What would you think about someone that you were talking to that showed you something on their phone (a restaurant listing you were both thinking of going to, or something on Maps), but then a Parler notification popped up? What if they were married and Grindr or Tinder or whatever notification popped up?
Would you judge them? Would you expect many other people to judge them, even if you don’t?
Don’t get me wrong, I don’t think Apple’s products would be problematic that way. But a big reason why is because they have and likely will continue to make decisions like the one we are discussing.
If they went full end to end super privacy, then got named by the feds repeatedly in whatever the next big csam/terrorist/whatever scandal, that could change, and that is even assuming Congress people don’t join in the action, which they’ve already shown an interest in doing.
Even if Apple wasn't scanning anyone's files, >99% of their users would not be pedophiles and no one would have any reason to assume that they were.
> If they went full end to end super privacy, then got named by the feds repeatedly in whatever the next big csam/terrorist/whatever scandal
The main effect from getting put on a list like that is to gain credit with privacy-conscious people for standing up for their users. Nobody says "oh no, I better stop using my favorite full disk encryption because it hasn't got any known backdoors in it."
> that is even assuming Congress people don’t join in the action, which they’ve already shown an interest in doing.
At which point you have government action and can bring out the constitutional arguments etc.
And none of your personal lack of being a witch is going to help you when you get the reputation as the ‘weird dude that uses that child porn storage app’.
I guarantee you 90% plus of the population, once they learn what Tor is, will have the reaction to Tor. And it’s a matter of time until it gets enough press for that. Same with anything that does what you describe (proper end to end, we don’t care what you store, and we don’t have the keys so pound sand LEO).
When something is low key/under the radar, it can be a healthy witch-hunt-free zone that also isn’t filled to the brim with witches. But something at the scale Apple is at can’t, and even Parler (which didn’t start that way) got too much visibility and ended up as you describe and got shut down.
The privacy conscious folks may nod their head and know, but most folks don’t get it, and if it gets widely used, it will be attacked this way by authority figures. The ‘think of the children’ routine is used a lot because it does work on the majority of the population.
As I said, Apple isn’t there yet, and likely would never be close - because they’re going to do things like they are now to avoid the Public backlash.
And as long as they put enough of a veneer on it, the vast majority of folks won’t think twice about continuing to use them (95%+ of current customers at least). Most of the market will continue using Android which is 10x worse near as I can tell.
The ‘mistake’ they seemed to have made here is being a bit too obvious about it and not keeping up the veneer well enough.
Overall, I suspect we’ll be seeing some move back to on-prem for a non-trivial percentage of folks because of this and other things going on. That said, I’m sure cloud will continue to grow exponentially because most folks just don’t care enough to pay to do otherwise.
This only happens when you start off with zero users and having an anti-witch-hunt policy is the only thing causing you to gain users, specially because they're disproportionately witches. Because without that policy the service would still have zero users.
It doesn't apply to any service that already has a large number of non-witches or has any effective means of also attracting users who are not witches.
> I guarantee you 90% plus of the population, once they learn what Tor is, will have the reaction to Tor.
Tor has a specific marketing disadvantage because by its nature it defeats most forms of tracking and advertising, which makes it adversarial to media companies who profit from tracking and advertising. This is why all the stories are about "the dark web" and not about that thing that helps dissidents in China and Iran evade authoritarian censorship.
It's also hard to get ordinary people to use it, and thereby understand that the technology itself isn't anything nefarious, because there is a noticeable latency cost to using it that most people aren't going to like.
None of this applies to a generic hosting services making it so they can't read their customers' personal files.
> When something is low key/under the radar, it can be a healthy witch-hunt-free zone that also isn’t filled to the brim with witches. But something at the scale Apple is at can’t
This is completely the opposite. It's the things at the scale of Apple that can do it because there aren't enough witches in the world to make a userbase the size of Apple's be more than 1% witches.
It also works for everyone as long as everyone does it, because then "no witch hunts" is common practice rather than something that makes you attract a disproportionate number of witches.
> even Parler (which didn’t start that way) got too much visibility and ended up as you describe and got shut down.
Parler was clearly the app that gained users by having a policy against witch hunts. It only started gaining a significant number of users when the other platforms started carelessly banning large numbers of users for alleged transgressions that were in many cases facially absurd, but it also attracted the people who were banned because they were actually bad.
And even then, it wasn't the users who abandoned them, it was Apple and Google and Amazon. Apple is obviously not going to do that to themselves.
Even putting aside how much of a stretch that is, how is anybody else supposed to know which service you use? It's your personal files. That nobody else should have access to them is the point.
It's not as if Apple or whomever should be providing anyone with a list of their customers, as that should cause you to not use them too. As far as I know they don't currently make their customer list public.