For anyone else wondering: yes, this does make said right-handed (aka sterile) neutrinos a candidate for dark matter, assuming some of them are much heavier than their left-handed counter parts to account for the 'cold' properties of dark matter that we observe.
I'd be curious to hear more about this. What mechanism forces you to add right-handed partners? Is it some conservation property? Are calculations too difficult without them?
Maybe it's also not clear if there really is a difference between saying "right-handed neutrinos exist but are undetectable" and "right-handed neutrinos are fake particles added for ease of modeling".
Edit: Wikipedia also says
> The neutral-current Z^0 interaction can cause any two fermions in the standard model to deflect: Either particles or anti-particles, with any electric charge, and both left- and right-chirality, although the strength of the interaction differs.
So could right-handed neutrinos be detected this way?
A Dirac mass term (the kind used for all other Standard Model fermions) involves both left-handed and right-handed particles:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sterile_neutrino#Mass
So you can't have one without both. (BTW, the linked section says "there are no Dirac mass terms in the Standard Model's Lagrangian", but it should really say that the Dirac mass terms in the Standard Model Lagrangian arise as a consequence of the Higgs mechanism.)
> Wikipedia also says
I can't find that quote, but I guess it's about experimentally observed particles. It would not apply to a right-handed neutrino:
It's an approximation that helicity equals chirality (which is what matters for weak force interactions), but this approximation is pretty good for particles moving close to the speed of light (which neutrinos tend to do, due to their low mass)
The issue is though, right now the standard model is at least ambiguous in terms of the majorana mass term. If it ends up the neutrino gets its mass from only the "normal" mass term, then why doesn't it have a majorana mass term? There's no current symmetry that says there can't be a majorana mass? If the neutrino's majorana mass is zero, then you'd probably have to introduce a symmetry into the standard model that says majorana particles can't exist.
But if the neutrino does end up having a non-zero majorana mass term then that means the neutrino is a majorana particle, and can undergo lepton number violating processes (e.g. neutrinoless double beta decay). Again, that's new physics.
So no matter how you give the neutrino mass, you're gonna have to modify the standard model in some "significant" way to accommodate. Either by specifically saying majorana particles can't exist, or by allowing for lepton number violating processes.
Now you could say, well then it might the case that majorana particles don't exist b/c that would require lepton number violating processes, so I don't need to introduce a new symmetry, I can just take advantage of one that's already lying around. That might be a valid claim to make...I'm not sure. I think the issue with that comes down to the difference between lepton number a global vs accidental symmetry in the standard model.
I have heard it is plausible that Dark Matter is merely another particle that fits in the standard model. I've heard it plausible that Dark Energy is e.g. a WIMP or other new particle in the standard model. And, on more-matter-than-antimatter, I imagine _some_ explanations of baryon asymmetry could come from outside the standard model but others (boundary condition, mirror anti-universe) would be fully standard-model-compatible, right?
That would leave only #5 as a mystery: Why is gravity as we know it in general relativity so different (weaker) than the force that a standard-model graviton would predict?
Whoever told you that was getting dark matter and dark energy mixed up.
Dark matter could be "another particle", possibly a sterile neutrino:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sterile_neutrino#Sterile_neutr...
Dark energy however is definitely something else. WIMPs in particular are hypothetical dark matter particles:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weakly_interacting_massive_par...
And if so, then I have two questions.
1. Antiparticles don't participate in the weak force? So if I had antimatter, and I made a nucleus of some kind, then it couldn't beta decay? If so, does this say anything about the matter/antimatter asymmetry in the universe?
2. At various times, I have seen references to anti-neutrinos. They seemed to say that what made them "anti" was simply that the spin was in the opposite direction relative to the direction of motion compared to a "regular" neutrino. Were they wrong? And if they were right, what about the direction of spin should make them unable to participate in the weak force?
No, it's about chirality:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wu_experiment
In theoretical terms, the equation used to describe all massive fermions known at the time (like the electron) is built out of four-component quantities called Dirac spinors:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirac_spinor
A Dirac spinor can be viewed as composed of two simpler, two-component quantities called Weyl spinors:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weyl_equation#Weyl_spinors
You can try to describe a fermion using only one Weyl spinor, but then it turns out that you can't build mass terms (unless you're willing to violate special relativity).
The massless equation you can write down with a Weyl spinor has two plane wave solutions with opposite helicity, left and right. A Dirac spinor combines a left-handed and a right-handed Weyl spinor; the mass term of the Dirac equation "mixes" them, in the sense that if you start out with a Dirac spinor having its left-handed component set to 0, the mass term will cause it to grow at a rate proportional to mass. If you set the mass to exactly zero, you're left with two uncoupled Weyl equations, one for the left-handed component, one for the right-handed one.
Knowing this, and faced with the experimental fact that weak interactions make a distinction between left and right, you write down separate weak interaction terms for the left- and right-handed components of your Dirac spinors. Eventually it turns out that the simplest choice, having only the left-handed components participate in those interactions, is the best fit to experiment:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weak_isospin#Relation_with_chi...
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
So, returning to a previous question: If I understand this correctly, it means that if we have a kind of nucleus that undergoes beta decay, and we built the exact same nucleus except out of antimatter, it would not undergo beta decay. Is that correct?
Has anyone actually done that experiment? Or is it beyond our ability to construct things out of antimatter?
No. Until 1964 you would have been told that applying CP, i.e. the combination of C transformation (charge conjugation, i.e. change the signs of all charges) and P transformation (parity, i.e. swap left and right) would result in exactly the same decay rate. You would get anti-neutrinos (which are right-handed) instead of neutrinos, but that would be the only difference.
Then it turned out that CP symmetry is also violated by weak interactions, though far from as neatly as just P:
I thought you said that going to antimatter meant that you reversed chirality, and that right-handed chirality meant that a particle did not take part in the weak interaction. I interpreted that to mean that it didn't take part at all, not with any probability. But the CP violation article seems to be saying that CP violation is a matter of differences in probabilities.
By the way, that article talks about anti-neutrinos, which from your initial post, I thought you were saying were impossible to detect if they existed?
I'm confused... can you make any of this clearer? I'm mis-understanding something - can you tell what?
- left-handed electron
- right-handed electron
- left-handed anti-electron
- right-handed anti-electron
Going from particle to anti-particle, you swap charge and chirality (that's the CP transformation). So for instance a left-handed electron with negative electric charge becomes a right-handed anti-electron with positive electric charge.
For neutrinos, given that left-handed neutrinos have weak interactions, then so do right-handed anti-neutrinos.
It's no harder to detect anti-neutrinos than neutrinos. It's right-handed neutrinos and left-handed anti-neutrinos you'd have a problem with.
The CP violation article talks about probabilities because CP violation is not nearly as neat as P violation alone. Instead of the clear-cut "left-handed neutrinos (and therefore right-handed anti-neutrinos) only" of P, you get small differences.
One last question: I was under the impression that the difference between a neutrino and an antineutrino was only chirality. What other property is there to distinguish a neutrino from an anti-neutrino?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weak_isospin#Relation_with_chi...
(including the text in the last two rows).
We know that either:
a) there’s mysterious undetectable particles, or
b) that something beyond the standard model is happening, as in your second and third points.
There’s a failed “prediction” that all fermions have similar mass terms, and that failure suggests either something strange (undetectable particles), something strange (fermions without consistent mass mechanisms) or something strange (novel physics).
I think that qualifies as a mystery.
Neutrinos were originally hypothesized in order to solve a problem which did not require them to have mass, and for a long time after they were actually observed, their measured masses remained within error bars straddling zero. It therefore made perfect sense to model them as massless.
But to actually include neutrino masses in the Standard Model is trivial, and was done long ago.
The most straightforward way to do it is to give them quark-like mass terms. This requires introducing a right-handed partner for each known (left-handed) neutrino, which some people don't like because right-handed particles don't partake in weak interactions, and weak interactions are the only (known) neutrino interactions (apart from gravity), so you end up with undetectable particles.
The main alternative is to use Majorana mass terms, making neutrinos their own anti-particles, which some people don't like because it deviates from the pattern of all other fermions in the Standard Model.
A third way is to say "it's both", typically involving the seesaw mechanism, which some people don't like because it requires unfashionable GUT-style beyond-Standard Model physics.
Point is, there is neither a failed "prediction" nor a great "mystery" here. There is uncertainty about which kind of mass term we should use for neutrinos, because the experimentally observable differences between the alternatives are really, really tiny.