News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kazakhstan to restrict crypto miners amid power shortages by adventured on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @11:02AM (#29095650)
> And at best crypto provides extremely limited utility for society.

Whenever you sell it, if you generated a profit on that sale, you are going to pay taxes on it (at least in the US).

That's a real value for society. Can it ever be enough to offset the added squeeze on the electricity grid (which we really don't need right now, with EVs coming on and our grid in serious need of upgrade/expansion)? Someone will have to do the math on that.

Re:Kazakhstan to restrict crypto miners amid power shortages by lottin on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @11:22AM (#29095938)
No. Your profit from trading bitcoins is someone else's loss. The amount wealth in society remains unchanged, only it's allocated differently. Total value added = zero. A tax on profits doesn't add any value either, it's just an additional re-allocation of the same wealth.
Re:Kazakhstan to restrict crypto miners amid power shortages by trevyn on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @12:32PM (#29096935)
That’s not strictly true; some forms of capital allocation increase future productivity (and therefore future wealth) at a greater rate than others.
Re:Kazakhstan to restrict crypto miners amid power shortages by TomSwirly on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @03:01PM (#29098890)
Crypto transactions cannot create or destroy fiat currency.

If you buy and hold cryptocurrency, at no time will it produce "dividends" in fiat currency, or physical objects like cell phones.

So if you make money by selling some cryptocoin, that is _entirely_ because someone else purchased it at a greater price than you did.

Their expectation is that someone else will later buy it at a greater price from them, and that person will be buying it on the hope that someone will pay yet more again.

No actual cashflows appear anywhere in this process.

What happens when there isn't a new Greater Fool?

Re:Kazakhstan to restrict crypto miners amid power shortages by ilammy on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @06:38PM (#29101371)
> at no time will it produce "dividends" in fiat currency, or physical objects like cell phones

Why it has to be physical? One could use cryptocurrencies to pay for virtual things on virtual internet, which are nevertheless thought to be meaningful.

Like, fiat currencies exist as a way of paying taxes to your government and also you can exchange them for goods and services.

Re:Kazakhstan to restrict crypto miners amid power shortages by trevyn on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @03:47PM (#29099415)
The value of fiat could go to zero.