News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by spywaregorilla on Friday October 22, 2021 @09:34AM (#28956996)
Stepping up enforcement fails all the time. If you want ransomware to stop being effective, make it illegal to pay the ransom.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by codegeek on Friday October 22, 2021 @10:42AM (#28957845)
That's like saying "make it illegal to get robbed". If I have a robber with a gun to my head asking for my wallet, I would comply. I wouldn't tell them sorry it is illegal to give you my wallet. You should not penalize the victim. Crack down on perps, not victims please.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by spywaregorilla on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:57AM (#28958779)
No those are not similar cases. Yours is urgent, violent, tiny scale, and individual level. The individual doesn't have any agency in this situation. The alternative is get shot and robbed.

If a corporation is unable to pay a ransom then the incentive to do the ransomware attack immediately drops.

Cracking down on perps would be nice, but is not feasible.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by nindalf on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:08PM (#28958925)
No. I can’t believe this needs to be explained, but the two situations are remarkably alike. If all of a corporations data is being held to ransom, there is no choice in the matter, they must pay. You’re talking like losing all their customers or IP or shutting down the corporation wouldn’t hurt anyone but it would hurt all their employees at the least.

What such an idiotic, short sighted policy would do is to encourage corporations to pay the ransom in secret. This only strengthens the hackers because now law enforcement has no idea who is being hit, when, and with what malware.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by jonas21 on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:45PM (#28959464)
Additionally, ransomware attackers frequently target hospitals because they know the issue can literally be a matter of life and death [1].

[1] https://www.aamc.org/news-insights/growing-threat-ransomware...

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by BeFlatXIII on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:59PM (#28961175)
Then a bunch of employees will have to find new jobs and some people have their retirement savings drained because it was illegal to pay the ransom and the business shut down. Society will move on. No long-term loss.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by true_religion on Saturday October 23, 2021 @12:19AM (#28965675)
The same can be said for highway robbery. It happens in my country and people say well it’s just a tax you have to pay for taking that road. Since the victims are businesses handling goods, the robbery fee is priced into imports and we all pay extra. It can’t be priced into exports because we are too negligible of an exporter, so instead workers in that industry are paid less and there is less money left over to invest so our growth lags behind other counties. Overall the whole country suffers, all because of a few thousand bandits sitting in the forest near the border.

But hey… our society moved on, so you’re right about that: you can definitely live with it.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by nindalf on Sunday October 24, 2021 @04:32AM (#28975932)
Is this Nigeria?
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by perl4ever on Friday October 22, 2021 @09:07PM (#28964683)
That's like a 40,000 foot perspective. As a sibling comment says, what about hospitals?

The total value of the stock markets didn't seem to suffer from Covid-19. But people have.

Maybe your point is that unrestricted ransomware shouldn't affect GDP? I'm honestly not sure. Doesn't there have to be a limit? Civilization depends on trust. Sometimes there are critical points.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by freedomben on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:08PM (#28962751)
Dang man, that is amazingly cold.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by BeFlatXIII on Saturday October 23, 2021 @11:12AM (#28969254)
Here are two representative arguments that I got sick of hearing and pushed me into the negative Kelvin:

1. Green energy requires too few employees per gigawatt compared to coal 2. It would be irresponsible to pursue a policy of a sharp correction toward affordable housing prices because it would push too many elderly into poverty

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by gopher_space on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:47PM (#28960260)
If "all" of your data is being held to ransom and that will tank your company then you are a bad businessperson and deserve whatever you get.

Right now it's apparently cheaper to pay a ransom than it is to implement sane security and backup procedures. That needs to end.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by camjohnson26 on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:04PM (#28960457)
That would be true if it was possible for any company to have perfect processes, but that’s not the case. Companies are run by real people with real flaws and a perfect system doesn’t exist.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by codegeek on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:38PM (#28960867)
That's like saying "Right now it's cheaper to not have locks so lets punish the homeowners who don't lock their doors instead of punishing the thieves and robbers"

Yes, security and backup measures are critical and companies SHOULD be scrutinized for those things especially if you deal with mission critical data/information. But that has nothing to do with Ransomware Gangs.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by WalterBright on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:35PM (#28962411)
I thought we were done with blaming the victim.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by gopher_space on Sunday October 24, 2021 @10:07PM (#28983811)
Disaster recovery plans are very common. Their plan for this disaster was to pay the ransom, thus perpetuating the cycle.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by perl4ever on Friday October 22, 2021 @09:14PM (#28964725)
"If all of a corporations data is being held to ransom, there is no choice in the matter, they must pay"

This sounds reasonable at first, but I think it might be leaning on anthropomorphizing a corporation a little much.

I think of them more as a machine, or a biological cell or microbe.

While it may be a machine optimized for survival, I'm not sure that they all are or that they must be.

An organism can self-destruct if that's what it's programmed to do.

And an organization in theory should be able to maintain processes that result in orderly self-destruction in certain circumstances, where it's appropriate in the wider society.

After all, companies typically go bankrupt rather than devolving into gang warfare, right?

A "humans first" society should not be prioritizing the survival of human created organizations above all else.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by spywaregorilla on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:35PM (#28959331)
Many ransom payments don't even release the ransom.

If paying in secret is a crime, with whistleblower opportunities, then paying in secret is not so easy. Forbidding payments will massively decrease the value of doing the attacks and reduce the number of them.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by foenix on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:09PM (#28958949)
I would have agreed with you if it weren't for the recent cases of ransomware attacks on hospitals https://cyber.forum.yale.edu/blog/2021/7/20/attributing-deat...

The anti-yakuza strategy suggested here probably wouldn't fit as a solution for attacking ransomware.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by codegeek on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:42PM (#28960908)
"unable to pay" is not the same as "should be illegal"

The perps don't give a shit about what is legal and illegal. They target preys that are vulnerable but have critical functions (e.g. a Hospital network). It is not just about individuals. If a Hospital Network gets attacked and has serious consequences, they won't do a board meeting to discuss "Gee, paying ransomware is illegal. We must say No. ".

I am not advocating that people should just pay but we cannot punish the victims even if the victims were careless (bad security practice etc).

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by elondaits on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:16AM (#28958292)
Also, there are middle-man "security companies" that you can pay to "help you decrypt your files" and what they do is simply pay the ransom under the table for you... So you can't really tell if a company paid the ransom or not.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by Enginerrrd on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:50AM (#28958703)
You can also make it illegal to seek assistance from an out-of-jurisdiction middle-man. Thus, any middle men are going to be subject to the same regulations.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by snapetom on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:44AM (#28958629)
Yep. It's like governments that forbid use of things like facial recognition software by its police departments. Sure, the police department doesn't use facial recognition, but they commonly work around this by using a vendor that may or may not use facial recognition. This model is actually commonly employed by both companies and that are forbidden to do something.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by 908B64B197 on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:18PM (#28961427)
Except in this case you can just... restore your wallet from back-up.

Pretty much the reason wallets are worthless is that if you snag one, all you get are plastic cards that are going to get cancelled in the next minutes/hours.

S3/Azure/Backblaze are really cheap and just work.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by GilbertErik on Friday October 22, 2021 @09:58AM (#28957243)
The main argument against making ransom payments illegal is that it simply drives ransom payments underground. Legislating something, similar to vices like drugs, alcohol or gambling, doesn't make it go away.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by a1369209993 on Friday October 22, 2021 @10:25AM (#28957588)
I assume they mean make it illegal for corporations to pay the ransom. It's obviously unjust and ineffective to punish private individuals for paying ransoms, but that's not where the money is. OTOH, corporations have budgets and can be prosecuted if X millions dollars disappears out of it.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by hcurtiss on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:05AM (#28958167)
I don’t view it as obviously unjust as applied to individuals. That may suck for that person, but turning off the revenue demands substantially reduces the odds others are subject to ransoms. If all you do is focus on the individual case, you never actually address the root cause.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by spywaregorilla on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:02PM (#28958853)
Make hiding ransomware attacks a criminal offense mandatory and offer whistleblower programs to companies that try to conceal it. This is an issue of national security. Individual alcohol problems are irrelevant and not comparable to large corporations.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by weego on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:36PM (#28960133)
And then you've just created a chain of legislation with the associated loopholes and confusion which will allow corporations to hide and deny any of it happening and then using legal fog to stonewall any Govt investigations and force people to risk their careers to call it out.

Forcing people to be whistle blowers is not a scalable enforcement plan. Very few people are willing to be one.

We need to legislate with the goal of corporate transparency not for more hidden behavior.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by hcurtiss on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:04AM (#28958148)
If you make it a felony to pay ransoms (which I strongly support), there will be far fewer ransom demands. Yes, some of it will go underground, but in my view it’s the only way to actually decrease the demand side of the equation.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by mjparrott on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:27AM (#28958434)
How will you know if the total amount of ransom payments goes down? How will you know how much is under the table vs over the table? This argument seems to be "the over the table stuff goes down therefore the total goes down" which is faulty logic.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by scoopertrooper on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:44AM (#28958624)
It would follow logically that it'd go down. It's like saying making murder illegal would only push murder under the table.

A company currently performs a simple mathematical equation when deciding to pay a ransom. Does the reputational and financial cost of not paying the ransom outweigh the price of the ransom? In a world where ransom payments were illegal, then those same companies would also have to include the legal penalties and probability of being caught as part of that equation.

Obviously, some companies would still see a net benefit in paying the ransom, but fewer would, so less ransoms would be paid.

It seems to me like you're trying to use 'war on drugs' logic on ransoms. The key difference is that companies don't want to pay ransoms, but do so out of necessity.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by addingnumbers on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:51AM (#28958712)
Reducing the growth rate of a subset of a total does reduce the growth rate of that total.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by true_religion on Saturday October 23, 2021 @12:23AM (#28965693)
Sure, but what you’ll end up with is that the fewer people who still do it while is illegal are those in the most desperate and sympathetic sounding straits.

It’s like prostitution, if it’s illegal you find that most sex workers are the most vulnerable in society. When it’s not, sex workers can be anyone who doesn’t want to drive 6 hours for Uber on the weekend for extra cash.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by sdenton4 on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:30PM (#28960060)
The other approach is to remove the transaction system. Make bitcoin trivially traceable (or drive it out of existence entirely) and it becomes much more difficult to handle the ransom payments, and thus, to profit from the operation.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by snapetom on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:47AM (#28958653)
I would have loved to have seen what would have happened to the East Coast of the US if Colonial wasn't allowed to pay ransomware, or the various beef suppliers in the Americas if they weren't allowed to pay.

Making it illegal to pay just isn't feasible for practical business purposes.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by toast0 on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:35PM (#28959334)
I imagine, Colonial would have restarted the pipeline without billing and figure it out later.

Probably similar for beef suppliers, although I didn't read any media about what systems were impacted there. Assuming some of the labelling or other food safety things were impacted, you would need an FDA waiver of some sort.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by pgeorgi on Friday October 22, 2021 @10:20AM (#28957510)
Make insecure software the problem of its producer, so that except for gross negligence by the user, the software vendor is on the hook (reimbursing customers) and will want to prevent ransomware from being a thing in the first place.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by mschuster91 on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:32AM (#28958494)
Even the most secure piece of software - assuming such a thing even exists! - can't do a thing against incompetent users.

Even a perfectly patched Windows instance can't be reasonably protected against an user executing an attachment of an email that then goes ahead and encrypts all files writable by the user. The only option is to ban the user from anything executable and interpreters as Apple does on their iDevices, but we all rightfully and regularly complain about that one.

As for vulnerable software: I agree, some pressure on Microsoft to open-source or at least provably audit their software would be nice - but it's rare to have a definitive attribution on how a piece of malware entered your organization, at least not in places where record-keeping and retention is restricted by laws like the GDPR.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by RNCTX on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:24AM (#28958401)
Bingo.

It's high comedy to me that 90+% of ransomware is targeted at Windows, and yet beyond the year 2020 you can still find corporate-speak in the wild that all basically boils down to a hare-brained assumption that the corporate vendor will in some way be liable if the customer suffers a breach.

When in fact the largest of software vendors sits in plain sight, obviously liable for poor designs that invite these breaches, and no one has held them to account for it.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by spywaregorilla on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:58AM (#28958792)
What percent of ransomware on windows is driven by software vulnerabilities rather than careless users?
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by RNCTX on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:59PM (#28961172)
All of it, because Windows is closed source. A user cannot be responsible for a black box's contents.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by toast0 on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:37PM (#28959357)
> gross negligence by the user

Not having tested, well scoped, and reasonably frequent backups for business critical corporate operations is gross negligence.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by pgeorgi on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:08PM (#28959793)
Not having updated the system (within reason: it _can_ take a week, but it should _not_ take a year) is gross negligence as far as vendor liability would be concerned.

But by all means, let's limit the minimum liability for software vendors for such scenarios to "costs of downtime and effort for reinstalling backups and getting everything up again": That should provide an incentive to make backup procedures effortless and have the systems make some noise if they aren't backed up (with regular recovery testing etc).

As it stands, software vendors say "users are to blame" as if their shitty software isn't enabling ransomware, users say "can't do anything about it, we're down for the next 6 months" as if ransomware is some force of nature (or act of God or whatever), when both positions, while not entirely untrue, are mostly lazy.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by rich_sasha on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:09PM (#28959801)
I think a constructive thing for governments to do is to gently push people in that direction.

Make high-quality, audited backups a legal requirement, or offer strong incentives for it, and much of the problem goes away. Companies may be able to outsource it, which arguably just shifts the attack vector elsewhere, but you would hope people who specialise in backups are better at it than their amateur clients.

Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by arcticbull on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:18PM (#28962866)
And make it illegal to purchase the tokens they use to make the payments.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by breakfastduck on Friday October 22, 2021 @10:13AM (#28957415)
Punish the victim not the perpetrator, nice.
Re:Governments turn tables on ransomware gang REvil by pushi... by fouric on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:01PM (#28958825)
Nobody is even suggesting that the perpetrator shouldn't continue to be punished (when caught).