News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel’s Alder Lake big.little CPU design, tested: it’s a ... by vondur on Thursday November 04, 2021 @02:22PM (#29110735)
In the Gamers Nexus review, they were using a high end 360MM AIO cooler and the CPU Temp shot up to 74C almost immediately during a blender session. Definitely a hot, power hungry CPU.
Re:Intel’s Alder Lake big.little CPU design, tested: it’s a ... by smolder on Thursday November 04, 2021 @03:44PM (#29111672)
It seems like all the focus has been on how these chips are at maximum load. I wonder how they perform under more typical light/mixed loads.

AFAIK, the theoretical benefit of doing the big-little arrangement is improved power scaling with load. At partial load, powering a wimpy "e-core" at its ideal clock speed should be more efficient (instructions per kwh) & possibly have better latency characteristics than the usual approach of doing a drastic underclock & undervolt on big performance-oriented cores.

Naturally I'm interested in seeing whether that theoretical advantage of the architecture has paid off. The maximum speed performance stats and wattage numbers give an incomplete picture. I want to see wattage and performance metrics across the spectrum of load levels, from <1% all the way up.

If the 12900K delivers roughly 5950 level performance using 25% more power than the 5950, that looks pretty bad. But if the 12900K can deliver 25% of its max performance for only 10% of its max power envelope, and the 5950 needs 30% of its max power envelope to keep up with that load, that's a big deal, and the intel chip will actually be the cooler one more often than not. That dynamism is what reviewers need to focus on explaining & quantifying, IMO.

Re:Intel’s Alder Lake big.little CPU design, tested: it’s a ... by LordDragonfang on Thursday November 04, 2021 @08:18PM (#29114050)
The LTT review [1] compares full-load-render benchmark tests against more real-world gaming performance, and the temps drop from a sustained 90 degrees to 60 degrees, so you seem to be right, there.

[1] https://youtu.be/-EogHCFd7w0?t=534

Re:Intel’s Alder Lake big.little CPU design, tested: it’s a ... by PragmaticPulp on Thursday November 04, 2021 @08:23PM (#29114077)
> In the Gamers Nexus review, they were using a high end 360MM AIO cooler and the CPU Temp shot up to 74C almost immediately during a blender session.

FWIW, my water cooled AMD Ryzen also shoots up to very high temperatures immediately when loaded. It can touch 80C like a lightswitch.

Water coolers have a lot of thermal mass in the water and the metal radiator. The CPU can't instantly heat all of this up.

What's actually happening is that the turbo boost is pushing the CPU as far as possible within the thermal limits on a short-term basis, then slowly lowering the boost frequency as the temperature saturates. Power consumption is very non-linear, so each additional MHz of boost is a significant amount of additional power. The boost algorithms are designed to spike high for short bursts at the onset of load because most desktop operations require short bursts of single-threaded performance.

Re:Intel’s Alder Lake big.little CPU design, tested: it’s a ... by consp on Friday November 05, 2021 @08:22AM (#29118176)
> FWIW, my water cooled AMD Ryzen also shoots up to very high temperatures immediately when loaded. It can touch 80C like a lightswitch.

It might be interesting to look into a block which covers the chiplets more. Mine does max 55 at normal speeds and PBO max/unlimited power it does about 70C max (and about 220W draw for a 5900X). I have no peaks like you describe. That used to be a bit more with my old water block which had copper on the chiplets but no water channels.

Re:Intel’s Alder Lake big.little CPU design, tested: it’s a ... by merb on Thursday November 04, 2021 @08:45PM (#29114219)
> FWIW, my water cooled AMD Ryzen also shoots up to very high temperatures immediately when loaded. It can touch 80C like a lightswitch.

you should probably looking at a nocturna dh15, no ryzen (on the market) will get to 80° when loaded, not even in long blender sessions) so you probably have a faulty water cooling or smth.

Re:Intel’s Alder Lake big.little CPU design, tested: it’s a ... by podiki on Thursday November 04, 2021 @08:54PM (#29114275)
Newer Ryzens can get plenty hot, and by design, e.g. https://www.pcgamer.com/amd-views-ryzen-5000-cpu-temperature...

In my experience with a 5600X and water cooling (nothing crazy, just an off the shelf AIO) sustained full CPU load will be in the 70s, but I've seen it hit 80 or so briefly.

Re:Intel’s Alder Lake big.little CPU design, tested: it’s a ... by merb on Friday November 05, 2021 @08:40PM (#29126317)
btw. i use a nh-dh15 and run the blender test and i only did go to ~65° maybe I was lucky with the silicion tough. but the stock cooler was horrible.
Re:Intel’s Alder Lake big.little CPU design, tested: it’s a ... by PragmaticPulp on Thursday November 04, 2021 @08:52PM (#29114265)
Definitely not faulty cooling. I have a 3950X on an NH-D15 in the other PC and it does the same thing. Not an amateur when it comes to cooling.

The Ryzen temperature spikes are a well-known phenomenon: https://www.google.com/search?q=ryzen+temperature+spikes

Re:Intel’s Alder Lake big.little CPU design, tested: it’s a ... by snuxoll on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:12PM (#29111979)
What's the die size of the ADL silicon? I know my 5800X will rocket up past 70C even on a custom loop with 30C water temps because the chiplets are so small and power dense that there's not enough surface area to transfer heat any quicker to the IHS.
Re:Intel’s Alder Lake big.little CPU design, tested: it’s a ... by fomine3 on Thursday November 04, 2021 @10:21PM (#29114777)
It must be hot because Intel set very high PL1/PL2 for 12900K. I'd like to see realistic performance comparison like PL1/PL1=150W.
Re:Intel’s Alder Lake big.little CPU design, tested: it’s a ... by zeusk on Thursday November 04, 2021 @03:37PM (#29111602)
immediate temp fluctuation is more of a heat transfer problem, not overall thermal budget.