I regularly use my crypto-backed (ie balance is in cryptocurrencies) Binance Visa card to make purchases. I have some money in cryptocurrency exchanges because their lending (used to lend to margin traders) systems have better interest rates than my banks savings accounts do and when I want to use the money I use my crypto-backed Visa card.
I suppose you can argue this is only possible because of the margin traders, but for me it acts as a higher interest savings account that’s a good place to keep some money that I don’t need immediately accessible (I need to move it to the card to use it) but is still accessible if I need to make a purchase with it.
In the past I’ve also used cryptocurrencies to transfer money between myself (I’m in Europe) and family in Australia, as a cheaper faster means of transfer than international bank transfer or western union.
So there are at least some legitimate uses, even if the criminal uses outnumber them.
To the user, this is transparent (for some cards anyway, eg Binance), so its effectively the same thing. Yes, I'm not actually sending the merchant crypto, but what does it matter? I am using my crypto balance to buy things, the fact that the merchant isn't receiving crypto is an implementation detail. Conceptually, it could be a choice left up to them.
The question was if anyone is using cryptocurrencies for legitimate purposes and I was saying that I am using cryptocurrencies to buy things, I didn't say that the people I'm buying things from are receiving the cryptocurrencies and to me it makes little difference if they are or aren't, I have a crypto balance that I use to buy things.
In the context of the question, it matters a lot. You're not using it as tendered currency.
The question was who is buying things legitimately with crypto, and your Binance card isn't that. You're buying things legitimately with that card... ...with real currency.
Why merchants prefer real currency to crypto is left as an exercise for the reader.
The question was: "Anybody actually uses crypto for legal goods and services?"
I am using crypto to buy suff, how it is facilitated under the hood is an implementation detail and none of my concern. I am using and spending cryptocurrencies to buy things. My balance on the card is currently primarily USDT (and some ETH). Not dollars, not pounds, not euro: a cryptocurrency. The fact that technically they sell that USDT to fiat when I make a purchase is transparent to me and not something I have to care about.
You could just as easily be exchanging black tar heroin for real currency and using that to make your purchases.
Are you then using heroin to acquire goods and services?
If I used a US credit card to buy something from a European store with prices in euro, am I spending USD from my USD balance or am I spending euro? From my perspective, I would say that I’m spending USD, even though the bank is exchanging it to euro under the hood and sending the merchant euro. How is it any different with crypto in my case?
It's a simple distinction.
Okay, less emotive comparison - you hold gold as a store of value. You liquidate some for US dollars, and then use those to purchase goods and services.
Again, did you buy those goods and services with gold, or with US dollars?
Some of the newfangled DeFi cryptocurrencies try to get around this, but of course they can't offer a visa card.
As with all things, its a trade-off. For me, Binance is a better trade-off than my bank, for the things I use Binance for. I also don't exclusively use Binance and I do keep some of my crypto in my own wallets, separately from the centralized exchanges.
From the perspective of the customer, you only ever see the dollars: that's what your account contains and that's what the number that goes down in exchange for the goods. Yes, behind the scenes, your bank turns that into Euro (liquidates the gold for you, in your example) and sends the Euro to the merchant, so as far as the merchant is concerned, the transaction is in Euro, but from the customers perspective, everything happened in USD.
I'm not arguing that you're not correct, that you are technically buying goods in Euro, what I'm saying is that from the customers perspective it may as well be in USD.
For the cryptocurrencies, of course I'm technically buying in USD, on-demand liquidating the cryptocurrencies to USD in the process, but from the customer experience, I may as well be transacting cryptocurrencies and I am spending my cryptocurrencies (via a transparent exchange behind the scenes) to make the purchase, just like a USD card holder spends their USD (via a transparent exchange behind the scenes) to make their Euro purchase and just how you would liquidate your gold (assuming there was a "gold" visa card where the bank handled the liquidation for you transparently behind the scenes) to make a USD purchase.
From my perspective, when I use the Binance card, I am using my crypto to buy something. How that works isn't relevant to me. I don't see the USD[1], I see my crypto balance go down and I get the purchased item. For all intents and purposes, I am using crypto to buy things. If I didn't have the crypto, I wouldn't be able to buy things with that card.
What the customer sees matters, since the money in a non-gold-backed account is just a number anyway, you're not really "spending" anything. But from the customers perspective, the number represents the USD (or whatever) that's in their account. When they make that number go down, that's what they're spending. If the bank decides that for some reason its more efficient to convert the money to GBP first, then to Euro and then back to USD, good for them, it doesn't affect the customer. Its an "implementation detail".
Or another scenario: What if I use a USD card to make a Euro purchase, but the merchants account is in GBP? (A UK-based business with an EU-localized store, perhaps) I am buying in USD, the actual purchase transaction happened in Euro and the merchant only ever sees GBP. You seem to be arguing that only the middle bit, the Euro transaction, matters. I'm saying which part matters depends on the observer: for me, the USD part is what matters, for the bank the Euro part might be the most important and for the merchant its the GBP part. For all intents and purposes, I spent USD, the merchant received GBP, but the bank processed Euro. The dictionary says "spend" means "to use up" or to "pay out" (and pay is to give), I'm using up the USD in this example.
[1] I mean, technically I do: the merchant quotes their price in USD and Binance does of course let you see the USD equivalent balance of your cryptocurrencies
Edit - “For now” is critical. Who knows what the next five years will bring??
Which, of course, would not be a very convincing argument to the vast majority of the population who aren't libertarians, including me.
Governments do stupid things all the time, and Crypto currencies is a great technology to keep governments honest. Even if most activity remained illegal (It won't) it would STILL be a beneficent technology. This illegal business is done with or without crypto, regardless.
A government once made being a Jew illegal and that was bad.
Therefore any government making anything illegal is bad.
That appears to be your logic, or am I missing something?
Why are drugs illegal? In a large part because black people used them. Also in part, because it threatened the traditional American way of life people were attached to.
Other than that, you need internet for your transactions. Guess who has the power to control the grid? Crypto does not make you independent in absolut terms. There might always be a way to access the internet, but only for those capable - and this won't be the one you're buying food from.
For now. Top level domain registration has already moved to crypto. Elon is working on Starlink. Wireless data transfer technologies are coming for a peer based internet infrastructure.
At this rate, I don’t know if that’s ever going to come about.. looks like it’s just gotten bogged down in ways to increase its value at the cost of its utility..
Even theoretically, how can they do this? I don't see it happening, even setting aside the much rehashed mining electricity consumption issue.
Yeah, theoretically it just used $2 worth of electricity somewhere in the world, but I’m pretty sure PayPal is going to do something nefarious with the $100+ you’d have to give them for the same service
All the hype benefits of pretending to use blockchain, without ever actually using it.
The tldr is thst Lightning is as safe as bitcoin because it uses bitcoin under the hood.
The website you linked is just a collection of random (and often contradictory, just read a few of the “energy” topic) opinions posted on medium.
The person you’re replying to was (sarcastically? I would’ve been) suggesting a solution, which isn’t any of those things.
As there are different ways to use a thing, and everything I’ve seen of Lightning (network not cable) is using the Blockchain in roughly the same sense as a USD denominated bank that happens to not ban accounts from trading Bitcoin uses the Blockchain — i.e. it does, but it’s very much also pretending — this seems reasonable, if not literal.
Freicoin failed to gain any appreciable adoption on the open market. Despite what people claim — e.g. “currency is supposed to be inflationary, cuz greater good” — when it’s their money on the line, they never choose inflationary money if they can easily opt out of it.
The failure of Freicoin underscores the reality that inflation is an anti-feature of money. No one actually wants inflation — if they have better options, they avoid it every time.
When the US government went off the gold standard, they doomed themselves to a Bitcoin future, because suddenly everyone could see the government’s money was backed by nothing. And if US dollars are backed by nothing, what stops a software developer from launching a competing money which is also backed by nothing? They removed all barriers to entry.
Now that everyone knows government money is backed by nothing, every available currency in this world has become an embarassingly hollow confidence racket. It’s merely a matter of whether you believe private sector confidence games made by competent engineers deliver superior technical/economic qualities compared to government confidence games.
Really, why would you want to hold a money in which a tiny group of people fully control the extent to which your money is debased year after year, when you could instead rely on an apolitical computer algorithm not controlled by anyone with a supply schedule known fully in advance which is auditable in real time using freely available open source software? Doesn’t that sound like a better form of money to you?
Visit “WTF Happened in 1971” [1] for another look at the impact of inflationary economics and currency debasement on middle and lower class people.
That is, people only accepted dollars in the understanding that convertibility wouldn't be suspended, just like they accepted the historical money that Freicoin was modeled after before knowing they'd do the Silvio Gesell scheme. It's an open question whether we've accurately modeled the full knock-on effects of reneging on the promise that got the currency off the ground (though personally I agree with you).
I don't like taxes either, but I also like living in a developed country. Inflation is a kind of tax, so nobody likes it, but at the same time pretty much everyone likes having what this tax provides (in the case of growing money supply, it's the ability to have money at all in circulation in the economy for the layperson).
Interestingly enough those policies where grounded in the same ideological background as today's crypto enthusiasm: Austrian economics.
In the 70's, Keynesian's political influence died (because of inflation haters), and so died the golden age of America, and the lower-income families spiralled to straight poverty. Now, after the 2008 crisis, Keynesianism is in charge again, and some people are really bullish with crypto for ideological reasons (because they've drank too much of the 80-90's propaganda comparing Keynesianism with Communism, really). But using lower and middle class persons as an argument reveals either poor historical knowledge or bad faith. It's pretty ironic anyway.
Year 1, you have $X dollars with $Y - 1 purchasing power.
Etc.
$Y > $Y - 1
Inflation is an anti-feature.
> What can it do for me?
It really sounds like you’ve never held Bitcoin. HN can change that for you really quickly if you’re open to it.
Currencies compete, and ones with inflation which punish holding the currency over the long term are fundamentally less user-friendly.
As long as inflation is low enough, people don't really care about it in general because there salary increases as much (and given than the average American has much more debt than saving, the inflation is actually a gift to them).
So I talked about workers, but how about investors and entrepreneurs? Say I have $10 million today sitting in a bank account. I can either let it sit idle, losing value to inflation every year, or invest it somewhere where it can create value. Now if the value of my $10 million increases in real terms (meaning that my purchasing power will naturally increase when time passes) the most rational thing to do is not to invest that money. It's actually unlikely that my investment will pay off anyway, because the amount of money spent by people will decrease year after year (because that's what deflation means).
I don't think the US is close to spiraling into authoritarianism within my lifetime or my children's lifetimes, but I would caution against rounding the tail risk to zero. Political change is glacially slow, except when it isn't.
Well, after 500 years...
Here is another notion. If you want to be anonymous you have to use anonymous protocols. If you explicit want to be able to track the movement of the tokens you are providing, like if you are a government who wants to ensure money is not moving to incorrect places, this is enabled easily and openly through crypto protocols.
I didn't meant the Nazi Germany thing to be a strawman, I was trying to be humorous while also bringing a historical example of the failings of government that is un-doubtable.
You should keep in mind. Public traceability is the default mode of Crypto. Public ledgering is the foundation of crypto protocols, after all. Only Monero has emerged as a viable anonymous product, and the one most traded on the dark net.
It’s incredibly hard to take anything you said after that seriously. Heck, you just made the exact same logical leap that anti-vaxxers are using to oppose vaccine mandates in Canada. That’s not good…either for dialogue or humanity.
>Heck, you just made the exact same logical leap that anti-vaxxers are using to oppose vaccine mandates in Canada.
At least I'm consistent then. Can you point out where my logical leap is?
You're comparing that to the possibility of banning a currency? There are no parallels between this and the Holocaust. You're consistent, but you're still wrong.
You can’t just default to offensive and think people will trust your silly financial ideas. It’s usually the opposite. Good job promoting your ideas.
Governments not only have the power to restrict the movement of money but tax records and transaction details let them know 90% of the most important details about everyone.
Additionally, sure without crypto there wouldn't wouldn't be these kinds of ransoms but the same attack could be used for terrorism/warfare. These ransoms just provide the incentive to develop solutions. A terrorist attack that had no option to decrypt the data could completely shut down entire countries.