News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by throwawaylinux on Saturday October 30, 2021 @09:05PM (#29053625)
This is a flimsy, transparent propaganda technique. Decry the person for not "speaking out" about some unrelated issue then act as though that has settled the debate. Their point is invalid, and anybody questioning that edict must also be a collaborator who supports that unrelated issue (and is therefore similarly invalidated and must not be allowed to speak). Much the same as when Assange was demonized for not "speaking out" exactly the necessary-but-unspecified amount against Republicans when wikileaks published damaging things about the Democrats (after having just spent years exposing Bush's war scandals, among other things).

I'm not accusing you of deliberately spreading propaganda, perhaps just repeating what I suppose must seem like an important and logically sound rebuttal to the enemy, known Russian agent Snowden.

Why would Snowden have anything to say about Russia? Do you think he knows or could say something that has not been said by a thousand others? Do you believe he would have knowledge and experience of the state security apparatus in Russia that would give him a unique and important perspective on things? Do you think he is in a better position to criticize Russia than other people?

Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by andreskytt on Sunday October 31, 2021 @08:01AM (#29056374)
Indeed, why he would say anything about a place where he lives and that provides him with both income and legal protection. Snowden is not my enemy and I’m not spreading propaganda. All I’m saying is that a person under complete control of one country does not offer a trustworthy perspective of the strategic adversary of said country. He might be right, he might be wrong but you and I will never know if and how deeply he is being influenced.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by throwawaylinux on Sunday October 31, 2021 @07:44PM (#29061587)
That's the same for everybody, nobody is above suspicion. Snowden exposed the US intelligence apparatus at grave risk to himself before he even knew he would get stuck in Russia. He already has much more credibility than the journalists and news corporations who are being deeply influenced by US government and intelligence agencies.

As I said, it's a propaganda technique. Do we screech at US journalists about why aren't they denouncing the US every time they publish a story about Russia? No.

Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by inpdx on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:50PM (#29054054)
"unrelated issue"? How could it possibly be unrelated?
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by throwawaylinux on Sunday October 31, 2021 @02:46AM (#29054983)
Yes, the issue in which Snowden is commenting on here and has expertise and a unique position to offer insight into is the US intelligence apparatus, which is unrelated to Russia, France, or Bolivia in this context.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by inpdx on Sunday October 31, 2021 @09:58AM (#29056997)
Just because he has no expertise in it doesn't make it unrelated. If you're living a country that regularly murders journalists, that's relevant to taking positions on journalism in other countries.
Re:Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance sta... by throwawaylinux on Sunday October 31, 2021 @07:38PM (#29061548)
Not being related makes it unrelated though.