News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by jsz0 on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @07:26PM (#2918794)
The obvious question now is, if Google can do this, why aren’t network operators banging down the company’s door to get involved and roll this out everywhere. Yes, there’s big investment involved, but these companies are kidding themselves if they think waiting and dealing with a lack of bandwidth in the future is going to work for them. Whoever jumps first and starts investing in these fiber-to-the-home initiatives is going to be rewarded with a lot of new customers in years to come.

They don't need Google to do it. FTTH/G-PON solutions are available to any ISP in the country and have been for several years. They haven't done it yet (besides Verizon FIOS who provisions at much lower speeds) because the demand really isn't there yet. Most customers do not pay more for faster speeds even when they are available. You've got a lot more customers who downgrade to slower speeds to save money than customers who pay more for faster speeds. More competition would certainly help but until you can convince normal people they actually need faster Internet connections it's not much of a competitive advantage. (as long as you can match or slightly exceed your competitors)

Once you hit about 20Mbit/5Mbit faster speeds are almost completely unnoticeable by most people who are just doing some normal browsing, IP video, e-mail, FaceBook, etc. That's what most people are using their Internet connections for these days. We really need a killer app that pushes the limits of most Internet connections and you'll see more companies betting on (expensive) upgrades to deliver those speeds. I don't see much on the horizon. You can already do pretty decent 1080P video at 10-20Mbit/sec. What type of apps are going to push the demand?

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by kayoone on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @04:35AM (#2919966)
> Once you hit about 20Mbit/5Mbit faster speeds are almost completely unnoticeable by most people who are just doing some normal browsing, IP video, e-mail, FaceBook, etc.

People always say this, some years ago it was 6Mbit, before that it was 2Mbit etc. The services change and with it the demand for higher bandwidth. In a few years when everything (TV, phone, internet) runs in super high quality through your broadband you will need more again. That said, i am currently happy with my 64/5Mbit at home, still have the option for 128/10 but dont need it right now.

Only have 32/2 in the office though and thats a bit on the low end when 6-7 people use it all the time.

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by drinian on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @08:21PM (#2918918)
How about just convincing Verizon to sell the higher speeds to those who want them, at a higher price? The hardware's there, but their most expensive FiOS business connections are far short of Google's numbers.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by jsz0 on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @09:52PM (#2919117)
Verizon does offer up to 150Mbit/35Mbit for their business packages. They probably don't see a market for it on the residential side. CableVision, Comcast, TWC, etc do offer 100Mbit+ connections for residential use in some limited markets. From what I've head they are not big sellers. (less than 1% of customers upgrade) That has probably slowed down wider deployment.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by joelhaus on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @11:53PM (#2919386)
Is this so different from 10 years ago, when no one realized that they wanted high-definition TV? I can't imagine that the demand for HD television was very high then either. Once it was available, manufacturers began making all of their equipment HD capable.

The fundamental cause of poor broadband network performance in this country is actually not a lack of demand, it's a lack of competition among ISP's -- otherwise, these speeds would come to market naturally.

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by k33l0r on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @01:42AM (#2919610)
Over here in Helsinki, Finland there's a cable operator that offers connections that go up to 200/10Mbit (54,90€/month) and one of the biggest ISPs is putting together a 1000Mbit residential connection trial (they already offer 100/10Mbit fibre connections).

I think the demand is there if the pricing is decent.

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by adestefan on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @09:46AM (#2920637)
I don't know if I'd call $80 reasonable. I pay $35 for my 25/5 with FIOS and am very happy with what I get and wouldn't pay more just for fast speeds.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by drinian on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @08:20PM (#2923222)
To be honest, I have their business service at home to avoid trouble when I'm running VPN servers, etc. and the occasional Web service from home -- not to mention the usage cap issue.

And it's nice to know that they're up to 35 mbits upload (much faster than what I have), but their hardware is capable of much more (assuming it's on par with Google Fiber's).

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by sbalea on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @12:38AM (#2919474)
Dunno about others, but the reason I'm not yet on Cablevision's 101/15Mbps plan is that they're charging a non refundable $300 fee to get you hooked up. I'm a software developer that works from home. If I won't do it, what are the chances your average Joe would?
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by madh on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @10:19PM (#2919188)
Co cast 100Mbit+ is $200/month in SF. Steep.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by slewis on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @09:19PM (#2919036)
Why are people comfortable with paying for tiered connection speeds, but not comfortable with a monthly data cap (that can be removed by paying more for a business connection)?
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by tossit543123 on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @10:22PM (#2919196)
I think its because paying for a tiered connection speed is set-and-forget. Paying with a monthly data cap effectively overlays an economic decision over each interaction you have with the internet. "Do I click this link? How much bandwidth will that use?" Even though I think most people probably would end up not thinking about it on a link-by-link basis, they do have to devote some mental power to monitoring how much of their data cap they've used, how much they have left in the current billing cycle (especially under billing regimes that charge way higher marginal costs when you exceed the initial cap - e.g. most US mobile phone voice minute plans).

It's just annoying. Even though it seems like tying the price of something to your use of that thing is the most efficient way to bill, it just sucks because then you have to think too much about every use: text messages, AOL hours, phone calls, until these things got so cheap that they weren't worth metering, all were in that category.

Personally, I suspect there's some behavioral economics ish at work here that is measurable, like...you know how some hotels and cruiseships have all-in prices? I bet people are actually willing to pay more for the same amount of consumption with the 'unlimited' plans because they enjoy not having to worry about it. This would also be pretty easy to test with cruiseship or all-inclusive resort data where they also sell other a la carte packages.

I have data cap plans on my phone and iPad, and I don't really mind them, but its only because I know that they are effectively unlimited: I never come close to using up the cap level of data. I don't watch Slingbox on my phone, etc.

I tell you what really burns me up though: the fact that even though I am paying per-gigabyte transfer fees on my iDevices, AT&T wants me to pay more money to tether to my laptop. Why the fuck should they care? The data is the data. I understood when the idae was that a tethered laptop would use assloads of data on the nominal "unlimited" plan exceeding their modelled costs, but...dude, I bought data transfer. why do you give a shit which device the packets end up on? I HATE THIS. It honestly annoys me more than if AT&T just built in the tethering to the price and I just had to pay it.

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by smerritt on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @12:32AM (#2919463)
There's two flavors of monthly data cap.

I have a Linode with a data cap of 300GB per month; if I use more than that, I pay a reasonable amount ($0.15/GB) for the excess. So if I use a lot of data one month, I get a charge on my credit card, and life goes on. I'm completely comfortable with this.

A residential Comcast connection has a data cap of 250GB per month; if I use more than that, they turn off my connection and ban me for a year. So if I use a lot of data one month, I find myself abruptly and semi-permanently screwed. I am absolutely not comfortable with this since the consequences are so severe and long-lasting.

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by Jach on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @09:31PM (#2919063)
I don't think this is the case at all. The problem people have with monthly caps is that they're frequently done with plans that advertised "UNLIMITED X!". There are also people who don't mind paying per GB. The problem most people have is when ISPs react according to content, such as capping your torrenting but leaving youtube untouched, or capping Netflix but not Facebook, etc.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by SolarUpNote on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @11:34PM (#2919341)
I thought there was a law against doing that (net neutrality).

I've heard that ISPs discriminate between "types" of content (video vs text). But I wasn't aware they were discriminating based on the company (Netflix vs YouTube).

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by Goronmon on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @09:14AM (#2920544)
I thought there was a law against doing that (net neutrality).

There is no law enforcing Net Neutrality.

And really, the concern isn't that a company like Comcast will meter Netflix, but not Facebook. It's that they will meter Netflix, but not "Comcast Video Streaming" if they were to offer such a service.

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by wmf on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @09:29PM (#2919055)
Because ISPs are keeping prices the same when introducing caps, effectively providing less service for the same money.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by njharman on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @10:18PM (#2919186)
Because when you pay for speed X you want speed X, you don't want speed X-n after you download Y GB of data.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by andreyf on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @08:09PM (#2918888)
I think a lot of passion behind this comes from Googlers having this kind of connection at work :)

http://www.speedtest.net/result/894208160.png

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by sjs on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @10:17PM (#2919183)
Almost makes me want to apply at Google.

I have a[n up to] 25 mbps line, Shaw is rolling out 50 mbps but upstream isn't really improving so big deal. Downstream is not my bottleneck for most things but online backups and such are painful. I'd blame the technology but DOCSIS 3 allows for more than that, and Telus has fibre in Canada with similarly castrated upstream bandwidth.

sigh

http://www.speedtest.net/result/1447275168.png

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by fl3tch on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @11:05PM (#2919272)
Which makes me wonder what kind of connection Speedtest.net has.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by cuu508 on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @05:33AM (#2920091)
Perhaps this measures capability of SpeedTest, not capability of Google :-)
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by RyanKearney on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @08:44AM (#2920459)
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by ahi on Thursday August 25, 2011 @07:39PM (#2926814)
It says a distance of 1200 miles but a ping of just 3ms, which means they're breaking the law. Speed of light in a vacuum: 299.8km per millisecond.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by RyanKearney on Friday August 26, 2011 @09:22AM (#2928371)
No, the location is taken from the RWHOIS data which just happened to not list the IP's actual location.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by onemoreact on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @10:30AM (#2920792)
Sorry, that 3ms ping suggests you are inside their network. Try getting that over the internet.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by RyanKearney on Friday August 26, 2011 @09:30AM (#2928393)
Incorrect, I've gotten pings of less than 1 millisecond from over the internet.

PING a152.g.akamai.net (204.0.5.50) 56(84) bytes of data. 64 bytes from 204.0.5.50: icmp_seq=1 ttl=59 time=0.852 ms

PING yahoo.com (209.191.122.70) 56(84) bytes of data. 64 bytes from ir1.fp.vip.mud.yahoo.com (209.191.122.70): icmp_seq=1 ttl=57 time=3.06 ms

PING google.com (74.125.73.104) 56(84) bytes of data. 64 bytes from tul01m01-in-f104.1e100.net (74.125.73.104): icmp_seq=1 ttl=55 time=8.38 ms

PING e3191.c.akamaiedge.net (184.86.157.15) 56(84) bytes of data. 64 bytes from a184-86-157-15.deploy.akamaitechnologies.com (184.86.157.15): icmp_seq=1 ttl=60 time=1.15 ms

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by sirlancer on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @08:39PM (#2918957)
The first productive applications that will utilize these speeds will be grid-based computing projects. Initial iterations of artificial intelligence will require large computing resources (GPGPU) in addition to high bandwidth, and low latency.

Projects like 'Test4Theory' that utilize Monte Carlo simulations will help us to accurately visualize and better predict the fundamental nature of our universe. The best contributors to these kind of projects will have high bandwidth fiber connections.

The first unproductive applications will be the next generation of first person games.

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by Klinky on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @10:49PM (#2919244)
"Grid computing" is going to need more than speeds similar to 100mbit Ethernet. "AI" has been around practically since computers were invented, so I am not sure how the "first iteration" of AI will be created thanks to these higher speeds.

Test4Theory is typical distributed computing setup with "small" datasets that require high processing time/simulation to get results. It's not like they are streaming live data from the LHC to your computer. They rely on an actual distributed/grid computer to do that.

Also next gen FPS will certainly not require or take advantage of 100mbit connections because most people don't have them. No one is going to make a game that comes near needing 100mbit/sec.

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by Geee on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @08:57PM (#2918999)
In the coming 2-5 years most 3D games will be ray-tracing-based and streaming technology would not only be very suitable for it but very beneficial, allowing huge game worlds with unlimited detail. Highly detailed or scanned 3D objects take easily terabytes of storage and streaming everything from the servers is really the only viable option.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by jpadkins on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @10:15AM (#2920742)
If that is true, than most games in production and pre-production now are using ray-tracing based engines.

Can you cite examples of major studios using ray tracing engines today?

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by DasIch on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @09:10PM (#2919016)
In that case you will still end up with a latency problem.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by Geee on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @09:26PM (#2919049)
There's local cache(s) too to help with latency. Basically, you have to keep your GPU memory full, cache on RAM, cache on SSD, cache on HDD and continue all the way down to the cloud servers. Check out this demo for example, which streams data from disk http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HScYuRhgEJw
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by Klinky on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @10:52PM (#2919248)
Game devs are not interested in making games that no one will be able to run. Regardless of the benefits of raytracing it is currently inefficient when compared with raster tech currently on GPUs. Hardware tessellation makes inefficient voxel tech moot except for scientific purposes. We can already stream data from the hard disk to the system ram into GPU memory.

I'd put mainstream voxel/raytracing tech as more like 10 - 20 years in the future.

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by Astrohacker on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @08:57PM (#2919000)
> We really need a killer app that pushes the limits of most Internet connections and you'll see more companies betting on (expensive) upgrades to deliver those speeds. I don't see much on the horizon.

If bitcoin gets very popular, running a node will require very fast download and upload speeds to get and rebroadcast the transactions.

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by jdunck on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @07:30PM (#2918805)
P2P live video.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by InclinedPlane on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @07:35PM (#2918811)
That's already a real thing and it doesn't require any higher bandwidth than even conventional cable/dsl provides.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by joelhaus on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @11:43PM (#2919358)
What if you want to steam high quality P2P video ( ≥720p )?
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by InclinedPlane on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @12:54AM (#2919506)
x264, 10mbps or less, there's no need for 100mbps or more for such things.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by taken11 on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @05:44AM (#2920117)
what if you have a video conference with 8 participants each at 720p?
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by bobbles on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @06:25AM (#2920187)
For some reason this comment put thoughts into my head of people having multiple large screens positioned around their house instead of windows.

You could have beautiful HD panoramic views from around the world in your cheap wall-facing apartment. Of course the technology would need to come down in price but we all know how quickly that tends to happen.

Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by crizCraig on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @08:53PM (#2918992)
veetle.com does a really good job at this. I have a six year old media center box that doesn't run anything that well besides veetle and 1080p at that.
Re:Google Fiber: 151Mbps down / 92Mbps up by maheshcasiraghi on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @11:17PM (#2919299)
As per below here, 5ms ping [rather than 1Gig down] seems to be the central focus of this kind of optic social venture.

It provides some insights on where BigG sees some future here.

These are apparently times where synchronicity vs. asynchronicity begins possibly to be a way hotter topic than definition vs. pixelation.

There is all the space to ponderate for a while on this as a social index: who would have said that only 3 years ago?

I wouldn't.