Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain
by renewiltord on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:06AM
(#29163551)
But that makes the NFT less valuable. If the content at the url changes without the hash you still have a useful NFT. With the hash, your NFT is burned when it changes.
As a buyer I would want that one less. In the fraud case adding the hash damages only me.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain
by hoten on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:53PM
(#29181434)
Without a hash you just simply trust the issuer unconditionally? And you prefer this trust over a cryptographic guarantee the content, and thus the meaning, of the NFT won't change?
This whole NFT really is inscrutable.
Re:NFT misconception: JPEG aren't stored on the Blockchain
by renewiltord on Thursday November 11, 2021 @04:11AM
(#29186040)
I see what you mean. By producing the content you can verify the cryptographic hash. Okay, I misunderstood previously.
Yes, that is meaningful. What usually happens in the case is you just as well use a content-addressing system like ipfs for the URI.
Yes, you could just as well store just the hash. Very reasonable.
Bundling a cryptographic hash with the original NFT assertion of content accurately describes the content the NFT was intended to be minted for.
Example analogy: an NFT is like a receipt for a baseball card signed by a player. If the NFT is minted when the URL to the content points to a baseball card for Player A (popular player rookie card), but someone hijacks the domain or the URL and changes the content of that URL to Player B (no-name player who only lasted half a season in the pro league), that hijacker has performed a misrepresentation/fraud. The hash doesn't prevent the content swap, but it provides assurance that the content still matches the original intent of the NFT minting.