News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by FabHK on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:21AM (#29011054)
> just 0.1% (about 50 miners) control close to 50% of mining capacity

So, the much-vaunted "mathematical guarantee" that only 21m BTC will ever be mined depends on the benevolence of those 50 miners not to fiddle with the code base. Makes perfect sense to trust those honourable individuals more than the central bankers in control of fiat. /s

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by tinus_hn on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:40AM (#29011148)
How are these miner going to fiddle with the code on your computer?

That is not the issue caused by this concentration of mining power.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by CompuHacker on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:51AM (#29011198)
If those 50 people start playing by different rules, the sum of the value of the two resulting currencies will probably be less than that of BTC as it stands now.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by tinus_hn on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:00AM (#29011241)
No, if they start to play with different rules their mined blocks will be refused by everyone on the network and be worthless. That’s not what the issue is with concentrated mining power.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by arcatek on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:12AM (#29011303)
If they start to play with different rules, one of the hard fork remaining branches (or both) will be refused by everyone on the network and be worthless.

There's no telling whether it'd be the "hijacked" branch or the original one - assuming they control 50%+ of the mining power, there's a decent argument that the remaining miners would follow their lead if only to stay on the largest branch.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by dannyw on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:40AM (#29011462)
What miners do is irrelevant: the code known as bitcoin, with a 21M hard cap, simply will reject any block that creates more than its allowed bitcoins as invalid, the same way it rejects a random string of bytes as invalid.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by danbruc on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:08AM (#29011628)
Depending on your definitions this might or might no be true but it also might be totally irrelevant.

There is a protocol and system specification. There are implementations of that specifications. There is a distributed system running those implementations. And the distributed system has a state. Each of those can change and each of those or a combination of them could arguably be called Bitcoin.

If everyone would run new implementations with a different coin cap, you can argue that it is no longer Bitcoin because Bitcoin is a very specific specification with a 21M coin cap, but this would have little bearing on the actual situation.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by tinus_hn on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @10:56AM (#29014122)
This is like saying because some people own the majority of printing presses, money is worthless.

Money has worth because people accept it in exchange for goods and services.

Bitcoin has worth because people accept it in exchange for goods and services.

It’s not the miners that create value, it’s the merchants. If miners start some fork they’ll leave the main blockchain, which will run fine without them. And they have absolutely no way of forcing anyone to use their fork. Only if the merchants start accepting coins from the forked blockchain will it become valuable. But that’s up to the merchants, not the miners.

There are problems with one miner controlling over 50% of the mining power. This is not such a problem.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by namaria on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:15PM (#29019239)
Cryptoheads really gone from "printed money is becoming worthless, we need currency with enforced scarcity" to "it's all arbitrary anyway".

It's been quite educational watching the whole cryptocurrency community re-invent economics 101 and find out the problem has never been technical, always been political.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by jstanley on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:49AM (#29011939)
The point is you need the economic majority to be on side in order to succeed with a hard fork. Just the top 50 miners switching on their own isn't enough.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by thesz on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:54AM (#29012680)
Add 50 more - to reduce hash rate even more. Announce hard fork right after difficulty adjustment. And then, suddenly, these who have not forked will be stalled for several weeks. Instead of 10 minutes per block, the time will be 30 minutes and possibly more. And to adjust the difficulty those who have not forked would need... a hard fork?

Yes, these 100 miners are pools. But where pool participants will go then? Will pools who have not forked keep pool participation fees low?

Etc.

The game here is not quite simple. It is much more complex than appears at first sight.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by tinus_hn on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @11:06AM (#29014287)
The difficulty adjusts automatically. Bitcoin wouldn’t have come this far if it were that fragile.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by jstanley on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @11:07AM (#29014297)
It doesn't adjust immediately though. If a large majority of miner suddenly disappears then the block mining rate does indeed drop until the next difficulty adjustment.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by tinus_hn on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @12:46PM (#29015767)
So if 50% of the mining power left the next block would take on average about 20 minutes. Where it routinely takes about that long, because that’s just the way statistics work. A non issue.

Here’s a graph of the time blocks took over the last three years:

https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/bitcoin-confirmationtim...

Look at the peaks and try to remember the issues that resulted in.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by thesz on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @02:24PM (#29017057)
First, 20 minutes in average for power-distributed time-to-block would result in much, much higher peaks. In your chart I see 25 minutes for a block, then it will be 50 minutes.

Second, instead of two weeks to hash rate adjustment, it will take four weeks.

And if these staying with this slow bitcoin would decide to leave to more profitable currencies (not necessarily Bitcoin, there are other SHA256-based PoW schemes), that will push hash rate adjustment even further into future.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by tinus_hn on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @03:06PM (#29017634)
These 25 minute peaks were caused by a similar event, witness the also slow rates in the surrounding blocks. So that’s approximately how bad it would get in this ‘disastrous’ event.

https://www.cnbc.com/2021/07/03/bitcoin-mining-difficulty-dr...

We survived.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by UncleMeat on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:02AM (#29012069)
In the sense that updating the code to do something else would make it “not Bitcoin”, sure. But I really don’t think this matters to much of anybody if the “OG Bitcoin” drops to zero and the hard fork with new behavior wins.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by capableweb on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:26AM (#29011378)
Developers of the core protocol would notice, add a flag and then miners/clients/exchanges who want to remain with the same dev team can signal they want to follow the "dev" chain instead of the "miner" chain.

Usually forks have checkpoints as well so things can't change willy-nilly.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by jstanley on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:50AM (#29011944)
If blocks in the "miner" chain break the rules of the "dev" chain, then no flag is required. You'll automatically stick with the chain that contains valid blocks, as determined by the implementation that you're running.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by analog31 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:25PM (#29019338)
Does this mean if enough people don't like you, they can cancel your money?
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by jornhub on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:53AM (#29011536)
If they have the majority mining power they could equally well undermine the security of the original branch, rendering it worthless as well. Miners have interests, core developers have interests, bitcoin users have all kinds of interests, none of them on their own decides what will happen. Without miners there is no bitcoin, but neither is there without developers or without users. Would you feel safe having your savings stored in the original bitcoin fork, knowing there is a mining cartel that holds 50% mining power? Some users will accept reasonable changes that weere lobbied for by the miners, if that means they get to enjoy the security provided by the miners.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by Melting_Harps on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @09:50AM (#29013249)
> If those 50 people start playing by different rules, the sum of the value of the two resulting currencies will probably be less than that of BTC as it stands now.

This is less a criticism towards you @CompuHacker and more about how ill-informed reporters are (especially it's most vocal critics) about Bitcoin's history.

We already went through this during the USAF/Segwit war that went on for far too long if you were there and delayed so many other key features that we are only now catching up to. With the added caveat that Roger Veer (a VERY ignorant whale with influencer status) and Jihan (CEO at the time of Bitmain with a monopoly on ASIC miners and large hashing power on the network) decided to hi-jack Bitcoin for their own ends. There were other whales/high net worth entities, including Coinbase, but lets keep it simple for arguments sake.

In short, it didn't work and no one uses/used their fork (Bcash) because the end result was that Bitcoin's mainchain and it's features was valued far more than what whales and hashing power/devices. Furthermore, upon the fork people arbitraged the coin and dumped it in exchange for Bitcoin and Bcash has never recovered since. Showing that playing by the rules has it's incentives and is rewarded: rewarding consensus is one of Bitcoin's core features, and I wish more people would realize this is the ecosystem is far more conducive toward progress than abject discord.

What's even more amusing is that a core developer of Bitcoin Core decided to help patch some of Bcash's source code, showing that what you fear has actually already played out and proved why Bitcoin has already proven itself and has a the battle scars to prove it.

It's remarkable what has happened in this space in the last 12 years, and in my ideal World I think their would be more time spent on that and what it has taught us via empirical experimentation rather than just the price.

Sidenote: It's why the plot of the 51% attack on the series Silicon Valley only made sense to people who really have no idea how the network attack would actually play out on decentralized networks.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by Valakas_ on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:53AM (#29011208)
No. Who holds the real power are nodes. Miners are just workers doing their job and getting paid for it.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by yourapostasy on Thursday October 28, 2021 @02:50PM (#29029911)
> ...the benevolence of those 50 miners...

What mechanisms do those 50 miners have to coordinate amongst each other, starting with how do they identify each other, communicate with each other, then overcome Prisoner's Dilemma in negotiating with each other?

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by worrycue on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:59AM (#29011233)
Being able to print more would actually be a benefit as it allows for inflation. Central banks typically aim for 1-3% inflation to get people spending money and allowing the economy to function instead of just hoarding it.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by Siira on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:18AM (#29011710)
“Hoarding” money, also known as saving in esoteric circles.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by bart_spoon on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @12:20PM (#29015370)
Its not simply "saving". Its where money is so much more valuable tomorrow than it is today, literally no one buys anything because why buy X today when you can buy 2 of X tomorrow? So the economy grinds to a halt.

Also, it exacerbates inequality immensely. When deflation is high, it means your existing money becomes more and more valuable for no other reason than existing. So the "rich get richer" in the most literal sense, for no other reason than having been rich in the first place. No investment or risk required.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by worrycue on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:12AM (#29012157)
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by mensetmanusman on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:52AM (#29011969)
The funny thing is that death or mental illness by a hoarder means the btc go poof until the end of time.

Therefore, over a long enough time scale, the number of available BTC tends towards zero.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by ur-whale on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:17AM (#29012213)
That's assuming that BTC's aren't infinitely divisible.

Currently, you can only chop them up into atoms worth 1e-8 BTC (satoshis), but there isn't much that needs be changed in the code and the protocol to get that to much finer grained.

Therefore, it's unlikely that there will ever be zero bitcoins.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by noch on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @09:27AM (#29013020)
> Currently, you can only chop them up into atoms worth 1e-8 BTC (satoshis), but there isn't much that needs be changed in the code and the protocol to get that to much finer grained.

Such a change would be a hard fork and, as you know, we don't do that in Bitcoin. But, no worries because we have millisatoshis in Lightning. Because Bitcoin scales in layers, each layer can implement more and more divisibility as required.

https://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/a/69704

As you said, bitcoin is infinitely divisible, therefore the world economy can run on 1 btc or 1 satoshi.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by ur-whale on Thursday October 28, 2021 @02:28PM (#29029517)
> Such a change would be a hard fork and, as you know, we don't do that in Bitcoin.

True, it'd be a hard fork. However, I don't believe hard forks are impossible if managed properly.

The taproot upgrade (not a hard fork, I know) was rather uncontroversial and accepted rather easily.

I suspect a hard fork allowing for - say - bitcoin amounts encoded in 64 bits would not necessarily generate the kind of upheaval the blocksize wars did.

And, hopefully, even for controversial upgrades, the lessons of said wars will have been learnt and the process of upgrading Bitcoin can be done in a slightly more reasonable / orderly fashion.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by spiralx on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @10:25PM (#29021620)
Whether you cut a pie into 10 million slices or 10 billion slices you still only have one pie in total in the same way that changing ten dimes for a hundred cents still means you have a dollar.

In a world where only 1,000,000 BTC remain in circulation if one person owns 500,000 of them means he controls half of the total value of BTC and that everyone else's coins will add up to the other 500,000 BTC, and being able to divide the each BTC into smaller and smaller amounts doesn't change that fact. Whether we can divide 500,000 BTC into 50 trillion Satoshis or 5 quadrillion "New Satoshis" worth 1e-10 BTC each doesn't make new wealth appear.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by xtracto on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @12:23PM (#29015425)
This is something not so many people take into account regarding cryptocurrencies. The real "total number" of any cryptocurrency is the total number of decimals they contain. There are currently a total of 2,100,000,000,000,000 Satoshis. A satoshi is $0.00059 USD. A Satoshi could cost $0.01 (1 cent) and it could still be paired with the US economy. If 99% of Satoshis became unavailable, we would still have 21,000,000,000,000 of Satoshis in circulation.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by glenvdb on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @06:51AM (#29011524)
You've revealed plainly that you haven't got a clue what you're talking about.

Miners can't change the protocol of the entire network.

The only malevolent thing they could do is perform a 51% attack if they all colluded together. And even that wouldn't achieve much, so there's not much incentive to do it. All they can do is a double spend. They would've been better off spending that energy on mining blocks to be rewarded with the Bitcoin subsidy.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by FabHK on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @09:24AM (#29012975)
So, let's play that out. Suppose 90% of miners (hash power) collude (as GP posited), for example validating blocks with a larger coinbase (mining reward). The "good" nodes don't accept these (but the "bad" miners can trivially have many nodes that do accept them). But now the "good" hash power drops to 10%, so only every 100 minutes a "good" block is mined (suppose this happened just after a difficulty adjustment), and that goes on for 20 weeks. In the meantime, the bad nodes and miners carry on as before, pretty much, but with their malicious change incorporated. If they're bored, they can devote some of their hash power to double spend attack the "good" chain. Which chain will come out on top?

Sure, it's unlikely. But not impossible. Just as runaway inflation in a reasonably managed fiat currency is not impossible. Just unlikely. (And, yes, hyper inflation has happened historically. Similarly, rewriting of the immutable Ethereum chain and BTC forks have happened historically.)

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by Sohcahtoa82 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @05:43PM (#29019490)
A malicious set of miners that decides to give itself a higher block reward will never have their blocks accepted by the "good" nodes. It's quite simply not possible. The blocks will be invalid and therefore rejected outright. It doesn't matter how much hashing power is behind them.

> If they're bored, they can devote some of their hash power to double spend attack the "good" chain. Which chain will come out on top?

That's a different attack entirely.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by eraad on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @06:34AM (#29092898)
Is this just a hard fork? This exists, I believe its called Bitcoin Cash or Bitcoin "Satoshi Vision".
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by H8crilA on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:05AM (#29011603)
Well, Ethereum miners decide on changing the protocol like all the time.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by woah on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @08:03AM (#29012085)
Also wrong. For an Ethereum (or bitcoin) upgrade that requires a hard fork to be accepted as “being Ethereum”, all the users running Ethereum nodes need to be OK with it and update their full node software to that version.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by christophilus on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @07:09AM (#29011634)
BTC != ETH. This is one of the arguments in BTC’s favor.