because it is nearly as good as the other scoring methods while being very simple.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:08PM (#29271260)
Exactly. I say

STAR: 5, Score 4, approval 4, IRV 1, FPTP 1

It would be ranked in this order too, but there's more expressivity here than an ordinal system can provide.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by Apofis on Thursday November 18, 2021 @05:12PM (#29271302)
Considering our present division, I have a big "spider-sense" tingle that approval voting will simply result in everyone just voting all blue or all red, that sounds like a bad deal to me. Run off voting would give moderates a good chance of putting the country right side up again.
Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by godelski on Friday November 19, 2021 @02:10AM (#29274597)
> everyone just voting all blue or all red

FWIW, this already happens. That will also happen under any system. I'm not sure why you think IRV encourages moderates. It actually encourages extremist candidates which is why I'm particularly against it.

Re:Seattle residents launch Approval Voting initiative for r... by madeofmeat on Saturday November 20, 2021 @12:09AM (#29285743)
"Everyone" doesn't vote all-red or all-blue. 30% vote all red, 30% all blue, and 40% stay home because there is never a sensible centrist candidate. Each of the 30% active voters then get mistaken for 50% of citizens.