News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by mixmastamyk on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @10:51AM (#29176020)
Reliable OSs were a thing for quite a while by the 90s. Didn’t have to contend with the variety of input from today however.
Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by bigbizisverywyz on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @11:37AM (#29176688)
I think you're a decade too soon there.

Windows 95 & 98 would crash pretty frequently. Not as badly as win 3 though. NT 4.0 was no bastion of stability either. Windows didn't stabilize until well after Win2000 versions.

MacOS 7 & 8 also not great. The first versions of OS X were also pretty flaky.

In my experience dependable reliability of workstations and servers didn't happen until the mid-2000s where just software couldn't simply blue screen an OS, or lock it up forever.

If I remember rightly it was about that time that MS got serious about driver reliability, which seemed to help a lot.

Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by oneplane on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @11:55AM (#29176966)
The middle versions seem to be the best ones somehow. Sire, the cooperative multitasking model of Mac OS 9 was a bit, crappy, but it was really reliable if you went to work at it from a task-oriented perspective. Same for Windows 2000, more stable than Windows XP for some reason.

For Mac OS X it was 10.3 to 10.5 that was the (seemingly) most stable.

I think the scope and size of hardware, software and interaction has just gone so large that it's not commercially viable anymore to test or QA the entire system to the same standard. It's also why service managers came along, we just assume that everything breaks and hope restarting it makes it go away...

Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by Jetrel on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:46PM (#29178639)
My recollection of (Apple's) System 7 is that it really got bitten by the rise of programs running dynamic code (i.e. Netscape). When everyone was operating on relatively pre-vetted apps, which had their buffer overflows cleaned up, it played pretty nice, but when that wasn't the case, it really blew up.

System 7.5 was rather worse-off than 7.0, but it got absolutely slammed because it was the first major mac OS that got saddled with web browsing, and the OS was just not fit to handle apps that had buffer overflows.

That was the big thing about those mac OSes; since they had no memory protection, if any app on the system buffer overflowed, it'd crash everything. It was fine in an environment where you really were only running one or two apps that were known to be really rock-solid, but it wasn't able to police misbehaving apps.

Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by dijit on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:44PM (#29178605)
UNIX's from the 90s were so reliable that there were memes about it.

"I run Solaris, so you know my machine restarts as often as I get laid."

Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by nitrogen on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @11:50AM (#29176886)
Maybe they're not talking about the currently surviving mainstream consumer OSes? There were other contenders that weren't for consumers or didn't survive MS's bullying, and on the other end there's probably a reason mainframes are still in use in places.
Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by mixmastamyk on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @11:54AM (#29176943)
No, not heard of mainframes or VMS? Unix?

Next-gen NT 3.X was rock-solid (from memory).

Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by hnlmorg on Thursday November 11, 2021 @03:25AM (#29185725)
The context here is desktop systems, not mainframes.

Though the interesting takeaway from your comparison is the fact that desktops these days run server kernels, which is a testament to the build quality of servers.

Which segues nicely into a recap of my point: 90s desktop systems didn't have memory protection et al so one buggy application would cause the system to crash. Everything was carefully layered like a house of cards. The switch to NT and UNIX largely fixed most of those issues but later builds of macOS seem as buggy to me as Win 9x and MacOS 8 and 9 were.

Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by mixmastamyk on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:10PM (#29230468)
There were a number of reliable desktop systems by the 90s, if you wanted to spend extra money for it.
Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by hnlmorg on Tuesday November 16, 2021 @05:46AM (#29239066)
You're conflating workstations with personal computers.

In the 90s systems like OS/2 and NeXT were defined as "workstations" to make a distinction between the old lineage of personal computing platforms (like Win 9x and Mac OS running on typically budget hardware) from high end systems running typically multi-user systems (often literally mainframe OSs).

Post-90s and the "workstation" definition went away when NeXT became OS X and NT replaced the DOS-bootloaded Windows lineage; and dedicated workstation hardware became cost ineffective due to improvements in consumer hardware -- not least of all x86 (and later AMD64).

But in the 90s the distinction was real.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Workstation

Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by mixmastamyk on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:07PM (#29181593)
Just remembered OS/2 Warp.
Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by jeffbee on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @11:45AM (#29176808)
MacOS in the mid-90s would crash if you sneezed. It would crash if you tried to scan a photo, crash if the network got unplugged, every Mac on the local network would crash if one of them crashed, it would crash if you touched the mouse while burning a CD, it would crash if you just left it alone for too long.
Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by mixmastamyk on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:10PM (#29181621)
Only with a lot of extensions, which I never did.
Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by jeffbee on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @07:17PM (#29182799)
All of those use cases I mentioned required extensions, though. CD-R, slide scanner, all that stuff usually wanted extensions.
Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by grishka on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @11:34AM (#29176633)
Didn't most of the mainstream 90s OSes lack memory protection AND use cooperative multitasking, which meant one bug in an app and the entire system crashes or freezes?
Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by Jetrel on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:06PM (#29179927)
Yeah, most of them did; especially most of the holdovers from the 80s.

This was one of the big draws to pulling down "mainframe/workstation" systems like unix (or what MS did by hiring what IIRC was the VMS team to build NT) onto desktop machines. These mainframe systems actually had memory protection, and more generally, had been built to do what "pc OSes" hadn't been designed to do, which was running several programs at once, for long periods of time, and juggling resource contention between them.

DOS machines, CP/M machines, Apples, Macs, Commodores, and several other early machines were pretty tactfully designed to avoid the (too heavy for their hardware) complexity of that by simply building themselves to run only one program at a time. There were hacks to let you run multiple programs (like the Multifinder in MacOS 6, which got mainlined into being a permanent thing in 7), but they were just that — hacks. They were fragile.

As computers started taking on the burden of juggling tons of different simultaneous programs, this fragility really started to blow up on them, and these previously "seeming stable" systems started to crash all the time.

Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by oneplane on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @11:58AM (#29176999)
Yep, to some degree at least. Even some more modern systems after that had some similar problems, where there was less or no direct interaction anymore and userspace and kernelspace was the 'best' boundary there was to offer. But the same problems still persisted within the space if the other one goes down.

Imagine having a fully functional app but you still can't do anything because the service 'on the other side' doesn't work. It's better because it won't crash the entire system, but it's the same because you still can't do the work you intended to do...

Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by p_l on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:06PM (#29177111)
No, that's pretty much MacOS Classic and classic windows line before 9x (9x added /some/ level of protection and preemption)
Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by grishka on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:32PM (#29177446)
> (9x added /some/ level of protection and preemption)

I do remember games freezing windows 9x so much that you had to reach for that reset button. Also when the system threw up a BSOD if you ejected a CD when you weren't supposed to.

Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by p_l on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:13PM (#29179112)
The latter was due to lack in error messaging to userspace - so you ended up with the only way the kernel could raise the error involved.

Games often did things that put the system out of whack, and while 9x had preemption for 32bit code (16bit was cooperative as separate thread, iirc) it wasn't impossible to break the OS state by simply putting bits of hw in weird state or by using a lot of resources.

Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by hnlmorg on Thursday November 11, 2021 @03:56AM (#29185925)
There were user space errors when an application crashed[1]. Hardware operations run in the kernel space so if the hardware is in a weird space it doesn't matter how good your user space is coded, it's down to the kernel to capture that error handle it. In fact this was one of the big arguments in the 90s in favour of micro kernels vs monolithic kernels -- albeit history has now taught us that we can have monolithic kernels and protection against drivers and/or hardware failing.

Any BSOD in Windows is a kernel panic. Most of the BSODs I recall were directly down Windows getting itself into a state that it couldn't recover from. Like IRQ errors, memory errors, etc. And it was often very easy for an application to force a BSOD. I remember this well as someone learning Win32 APIs "by experimentation".

Also to say you "it wasn't impossible to break 9x by using a lot of resources" but that is a huge understatement. Even today tou can still break modern operating systems by using too many resources and they have far better protections (OOM killer, smarter paging and stored on media with orders of magnitude higher IOPS, multi-core CPUs that offer true parallelism of operations, etc). 9x, on the other hand, had very little to protect you in that regard. I couldn't even estimate the number of times I've hit ctrl+alt+del on Windows 9x, preying there is enough capacity for the OS to kick in the task manager[2], which back then would also suspend all operations of other applications, thus allowing me to manually terminate whatever processes were causing Windows to grind to a halt.

As an aside, it was also possible for applications to hide themselves from task manager too. I had great fun playing around with writing a remote administration tool for college (sadly not for "official" purposes...) so figured out a number of tricks in 95 to work around user permissions, task management, and so on and so forth. Basically 9x was a playground where running applications could pretty much do whatever they wanted.

[1] https://telcontar.net/store/archive/CrashGallery/images/cras...

[2] https://telcontar.net/store/archive/CrashGallery/images/cras...

Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by mixmastamyk on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:59PM (#29178855)
If by mainstream you mean cheap? Yes. But if you wanted to spend money on reliability it was the original option.
Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by culopatin on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:47PM (#29180540)
I think your nostalgia is talking. 90s crashes are what got me in IT and the badge of “the cousin you call when your computer doesn’t work”. All because of windows 98 crashes. Then my Masters was Windows Me. That was the boss to beat.
Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by mixmastamyk on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:04PM (#29181569)
Inexperience talking, thinking the entire industry revolved around Win98 because you used it. Answers are in sibling threads.
Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by gommm on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @11:40AM (#29176742)
I'd say 2000s, 90s gave us windows 9x and ME which were far from being reliable. Same for Mac Os 7 & 8.
Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by mixmastamyk on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:24PM (#29178285)
No, VMS and Unix were robust by the late '70s. Mainframes earlier. 386BSD debuted in '92.
Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by hnlmorg on Thursday November 11, 2021 @04:05AM (#29185988)
Most people weren't running VMS nor Unix as their desktop OS in the 90s. Post-90s we had OS X (Unix) and Windows 2000/XP (NT)...basically the servers became consumer desktop operating systems because Microsoft and Apple realised exactly your point (and desktop hardware became powerful enough to run it too).

And that brings me back to my original point: recent versions macOS feels like a departure from the rock solid mainframe platforms and a return to the old monolithic kernels that would panic every few days.

Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by mixmastamyk on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:20PM (#29230627)
Yes and no. My point was that reliability is old... older than the desktop. It was invented by the 70s and came to the desktop by the 90s, a few years after the 386 made it possible and the price was brought down to an extra thousand dollars or so.

Also, there is nothing special about a "server operating systems," it's just another application. Reliability came from hardware and OS isolation, which costs more. Too costly for end-users in the 80s, reasonable for those who cared by the mid-90s. Which is what my original comment said.

NT, OS/2, 386BSD... all from the 90s, Q.E.D.

Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by hnlmorg on Tuesday November 16, 2021 @05:27AM (#29238943)
> Yes and no. My point was that reliability is old... older than the desktop. It was invented by the 70s and came to the desktop by the 90s, a few years after the 386 made it possible and the price was brought down to an extra thousand dollars or so.

I don't know about you but I wasn't running Internet Explorer on 386BSD in the mid 90s. :P I do get your point -- I honestly do -- and it is a well formed one too. Unfortunately you're missing the context of the conversation by listing all these workstations. Instability of the main personal computing platforms was a real thing. Listing niche platforms and workstations doesn't change the everyday trauma that the majority of desktop users faced.

> Also, there is nothing special about a "server operating systems," it's just another application. Reliability came from hardware and OS isolation, which costs more.

You second sentence contradicts your first sentence. In fact your second sentence basically agrees with an earlier point I'm making despite it being prefixed by a sentence that reads like you're trying to disagree with it.

> Too costly for end-users in the 80s, reasonable for those who cared by the mid-90s. Which is what my original comment said.

I think you're overestimating the budget most households had in the mid-90s. And definitely overestimating the capabilities of most desktop users. In 1995 I wasn't even running an Intel CPU, instead having cheap knock off that lacked a number of features (it might have been Cyrix but I'm not 100% sure). Let alone a workstation.

Your post is very typical of the "you could just..." meme on HN where a comment starts out making a claim that something is easy and then goes on to list something that is very much specialised tech and well outside the realm of "easy" for your average user.

> NT, OS/2, 386BSD... all from the 90s, Q.E.D.

As were BeOS, NeXT and plenty of others. And in fact I personally did run BeOS, Linux, (amongst others) in the late 90s -- when I eventually replaced the Intel-clone with a workstation class board (and it was a fantastic bit of hardware too: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ABIT_BP6 ). But my point wasn't that no stable platforms existed -- obviously they did. The point was instability was a common pain for personal computing in the 90s. Even with BeOS and Linux installed I still found I needed to drop back to Windows regularly for specific tasks and I'm in the top 1% of technically capable users. So imagine what the other 99% were stuck with.

This is where you're talking cross purposes. You're making a point nobody technically disagrees with but equally nobody was technically discussing either. You're making an academic point that doesn't contradict the spirit of the conversation.

Re:M1 Pro and M1 Max MBP owners complain of crashes playing ... by mixmastamyk on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:10PM (#29181627)
NT 3.x, OS/2 for the enterprise folks.