Re:Samsung cites Kubrick's "2001" as Prior Art in Patent Cas...
by xutopia on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @02:59PM
(#2917899)
Can patents be invalidated like this? I'm surprised this is the case. Makes the whole thing that much more absurd.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Samsung cites Kubrick's "2001" as Prior Art in Patent Cas...
by wanorris on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @03:10PM
(#2917942)
It's a design patent, so yes. Previous use of an equivalent design on a TV show is a good as design anywhere else.
On the other hand, if someone invents a working replicator, Star Trek will not count as prior art. :-)
Re:Samsung cites Kubrick's "2001" as Prior Art in Patent Cas...
by hugh3 on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @04:05PM
(#2918177)
Only because the show didn't go into sufficient detail about how the replicator worked.
Re:Samsung cites Kubrick's "2001" as Prior Art in Patent Cas...
by stan_rogers on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @04:20PM
(#2918219)
It's just a serialized and retrieved transport. The key, as with the transporter, is in the Heisenberg compensators -- I have a feeling they may well be patentable under any system that allows patents.
Re:Samsung cites Kubrick's "2001" as Prior Art in Patent Cas...
by meric on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @04:34AM
(#2919962)
Unless it was for a patent for the design of the said replicator...
Re:Samsung cites Kubrick's "2001" as Prior Art in Patent Cas...
by bhickey on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @03:34PM
(#2918062)
Donald Duck was used as prior art to invalidate a method of ship raising. This was discussed at length on HN six months ago: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2232857
Re:Samsung cites Kubrick's "2001" as Prior Art in Patent Cas...
by monochromatic on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @03:08PM
(#2917935)
You'd be hard pressed to invalidate a utility patent with some footage from a movie, because it probably wouldn't be "enabling." But design patents just claim ornamental designs.
Re:Samsung cites Kubrick's "2001" as Prior Art in Patent Cas...
by hugh3 on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @05:52PM
(#2918537)
Some footage could be considered "enabling". For instance if I wanted to patent "Slingshot-launched rideable rocket as a means for catching roadrunners" there'd probably be prior art.
Re:Samsung cites Kubrick's "2001" as Prior Art in Patent Cas...
by monochromatic on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @10:33AM
(#2920800)
Sure, in a simple technology... could happen. That's why I hedged my statement a little bit with "probably."
Re:Samsung cites Kubrick's "2001" as Prior Art in Patent Cas...
by michaelfeathers on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @03:13PM
(#2917963)
It can certainly happen before patents are approved. A description in Robert Heinlein's book, 'Stranger in a Strange Land' was used as prior art to prevent a patent on water beds.
Re:Samsung cites Kubrick's "2001" as Prior Art in Patent Cas...
by Apocryphon on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @04:38PM
(#2918268)
So the solution to patent trolling is to have more hard sci-fi that describes mechanisms of upcoming future technology in detail, thus preventing companies from patenting them?
Re:Samsung cites Kubrick's "2001" as Prior Art in Patent Cas...
by michaelfeathers on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @06:47PM
(#2918682)
Works for me.
Re:Samsung cites Kubrick's "2001" as Prior Art in Patent Cas...
by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @04:41PM
(#2918282)
Regular [Utility] Patents can be invalidated by any prior disclosure of the invention, it doesn't matter what form that disclosure is in provided it is rendered in public (and, with a few more conditions, not part of a recognised trade show in the US).
There's a UK patent application, a doggy doorbell IIRC, that was refused based on a British children's comic called the Beano anticipating it.
Re:Samsung cites Kubrick's "2001" as Prior Art in Patent Cas...
by watmough on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @05:23PM
(#2918424)
That reminds me of something the New Scientist published years ago, ahh yes, the thermonuclear cat flap...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Paul_Pedrick#Chromatical...
You couldn't make this stuff up.