News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data by mach1ne on Monday November 08, 2021 @04:34AM (#29147576)
Very recently they added their first closed-source component to their code, supposedly a spam filter. This sort of went by HN. I can't help but think that the timing with all these requests is rather coincidental.
Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data by Klonoar on Monday November 08, 2021 @04:51AM (#29147667)
It didn't "sort of go by HN", it was on the front page for a bit and had some 97 comments.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29072031

Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data by 0xy on Monday November 08, 2021 @04:43AM (#29147614)
Their server code was closed source for over a year with no explanation, turns out it was to add a shitcoin called "MobileCoin" that Signal's founder has a financial interest in.

Ever since that, I don't think you should consider Signal's server "open source" at all. They've shown they'll conceal, diverge and cover up for their own enrichment. What will they do when they're threatened? Cave.

Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data by nix23 on Monday November 08, 2021 @05:29AM (#29147894)
https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Server

>Last commit 7 Days ago

>AGPL-3.0 License

That's the present

Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data by 0xy on Monday November 08, 2021 @10:53PM (#29157532)
How does this disprove what I said? I said it WAS closed source. It's also not complete anymore, so I think it's still safe to call it closed source.

If there's a single piece of closed source code running on the servers, it ceases to be open source.

Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data by nix23 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @06:26AM (#29160236)
>If there's a single piece of closed source code running on the servers, it ceases to be open source.

Yeah no that's not the definition of opensource, if my opensource mailserver has a closed source spam-scanner, my mail server is still opensource - the spam-scanner

Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data by 0xy on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:21AM (#29173114)
And when the spam scanner looks like:

phone_home_to_nsa(metadata, ip_address, sender, recipient);

Are you still comfortable with this 'open source' project?

Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data by onphonenow on Monday November 08, 2021 @05:12AM (#29147779)
No kidding such a bad look
Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data by approxim8ion on Monday November 08, 2021 @04:40AM (#29147602)
My understanding is that this component was added to their server code. If their clients are still verifyiably encrypting the content and limiting the metadata for your messages, it should not be much of an issue.
Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data by BelenusMordred on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:15AM (#29148164)
Don't really understand the cries for their server code to be constantly updated or even open sourced, you can't ever verify that's what they are running anyway.

Maybe there's some sort of cryptographic attestation out there which could fulfil such purposes but quite sure it's not that practical.

Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data by robryk on Monday November 08, 2021 @07:28AM (#29148618)
That's true and it's one reason I'm not too comfortable with Signal's access to metadata (even though they are the best nonfederated communicator in that regard).

There are a few reasons why I would prefer them to provide source code that they claim is running in the service due to the metadata issue:

a) if it's actually running there, people can find simple bugs in it that could allow that metadata to be stored or revealed by accident,

b) if it's not actually running there, but something very close is (i.e. that code with small amount of patches), then the advantage above still applies and if those patches come to light, they can be easily evaluated for intent and effect,

c) if they're running something completely different (which would be very weird), it'd be noticeable and it would be an obvious lie once exposed.

Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data by robryk on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:12AM (#29148135)
Every time you send a message with Signal, you inform the server which user the message is for. Thus, the server can remember (sending IP, target phone number) pairs and, for similar reasons, (phone number, IP of the user when retrieving messages) pairs. We rely on the server to discard this information; if not discarded, it reveals the social graph and the phone number<->IPs used mapping.
Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data by sam_lowry_ on Monday November 08, 2021 @06:33AM (#29148260)
And since Snowden we know that meta-information is as important as information. So Signal being E2E encrypted goes only halfway towards ensuring the privacy of our communications.
Re:MLAT order from Luxembourg for Signal user data by approxim8ion on Monday November 08, 2021 @09:37AM (#29149684)
I'm aware of this, but it's not like it's a new concern with this piece of code. This has always been the case.