News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by m0sa on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:52AM (#29158546)
I'd expect at least a hash of the image to be stored on the blockhain..
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by framecowbird on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:56AM (#29158583)
Exactly. I don't understand this. What's the half life of a URI? A year?

Surely we're going to see a whole bunch of the links replaced with porn any day now..

Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by vbezhenar on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:55AM (#29158574)
NFT is low tech scam. I'm surprised so much money were attracted. Must be very good marketing campaign.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by arcticbull on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:57AM (#29158592)
Lots of wash trading to bid up prices and create the impression of enthusiasm. Drags in the suckers. Like Logan Paul and his 99.9% loss on a $600,000 investment. He is the biggest fool. [1] But hey, he was in it for the tech/art right? He's still got the weird yellow robot bee thing.

[1] https://twitter.com/coffeebreak_YT/status/145670132936840397...

Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by LurkingPenguin on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:57AM (#29158590)
The best scams are usually low tech or even no tech.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by can16358p on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:13AM (#29158699)
The idea of NFT is not scam, but the current scene is more like it. Not exactly like scam but more like a super-hyped balloon.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by vbezhenar on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:18AM (#29158729)
I'd expect better technical foundation to sell something so expensive. Like guaranteed formats, guarantees for storing hashes, unique guarantees, some kind of image perceptual hash, some kind of P2P distributed storage for data itself. So even non-technical buyer can be sure that goods he bought are protected. Right now you need to ensure that NFT data is stored on IPFS, you need to ensure that IPFS data including that JSON file will not disappear, you need to check blockchain to prevent multiple sells (and you can't prevent someone to sell dupes in the future).

Right now NFT seems like few bytes pretending to be some kind of URL and that's about it.

Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by can16358p on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @03:36AM (#29159130)
Sure, I agree with your technical foundation views.

What I meant is that the basic idea of NFTs is promising, but the current implementation is nothing practical.

Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by Kiro on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @05:14AM (#29159758)
None of that matters. What gives NFT its value is that it was minted by X. It's purely a social contract so it doesn't need any technical foundation.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by quotemstr on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:57AM (#29158587)
Yeah. That's the shocking thing: I can understand offloading the raster data storage to various external services, but a hash is practically free to store and provides a kind of verifiability that a mere URL doesn't. Seems like an egregious oversight.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by vbezhenar on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:59AM (#29158609)
IPFS URL actually contains hash or something like that.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by soco on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @03:56AM (#29159259)
The article fails to underline that if you want anything serious you would use IPFS URIs and pin it at least once. I would say, they don't know much technically and just jumped on the bandwagon. Because the serious aren't many in this NFT area.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by hoten on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:55AM (#29158568)
Wait, is this not how it works? Seemed like a safe assumption...
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by TheDong on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:17AM (#29158721)
It does not contain a hash, and the image may vary over time or based on the requesting server.

See Moxie's tweet thread showing this experimentally: https://twitter.com/moxie/status/1448066579611234305

Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by robertlagrant on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:03AM (#29158633)
Yeah it's an encrypted thing pointing to a URL which has a JSON file in it that contains a URL of an image.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by can16358p on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:14AM (#29158704)
It's not even encrypted.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by robertlagrant on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @08:23AM (#29161372)
Yes. You're right. I mean it's a thing signed on the blockchain that points at a URL that has a JSON file that points to another URL.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by renewiltord on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:56AM (#29158581)
No. The value in the thing is in the key that minted it. Think of it like a signed baseball: easy to replicate, but the original is worthwhile.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by quotemstr on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:59AM (#29158611)
Sure. But a hash is so easy to compute and store that there's really no excuse for not including one.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by renewiltord on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:01AM (#29158626)
I don’t understand. What purpose does the hash provide?
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by thephyber on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @07:16AM (#29160664)
The NFT is a pointer to content (pointed by a URL). If the underlying content at that URL changes, the assumptions about the original NFT minting / first transaction change.

Bundling a cryptographic hash with the original NFT assertion of content accurately describes the content the NFT was intended to be minted for.

Example analogy: an NFT is like a receipt for a baseball card signed by a player. If the NFT is minted when the URL to the content points to a baseball card for Player A (popular player rookie card), but someone hijacks the domain or the URL and changes the content of that URL to Player B (no-name player who only lasted half a season in the pro league), that hijacker has performed a misrepresentation/fraud. The hash doesn't prevent the content swap, but it provides assurance that the content still matches the original intent of the NFT minting.

Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by renewiltord on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:06AM (#29163551)
But that makes the NFT less valuable. If the content at the url changes without the hash you still have a useful NFT. With the hash, your NFT is burned when it changes.

As a buyer I would want that one less. In the fraud case adding the hash damages only me.

Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by hoten on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:53PM (#29181434)
Without a hash you just simply trust the issuer unconditionally? And you prefer this trust over a cryptographic guarantee the content, and thus the meaning, of the NFT won't change?

This whole NFT really is inscrutable.

Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by renewiltord on Thursday November 11, 2021 @04:11AM (#29186040)
I see what you mean. By producing the content you can verify the cryptographic hash. Okay, I misunderstood previously.

Yes, that is meaningful. What usually happens in the case is you just as well use a content-addressing system like ipfs for the URI.

Yes, you could just as well store just the hash. Very reasonable.

Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by Kiro on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:52AM (#29158916)
Why are people downvoting this? It's a very good point: the value of the NFT is the fact that it was minted by X. Nothing else really matters and what's stored in the NFT is just fluff.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by arcticbull on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:56AM (#29158576)
Even if it is, you can't really reconstitute the image from the SHA. I mean, unless we just created a new proof of waste algorithm.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by quotemstr on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:58AM (#29158602)
You can't rebuild the image from the hash, but you can query various content-addressed stores for the image, potentially letting proof-of-space cryptocurrency systems do double duty as both verifiable resource commitments and repositories of blockchain external data.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by arcticbull on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:00AM (#29158615)
Proof of wasted space. Proof of space algorithms just fill hard drives with garbage.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by quotemstr on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:01AM (#29158622)
Better than continuously burning electricity, yes? And if the stored data is actually useful, is the net result all that bad?
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by arcticbull on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:09AM (#29158668)
I mean, it's still worse than not doing any of this lol, and that's the null hypothesis we should be using. Yes, getting stabbed is better than getting shot, but maybe stay inside and fire up a nice S3 bucket.

The real problem is any proof of resource scheme immediately becomes a grey goo where folks are incentivized to consume literally all that resource wether it makes sense or not. It has no negative feedback loop. It cannot make sense.

Also, because of market pricing of the tokens businesses cannot actually leverage it (as they don't want wacky prices that vary by the minute) so you're left with, as usual, illegal content, gambling, speculation and other misc crime. Basically why Filecoin has a small rack of hard drives' worth of stored data and Chia has exabytes and exabytes of garbage - or did, does anyone care about that one anymore?

It makes more sense to just store garbage if your goal is to run a neat little pyramid scheme.

Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by Dylan16807 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:02AM (#29158628)
If they store images instead then it's not garbage.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by Dylan16807 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:00AM (#29158617)
Reconstitute no. Get yes. A hash is much better than an average filename is much better than somesite/NFT_4556.jpg
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain by fomine3 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:16AM (#29158717)
This. Surprising.