Re:Why not to whitelist operating system user agents
by roobs on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:31AM
(#29224778)
Try Japanese business banking - where you have to pick an OS and stick with it when registering (with a paper form), and must use either the ESR release of Firefox or Internet Explorer. If you don't have a user agent of either of those it won't even let you sign in.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why not to whitelist operating system user agents
by raxxorrax on Monday November 15, 2021 @03:48AM
(#29225189)
Basically security done wrong because it will only affect users and won't stop attackers.
Re:Why not to whitelist operating system user agents
by silon42 on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:52AM
(#29224885)
For a while Firefox ESR was the only one still supporting digital certificate request/generation (KEYGEN).
My (not in Japan) and other banks used this as one securiy mechanism. With new EU rules they've now downgraded their security to a Phone app + some SMS verification.
Re:Why not to whitelist operating system user agents
by GoblinSlayer on Monday November 15, 2021 @03:04AM
(#29224940)
Always spoof your user agent string, for firefox the setting is general.useragent.override
Re:Why not to whitelist operating system user agents
by zinekeller on Monday November 15, 2021 @09:48AM
(#29228015)
You think that's that easy?
Maybe now, not really sure if there are now changes (hopefully, since Microsoft is dropping IE), but in a time where browser plugins are abound you can't place an ActiveX plugin inside Firefox (or vice versa).
Re:Why not to whitelist operating system user agents
by ricardobayes on Monday November 15, 2021 @08:32AM
(#29227112)
Try Spanish online digital administration. The digital certificates only worked in IE. And mid-process they require installing a Java-based program that required a different type of digital certificate. That of course make you restart the browser and lose all the data entered.
Just wow. I couldn't even come up with such a bad process if I wanted.
Re:Why not to whitelist operating system user agents
by pezezin on Tuesday November 16, 2021 @07:43AM
(#29239850)
Oh boy are you wrong. We Spanish people love trash talking our own country, but after 3 years in Japan, I can tell you that the Spanish banks and bureaucracy are light-years ahead of Japan.
At least in Spain we have online administration, even if it's not perfect. Here? Hand written forms, hankos and fax machines. Everything is at least ten times as difficult as it should be.
Re:Why not to whitelist operating system user agents
by diggan on Monday November 15, 2021 @08:39AM
(#29227194)
Not sure if you're referring to something old, I've only been in Spain since 2012 but I'm having zero issues with the digital certificate for various government websites, from hacienda to local city governments websites. Never have I been forced to install Java either. I usually use Firefox on Linux and seems to work fine, at least for me.
Re:Why not to whitelist operating system user agents
by ricardobayes on Tuesday November 16, 2021 @03:50AM
(#29238357)
It was just yesterday. To sign in you need @clave, but to actually sign the document, you need AutoFirma, that's the java-based tool.
Re:Why not to whitelist operating system user agents
by diggan on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @07:20AM
(#29252109)
That's strange, I've never needed @clave nor AutoFirm (and in fact, I've never even heard of AutoFirma before). I just use the digital certificate (for signing in and for signing documents) received from the government to sign everything directly in the browser, without any Java or anything else really.
Re:Why not to whitelist operating system user agents
by ricardobayes on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @12:19PM
(#29255851)
Well yes, your comment outlines the issue. Why is there three different certificates supposed to do the same thing?