News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by tobyjsullivan on Thursday October 21, 2021 @09:26PM (#28952804)
Pseudo-relevant anecdote: I wanted to buy a used car a few months ago off someone on Facebook. We were meeting up same day so the easiest method seemed to be cash. I went to the bank to withdraw $7000 and was informed, much to my surprise, that it is impossible to withdraw more than $3000 without 48 hours notice.

Suffice it to say, I've been seriously considering the tradeoffs of hoarding cash under my mattress.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by vl on Thursday October 21, 2021 @10:49PM (#28953218)
There was underreported shortage of cash since the start of pandemic. My branch for a while wouldn’t give out more than a $1000. Before the pandemic $10000 were fine.
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by anonporridge on Thursday October 21, 2021 @11:33PM (#28953458)
There has also been a shortage of metal coins, because physical exchange isn't happening as much during covid.

Although, I still personally believe that coins at least up to the US quarter should probably be abolished. Quarters are really the only thing semi useful as a medium of exchange, and even they are starting to lose their utility. Maybe dollar coins can still be useful.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by paulmd on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:38AM (#28958548)
the US killed the half-penny when it was worth what a dime was worth today - practically speaking, anything under a quarter is too little to be worth worrying about.

Yes, this likely means retailers will play games with change, but other times you will come out on top with the rounding. And think about it this way - yes, sometimes retailers played games with the half-penny too. A few decades on, once you've gotten out of the mindset that someone is "cheating you" out of maybe as much as a quarter-penny every transaction, nobody cares, it's not an actual significant amount of money.

there also are significant costs associated with maintaining currency units that small - it costs more than a penny to make a penny, and while sure, that penny gets used through multiple transactions, that also incurs additional costs on everybody who has to handle that penny in every single transaction. The amount of time and energy spent handling that penny probably winds up being dollars over the lifespan of the penny.

this also gives interesting context to the expression "a penny saved is a penny earned" - that expression today would be "a dollar saved is a dollar earned". A penny was actually a decently significant amount of money when that expression was coined, it wasn't literally "every single quarter-penny matters".

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by post_from_work on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:13AM (#28953935)
Granted I live in Japan, but I carry a coinpurse (an old camera bag) because the 10-yen, 100-yen, and 500-yen coins are so useful. Vending machines are on practically every corner here, and the drink sizes are such that $1.20 for a drink is normal. I think most US vending machines have gigantic cans of Coca-Cola / Red Bull / Monster for $3+.

The US probably could get by with just $1 and $5 coins.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by sofixa on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:39AM (#28954579)
Vending machines in France usually have NFC readers to allow contactless payments by card or phone. It's so much more practical than carrying a bunch of coins.
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by leppr on Friday October 22, 2021 @08:45AM (#28956555)
But it's much much harder to acquire a privacy-respecting contactless payment setup than carry a bunch of coins.
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by mdp2021 on Friday October 22, 2021 @09:49AM (#28957156)
> privacy-respecting contactless payment setup

Do you know any? If I could vet its security and """reasonably total""" privacy, the idea could be tempting - e.g. to buy a cheap device to only do monetary transactions. I am not sure, first of all, how you would transform cash into credit into a personal device.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by leppr on Saturday October 23, 2021 @08:29AM (#28967782)
I don't know of a way that's both widespread, cheap and legal.

* Country-specific: prepaid cards like Suica in Japan, purchasable with cash from ATMs.

* Not that cheap: offshore bank account.

* Not legal: crypto card with "borrowed" KYC.

So basically unless you're lucky to be living in a country with a privacy-respecting culture, you have to act like a criminal to regain the basic right to privacy.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by mdp2021 on Sunday October 24, 2021 @11:09AM (#28978616)
Do you mean that you obtain a card, go to an ATM, insert the card and the cash, and recharge it - without the ATM knowing it is you?

Because I also know of systems which are related to banks, but explicitly come from your account, invisibly to the seller - but the bank knows everything.

I have seen anonymous pre-paid cards which had in the back the space for a signature, and were accompanied by instructions such as "must be signed to be valid".

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by GuB-42 on Friday October 22, 2021 @06:45AM (#28955601)
Many vending machines in Tokyo accept contactless subway cards (suica) for payment, but not all of them.

The Japanese still love their cash and coins. And even though they have a variety of NFC payment options and credit cards are not as terrible as they once were, their adoption rate is slow.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by marban on Friday October 22, 2021 @08:31AM (#28956451)
Can't wait to swipe my Hello Kitty Icoca for a can of Boss Flash Brew ;)
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by Robotbeat on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:29AM (#28953995)
Last vending machine I used had cans for 75¢ and bottles for $1.25.
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by post_from_work on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:03AM (#28954408)
Damn a $0.75 can is cheap even by Japanese standards, and I'm assuming that's a US-standard 12FL OZ can (bigger than Japanese ones too).
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by anonporridge on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:24AM (#28953981)
What's the value of coins? Paper and plastic notes seems more convenient in most cases.

Metal coins seem like a case of holding onto tradition despite losing the original reason for the tradition.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by franga2000 on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:50AM (#28954351)
As you said, in most cases. Mechanical (no electronics) vending machines are only possible with coins and even with electronics, sorting/recognising coins is far easier than notes. A basic coin also takes more effort to forge (well enough to pass at a gas station) than a basic note, although notes seeming everywhere else but the US have obvious safety features that completely beat coins.

They're also much easier to handle when you need many different ones, like when you're trying to assemble an exact amount. I can just look into my wallet and pick out the coins I need, whereas with notes, I'd have to spread them out like an awkward floppy hand of cards and especially if they weren't distinct enough scanning through and finding the right ones sounds plain annoying.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by bbarnett on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:07AM (#28958189)
Coins also last a lot longer, and are harder to accidentally damage / destroy. Canada moved to 1 and 2 dollar coins, for just this reason.

(Plus, 2 dollars is like a quarter 50 years ago....)

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by toast0 on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:01AM (#28954117)
Detecting quarters is a lot easier, faster, and more reliable than detecting dollar bills. Card payments really want to be made online and transaction fees are brutal for small amounts anyway, so you end up with special purpose stored value cards and all of the lost change that implies.

Plus, quarters are better to flip to make decisions than bills.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by zerocount on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:49AM (#28954998)
Yep, tails never fails!
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by umangrathi on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:19AM (#28954204)
On the other end here in India there are few vending machines, but mostly are now based on digital payments.
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by bbarnett on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:02AM (#28958122)
Canada got rid of pennies.
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by blacksmith_tb on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:13PM (#28960579)
That's interesting, Wells at least seems to have increased cash withdrawal limits from their ATMs during the pandemic (and/or it's been years since I withdrew enough cash to notice), my memory was that I couldn't pull out more than ~$300/day but I see there's a $1000 option now (not sure how many customers they could serve taking that much out, I did recently see one ATM out of service to be refilled in the middle of the afternoon).
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by astura on Thursday October 21, 2021 @10:50PM (#28953225)
I've always heard the best way to do this transaction is for buyer and seller to meet at buyers bank. Buyer obtains cashier's check with seller watching and hands it over to seller before leaving bank. This way seller knows cashier's check is real, you don't have to deal with large amounts of cash, and nobody's at risk of getting robbed.

Downside is you have to go during banking hours and you have to make an extra trip.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by thorin on Friday October 22, 2021 @06:01AM (#28955380)
I don't really see people doing this in the UK anymore. Cars can be bought with a debit card if you have the funds, sometimes a call to the bank is required for verification.

When I've bought 2nd hand kayaks from someone's home, I've been able to transfer the money on my phone through the banking app and they've seen the funds arrive in seconds. Is this not the case in the US?

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by nly on Friday October 22, 2021 @06:06AM (#28955403)
The US banking system is still dog shit by comparison to the UK/EU.

That said, Faster Payments in the UK are not guaranteed to be instant and can take up to 2 hours. Also, some banks will arbitrarily downgrade them back to slow old BACs if it flags up as risky on their systems or if it's someone you haven't sent money to before.

In general I agree it's not a problem though, you're not going to let the buyer take the keys until the money is in your account.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by sokoloff on Friday October 22, 2021 @08:17AM (#28956328)
Every secondhand item I've bought or sold on Craigslist (including a car bought and a car sold) was transacted in cash (literal banknotes). There is 0.0% chance that I'd consider paying or accepting anything else as it's just not the normal practice, meaning the risk of fraud is much higher.
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by rahoulb on Friday October 22, 2021 @06:14AM (#28955440)
I did this a couple of months ago (in the UK) - bought a car and did the bank transfer on my phone, sat in the guy's front room.

However, I did need to borrow his card reader/code generator thing - put my card in, enter the PIN and the amount and then type in the code it generated into my phone to authorise the transfer. Presumably because of the large amount going to a new payee.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by nly on Friday October 22, 2021 @06:19AM (#28955467)
What bank was this with? Barclays for instance, while still having card readers, has a digital version built in to the app now.
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by rahoulb on Friday October 22, 2021 @09:48AM (#28957146)
NatWest.

They have some biometric auth thing in the app now but I've not set it up or even looked at it yet.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by Robotbeat on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:33AM (#28954006)
That’s a really good idea.
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by r00f on Friday October 22, 2021 @07:26AM (#28955902)
It can be just bank policy, not related to any shortage or whatever. My bank allowed me to withdraw $ 30k, and didn't even ask why, they just said "come tomorrow, we don't have that cash today".
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by tobyjsullivan on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:04PM (#28958885)
Yeah, it's not a shortage. It's bank policy to mitigate the risk of bank runs. What bothered me was the 24hr (or 48 hr in my case) notice requirement. That day I learned that my money is only actually mine (in the sense that I can use it as I please) if the bank decides to allow me.

As time goes on, those dollar maximums and notice periods are malleable and completely outside my control.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by OldHand2018 on Friday October 22, 2021 @09:57PM (#28964951)
> That day I learned that my money is only actually mine (in the sense that I can use it as I please) if the bank decides to allow me.

It’s possible that the kind of account you have with that bank plays a role here. There has been a lot of deregulation over the last 10 years or something, but it used to be that your account had a descriptive name - passbook savings, demand deposit, etc. And those names meant something! A demand account meant you could demand your money any time you wanted, but it was against the law to earn interest. A passbook savings account earned interest, but you were limited in how often you could take money out, etc.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by Spooky23 on Thursday October 21, 2021 @10:22PM (#28953089)
Depends on the bank. Most branches are really sales offices. Usually there’s a few that actually stock cash.
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by dghlsakjg on Thursday October 21, 2021 @11:03PM (#28953290)
That’s wild. When I was a teller (15 years ago maybe) we would routinely keep around 7-10k in our drawers, and another 40k as ready money in the day safe.

Granted, we were a drive up branch that dealt with commercial/retail so a lot of customers would routinely be dealing with 5k worth of cash. Other branches had similar amounts of cash though.

Strange world

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by anonporridge on Thursday October 21, 2021 @11:23PM (#28953402)
I've also been hit by not being able to withdraw more than about $5k cash as a retail customer without multi day notice. I do wonder if it's not all nefarious as cash has become drastically less common over the past couple decades.

Still, it's especially interesting because the numbers even 15 years ago are much higher in real terms than today.

This is another advantage of inflation.

You can set rules like, you have to declare more than $10k worth of assets traveling with you on flights, and every year, the plummeting value of that dollar metric includes more and more people and activities in the surveillance state.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by lazide on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:08AM (#28954144)
Cash is a bit of a pain to deal with, and most branches all normal withdrawals are going to be via the ATM anyway.

Cash is also a security risk and liability from a ‘getting robbed’ perspective.

So it’s rare to really need more anymore, except for outlier situations like car sales, which they generally don’t handle well.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by dghlsakjg on Friday October 22, 2021 @10:27AM (#28957622)
True, but so much of banking has been moved to online and mobile so visits to an actual branch are almost always outlier situations.

I shouldn’t have to schedule something ahead of time which is the equivalent of cashing the average American paycheck. Cash might be a bit of a pain, but there are still plenty of common and good reasons why I might want 5k of my money without having to wait a few days for it.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by lazide on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:12PM (#28962794)
100% agree, however a lot of the banks seem to not have picked up on this yet.
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by acheron on Friday October 22, 2021 @09:11AM (#28956780)
Same, though it was about 20 years ago for me.

I remember a guy withdrawing $25k in cash one day. That was unusual, which is why I remember it, but it wasn’t a problem either. (We gave it to him in a big sack, and I was disappointed that the sack didn’t have a large $ printed on the side.)

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by Spooky23 on Friday October 22, 2021 @10:03AM (#28957303)
Look at the security at most bank branches - it’s awful.

My wife used to work at a regional branch that did cash management for other banks. The place was like a fortress and had a lot of physical security measures to protect the people and dollars. That branch was nuts - they’d handle millions in currency and be able to handle six figure withdrawals. Midtown Manhattan banks can do that too.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by wink on Friday October 22, 2021 @08:21AM (#28956360)
Same thing here, wanted to buy a car in cash, called the bank "Can I have x thousand EUR today?" - "No, you need to tell us 24h in advance" - "OK, can I have x-1 thousand EUR tomorrow?" - "Are you kidding me?"

Well, either they made it or I went to 2 different branches, but it was a classic "Why even have the rule with an arbitrary number"

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by mdp2021 on Friday October 22, 2021 @09:40AM (#28957066)
> it is impossible to withdraw more than

In some countries that's the law.

> I wanted to buy a used car ... the easiest method seemed to be cash

In some countries that became illegal over a certain threshold of expense the payment must be traceable).

I was recently told (but did not verify) that car sellers, in some countries, out of some regulation, nowadays will even ask you how you "made" that money. (And I replied that they'd better know better before being impertinent.)

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by dannyw on Friday October 22, 2021 @09:55AM (#28957214)
sounds like you live in a police state.
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by mdp2021 on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:45AM (#28958635)
A place with a traditionally skewed (Pareto) distribution in all non-monetary contexts, in which it was decided that Median Jack should rule and anti-intellectualism ate society and state.

I am trying to flee - if you know a place in which values (such as aptitude and civilization) are still in place, drop a note.

Interestingly for the context, it was a crisis in banking that "made the first alarms ring", in my case, years ago.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by anonporridge on Thursday October 21, 2021 @09:42PM (#28952898)
You're not that many steps away from being a gold bug or a bitcoin hodler.
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by strken on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:06AM (#28953660)
I don't think this is true. I don't know anyone who would have benefited from owning gold or bitcoin in an emergency. However, my hometown once had its only internet exchange catch on fire, and the bank had a multiple-hour queue going around the block to withdraw a maximum of (I think) $300 in cash. I've also loaned money to people whose bank accounts got flagged.

For those reasons I keep a week of cash on hand, not because civilisation might collapse, but as a buffer if my access to the banking system is disrupted.

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by zerocount on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:56AM (#28955044)
I owned an ounce of gold in the past. When I needed some quick cash many of the buyers wouldn't buy it for fear of it being fake. The ones that would buy it wanted to pay less than the spot price. I've never owned it since, but silver coins were a different story. I had 1oz Canadian maple leafs that sold very quickly.
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by toast0 on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:20AM (#28954210)
Depending on your hobbies, having access to cash to make purchases is pretty important. (Do you collect arcade machines, vintage bikes or vintage anything else? If so, you might want to buy something with cash that costs a $1000 or two).

For a while last year, bank branches had pretty limited hours, and I bank with a out of state credit union (because they have decent interest rates, even if that's 0.5% these days), and some co-op network branches weren't doing shared branching either. So, if I want to be able to buy something over my daily ATM limit, I had to hoard cash, since I couldm't be sure I'd have access to it.

Of course, prices haven't been great for buyers on most things (although I did pick up a well priced Street Fighter II Turbo early last summer and a not terribly priced tandem this spring; lots more nice things went at prices I'm not willing to pay)

Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by adfrhgeaq5hy on Thursday October 21, 2021 @11:47PM (#28953555)
The reason those people exist is that the US banking system is so bizarrely dysfunctional. The American system is corrupt and byzantine and antiquated and leaves tens of millions of people out in the cold. Those people are absolutely right to be furious. They're just wrong about the solution.
Re:Banks, gangsters and the strange resurgence of cash by da_big_ghey on Thursday October 21, 2021 @10:14PM (#28953051)
I dont think either of those is any great option but government has really damaged our banking system. Having no ability to withdraw own money or having the IRS snoop if you have more than $x in an account is so really wrong and makes me want to look elsewhere, just there dont seem to be many good alternatives.