News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by KKKKkkkk1 on Saturday October 30, 2021 @07:59PM (#29053281)
Does E. Snowden have anything to say about the state of the media in the country where he lives?
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by throwawaylinux on Saturday October 30, 2021 @09:05PM (#29053625)
This is a flimsy, transparent propaganda technique. Decry the person for not "speaking out" about some unrelated issue then act as though that has settled the debate. Their point is invalid, and anybody questioning that edict must also be a collaborator who supports that unrelated issue (and is therefore similarly invalidated and must not be allowed to speak). Much the same as when Assange was demonized for not "speaking out" exactly the necessary-but-unspecified amount against Republicans when wikileaks published damaging things about the Democrats (after having just spent years exposing Bush's war scandals, among other things).

I'm not accusing you of deliberately spreading propaganda, perhaps just repeating what I suppose must seem like an important and logically sound rebuttal to the enemy, known Russian agent Snowden.

Why would Snowden have anything to say about Russia? Do you think he knows or could say something that has not been said by a thousand others? Do you believe he would have knowledge and experience of the state security apparatus in Russia that would give him a unique and important perspective on things? Do you think he is in a better position to criticize Russia than other people?

Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by andreskytt on Sunday October 31, 2021 @08:01AM (#29056374)
Indeed, why he would say anything about a place where he lives and that provides him with both income and legal protection. Snowden is not my enemy and I’m not spreading propaganda. All I’m saying is that a person under complete control of one country does not offer a trustworthy perspective of the strategic adversary of said country. He might be right, he might be wrong but you and I will never know if and how deeply he is being influenced.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by throwawaylinux on Sunday October 31, 2021 @07:44PM (#29061587)
That's the same for everybody, nobody is above suspicion. Snowden exposed the US intelligence apparatus at grave risk to himself before he even knew he would get stuck in Russia. He already has much more credibility than the journalists and news corporations who are being deeply influenced by US government and intelligence agencies.

As I said, it's a propaganda technique. Do we screech at US journalists about why aren't they denouncing the US every time they publish a story about Russia? No.

Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by inpdx on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:50PM (#29054054)
"unrelated issue"? How could it possibly be unrelated?
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by throwawaylinux on Sunday October 31, 2021 @02:46AM (#29054983)
Yes, the issue in which Snowden is commenting on here and has expertise and a unique position to offer insight into is the US intelligence apparatus, which is unrelated to Russia, France, or Bolivia in this context.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by inpdx on Sunday October 31, 2021 @09:58AM (#29056997)
Just because he has no expertise in it doesn't make it unrelated. If you're living a country that regularly murders journalists, that's relevant to taking positions on journalism in other countries.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by throwawaylinux on Sunday October 31, 2021 @07:38PM (#29061548)
Not being related makes it unrelated though.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by CIADidHarryHolt on Saturday October 30, 2021 @07:59PM (#29053288)
Not if he wants to live in that country, or at all.

The reason why he's in Russia and not buried in an unmarked ditch is because Russia considers exposing Americas equal hypocrisy to be politically useful.

Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by busymom0 on Saturday October 30, 2021 @09:45PM (#29053789)
No. He was actually heading to Ecuador but US Admin specifically cancelled his passport while he was in transit at Moscow Airport from Hong Kong. He ended up having to stay at that airport for a while before he got asylum in Russia. And then this became the talking point on how "he's a Russian agent". The administration specifically intended this to happen.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by jakelazaroff on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:01PM (#29053868)
This may be a dumb question, but why does that matter? At this point, he’s a famous political refugee; it’s not like he’d be flying commercial. If both Russia and Ecuador wanted to send him to the latter, why should they care that his US passport was revoked?
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by busymom0 on Saturday October 30, 2021 @11:49PM (#29054310)
For 2 reasons:

1. US warned every country in both Europe and South America said to be considering shelter for Snowden of grave consequences should they offer asylum to the whistleblower. Without his US passport, Snowden couldn't go anywhere and Ecuador reversed their safe passage.

2. This also gave political fodder for the establishment cronies to call and label anyone who would defend Snowden a "Russian Agent".

I would recommend reading these two by Glenn Greenwald (he was the journalist who worked with Snowden to publish the docs):

https://greenwald.substack.com/p/ben-rhodes-book-proves-obam...

https://greenwald.substack.com/p/as-anger-toward-belarus-mou...

> Led by then-Vice President Joe Biden, U.S. officials warned every country in both Europe and South America said to be considering shelter for Snowden of grave consequences should they offer asylum to the whistleblower. Threats to Havana caused the Cuban government to rescind its commitment of safe passage they had issued to Snowden's lawyer. Under Biden's pressure, Ecuador also reversed itself by proclaiming the safe passage document issued to Snowden was a mistake.

I would also recommend the Citizen Four documentary:

https://youtu.be/EDhB-A23IUk

Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by jakelazaroff on Sunday October 31, 2021 @12:02AM (#29054361)
I understand 1 and 2; I just don’t understand why his passport is relevant. The threat is what made them withdraw the offer of asylum, not the revoked passport.

Related, I also don’t understand why, if the US was able to pressure other countries into withdraw their commitments, they wouldn’t just wait until Snowden was in one of those countries so they could pressure for extradition.

Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by hypeatei on Saturday October 30, 2021 @08:53PM (#29053567)
IIRC, his original destination wasn't Russia. His passport was revoked before he was able to leave, which meant he couldn't make it to Latin America.

But yeah, I agree with your point about the Russian government political motives.

Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by sodality2 on Saturday October 30, 2021 @09:26PM (#29053706)
It was a deliberate plan by the intelligence agencies to discredit him ("he's in le russia"). His passport was cancelled specifically when it would leave him stuck in that country.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by andreskytt on Sunday October 31, 2021 @08:03AM (#29056382)
Making definitive claims about plans of intelligence services is not necessarily a very useful endeavor.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by daniel-cussen on Saturday October 30, 2021 @08:19PM (#29053399)
I think it's perfectly reasonable to give the only country that gave him asylum a pass, and turn a blind eye. He's under no obligation to be a megaphone against injustice in all forms in all places.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by PakG1 on Saturday October 30, 2021 @08:54PM (#29053576)
He's not giving them a pass. But there's only a few countries right now where he can be alive and well. None of them would be considered free the way you would desire, and so if he wants to remain alive and well, he has certain obligations. It's better for him than being dead.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by midev on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:49PM (#29054048)
I love it. He leaves for one of the most repressive countries in the world, but gets a pass because he's critical of the United States.

This is why nobody takes him or his supporters seriously.

Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by PakG1 on Sunday October 31, 2021 @03:05AM (#29055074)
I read my comment again and I'm not sure how you got from my comment to writing what you did. I think we have a communication problem or a comprehension problem.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by jessaustin on Saturday October 30, 2021 @11:54PM (#29054329)
...nobody...

Who are you trying to convince?

Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by midev on Saturday October 30, 2021 @11:59PM (#29054351)
Oh yeah I forgot how revered he is. Which is why he's hiding in oppressive regimes, lol.

Even in the tech community, the most sympathetic group possible, half the people revile him as a self-serving traitor.

Nobody takes him or his supporters serious. Hard to hear, I know.

Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by jessaustin on Sunday October 31, 2021 @06:09AM (#29055882)
It's a simple question. You don't seem to have answered it.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by midev on Monday November 01, 2021 @08:35PM (#29075351)
It's kind of a dumb question, to be fair. It should be fairly obvious that I'm trying to sway the people reading the comment.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by daniel-cussen on Sunday October 31, 2021 @12:19AM (#29054442)
You just can't make enemies with everyone at that larger-than-life, history-affecting scale. You can't expect to solve all of the world's problems alone by denouncing every country on earth, even though you probably could construct the argument, for every single country on earth, that that country could be denounced for something. He's just one guy, he does what he can, and assassination absolutely on the table for activists who piss off the most powerful people on the planet enough.

Bill Browder talks about what happened to him when he pissed off the most powerful people in Russia. I don't admire the guy, basically he figured out every story he could get into the WSJ or Nytimes made them $41M in preventing stock shenanigans like massive dilution so that his shares actually could appreciate from the rapidly growing Russia economy, so that was his whole angle, shaming those guys in the paper. It's not clear it was truth, or whether it was slander, there was shady business going on, but he's no saint. When a news article is worth $41 million, like how much is that per word, and are you going to get a PR person to review the words, check if you can't get the article to be worth $42M in stock? Are you sure it's exactly $41M? Can't you just give it a little nuance, use a thesaurus maybe? Besides, damningly, he gave up his US citizenship to avoid paying taxes (like he obviously doesn't say that because tax lawyers tell you if you say that you are forbidden from ever setting foot in America for life), and that backfired because that means you are forfeiting America's protection and help because you didn't want to contribute back into the system. And he now can't make political contributions as a citizen, which I'm getting to.

He got kicked out of Russia, which makes perfect sense, like this guy thinks he milk American institutions, totally imperialistically meaning imposing American values on Russian companies, for no other reason but to make billions of dollars, and hoard that wealth with cunning tax evasion (guys like this absolutely don't pay taxes for ten years after you stop being a citizen, though that's the law, and to my understanding they literally value the money they pay in taxes 0%, or even negative). And USA actually is fine with you going to some banana republic and lording it over them, I mean it's perverse, but it's happened many many times in US history. And that's precisely why you still have to pay taxes if you're overseas if you're American, though in practice you only pay if you are upper class in a foreign country, which is by design. Or what, you expect the embassies to evacuate you after you caused a revolution, or you want American marines to force a country to redo an election you didn't like, that costs money that has to come from taxes, you don't want to pay anything for that?

And that guy is an activist now, he got some other citizenships, he lobbied all kinds of governments to punish a few of Putin's, like, he calls them henchmen or something, maybe they are, I don't know, it's always the same 7 guys and nobody else so they can't get bank accounts, they're the ones who seem to have beaten his lawyer to death. And he says, he's gotten 7 red notices from Interpol from Russia, it's a huge problem if you get just one.

It's realistic for him to expect to be assassinated, he says in his book he could have 1000 bodyguards and it wouldn't matter, Putin could get him anyway, and he has other strategies to protect himself. And several assassinations have been attributed to Russia in the last ten years, in London a few times, I think in London repeatedly, the nerve gas some years ago was attributed to them, some polonium in someone's tea, it's a realistic outcome if you're enough of a thorn in a powerful someone's side.

So one viable strategy is, piss people off less.

Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by midev on Sunday October 31, 2021 @12:34AM (#29054514)
So you're saying he betrayed the United States for a far worse, criminally oppressive regime? Everything in your comment makes him out to be a far bigger piece of shit. He betrayed the world for Russia, and now has far more deaths on his hands.

Damn you made me think even less of Snowden. You should tell more people about Bill Browder's story.

Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by daniel-cussen on Sunday October 31, 2021 @02:38AM (#29054939)
I don't know...well Bill Browder definitely betrayed both America and Russia, he was playing them off each other all the way. He was living in Russia and was actually married a Russian woman, and says he loves Russia, who knows. I believe the death of Sergey Magnitsky, a lawyer, was surely fucked up or countries wouldn't agree to pass a law called the Magnitsky Act, though in either case Russia would still both oppose the act and, according to Browder try to get it called something else. But I distrust his testimony.

He just spent too much of his life doing nothing other than serving his true nation, his pocket. So he grows up in America--that's already a privilege in my book. I think he went to Colorado, then Stanford for Business School. This was in the 80s, so Stanford was earning huge amounts of funding from the Department of Defense for all kinds of crazy cold war tech, and there was so much trust and mutual benefit in this relationship that the DoD...I don't know how to communicate it, but let Stanford charge "overhead" which went to the school in general. So the electrical engineering students in particular would make a breakthrough, and they'd get paid well, but then the money sloshed around the whole school. The Cold War was when Stanford went from a respectable, but second-tier school to a first-tier school, and it could really make its huge campus look like a billion bucks. So Browder goes to Business School in Stanford, and then the Cold War ends, so he goes to Eastern Europe and then Russia, like he himself said because his parents and grandparents were the most famous communists in America, he'd become the biggest capitalist in Russia. So, would he become Russian then? Would he stay in Russia and learn Russian? Will deriving a fortune, we're talking billions, from Russia, help Russia in some roundabout way? Because additionally, IIRC he gave up his US citizenship in the early nineties, like right away, he did not want to get caught dead paying taxes. And he didn't pay shit. He made billions, his fund was one of the fastest growing in the nineties, and apparently he flew from Britain, where he had become a citizen (I think you can't just not have a citizenship, I think you can't drop a citizenship without securing another one first). He flew to Russia all the time.

And I consider credible that Russia was a gangster-driven economy. This is actually not that surprising or, frankly even evil in the specific circumstances, it's just a consequence of the black market being the only market, so a return to market economics would have to come from the black market expanding and part of it getting split off into a gray and a white market. It's just not realistic to expect hard-line Communists to adapt to a market system they've been fighting their whole lives and expect them to have the combination of skills needed to address all the challenges that face a capitalist.

Whereas the black marketer actually has those skills right now, they're not meaningfully worse skills because he was selling Beatles's records or passports or rare books, the point is he's selling, he's bargaining, he's negotiating, he's in the market and getting a feel for the market, he's sometimes speculating, and you need that too, and that's a really tricky thing, and the market needs good speculators in order to smooth out the booms and busts. Keep in mind, under the thesis that Russia is run by gangster capitalists, it still puts a very high price on its national security and isn't selling itself out to other countries, it preserved a huge degree of autonomy and sovereignty to the point Russia could take in Snowden despite America's pressure against it. So at the very least, there's some patriotism. Moreso than Browder for sure.

Further, when the government basically collapsed people needed to eat, and the arrangement was they had all this stock, perhaps entitled to dividends, but nothing to eat, pretty much, really struggling. They were used to getting their rations (Socialism you get rations and you wait a long time in line), until they didn't. So my understanding is the black marketeers used their growing black market--and remember, because under Socialism pretty much any good an American could normally buy with money was sold in the black market instead, this was the seed from which the Russian economy was born, there was no other way for it to go but this-to make sure people could survive this catastrophe. And it sounds like it was fucking hard work, like can you imagine the logistics, roads must have been going to pot, exchanging goods using Vodka as currency, financing it all because those pieces of paper stock certificates were worth little at the beginning of Russian capitalism, and this is food we're talking about so you actually have to make sure everybody gets at least something, I'm not convinced gangster capitalism is really that harmful, well certainly it can be, but black markets are not inferior to white markets if at the end of the day you are actually acting in good faith. For sure black marketers can act in good faith. Black markets also have some built-in advantages over white markets, particularly that nobody asks you to sign demonic contracts in black markets (think arbitration clauses). No contract enforcement can be good to the extent contract enforcement of abusive contracts is bad. Plus, for privacy, you don't have to fill out nosy forms to participate, nobody ever asks you for your social like so many Fortune 500 companies do, they may know you by first name and face and that's it. Buyer and seller might have a remarkable affinity, because to have a desirable rare Rock and Roll record the seller would have to at least have liked the album enough to get it, and the buyer likes the album too, maybe they have something in common. On top of that, the seller is taking a big risk for the sake of the buyer. And I think the biggest thing that conditions markets of any type: what is being exchanged and why? That defines how the interaction will go more than whether the market is illegal according to this guy or grey according to an encyclopedia.

Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by andreskytt on Sunday October 31, 2021 @08:10AM (#29056414)
Equal hypocrisy, you say? So what universally accepted scale did you weigh the entirety of US and Russian societies on finding them equal? Maybe it might make sense to look at some metrics with an agreed-upon methodology.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by KennyBlanken on Saturday October 30, 2021 @11:10PM (#29054140)
In the US the media is neither state owned nor state controlled, with the exception of Voice of America.

The closest we have to state-owned is NPR, and if you think NPR is the lapdog of the government, you don't listen to NPR very much.

Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by b215826 on Saturday October 30, 2021 @08:32PM (#29053467)
Do you have an argument to make other than whatabouting Snowden? Don't you think that being forced to seek exile in Russia makes it difficult for him to say anything about the media there?
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by whatshisface on Saturday October 30, 2021 @08:57PM (#29053588)
It's questionable how much he'd even want to say, given that everyone already knows what the media is like there anyway.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by midev on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:45PM (#29054039)
It makes him a self-serving hypocrite.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by throwawaylinux on Sunday October 31, 2021 @02:54AM (#29055018)
So no argument then.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by lotusmars on Saturday October 30, 2021 @11:13PM (#29054159)
As a Russian, this is the reason I can’t support Snowden or take him seriously.

He keeps his trap shut about our suffering or plays softball at best which effectively makes him a great weapon in FSB/Russian oligarch hands and a RT mouthpiece.

Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by programmarchy on Saturday October 30, 2021 @11:28PM (#29054215)
I don’t think it’s fair to blame Snowden or Russia for the asylum situation. Why should Snowden make a martyr of himself and why shouldn’t Russia point out the hypocrisy of the US? The US government could, you know, drop his charges, thank him for the risk he took in an attempt to improve his country, acknowledge the overreach of the intelligence agencies, and stop doing shady, illegal shit to its own citizens.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by jazzyjackson on Saturday October 30, 2021 @09:05PM (#29053624)
Haven't you heard "enemy of my enemy is my friend" ?
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by chadcmulligan on Saturday October 30, 2021 @09:48PM (#29053803)
The whole enemy thing is being encouraged by those who make money off it. The arms suppliers sell to everyone, the idea of countries as enemies is good for business, and keeps everyone in line. It's a systemic issue for the world that needs to be addressed, sure there are underlying ideologic differences, but without the war machine actively fanning the fires we could no doubt find more common ground.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by midev on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:46PM (#29054046)
Fortune cookies are rarely good advice. Him aligning himself with actual evil diminishes anything he has to say.