News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. appeals court affirms hold on Biden Covid-19 vaccine... by throwawaysea on Friday November 12, 2021 @08:45PM (#29206565)
Good. Bodily autonomy is a fundamental civil liberty, alongside medical privacy. In any just and free society, it doesn’t make sense to force people to undergo a medical procedure to do everyday things. If others are so fearful, they need to quarantine themselves instead of imposing forced medical procedures on others. After all, even with the vaccine they won’t be perfectly safe.
Re:U.S. appeals court affirms hold on Biden Covid-19 vaccine... by rytcio on Friday November 12, 2021 @08:54PM (#29206640)
My body, my choice...sometimes
[dead]
Re:U.S. appeals court affirms hold on Biden Covid-19 vaccine... by anfilt on Saturday November 13, 2021 @02:22AM (#29208074)
A seat belt is not quite the same. Both sure involve autonomy. However, not wearing your seat belt mainly puts your self at risk. A virus can spread to others.

As for externalties of like medical care sure not using a seat belt or taking the vaccine mean your more likely to need medical care. I will add though without seat belt your more likely to die at the scene. Thusly, how much more externalties not wearing a seat belt will cause I don't know, and would need some data on that point.

There is also an other big difference between a seat belt and vaccine. Mandating a vaccine is forcing someone to under go a medical procedure. Albeit a simple one. Where as a seat belt does not.

Although, bringing up seat belts I find it funny we allow people to drive motor cycles on public roads, but you must wear a seat belt in a car. So clearly this was not just about externalties. So the rule seems quite silly to me. (probably the car insurance lobby pushed for it)

In my honest opinion it would be better the state did not mandate either of these in my opinion. What is sad is the vaccine some how has become political, and people are not taking for either stupid reasons or believing false hoods. Despite this I don't think we should be quick abandon principles of liberty because of idiots. Every precedent set today can be used to forward an other one in the future you may not agree with. So best tread carefully.

Re:U.S. appeals court affirms hold on Biden Covid-19 vaccine... by DarknessFalls on Saturday November 13, 2021 @09:35AM (#29209998)
My main point was that insurance companies should shift the financial burden to people who refuse to get vaccinated. And hospitals should prioritize the vaccinated in ICUs, even for elective procedures.
[dead]
Re:U.S. appeals court affirms hold on Biden Covid-19 vaccine... by dang on Saturday November 13, 2021 @03:46PM (#29213031)
You've been using HN primarily for ideological battle lately—indeed, to post almost exclusively about one hot flamewar topic (this one). That's not allowed here, regardless of what you're battling for or against, because it's not in the intended spirit of the site (curiosity), and indeed it destroys that spirit.

Would you please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and use HN as intended? I don't want to ban you but we don't allow single-purpose accounts or ideological battle accounts here and that is unfortunately what yours has turned into.

Re:U.S. appeals court affirms hold on Biden Covid-19 vaccine... by version_five on Wednesday November 17, 2021 @08:44PM (#29261158)
Not that I'm anybody, but though I've seen the GP post a lot on this topic, his posts generally feel respectful, genuinely interesting, and not meant to incite flamewars. I can see the argument that this isn't what the site is for, but its nice to have a contrarian view that is generally nuanced and thought out, and not just some crazy stuff with no basis in reality. Anyway, it's not my place to say whether someone is "using HN as intended" - just to say that I've seen lots of real abuses and wouldn't consider the stuff this person posts to qualify.
Re:U.S. appeals court affirms hold on Biden Covid-19 vaccine... by dang on Friday November 19, 2021 @04:51PM (#29283040)
I don't have a problem with contrarian views, but to use this site as intended, people need to be primarily oriented to intellectual curiosity, not hot political agendas. Those two sets are basically disjoint, so when an account is doing the latter, it stands out quite badly.

Of course, even within the latter category there's still a big difference between vandalizing the thread with flamebait vs. staying substantive and respectful.

Re:U.S. appeals court affirms hold on Biden Covid-19 vaccine... by josephcsible on Saturday November 13, 2021 @02:14AM (#29208042)
Do you think insurance should refuse to cover medical costs for anything caused by smoking or obesity? If not, why the difference?
Re:U.S. appeals court affirms hold on Biden Covid-19 vaccine... by DarknessFalls on Saturday November 13, 2021 @09:33AM (#29209988)
Insurance does raise rates for people who are obese, quite significantly. So the distinction here is that they aren't taking similar action for people who refuse the vaccine.
Re:U.S. appeals court affirms hold on Biden Covid-19 vaccine... by TheParkShark on Saturday November 13, 2021 @11:00AM (#29210656)
This doesn’t apply to all insurances and doesn’t address the actual question at hand. Should obese people, smokers, alcoholics, drug users, etc be denied medical care for the choices they make?

If not, is this insurance argument of yours based on actually wanting medical care changes for the benefit of all or just to intimidate more people into getting the vaccine?

Re:U.S. appeals court affirms hold on Biden Covid-19 vaccine... by josephcsible on Saturday November 13, 2021 @10:23AM (#29210355)
Distinguish raising rates from refusing to cover costs. Also, my health insurance company has no idea how much I weigh, so I'm not sure how common that actually is.