Money is simply a representation of value. If you can create value out of "thin air", or even the perception of value out of thin air, then you can make a profit. That much has always been true.
What gives the C-Corp shares value, particularly the ones that trade at very high P/E ratios? Speculation on future growth, speculation on potential dividends, speculation on favorable market conditions, speculation on quantitative easing bringing yet more trillions flowing into stock market, etc.
What's interesting to me, is that people think our US Federal Reserve fiat monetary system is not an MLM scheme in the same way. We know who profits from the existing system: the older participants who got in early. We know who's been totally screwed by the current system: millennials and Gen Zers who can't afford housing, saddled with debt, living with their parents in their 30s:
https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/09/04/a-majority-...
A business is a productive asset. Cryptocurrency tokens are not.
Business (noun) is not a productive asset.
1) There are literally millions of empty and bad-faith businesses that you never hear about because they successfully fly under the radar
2) People definitely (though, to your point: not the general public yet) call out some tokens as being scams. It’s much more of a “wild west” (aka: lots of dirty business going on that no one knows how to identify much less stop), but people in the space can pretty easily tell if a token has integrity or not. Look at Beeple, for example. I think most people who read the story would agree he’s not scamming.
The only difference is that C-corp shares are marketed to investors as securities, while Wordcoin is disguised as a so called cryptocurrency/tokens.
This seems to be the way this has always operated right the way back to Bitcoin - distribute tokens, and fund a market to provide initial "liquidity" until enough people are using it to maintain some semblance of value.
Fundamentally, the definition of money is a token of exchange that people are willing to use. What preferences one form of money over others is the government allowing/requiring tax payments in it. (Which presumably is now the case for bitcoin in El Salvador at least.) The easiest way to succeed at this is to provide funds to create a market - with the proviso that as more and more currencies get created, the "supply" part of the equation gets a bit out of hand. Something very similar happened with the 1840´s libertarian banking experiments in the US.
With Worldcoin the creator of this "orb" hardware has complete control of currency creation. I don't see any path towards decentralization here..
Not really; no (even theoretically democratic) has a flat distribution of citizen political power for that to be true in general; it is true in cases where the general opinion happens to be in line with elite opinion, or so strong as to overcome the power inequalities, but otherwise governments act according to elite opinion, not general popular will.
I wasn't saying that chargebacks don't exist. I was saying that the government dictating that you cannot lose all your money in a foolish endeavor would, in some parts be seen as infringing on your "freedoms".
Force safety nets was the discussion, as i took it. And some countries are resoundingly against forced safety nets.
Everybody agreed it was a good thing when the Fed shut down several scam colleges and forcibly discharged all the debt students had taken on. People aren't really meant to evaluate whether colleges are "real".
On the other hand, gambling laws tend to be contested. Gambling is regulated - most Casinos don't cheat but may have unfair odds. People who support gambling argue that adults can make unwise decisions so long as we can assure Casinos are honest and post odds.
The alternative view re gambling is that gambling rewards part of the human brain that we are bad at regulating and the government should step in and prevent even "honest" gambling.
Both of those takes on gambling have merits. If you oppose gambling because it's unethical, would it be ok to ban people who collect trading cards at insane prices hoping to resell them? Likewise if you support gambling, don't you have to admit it's brought many to financial and family ruin?
The question re crypto is whether crypto is more like gambling or more like a scammy college. My position is that crypto is a scam, not an honest casino.
I mean, some people might think that, but every functioning state in the world has laws against fraud, at the very least, and generally various investor safeguarding laws beyond that.
The pump and dump aspect is that the reasons given why anyone should value the token are flimsy. If they were solid then it would just be a good investment.
There is a mechanic at the heart of investment that, purified of anything resembling social worth, becomes a gambling game that people can play for fun, despite knowing that it has no other value.
There's definitely a wastefulness aspect that may have been underestimated, though...
step 2) ???
step 3) profit!
It's always marketing, on the missing dots in this kind of list. Otherwise people don't know where they can buy whatever it is you are selling. Underpants, apparently, in this case.
Also you're so very right.