Ask HN: How screwed am I if I drop out?
From what I can tell, the market for entry level positions is brutally competitive, and I need every edge I can get.
* I'm a freshman studying CS at UIUC
* I've had two internships applying ML to niche problems. In one of these, when I was 15, I beat the SOTA on a problem in the field of applied geophysics on a contract for the US Air Force.
* I took DS/Algo and ML courses at my home state's university while in HS.
* I can do FizzBuzz, invert a binary tree, implement a hashmap, etc., but could definitely benefit from grinding leetcode.
All that being said, I have a visceral hatred for my classes, and feel like they are eroding any passion I previously had for mathematics, science, and CS. How screwed would I be if I dropped out right now?
(
23 comments
| 8 points
| on HN
)
What is concerning is this “visceral hatred” for the curriculum. You’d be well served by exploring why that is the case! Ask around, what are graduates of your program up to these days? Say 1, 5, 10 years after graduation. Search around on LinkedIn to get some idea.
I know the disgruntled genius trope is popular on HN, but it is extremely rare irl. What is common irl, however, are delusional undergraduates that feel the faculty at their school is holding them back from a life of fast cars and never ending excitement!
If OP thinks college is somehow eroding some former joy in mathematics than I have no idea how jumping straight to some job will help? Could it be that reality is just not meeting some unrealistic expectations expectations?
If I were this student’s faculty advisor I would spend a lot of time talking to them about this. In my experience this sounds like the tip of a very large iceberg that may require some counseling and intervention.
Make it work for you - skip as many classes as possible, turn in whatever shit they require. Just get in and out as fast as you can. Also taking CLEP exams can help you graduate one year early.
I had the same experience as you. In classes, it felt like my skin was on fire. About 20% of my effort went towards classes, and 80% went towards my own passion projects.
"I have never let my schooling interfere with my education" - Mark Twain
I think you should explore different majors (I'd recommend math) or just using the next three years to embrace your hobbies. You don't have to get all A's in college. Just do what you need to get B's and focus on a startup idea or something else.
The current education system has a lot of faults, but on average, its still beneficial, and even if you just want to criticize it, your in a much better position to do so and be heard if you actually did it. I'd say suck it up and stay in school. It's a long game.
In 10 years (as the OP progresses in their career) the tech they would have learned about in school will be obsolete. If they haven't continued to learn, THEN they'll be worse off -- but that has nothing to do with credentials or what they learned in school.
I've been on the hiring side of the interview process many times. As a software developer progresses in their career they need to think about software architecture and mentoring more than anything else -- things that schools just don't teach well at all.
I'm never looking at the (school) credentials of a senior software developer. I'm always looking at what they've done with their career, and how they handle the fundamentals in an interview.
A CS degree does not teach specific techs though. And I don't really think CS fundamentals and math will became obsolete in 10 years.
What OP would be missing out on is the social aspect of university and the lack of credentials in the future. I agree that lack of a degree can definitely hurt you or completely disqualify you for certain positions. There's also potentially negative status that comes with not having a degree or being someone who wasn't commited/capable/hardworking enough to finish what they started. (This last part obviously isn't necessarily true but the perception could be there anyway)
When I was in my 20's I knew everything and had a strong opinion about all things technical. Now with decades of experience and a PhD in SE, there is so much that I still don't know. My common response to any request for opinion is "It depends! -- define 'better'".
Programming languages, operating systems, frameworks, etc are changing all the time. What was hot a decade ago is now virtually untouchable. It has been the solid foundations gained in those hated classes that have kept me productive in my ever narrowing field of specialization.
I DID NOT drop out of college completely. Instead I really just slow rolled the whole process. It took me 6 years and this included usually taking 1-2 courses over the summer. It was not an enjoyable time and my classes never stopped sucking. That being said I am glad I completed it and having a job really took a lot of pressure off of my to try and get the best grades. I would shot for a solid B and when I knew that was in the bag I would completely ramp down my scholastic efforts.
I think if I could give you any advice it is that life is hard, no matter the company, its location, the country it is in, the industry that it operates in, nor the people who work there be 100% what you like. You will run into innumerable challenges and situations you can't stand in your career, do not develop the habit of running away from them. Instead focus on what you can change to make them less painful. Leaving is always an option but I would strongly encourage you to not let it be the first one!
Some other food for thought, could you change your degree from just being CS focused to being more interdisciplinary? When I went to school they had a build your own degree where you could combine courses from three different colleges, for example you could do a Statistics, Finance, and CS degree. Just a thought.
Everyone's a little different, and mostly I'm joking but I'll say: If you think school erodes your passions, just wait until you experience industry.
Pick something fun, like English or History. Now is time to learn how to make friends. If you don't develop social skills now the rest of your life will be harder.
The degree doesn't really matter in my experience, but college is still a great way to widen your worldview.
You might not be completely screwed if you drop out but there's a lot of potential downside and no upside apart from the short term personal gratification you might get from dropping out.
As it stands, I think this is bad advice. There are plenty of potential downsides to staying in something that the OP describes as 'visceral hatred'.
The OP clearly has no problem learning on their own.
I've been on the 'hiring' side of the interview table many times -- I wouldn't think twice about hiring this person as long as they had a nice personality. They definitely sound like they'd be qualified for just about anything they wanted to do with software.
A couple of other factors
- Regret from not finishing the degree. Many people struggle mentally with having this unfinished thing in their life and it bothers them for years. So much that many people go back to university later in life just to finish it.
- Not everyone hires like you. Some companies won't give you time of day without a relevant degree. Especially given that OP mentions ML a couple of times and those jobs often require an advanced degree not just a bachelor's. Dropping out might close a lot of doors for OP if they're really interested in the field.
And not to put too fine a point on it but the university years are probably going to be your last chance to fuck around and explore and enjoy life as a young person.
It is also extremely hard to go back to school as an adult because if you have anything resembling a life like work or kids or responsibilities then suddenly normal school things like "the professor decided there's a group project and presentations are at 12:45pm on Thursdays and what do you mean you can't make it?"
So, dear programmer, something that will be of use to you as debugging practice.
In fact, think of it as debugging. You are not getting the desired outcome for the inputs. Why?
Are you just burned out? Can you spend a summer digital nomadic it through Thailand or something to get a break from school? Take a summer job or internship and see if you like actually working as much as you think?
Is it the major or program itself? Would you be better in something like Computer Information Systems that's less theoretical? Would you be happier taking liberal arts classes all day and coding all night? Etc.
Okay you can pass the coding interview, but you don't say what you actually want to do. There's a reason so many startups were founded in college dorm rooms. You have few obligations so low cost of failure, access to world class resources, and a peer group for support or additional skills. Try your ideas out and see if you're as good as you think. And if you start making money, maybe then drop out.
On the other hand, maybe the school isn't a good fit? Do you need a different major or different type of school? Maybe you need something more like WGU where its more self paced and you can just do it at your own pace. Maybe you need to be in a department where people are working kn the thing you want to work on.
Speaking from experience, I dropped out because I knee what I wanted to do and I was good at it and ugugugugygughhh why am I taking this dumb old class when I could be doing my thing?
However: -the bullshit you have to deal with in college is tiny small potatoes compared with Life itself. You don't know that yet but you will. I finally dragged myself to the finish line years later and spent a lot of time going "haha oh yeah I totally would've gotten mad about this."
-while the market is hot right now, there is no guarantee it will remain as such. I dropped out a few months before the dotcom bust. And then 2008. And so on.
-did you see that post going around where the person filled their resume with random buzzwords and it sailed through the keyword filters and got them a ton of callbacks? Lots of places are using resume screening software where your resume only gets to a human if it gets through the filters. And they can check the box for "has degree" and never see your resume even if you're qualified in every other way. Less so for startups and tech companies but a thing for lots of other places you might want to work one day.
I could barely keep my head above water during university. Problem sets, projects, and exams occupied me 24/7. Holding down a job was a piece of cake relatively speaking, admitting all manner of idle mischief, not to mention fun encounters with the opposite gender in and out of the office.