News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by gruturo on Monday October 25, 2021 @09:03AM (#28987297)
> France and Italy could have had moderate communist governments

As an Italian born in the 70's, thanks but no thanks?

Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by eecc on Monday October 25, 2021 @09:15AM (#28987391)
Why? Has the “partitocrazia” first and the ‘80s cleptocracy, Berlusconi’s downward spiral, and the last attempts an installing neoliberal proxy governments done any good to the country?

I guess there’s no point discussing impossible alternative scenarios - especially given the extremely conservative attitude of Italian society - but an Italy with a more Scandinavian-like compromise would have been an interesting country to live in.

Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by fsloth on Monday October 25, 2021 @09:32AM (#28987567)
"Italy with a more Scandinavian-like compromise"

Not OP but as a Finnish (so not True Scandinavian but close enough)- Scandinavian wellfare state is as far from Communism as anything. Please don't confuse our social democratic parties with actual communists.

The Scandinavian liberal and egalitarian political outlook predates Marx (and Adam Smith in fact) - see for example Anders Chydenius https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anders_Chydenius . While set in familiar enlightenment milieu Scandinavian concept of wellfare-state cannot be understood by labeling it as "socialism" which is a later construct.

Wellfare state itself of course was born after second world-war but the philosophical basis is more or less set in an earlier egalitarian view of man.

Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by TheOtherHobbes on Monday October 25, 2021 @11:06AM (#28988632)
Yet strangely, if anyone suggests similar goals for the US they're invariably attacked as socialist or communist.

It's more accurate to say that socialism is a later expression of the same ideals - which actually date back to the late 18th century, when they appeared around Europe during a period of revolutions and enlightenment-inspired liberalism.

Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by kragen on Monday October 25, 2021 @11:51AM (#28989213)
Socialism by that name predates Marx, but (unlike, I think, liberalism) you can find recognizable socialist thinking in the classics. The impulse toward egalitarianism is omnipresent throughout history, because equality is such an appealing Schelling point. Marx's genius was finding a justification for extremist Digger-style egalitarian ideology in the face of such dramatic manifestations of the positive-sum potential of voluntary exchange; in an earlier era where the gain of one feudal lord was inevitably the loss of another, the Digger approach is almost inevitable, but in the face of the explosive prosperity of the Industrial Revolution, Marx had to do quite a bit of work to explain how voluntary trade worsened the situation of the working class.

To a great extent he was correct in his analysis of existing conditions, but, as it turned out, not about their inevitability or about how to improve them.

Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by sudosysgen on Monday October 25, 2021 @09:49PM (#28995504)
This is not at all what Marx believed. I understand where the misconception comes from though.

Marx was quite particular amongst socialism because he did not believe humans were equal in ability.

Indeed, he argued with other socialists and believed that different people had superior and inferior abilities, and even that the more productive people logically deserved a higher wage, and so did the people with greater need.

This is why unlike other socialists of the era, Marx did not advocate for equal wages - he thought that people that were more productive should have a greater income (as well as people who needed it, ie, people with families, handicapped, etc...)

He also did not believe that conditions would not improve - he was a radical proponent of economic growth, and thought that things would improve for a significant amount of time until a plateau was hit, at which point a transition to communism would be the only alternative to decay.

Instead, Marx's argument was not that capitalism created inequality - he thought that inequality was inherent to the human condition - but that capitalism fundamentally engendered inequality on the basis not of personal ability, but on the basis of artificial social relations that rewarded the ownership of capital far more than the inherent inequality of humans ability and human need.

He also would vehemently disagree that voluntary trade worsened the situation of the working class - he wrote extensively about how capitalism was an immense improvement over feudalism, and how it would and was improving the situation of the working class materially. The issue he had is that the thought that this material improvement would eventually stop contributing to well-being, and that eventually the social harm caused by the capitalist social relations would lead to a plateau then decay of overall wellbeing.

If you look at his immediate suggestion in how to improve them, you would find them much more inline with modern welfare states than anything else, and indeed that was why Lenin basically instated a welfare state when he took power.

Here are the actual policies that Marx wanted to see implemented:

1. Abolition of property in land and application of all rents of land to public purposes.

2. A heavy progressive or graduated income tax.

3. Abolition of all rights of inheritance.

4. Confiscation of the property of all emigrants and rebels.

5. Centralisation of credit in the hands of the state, by means of a national bank with State capital and an exclusive monopoly.

6. Centralisation of the means of communication and transport in the hands of the State.

7. Extension of factories and instruments of production owned by the State; the bringing into cultivation of waste-lands, and the improvement of the soil generally in accordance with a common plan.

8. Equal liability of all to work. Establishment of industrial armies, especially for agriculture.

9. Combination of agriculture with manufacturing industries; gradual abolition of all the distinction between town and country by a more equable distribution of the populace over the country.

10. Free education for all children in public schools. Abolition of children’s factory labour in its present form. Combination of education with industrial production, &c, &c.

These are certainly quite radical. But all of these are suggestions that are either already implemented today in capitalist countries, or that liberal capitalists have advocated for. Except for 1., 3. and 2., he was actually correct about how to improve the conditions of the working class - the abolition of private property of capital was his eventual goal, yes, but he was incredibly precient about the policies that would be used to improve capitalist society.

Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by kragen on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @12:13AM (#28996316)
Thank you for sharing your point of view! I agree with most of what you said, and I was remiss in not quoting the Communist Manifesto myself.

Still, I don't think you can be a liberal capitalist and favor "confiscation of the property of all emigrants", "equal liability of all to work", or even "abolution of property in land", or even an exclusive monopoly on credit, and given that "the means of communication" here presumably means newspapers (as opposed to mails and telegraph companies) I don't see how a liberal could be in favor of that either, since it abolishes freedom of the press; and centralization of the means of transport in the hands of the state eliminates freedom of domestic travel. In countries that have abolished freedom of the press, property in land, freedom of domestic travel, and/or the freedom to emigrate without having all your property confiscated, it has not in fact improved the conditions of the working class; very much the contrary, it has been used to enslave and impoverish them. Even inheritance abolition and heavy income taxes are not clearly compatible with liberalism, but they aren't as central to liberalism as land tenure and the freedoms of the press, travel, and emigration. (Georgists want to abolish land ownership too, but George didn't claim to be a liberal.)

I didn't mean to say that Marx claimed that voluntary exchange worsened the condition of the working class more than feudalism, just that in its capitalist form it still tended to the immiseration of the working class.

As for "prescience," I'm not sure it was a question of prescience; I think that to a great degree the Russian Revolution and the Warsaw Pact simply moved the Overton Window a long way toward Marxist policies. I think capitalist societies adopted Marx's policies not, in many cases, because they would have anyway, but because (a) they were under pressure to do so when the policies were popular, so people wouldn't emigrate to Russia or replace their own governments with Communist ones, and (b) they were under less pressure not to do so when the policies were unpopular, because there were less and less places where you could escape from those policies.

Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by sudosysgen on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @05:35PM (#29006596)
Do you think that capitalist societies would not have eventually ended child labor, nationalized some key industries, and provided free education without the October revolution? I think that this would have happened anyways, these policies are just too helpful.

As far as the things you quoted - confiscating the property of all emigrants really means capital controls. Many liberal countries did in fact do this during periods of reform, such as Iceland in 2008.

But beyond that, capital controls were instituted under the Bretton Woods system. The idea of preventing people from leaving with their capital was indeed quite popular, and in that it allowed for example Iceland to reform their banking system, or a country from instituting public education and raising income taxes, many economists do think that they improve welfare.

Equal liability of all to work was also something that liberals implemented - here it basically just means public works projects open to all.

As far as "the means of communication", Marx does mean mails, telegraphs, and radio communication. He had argued otherwise for public newspapers, but argued against any kind of censorship of the press - making this actually yet another policy liberals would adopt :

In order to combat freedom of the press, the thesis of the permanent immaturity of the human race has to be defended. It is sheer tautology to assert that if absence of freedom is men's essence, freedom is contrary to his essence. Malicious sceptics could be daring enough not to take the speaker at his word.

https://wikirouge.net/texts/en/On_the_Assembly_of_the_Estate...

A historical document such as this one needs to be read in it's historical context. At the time, the income tax in England was of 3% - our modern income taxes of 20-30% are what Marx was referring to by saying heavy income taxes,

As far as abolishing property of land and renting it out, this is essentially just another way of saying "Land value tax". While it's not a liberal policy in essence, it is a policy that liberals advocate nowadays, and that many liberal capitalist countries such as Denmark, Singapore and Taiwan implement.

Completely abolishing inheritance of capital is something that no country has done in the capitalist world, yes, but it is again something that many liberals do advocate for, and nowadays inheritance tax rates of 50% do exist.

As far as saying that capitalism made the working class better off but that it will never completely stop immiseration of the working class, is that not what I said?

Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by kragen on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:09AM (#29009772)
> Do you think that capitalist societies would not have eventually ended child labor, nationalized some key industries, and provided free education without the October revolution? I think that this would have happened anyways, these policies are just too helpful.

I don't know, but I don't think the answer depends on how socially beneficial these policies are; it depends on how much support they had among elites in different countries. It would be wonderful if elites favored all helpful policies (and only helpful policies), but surely nobody thinks that that is the case.

> The idea of preventing people from leaving with their capital was indeed quite popular, ... many economists do think that they improve welfare.

I was saying these aren't liberal policies. They certainly are popular, and it's unsurprising that many people disagree with me about whether they improve the welfare (generally or of the working class in particular.) However, I think "confiscating the property of emigrants" goes very significantly beyond what we normally understand as "capital controls"; an emigrant might return, after all, or rent out his house to tenants who pay the rent to his factor in the city, and these are not possible if you confiscate his property.

> Equal liability of all to work was also something that liberals implemented - here it basically just means public works projects open to all.

I read "liability of all to work" as a universal corvee system, which would be completely incompatible with liberalism, and which was in fact implemented (with some exceptions, for example for children and retirees) in officially Marxist societies. Clearly you know Marx's work much better than I do; can you point to something where he clarifies what he and Engels meant here?

> As far as "the means of communication", Marx does mean mails, telegraphs, and radio communication.

Since the Communist Manifesto was published in 01848, and Bose's first public demonstration of radio communication was in 01895, and Marconi's the following year, it seems unlikely that Marx meant radio communication. As for mails and telegraphs, do you know of anywhere that he or Engels went into more detail on this?

> He had argued otherwise for public newspapers, but argued against any kind of censorship of the press - making this actually yet another policy liberals would adopt:

Here by "freedom of the press" Marx seems to mean "freedom of information" in the FOIA sense; specifically the policy he is advocating is the "unabridged and daily publication" of the debates of the Provincial Assembly. Since such things are normally done by the State if they are done at all, this doesn't seem at all incompatible with the newspapers being all State-owned, much less the death penalty for posting broadsheets calling Stalin a wanker.

> At the time, the income tax in England was of 3% - our modern income taxes of 20-30% are what Marx was referring to by saying heavy income taxes,

I suppose you are right about this. Thank you.

> As far as saying that capitalism made the working class better off but that it will never completely stop immiseration of the working class, is that not what I said?

I think those two clauses are inconsistent with one another; it is impossible for them to be simultaneously true in any possible world. The immiseration of the working class would be the gradual decrease over time of its wages down to the bare minimum required for survival. An increase over time of the wages of the working class is precisely the opposite. Unless you mean that the working class had less income than previously but at least wasn't literally enslaved any more?

But, looking again at what I originally wrote, I see that my original point seems to have been that Marx was comparing the capitalist system of voluntary wage-labor, not with the feudal past, but rather with a hypothetical future Communist system, which also wasn't based on voluntary exchanges. Within a feudal system, where wealth is understood as land, it's easy to imagine how people would readily conclude that any voluntary trade had a winner (who received more value than they gave) and a loser (who gave more value than they received); this mentality is still common in many places.

But the ideologies of liberalism and capitalism were based on the widely shared presumption of positive-sum transactions, and in the face of conspicuous rapidly increasing general wealth, plus the gradual capitalist replacement of relations of involuntary servitude (including chattel slavery, indentured servitude, captured apprentices, impressed soldiers, the corvee labor later reinstated in places like the USSR, and manorial serf labor, as well as the much more recent prohibitions on debt bondage) with voluntary wage-labor, the zero-sum worldview would seem to be implausible, which you would think would give rise to the common-sense presumption that transactions would only occur when both parties believed they benefited by them, and that they would usually be right about it.

So, I was saying, Marx had to do a lot of work to construct an account of how such voluntary exchanges were still harmful to the workers. Nowadays we have much better conceptual tools for this, like the Nash equilibrium, the whole apparatus of game theory, Schelling's theory of negotiation, behavioral-economic experimental results on things like the Iterated Prisoner's Dilemma, and so on.

> As far as abolishing property of land and renting it out, this is essentially just another way of saying "Land value tax". While it's not a liberal policy in essence, it is a policy that liberals advocate nowadays, and that many liberal capitalist countries such as Denmark, Singapore and Taiwan implement.

I don't think the people who are advocating a land value tax are liberals, and surely you would agree that Denmark, Singapore, and Taiwan have significant departures from liberalism; Singapore doesn't even have freedom of the press. I also don't think a land-value tax normally amounts to abolishing property in land.

(Not being a liberal policy doesn't necessarily mean it's bad. The liberals could be wrong. But I think it's important to be clear about the reasoning behind different policy proposals.)

> Completely abolishing inheritance of capital is something that no country has done in the capitalist world, yes, but it is again something that many liberals do advocate for, and nowadays inheritance tax rates of 50% do exist.

Again, I don't think the people who are advocating such policies are liberals.

Thank you again for taking the time to explain your understanding of the situation to me!

Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by thereddaikon on Monday October 25, 2021 @10:15AM (#28988035)
Social Democracies are not Communist States. Communism requires certain extreme actions, not least of which is dissolving private property and seizing it for the state. Last I heard, Norway isn't taking everyone's land away and forcing everyone to live in communes.
Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by eecc on Monday October 25, 2021 @11:40AM (#28989067)
Sure, but the OP said "moderate communism" and I wrote that a Scandinavian-like compromise would have been an interesting scenario for Italy.

I didn't quite say the two were the same thing, although some - n.b. some - ethical assumptions are cut from the same cloth.

Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by thereddaikon on Monday October 25, 2021 @02:31PM (#28991390)
I'm in agreement with another user's opinion that there is no such thing as moderate communism given that several of its core concepts are radically distinct from other forms of government/economic systems. Rejecting private property as a concept is a big threshold to cross. So is a full collectivization of labor. There is only one nation I know of that operated with a similar view but wasn't Marxist and that's the Inca.
Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by simonh on Monday October 25, 2021 @09:50AM (#28987770)
Scandinavia is in no way communist, not even "moderate' communist. For the nearest equivalent to that, Yugoslavia would be a better comparison.

If you look at the rapid industrialisation and growth of Italy through to the 60s starting from a similarly dire start, they leaped ahead of Yugoslavia. Yes Italy suffered recession through the 80s and 90s, but the Yugoslav economy completely collapsed. 150% inflation in Italy spread over a decade? Try 9,000% inflation in Yugoslavia over just 6 years in the same era. They were even a net importer agricultural produce despite 29% of their work force being in agriculture.

More recently since you brought him up yes Berlusconi was an idiot that hurt Italy, no question, but to really wipe out an economy right down to the roots there's no substitute for Marxism.

Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by eecc on Monday October 25, 2021 @11:44AM (#28989110)
Italy also benefited from access to the European market, while Yugoslavia was stuck - and even there not quite well integrated either - with the flailing economies of the Eastern Block.

About your last statement, you seem to forget some of the attempts at Neoliberal Edens in South America of the '90s. They didn't go that well, haven't they?

Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by simonh on Monday October 25, 2021 @02:39PM (#28991479)
Yugoslavia did trade with Europe, it was independent and not a member of the Warsaw Pact. Only 25% of its trade was with the eastern block.
Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by eecc on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @03:02AM (#28997256)
Hey, went to double check that claim and learned on Wikipedia that Yugoslavia did IMF backed austerity policies in the ‘80s.
Re:Project SPHINX – When the USSR tried to change the comput... by Ginden on Monday October 25, 2021 @12:47PM (#28990021)
I'm not sure if any liberal thinker would label policies such as fixed exchange rates, constant deficit funded by foreign borrowing, military dictatorships, as "liberal".