News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by wombatpm on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:26PM (#29222932)
In the early 80s a 13% mortgage rate was not uncommon. People survived. Very little blood was spilled
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by blip54321 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:31PM (#29222970)
There's a world of difference between high interest rates (which are good and healthy) and rising interest rates (which implode the economy).

You gotta look at the derivative.

Rising interest rates are really, really bad. Anyone who relies on revolving business debt, credit card debt, or other non-fixed-rate debt goes bankrupt.

I kinda wish I entered the economy when we still had 12% interest rates. Each time a recession hits, we level it off by lowering them a bit, and we've kinda hit the floor.

I don't think we can get back to 12% interest within my lifetime without some kind of economic collapse or cataclysmic event.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by listenallyall on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:57PM (#29223129)
> Anyone who relies on revolving business debt, credit card debt, or other non-fixed-rate debt goes bankrupt.

This is hyperbole. Rising interest rates aren't fun, but they aren't cataclysmic. Rates have gone up and down for decades. Further, if you signal that you're taking the option to raise rates off the table, risk tolerance and asset prices will explode (some would say this has already happened due to Fed signaling).

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by hogFeast on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:20PM (#29223275)
To explain more about the logic used by the guy you replied to...

...the problem is people think: interest rates go up, economy slows down, we can never raise interest rates. This logic takes on a life of its own.

The US economy was in this position in the late 60s: the Fed was under pressure to accommodate govt financing, they raised rates in 1959 and were blamed for causing a recession that influenced the outcome of the 1960 election, in 1967 they attempted to raise rates briefly but did so at the wrong time...eventual result (combined with some unfortunate timing with oil price changes) is rates never rise, inflation does, serious problems.

When the discussion moves to this point, and we have been moving this way for years, I think it is a sign that something has gone quite wrong. And that expectations around interest rates and Fed behaviour are actually adding volatility and uncertainty, not reducing it.

You are quite correct though. Rising interest rates are not bad. It is just the price of money. Falling interest rates can be just as bad too, but the problems are usually subtle (i.e. financial repression, which is what is happening now, no-one will realise what has happened until they try to retire in 20/30 years and realise they can't). Public policy has moved to this risky stage where people blame everything on politicians...the result is, unfortunately, inevitable.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by refurb on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:50AM (#29224528)
This is the exact situation many financial commentators highlighted post-2008, so I think your historical points are very relevant.

The Federal Reserve is supposed to have independence from the government. It will develop its own monetary policy which doesn't need government approval. In reality, the President appoints all the Governors, so people get selected based on doing what the President wants done.

The Fed's monetary policy is typically an inflation target - keep the money supply growing to encourage growth, but keep inflation in check as well.

The problem is the political influence starts to impact the pure decisions about what's best for the economy. Election coming up? Well, hold off on increasing rates since we need good employment numbers for the next few months.

If the economy gets unstable the Fed ends up riding the razor's edge trying to stick to policy but not piss off the President. Problem is that the economy can go off the rails faster than the Fed can response.

The issue highlighted after 2008 was that "yeah, printing new dollars and buying distressed assets worked pretty well! and no massive inflation so far. But there will be incredible pressure to not raise rates later and if the Fed waits too long to apply the brakes, they won't be able to get ahead of it and inflation will skyrocket."

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by hogFeast on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:22PM (#29233659)
Chairman McChensey Martin (who served in the late 60s when all this started to blow up) used to say that the Fed is independent within government. So the Fed is able to develop policy independently but doesn't have room to actually run counter to whatever the Executive is doing.

I don't think the impact is necessarily elections anymore, if it ever was. But the Fed was supporting bond auctions through 2020. I don't think it will stop them raising rates but it has stopped them raising rates fast enough imo.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by snidane on Monday November 15, 2021 @08:21AM (#29227015)
The apparently only empirical study relating interest rates and growth was done by Richard Werner, concluding growth actually historically happened in high interest rate environments, whereas the current economic dogma states exactly otherwise.

https://youtu.be/JD2z4l1DiBw

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by imtringued on Monday November 15, 2021 @08:51AM (#29227327)
I don't know what his point is. There is no absolute level of low or high interest rates.

Interest rates merely balance the supply and demand of/for labor.

Growth usually happens when there is high demand for labor and that means interest rates are high during periods of growth. When you think about it, interest is just the risk adjusted yield of a labor saving investment plus minus bank fees and profit share of the borrower. That means the existence of high yielding investments is what drives interest rates up as lots of borrowers got to the bank and present their fantastic business ideas and the bank picks the highest yielding ones.

Well, I also have to say something. Growth didn't really stop with lower interest rates. The economy is much bigger than 30 years ago.

Also about negative interest rates, it's a fallacy to think they are supposed to stimulate borrowing. They are supposed to balance people's desire to be in debt with people's desire to hold onto credit (equivalent to demand/supply of labor). That means negative interest rates exist as a disincentive to save money because nobody wants to borrow money.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by hogFeast on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:26PM (#29233700)
Richard Werner is a bit nutty but his work does have value. He takes a heavily heterodox position on interest rates, some of this is him being misleading in order to be controversial. But his points about the impact of interest rates on bank profits are very trenchant (and btw, the reason why he is a bit nutty is because his professional experience was Japan in the late 80s/90s, that scenario tested all the assumptions about macro and found a lot of them were false, his book Princes of the Yen is good...although, again, very heterodox).
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by blip54321 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:18PM (#29223266)
I hope you're right.

The extent to which you might be right or wrong depends to some extent on how much debt there is in the system (or how leveraged/wound up the economy is).

A debt-based economy is much more vulnerable. Last time we raised interest rates rapidly, in the eighties, household debt was less than half of what it is today, adjusted for GDP.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by listenallyall on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:12AM (#29224313)
Yes, whenever rates eventually rise, it's going to hurt some people. People and companies burdened with debt. Some will in fact go bankrupt (most will not, of course). But that's not a reason not to do it, all that is, is more evidence of fiscal irresponsibility. Any company which is unable to withstand higher debt costs is just as poorly managed as one which is unable to withstand a rise in any other input cost. If McDonald's went bankrupt tomorrow claiming rising beef costs, you'd say their business plan was flawed, being overly reliant on subsidized farming and not planning ahead for contingencies. The same is entirely true for a company that is bankrupted by higher interest rates. Making excuses and accommodating heavy debtors by keeping rates artificially low is one of the most damaging things you can do.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by hndamien on Monday November 15, 2021 @07:35PM (#29235004)
The caveat is that the currency is being debased and interest rates are being manipulated, forcing people out on the risk curve.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by 01100011 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:56PM (#29223501)
I really don't know if this is correct or not, but one thing I've heard is that low rates disincentivize lending by banks because loans are less profitable. Higher rates will actually encourage lending. Much of the money in circulation comes from the banks because of fractional lending and not from the fed's printing presses. I'm curious if anyone has a take on that.

Also, I think rates need to be looked at in comparison to GDP growth. High rates are fine when GDP growth is greater. If rates shoot higher because the fed is trying to stop runaway supply-side driven inflation while GDP growth is low it could easily kick off a depression.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by sokoloff on Monday November 15, 2021 @04:56AM (#29225633)
Higher rates increase willingness to lend. Lower rates increase willingness to borrow. You need both a willing lender and a willing borrower for lending to happen.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by listenallyall on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:07PM (#29223573)
Spreads compress when rates are low, so yes, loans are less profitable per dollar when rates are low. But many more people and companies want to borrow so banks make out fine. And there are plenty of other financing sources available for companies, including issuing equity, VCs, junk bonds, which grow in popularity when investors need to chase yields.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by JamesBarney on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:25PM (#29223668)
The reason we had a 12% interest rate was because we had a 13% inflation rate.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by snidane on Monday November 15, 2021 @08:17AM (#29226969)
Even worse than rising interest rates is a society addicted to the fentanyl of zero interest rates.

There is a reason major religions regulated debt in general, because that is how societal slavery develops. Of course we, the modern people of technology, 'know better' than our primitive ancient ancestors.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by imtringued on Monday November 15, 2021 @08:34AM (#29227143)
I don't get it. Most religions were against usury and they insisted on debt forgiveness if the debtor can't pay.

Charging 0% interest is absolutely fantastic. The only problem is that we don't do the debt forgiveness. We bail out banks and then expect tax payers to shoulder some or all of the losses. It was especially bad with Germany vs Greece. German banks were bailed out and public healthcare was basically eliminated in Greece.

The only reason why anyone would be against low interest rates is that they noticed that those interest rates eat into economic rents and therefore the owner of money benefited from the economic rents rather than the owner of the monopoly. In that sense, the only difference is that the money goes to the land owner instead of going to the bank. People don't realize that if they buy a $600k house with 0% interest that they would still have to pay $600k at 5% interest except most of the money goes to the bank instead of the seller who only gets $250k (made up number).

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by AniseAbyss on Monday November 15, 2021 @09:22AM (#29227699)
Debt forgiveness does exist. You can declare bankruptcy.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by nostrademons on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:39PM (#29223768)
I think people forget just how bad the early 80s recession was, possibly because most of the people affected then are dead or senior citizens now. Nationwide was 10% (on par with the 2009 recession), and in some cities it went up to 25%. Farmers drove their tractors into Washington DC and blockaded the Eccles building. Car dealers sent coffins containing the keys of unsold vehicles. Construction workers sent 2x4s to Volcker because nobody needed them for home construction. The Treasury Secretary publicly undermined him, and the House Majority Leader called for his resignation.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by coldcode on Monday November 15, 2021 @07:56AM (#29226770)
I owned a house shortly after that period, I knew people with 18% mortgages who just walked away from the house when rates went down again.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by abdabab on Monday November 15, 2021 @04:15PM (#29232873)
> Car dealers sent coffins containing the keys of unsold vehicles

This sounded so strange that I had to look it up and found this article https://www.federalreservehistory.org/essays/anti-inflation-...

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by refurb on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:42AM (#29224487)
Sure, but the mortgage rate was around half that in the year before and just as high in 1974. Though compared to today, 13% is high but not ridiculous. 13% today would be ridiculous.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FEDFUNDS

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by nly on Monday November 15, 2021 @08:11AM (#29226906)
Yeah and houses were only 3x a single income, not 10x

The people who bought in the 80s and 90s refinanced as rates fell and saw massive appreciation in the value of their homes.

People buying today will see the opposite