News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:12PM (#29074527)
I was hoping to click through to see what they’re talking about, but apparently this letter is the entire company.

It reads to me like they were parking on the name and FB got there first (with regards to actually using the name). And we should care why? “Stole our name and livelihood” is ridiculous here.

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by anyfactor on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:21PM (#29074638)
This is just ridiculous. I hope this post gets removed because it is now going to get picked up by major news organization and it might even overshadow the real and current problems of Facebook.

This reminds me of this sketch: https://youtu.be/pvjgIxuVdo4

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by pietrovismara on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:20PM (#29074619)
Read again:

> One more thing: Our new product launch just got delayed because of Facebook. We must deal with these matters. In the coming weeks, we will make an announcement earlier than we expected. We promise it will be good. Stay tuned.

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by filoleg on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:25PM (#29074695)
How does it change anything? If I understand it correctly, they are a company with no existing product, and yet Facebook somehow stole their name and livelihood?

Stealing name implies that the company previously had some value attached to that name, such as recognition or a product. So far they have neither. I understand that it is unfortunate it happened to them, but given that the company doesn't even have a product launched yet, changing the name to something else shouldn't cause much trouble.

But on the bright side, at least now they have an excuse ready in case their company flops. And a lot of people who could sympathize with them too, because "facebook bad". Media loves this stuff, because it prints clicks and views like hotcakes.

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by gnu8 on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:27PM (#29074735)
All I'm hearing is that Facebook is entitled to a name someone else was already using because they are a wealthy and successful company and I am not convinced.
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by filoleg on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:32PM (#29074796)
The argument isn't about whether FB is entitled to the name. FB might not be entitled to that name, and I am not saying they are.

All I am saying is that the claim of Meta (non-FB one) about their "name and livelihood being stolen" is ridiculous and difficult to take at face value, given they have no product and no name-recognition.

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by gigglesupstairs on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:44PM (#29074913)
Do you have any internal knowledge of product this company is working on and hence it is of no real value to “you”? How much time have they been working on this product? What’s the cost involved? How many people? Does it really matter whether they have a live product or if it is successful or not if it doesn’t affect the real topic here, which is of identity?
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by filoleg on Monday November 01, 2021 @08:16PM (#29075193)
> Do you have any internal knowledge of product this company is working on and hence it is of no real value to “you”?

Regardless of what they are working on, if it doesn't exist, the value of it is presently zero.

Also, as others have mentioned, FB fully legally bought the trademark on Meta back in 2017 (through Chan-Zuckerberg Initiative). The company in the OP has no claims towards the name. Well, it appears they have a trademark on Metacompany (no space or dots), while FB (or rather, Chan-Zuckerberg Initiative) had the trademark for Meta since 2017. If anything, the company in the article is infringing on a trademark that FB has been the owner of for nearly 4 years.

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by gigglesupstairs on Monday November 01, 2021 @08:43PM (#29075411)
> If anything, the company in the article is infringing on a trademark that FB has been the owner of for nearly 4 years.

I don't disagree with you here.

> if it doesn't exist,

But you don't know that, do you? And that was the intent of my original comment. We can speculate basis the available data all we want, but we don't "know know" that their product doesn't exist. And no, launch of a product is not the only benchmark here.

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by filoleg on Monday November 01, 2021 @08:52PM (#29075474)
>> if it doesn't exist

> But you don't know that, do you?

I think there was a misunderstanding here, so let me clarify.

When I said that the product doesn't exist, I wasn't saying that it was all fake and they made up a non-existent product just to cash in on this controversy.

By saying that it doesn't exist, I meant that there is no released product that anyone can use. Sure, they might have it somewhere on some engineer's machine or desk or whatever internally, no way for us to know. But for all practical intents and purposes, the product isn't released and there is no way for anyone to use it. Hell, there is no way for anyone to even know what the actual product is, and googling didn't help much. And if no one has access to the product and no one knows what it is, then it doesn't exist as a product on the market.

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by mygo on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:07PM (#29076021)
> Regardless of what they are working on, if it doesn't exist, the value of it is presently zero.

That’s not true. Do you know how many multi-million-dollar companies have nothing more than an idea on a paper napkin that they managed to sell to investors? You didn’t even bring up the matter of whether they have investors who have placed a valuation on their business. Or even if they have paid into their own business’ equity, which is then of monetary value.

In fact a business’ monetary valuation has nothing to do with whether it has a product. Some high-value businesses have zero products. If we’re speaking valuation, what matters is the value of the assets they have listed under the business, their liabilities, their owner’s equity, etc.

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by ishyaboibro on Sunday November 07, 2021 @02:04PM (#29142413)
From the USPTO docs and screenshot included within them, they seemed to describe themselves as a provider of services. Their LLC's address is a residential home, which is fine, but a little shady for a company that vaguely states the services it provides, while also having a supposed "product launch" delayed, despite no evidence whatsoever of anyone associated with the company, no SEC filings or white papers, or really anything to prove any of what theyre saying. It's kinda weird.
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by killingtime74 on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:40PM (#29074881)
You can’t “steal” a name. The English language is not up for ownership. Trademarks serve a specific purpose of indicating trade source and are there for public policy reasons. You have to use the trademark in trade for it to be protected.

Furthermore if you use your mark for running a noodle store and me for a shoe store there is no conflict.

If Facebook is within the law (the other guy is not even using it) there is no morality involved. (I am a lawyer)

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by The-Mad-King on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @02:43PM (#29098708)
That is an good point. If the SME is not in the same industry, it would actually work in their favor. They could use some decent SEO and clever but legal word choices for certain lines and logo choices, they could have a ton of internet traffic directed to thier site just by people typing the web address incorrectly.

I did find this: "Meta Company develops augmented reality solutions. It offers Meta 1 and Meta 2 Development Kits for developers and creators, makers and artists, which provide the field of view, access to digital information and direct hand interaction with holograms. The Company serves clients in manufacturing, communication and media, medicine, simulation and education, remote assistance and 3D modeling industries."

NFI what that exactly means, but they are in comm's and media and if that is the same company, thats pretty dam close to facebook's whole "thang" isnt it?

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by marcinzm on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:31PM (#29074793)
Using in what way? Having a domain, no trademark and no product doesn't mean you're using it in any real way.
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by paulgb on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:37PM (#29074856)
It sounds like they do have a trademark:

> At least two law firms were involved: One in the USA that requested our trademark and domains

But everything else you say I agree with. And the trademark was probably on MetaCompany since that seems to be their brand.

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by brailsafe on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:37PM (#29074858)
Did they not mention owning the trademark?
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by marcinzm on Monday November 01, 2021 @09:48PM (#29075863)
No, they mentioned a trademark without saying what it was on exactly which suggest to me it barely overlaps. I didn't find any recent trademarks for 'Meta' in the US that would overlap with Facebook. There's one for selling computer hardware and one for SaaS consulting.
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by brailsafe on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @02:08AM (#29077653)
I have a hard time imagining that it's at all relevant whether or not their business genuinely overlapped. If you're big enough, it doesn't matter unless your target has the means to drag you through court as well. I'm reminded of the Backcountry.com case from a few years ago, where they were apparently hunting down every commercial use of the term Backcountry.

https://www.outsidebusinessjournal.com/issues/the-backcountr...

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by dwild on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @10:04AM (#29081395)
They were using it just as much as Facebook though... and actually less than the Chan Zuckerberg Initiative but that's beside the point I'm making.

Let's say that Meta Company had released their product a month ago, would you have sided with Facebook if they had said that the Meta Conpany stole their name? Funnily enough you probably wouldn't because they are a wealthy and successful company.

No one here is saying Facebook is entitled to that name because they are wealthy. We are saying they are entitled by that name because the Meta Company was still not doing business using that name. No one is entitled to any name, it has nothing to do with wealth. Do the Meta Company had registered a trademark on it already? Well nice, yeah I will side with them and hope that they win the lawsuit (though I wouldn't if they were the equivalent of patents trolls over trademark... which I fear is the case, but I still trust them that they plan to do real business with that name).

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by filoleg on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @01:28PM (#29097752)
>Do the Meta Company had registered a trademark on it already?

From everything I read, it seems like Meta Company has a trademark registered for Metacompany (no space or dots), while Chan-Zuckerberg Initiative has had the trademark for Meta since 2017. Metacompany vs. Meta, and since Zucc is using straight up Meta (without the -company suffix), the outcome seems fairly clear.

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by sp332 on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:36PM (#29074850)
The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative (part-owned by Mark) bought a company called Meta along with its trademark in 2017.
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by soneca on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:31PM (#29074786)
They were using for what?
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by filoleg on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:35PM (#29074835)
For potential free PR for their upcoming product launch (which I am not even sure is real) due to this "controversy".
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by yadaeno on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:32PM (#29074794)
This reads like a kickstarter scam. Also the "Facebook Instagram Twitter" link at the bottom points to an Instagram account with 0 followers, 0 following.
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by dreyfan on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:21PM (#29074628)
That means literally zero.
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:31PM (#29074782)
That's exactly what I meant by parking. Isn't that what it means? Maybe I should have said this letter is the entire company so far.
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by EugeneOZ on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:23PM (#29074679)
If product is not released yet, then their expenses of changing the name are not as huge as they declare.
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by hnlmorg on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:42PM (#29074905)
You don't actually know that though. For all we know MetaCompany might have a large stock pile of branded hardware.

At this point in time all we have is blind speculation based on a piece of PR that might or might not be true.

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by pietrovismara on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:30PM (#29074771)
This doesn't justify what facebook is doing at all. What if I steal 10$ from you? Would it change your life or deprive you of food? Probably not, but that doesn't make it legal to do.
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by bryans on Monday November 01, 2021 @08:17PM (#29075208)
That's not how business works at all. You don't need to have a massive social media presence (or even a website) to be an operational business. And, in fact, a huge portion of startups operate in stealth mode until they are ready for public consumption -- but that doesn't mean they don't have a product or customers or investment.
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by frays on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:25PM (#29074693)
Here is their Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meta_(company)
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by mazlix on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:29PM (#29074753)
That is not the same as Meta, LLC registered in Illinois (made with <3 in Chicago, IL is at the bottom of this page).

https://apps.ilsos.gov/corporatellc/CorporateLlcController

The manager name listed on the Corporate LLC search does not match the founders in the Wikipedia

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by Nicksil on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:26PM (#29074719)
>Here is their Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meta_(company)

Discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29074478

Seems like it may not be the same company.

Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by soco on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @05:35AM (#29078944)
So they took the livelihood etc from somebody else too?
Re:Facebook Stole Our Name and Livelihood by ishyaboibro on Sunday November 07, 2021 @02:11PM (#29142475)
from meta, the AR company? I mean, their headset sort of lost traction a while back. I dont think FB had anything to do with it but considering their current domination of consumer VR I suppose I wouldnt put it past them to taking down/buying up a potential competitor in the AR field.