News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by nicoburns on Friday October 29, 2021 @08:49AM (#29037773)
For me these kind of ridiculous projects from both Facebook and Google are the prime evidence that we ought to be taxing these companies more.

They're essentially circumventing market mechanisms (which would require a whole lot more people than just Zuckerberg to think that such a project was a good idea) and wasting a bunch of resources because they've been overcompensated for their other successful projects.

Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by syrrim on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:14AM (#29037987)
>They're essentially circumventing market mechanisms

That's the point. Market mechanisms will only fund things that will obviously succeed in a short time. A market cannot innovate or be creative. A single person, with a proven track record of being ahead of the curve, can.

>and wasting a bunch of resources

The tremendous excess of resources we enjoy today comes from allowing a large number of people to explore ideas without first proving that does ideas were guaranteed successes. Not only can we easily afford to waste resources, we can't afford not to.

Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by nicoburns on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:18AM (#29038023)
> The tremendous excess of resources we enjoy today comes from allowing a large number of people to explore ideas without first proving that does ideas were guaranteed successes.

Yes, that is why I believe we should distribute resources so that as large as possible a number of people continue to have that opportunity, rather than concentrating so many resources in one man's project.

Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by dkarp on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:24AM (#29038079)
Is a company with tens of thousands of employees really one man's project?
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by nicoburns on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:29AM (#29038128)
Yes and no. Obviously other people are involved. But it's driven by one man. One man gets to decide the direction and has ultimate control.

This is clearly a very different situation to for example the case of 2 companies with 5000 employees or 4 companies with 2500 employees, or even 2000 companies with 5 employees. Those cases would all allow for much more variation in approach, and this in turn would allow much greater scope for market feedback from consumers to affect the development of the products offered.

Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by zaphar on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:42AM (#29038277)

    One man gets to decide the direction and has ultimate control.
This is one of those statements that sounds pithy and is theoretically correct but in practice. The person at the top has far less control than people think they do and it's incredibly difficult to wield what control they do have with any kind of precision or accuracy. What actually happens is the the organization is full of people who attempt to do what they think they are inferring the people above them want and the result is an aggregation of all those little inferences of varying quality and accuracy. The bigger the organization the less control the person at the top actually has.
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by nicoburns on Friday October 29, 2021 @11:20AM (#29039525)
It's still very difficult for someone working under someone else to work in a direction that there superior is outright opposed to. For example, imagine someone at Facebook wanting to take a pro-privacy stance. They might be able to have some impact, but they're going to be overruled and undermined at every turn, whereas if there were a competitor with a staunchly pro-privacy leader / leadership team then that would be very different.
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by dnautics on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:37AM (#29038211)
> Market mechanisms will only fund things that will obviously succeed in a short time.

Glynn research institute.

For that matter celera, which arguably shows that the market will fund things that will obviously NOT work in a short period of time; anyone with half a brain could have told you that they were unlikely to be able to 'patent half the genome' but it's like greed and not understanding the narrative dominated.

Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by dkarp on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:22AM (#29038064)
This is a really good comment.

I think this sort of research done by large corporations is a big reason for the US's success. Just look at Xerox's PARC[0] where so much was incubated that couldn't have been if Xerox just focused on short term profit seeking.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PARC_(company)

Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by sonnyp on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:27AM (#29038109)
It's one thing to run a small research lab - it's an other to bet your entire company future on something that doesn't exist yet.
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by dkarp on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:51AM (#29038367)
It's a bold move, a big gamble. Isn't that what sets Silicon Valley apart from traditional companies?
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by 2pEXgD0fZ5cF on Friday October 29, 2021 @08:54AM (#29037813)
I wish it was harder for these megacorps to just buy every single rising competitor as soon as possible. Because honestly I doubt they would be able to survive or be as successful without that whole routine.

The market can't self regulate if only very few megacorps have an iron grip on it and can stamp out any threat immediately.

Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by Factorium on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:02AM (#29037884)
Correct. Force them to divest Instagram and Whatsapp, and prevent them from acquiring any more companies. Problem solved.
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by krageon on Friday October 29, 2021 @08:59AM (#29037857)
This is the market self-regulating. If you don't like what happens (I do agree), then you dislike the concept. Which makes sense, because the whole "might makes right" approach of such philosophies only serves to enable bullying and callous behaviour. Essentially the issues we see today.
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by ipaddr on Friday October 29, 2021 @08:59AM (#29037859)
There are many reasons not to like this but circumventing market mechanisms doesn't register. You want Mark to have to have to report to a bunch of investors so they can vet his ideas before he is allowed to proceed. If this was investor funded couldn't Mark fund this himself?

Should we have prevented Amazon from investing into AWS? The meta universe seems like the next social platform and it's related to the facebook mission of connecting people virtually.

Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by nicoburns on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:11AM (#29037956)
> Should we have prevented Amazon from investing into AWS?

It's not about preventing it outright. It's about constrain resources to bias towards the invested-in company actually being profitable to allow other companies to compete with them on a level playing field.

> If this was investor funded couldn't Mark fund this himself?

If Facebook didn't make as much money then Mark wouldn't have as much money to invest. Which IMO would be a good thing as it would mean that wealth would be more distributed which would likely lead to it being used more wisely due to the wisdom of the crowd. Mark could probably still launch such a project (and I have no problem with that), just not with "hiring 10,000 staff in Europe for an unproven project" level of resources (which I do have a problem with).

Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by JohnPrine on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:25AM (#29038090)
By this logic Facebook never would have gotten funded in the first place. What makes you so sure the metaverse concept will fail?
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by hytdstd on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:23AM (#29038076)
It sounds to me like you have a problem with the concept of conglomerates utilizing their capital.
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by nicoburns on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:30AM (#29038138)
I have a problem with them having so much capital in the first place because I think on average they don't tend to use it very well compared to smaller companies.
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by hytdstd on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:39AM (#29038240)
Purely out of curiosity: why does poor capital utilization concern you? It's their gamble, their resources, their right, I think.
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by dageshi on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:03AM (#29037888)
Perhaps you could tell us which business ideas and scientific theories will be correct so none of us have to waste any money on ridiculous projects?
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by nicoburns on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:12AM (#29037963)
The idea is to distribute resources so that we get more experiments. Many of them will be ridiculous projects, but some of them most likely won't be. We don't get that when all the resources are concentrated in a single project like this.
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by dageshi on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:41AM (#29038264)
There's no lack of VC spending on startups in this world, some of them are quite ridiculous. I'm not sure what you would propose would make any difference to anything.
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by TigeriusKirk on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:09AM (#29038574)
If anything, there's a oversupply of VC money right now. You can get funding for incredibly whacky ideas. There's just not enough good ideas for the amount of money available, so it's sloshing into anything and everything.
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by lotsofpulp on Friday October 29, 2021 @08:58AM (#29037842)
> because they've been overcompensated

How is this determined? Are market mechanisms not working in stock trading either? Seems like they are delivering decent profit numbers for their investors, compared to other companies.

Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by nicoburns on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:14AM (#29037991)
> Seems like they are delivering decent profit numbers for their investor

This is IMO completely the wrong benchmark. Are they delivering value to society? Yes some, but IMO not nearly in proportion to the amount of wealth they've accrued. Your free to make your own judgement about that, but if you agree then you also agree that market mechanisms are not working in this case.

Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by lotsofpulp on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:19AM (#29038030)
> Are they delivering value to society? Yes some, but IMO not nearly in proportion to the amount of wealth they've accrued.

How is this determined? I am trying to see if there is some actionable chain of reasoning here, or if people are just stating the top 5 companies in the public markets qualify? Is it a certain net profit margin? A combination of various factors?

The funny thing is Facebook (or Meta I guess) could fall of the face of the earth tomorrow and humanity would not really be impacted other than temporarily losing WhatsApp groups and having to migrate to a different chat program.

Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by nicoburns on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:34AM (#29038179)
> How is this determined?

That's my personal judgement.

The actionable response would be progressive taxation on corporate profits which would stop companies getting quite so large, and force (or strongly encourage) companies that wanted to continue growing beyond a certain point to split (which would have the effect of spreading control/power over the economy around).

> The funny thing is Facebook (or Meta I guess) could fall of the face of the earth tomorrow and humanity would not really be impacted other than temporarily losing WhatsApp groups and having to migrate to a different chat program.

Isn't that exactly the problem though. So much of societies resources going towards something that isn't ultimately that important. The opportunity cost here is huge.

Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by hytdstd on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:44AM (#29038296)
I apologize if I'm being too pedantic, but actually facebook closing would affect lots of companies who use fb ads to reach customers.
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by wrnr on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:14AM (#29037985)
I was never a fan of facebook (the website), but i'm sort of glad they are doing this metaverse thing. Computer graphics remains one of the most exiting fields in computer science, even good old geometry is having a comeback, and we could use the funding. It's not that any other big institutions believes there is anything of value here. It may be trickle down innovation, but at least facebook created react, I'm not one of them, but a lot of people not at facebook make a good living with that. What is the last time EY, PWC, Capgemini, BCG, McKinsey, Deloitte did anything for the common man. Sure they employ together millions of engineers, and that is something, but they bill over a trilion dollars for writing reports and keeping some old linux box running [1]. Talking about resources squandered and misdirected talent, it's not something you read about in the news very often.

[1]https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20190507005765/en/Man...

Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by JohnPrine on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:23AM (#29038070)
Yeah, that money should go to the government instead! Because the government never wastes resources right?
Re:Zuckerberg wants to be the hero of the metaverse because ... by Aunche on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:41AM (#29038263)
I'd agree with you if Congress wasn't the biggest offender of wasting resources. At least you can sell Facebook shares or sue Zuckerberg if you feel like he's wasting your money. A Senator gets reelected when they waste money because they waste it in their home state.