News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bugs in our pockets: the risks of client-side scanning by AnthonyMouse on Friday October 29, 2021 @12:02PM (#29040100)
> ‘if you create a place which is anti-witch-hunt and you enforce it and it gets a reputation as anti-witch-hunt, you’ll end up having 3 strong civil minded libertarians and a gazillion witchs’.

This only happens when you start off with zero users and having an anti-witch-hunt policy is the only thing causing you to gain users, specially because they're disproportionately witches. Because without that policy the service would still have zero users.

It doesn't apply to any service that already has a large number of non-witches or has any effective means of also attracting users who are not witches.

> I guarantee you 90% plus of the population, once they learn what Tor is, will have the reaction to Tor.

Tor has a specific marketing disadvantage because by its nature it defeats most forms of tracking and advertising, which makes it adversarial to media companies who profit from tracking and advertising. This is why all the stories are about "the dark web" and not about that thing that helps dissidents in China and Iran evade authoritarian censorship.

It's also hard to get ordinary people to use it, and thereby understand that the technology itself isn't anything nefarious, because there is a noticeable latency cost to using it that most people aren't going to like.

None of this applies to a generic hosting services making it so they can't read their customers' personal files.

> When something is low key/under the radar, it can be a healthy witch-hunt-free zone that also isn’t filled to the brim with witches. But something at the scale Apple is at can’t

This is completely the opposite. It's the things at the scale of Apple that can do it because there aren't enough witches in the world to make a userbase the size of Apple's be more than 1% witches.

It also works for everyone as long as everyone does it, because then "no witch hunts" is common practice rather than something that makes you attract a disproportionate number of witches.

> even Parler (which didn’t start that way) got too much visibility and ended up as you describe and got shut down.

Parler was clearly the app that gained users by having a policy against witch hunts. It only started gaining a significant number of users when the other platforms started carelessly banning large numbers of users for alleged transgressions that were in many cases facially absurd, but it also attracted the people who were banned because they were actually bad.

And even then, it wasn't the users who abandoned them, it was Apple and Google and Amazon. Apple is obviously not going to do that to themselves.

There are no comments on this comment yet.