Hell, outside of technical circles, I doubt most adults are able to truly understand the scope of what FB does!
This is of course to set up a pipeline for new Facebook users. Doesn't have to be bad, but it is what it is and there shouldn't be naive illusions about it.
Also being a constant contrarian is a special flavour here.
On several occasions I've searched for apps by name, and not only are they not in the top few results, the App Store shows me borderline adult content within just a few screens of the top. I have no idea why it is so hard to find apps searching by name, but it is one of the main reasons I don't let my kids use the App Store app.
If we're comparing with Youtube, I can't help but think people aren't looking very hard. My kids' school can recommend dozens of places to get computer activities for kids. None of them are from big tech companies. There's a ton of small players in edtech, many with high quality content (I bring up prodigygame.com here from time to time, but there are others)
If you want to look specifically into communication tools for kids, the thing to be aware of is COPPA: it's an extremely restrictive regulation that governs what is allowable in apps/websites targeted at kids (e.g. something as basic as avatars are a no go, because they can expose the kid's appearance to strangers). Considering the horror stories you hear about teens and instagram, it's actually fairly understandable that the regulatory position is that kids have no business exposing themselves to online threats. Doctors also often suggest limiting screen time to no more than an hour a day. Parents letting screens babysit their kids do so against all sorts of expert advice.
People also bring up covid quarantines as a justification for more online engagement, but IMHO, this is an abnormal situation in the first place, and even then, there are various ways for kids to socialize, be it via zoom at school or just going to the nearby playground. And FWIW, I didn't have any of this fancy pants online social stuff growing up and I turned out just fine, even without a whole lot of in-person socialization either.
Not sure what kids using iPad has to do with them having access to Messenger and iMessage? Or, even YouTube app access.
Speaking as a parent ... It is a parent's job to make sure the software and the content children are using is appropriate for them and is in their interest. If one is relying on for profit companies, then .... I'd rather not say.
As a parent I'm now faced with the situation where I either need to block my kids from 50% of the interactions their friendship groups have and miss out on the media that their friends consume, of find a way that they can do that safely. Which is the crux of my complaint.
If kids are using iMessage I can't say it's OK for my child to communicate with an allowed list of contacts, or it is OK at certain times, or ensure they don't take selfies or send photos they shouldn't.
As it is we have set screen time each weekend, and do our best to educate them on responsible use of messaging but in my opinion apps should have far more fine grained control, especially when targetted at children.
I have so many friends who leave their tablet babysit the baby and feeding them so much multimedia content it's making me physically sick. And it's a lot more widespread, kid sees shiny and soundy and quiets down, then won't eat without a tablet shoved to their face.
YTKids is full of trash and ads with no way to moderate. I’m thinking about starting a video library app for $4.99/mo that has curated age appropriate educational video content for kids. How many HN parents would be interested in something like that?
This thread has been interesting.
But what do you think is the endgame for Facebook in providing a service for kids which are approved by the parents? None other than improving their prospects of LTV i.e. getting the 6 year old invested in the platform so they could yield conversions when 13(or what ever the age in which they get access to broader content i.e. Ads).
So the real question here to a parent is, Do you want your child to get invested in a platform which has consistently proven to be unethical, immoral, indulge in outright illegal activities or has been attributed with degrading democracies around the world?
May be Facebook wouldn't sell the data of kids until they're 13 or 18 but If I'm a parent I wouldn't want even my 18 year old to do anything with a platform like Facebook.
Without commenting on any of the wider topics.
Let he who is without a misspent youth on 4chan cast the first stone.
Castigating parents for making bad choices around their children's online behavior seems a bit unfair.
I'd say it's safe to say the kids are off on their own after a certain age, and making their own choices on the world wide web. The vast majority of parents are not IT professionals and not up for the task of closely filtering access to the entire internet.
Not one bit of this can be solved by pushing the responsibility on individual parents.
Also be aware that kids will break from the prison their parents set up sooner than they might want.
Interestingly I’m married to the product of this sheltering. When anything bad happens at all, she panics. Like panic attack panics. Things happen when they happen, and you’re attempting to control that instead of teaching.
There will never be a proper age to ween them into the real world.
Messenger for Kids is a well thought out app that lets parents have a lot of control over who their kids talk to. It also allows you to monitor their conversations way that respects the kids' privacy.
Contrast this with iMessage, where literally anyone can randomly message a child using their Apple ID, and there are zero controls available to parents for monitoring or approving contacts.
Look beyond messaging, and the Apple store targets kids with crappy apps filled to the brim with creepy ads. YouTube recommends creepy, addictive, unmoderated, content.
Facebook, and maybe Microsoft, are literally the only companies making products that are actually designed for kids.