If the former, gradual seeding could leave a persistent effect behind in the form of increased whale populations. Seeding wouldn't just be a one-time exchange of money for CO2 sequestration.
organisms like krill that now have difficulty accreting carbonate structure and surviving due to the increased co2 acidity of the oceans :D
There are also lots of spirals like this that lead to rapid population collapse.
The thing that scares people about climate change is that we don't know when humans will be caught in one of those collapses, but we know that it will happen eventually. There are lots and lots of species that we need to sustain billions of humans.
You never get quite the same thing but convergent evolution can mean extinction isn’t 100% permanent given enough time.
key words "given enough time"
At present, the magnitude of those rates is 100k to 1.
That’s clearly an unsustainable situation.
you're not actually concerned about the space available for new species. you're not even concerned with the species we have now. if you were concerned about species diversity, you would be concerned that we are way below replacement rates. you can't spin a mass extinction as some kind of victory for the liberty of nature.
We don't even understand any single organism or any ecosystem completely.
They’re also not static.
So sounds like removing the whales has removed iron from the system permanently and it can't recover then.