Surely we're going to see a whole bunch of the links replaced with porn any day now..
[1] https://twitter.com/coffeebreak_YT/status/145670132936840397...
Right now NFT seems like few bytes pretending to be some kind of URL and that's about it.
What I meant is that the basic idea of NFTs is promising, but the current implementation is nothing practical.
See Moxie's tweet thread showing this experimentally: https://twitter.com/moxie/status/1448066579611234305
Bundling a cryptographic hash with the original NFT assertion of content accurately describes the content the NFT was intended to be minted for.
Example analogy: an NFT is like a receipt for a baseball card signed by a player. If the NFT is minted when the URL to the content points to a baseball card for Player A (popular player rookie card), but someone hijacks the domain or the URL and changes the content of that URL to Player B (no-name player who only lasted half a season in the pro league), that hijacker has performed a misrepresentation/fraud. The hash doesn't prevent the content swap, but it provides assurance that the content still matches the original intent of the NFT minting.
As a buyer I would want that one less. In the fraud case adding the hash damages only me.
This whole NFT really is inscrutable.
Yes, that is meaningful. What usually happens in the case is you just as well use a content-addressing system like ipfs for the URI.
Yes, you could just as well store just the hash. Very reasonable.
The real problem is any proof of resource scheme immediately becomes a grey goo where folks are incentivized to consume literally all that resource wether it makes sense or not. It has no negative feedback loop. It cannot make sense.
Also, because of market pricing of the tokens businesses cannot actually leverage it (as they don't want wacky prices that vary by the minute) so you're left with, as usual, illegal content, gambling, speculation and other misc crime. Basically why Filecoin has a small rack of hard drives' worth of stored data and Chia has exabytes and exabytes of garbage - or did, does anyone care about that one anymore?
It makes more sense to just store garbage if your goal is to run a neat little pyramid scheme.