News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Willingness to look stupid by cycomanic on Thursday October 21, 2021 @06:32AM (#28942583)
I have to say this part (and quite a few other parts of the post) come across as quite arrogant. I mean if he really wants the computer with the smallest box, why can't he explain why.

I agree with the general gist of the post: don't be afraid to ask stupid questions. However, the post has an underlying "feeling" of "my questions are not really stupid, I'm just so smart that others don't realise". I know that I ask plenty of stupid questions when I ask questions, I often realise how stupid they were just after the answer.

Re:Willingness to look stupid by jszymborski on Thursday October 21, 2021 @11:28AM (#28945849)
I frankly had the same impression. It felt it was less about the willingness to look to stupid, but rather the stupidity of people who surrounded him and their inability to see this individual's brilliance.

Perhaps this is an unkind reading, but particularly the laptop scenario felt telling that this person might feel above explaining why they might prefer a laptop which comes in a smaller box.

On the surface that is very much a ridiculous request, regardless of how sensible it might actually be. Surely that shouldn't stop you from making the request, but you must understand that someone is merely doing their job to make sure that you understand what you're asking for.

If I go to a tuba shop and ask how many litres of ranch dressing it holds, I'm not going to scoff when the salesperson reminds me that it isn't a fancy brass bowl.

Re:Willingness to look stupid by davidivadavid on Thursday October 21, 2021 @11:55AM (#28946371)
Yeah, this looks like a typical case of the "XY problem" where it's really hard to tell if the person making the request is framing that request wrongly/with unnecessary constraints to satisfy what they actually want.
Re:Willingness to look stupid by myohmy on Thursday October 21, 2021 @05:44PM (#28951181)
This is why I look for sales training in my hires. Its clear that the Apple rep was asking probing questions trying to wrestle him into a decision funnel. I've sold laptops to a bunch of grandmas who've given me questions like that, and never to a "CPU designer".

...come to think of it, maybe one of the grandmas was a CPU designer all a long!!

Re:Willingness to look stupid by davidivadavid on Thursday October 21, 2021 @06:12PM (#28951466)
She's probably fuming right now that you dared ask her a concrete question about what she wanted.
Re:Willingness to look stupid by genewitch on Thursday October 21, 2021 @09:10PM (#28952703)
What could possibly be more concrete than "bring me the computer what comes in the smallest box"?
Re:Willingness to look stupid by PebblesRox on Thursday October 21, 2021 @07:32PM (#28952125)
On the other hand, if I was in a situation where I wanted the computer with the smallest box for whatever reason, I would find it really difficult to ask for that because I would be embarrassed by how it doesn't fit the expected pattern of what I should be looking for. I will often wimp out and not be clear about my preferences in situations like these because I'm afraid of awkwardness. So I do admire the willingness to speak up about unusual preferences.
Re:Willingness to look stupid by NiceWayToDoIT on Thursday October 21, 2021 @07:10AM (#28942815)
I think it is measure of time, for author it looks simple to put everything in few words instead of having long explanation, I find this typical in IT, where my coworkers all the time trying to compress explanation in fewest words possible. Maybe laziness or type of optimization, but usually back fires as other people ask you multiple questions, arising from their own point of view.
Re:Willingness to look stupid by b3morales on Thursday October 21, 2021 @01:20PM (#28947786)
That doesn't sound like backfiring to me. The hardest part of explaining something complex is matching it to the recipient's existing frame of reference. Letting them lead the explanation by asking questions can be an effective way for them to fit the new information into their current understanding.
Re:Willingness to look stupid by NiceWayToDoIT on Friday October 22, 2021 @11:53PM (#28965544)
> The hardest part of explaining something complex is matching it to the recipient's existing frame of reference.

Nicely said, I was trying to say that significant number of us is quite bad at it. And on the other hand, if frames are completely different, first compressed explanation looks like "noise noise word noise noise ...". On the other hand, often I see people struggling to start explaining as they know they will loose 30 min of time just to get to basics, so saying "I need computer in smallest box" - can be translated to "I want you to trust me and not bore me with you daily sale's pitch script you have learned by cart, I do not have time explain, I just need what I want not what you want to recommend me, unlike other customers I do not need your assistance I just need you to give me what I want. If customer is always right, just give me what I want, and I will make a purchase and you can move to the next customer."

Sometimes I think that this inpatient arose from search engines, where you type at most 3 words and you get your 10 results you were searching for. So, I assume it is reflected how we communicate with other fellow humans, demanding immediate results instead of 2 way communication.

We can argue it is rude, but for person who built his strong will over years in a hard way, attempt of manipulation and selling is also rude and intruding.

I do not have you ever been to Turkey or Greece where you have these shop owners who are literally trying to drag you in to the shop so you can buy something. For them it is like a ritual or the game, but if you do not want to be part of that theater show, you will find it very annoying.

In many Balkan countries they will ask you multiple times to eat or drink, and polite answer is "I cannot" but if you give that answer it is basically conversation starter for "Why? Are you ok? Is there something wrong...", it is part of social game to continue conversation. If you answer "I don't want to" although it is technically most correct, you will be showered with responses as "that is rude", "we will not poison you", "why is something wrong with my food", "why are you angry at me" ... and all you wanted to say is "I do not need any food or drink at this time as my body does not needed it, and I am perfectly content with my energy and liquid levels" :)

So, for many technical persons, who live most of their live in their own head, trying to juggle multiple ideas and resolve who knows what, small talk can be a major annoyance.

And I do not want to start with "this is secret project idea I am working on, I should not share it with anyone, someone may steal my idea ..." and everything along those lines...

Re:Willingness to look stupid by dangerface on Thursday October 21, 2021 @07:32AM (#28942968)
I try to give short simple examples because when I try to tell people the truth their eyes glaze over and their brain turns off while the nerd talks his techno jumble.

Non technical people only have the patience to learn / listen to very basic concepts.

> but usually back fires as other people ask you multiple questions, arising from their own point of view.

I don't think this is back firing its just giving the non technical person the time to take in whats been said and then they ask follow up questions to confirm their understanding. I have had people get frustrated that I was talking down to them, when that happens I stop and talk to them as if they have my knowledge and they immediately regret that and ask me to go back to explaining like they are a child. Its not me trying to fluff my ego by talking down, I just legitimately know more about the topic than them, thats why they are paying me, I guess some times they just need reminded of that.

Re:Willingness to look stupid by karmelapple on Thursday October 21, 2021 @09:47AM (#28944296)
> Non technical people only have the patience to learn / listen to very basic concepts.

I know many people who would consider themselves non-technical, yet who certainly take the time to learn complex concepts. Some of those are indeed technological concepts.

> I try to give short simple examples because when I try to tell people the truth their eyes glaze over and their brain turns off while the nerd talks his techno jumble.

The short simple examples you give are also truthful, correct?

Perhaps the additional information you'd like to explain simply isn't needed for the other person's goal.

A great way to have both technical and non-technical people's eyes glaze over is detailing all kinds of minute details before describing some of the high-level goals or giving context as to why you're getting so deep into the details. As you mention, simple examples can get a lot across, and can be a springboard to more questions being asked, to allow the other person to decide what depth of knowledge they would like to know.

The non-technical person you're talking to may very well have the patience to learn the deep technical truth you'd like to explain, but they may have no reason to know it. In the scenario you're thinking of, you're doing the technical work, not them, correct? So why would they need to know deep technical details? A basic outline, with some corner cases pointed out, is likely all they need. Not because they don't have patience to learn what you're explaining, but because they have other things that are more important to their or your organization's success.

Re:Willingness to look stupid by h2odragon on Thursday October 21, 2021 @08:41AM (#28943562)
Our genuine joy and excitement about the minute details of subnetting or data compression or whatever; during those explanations often doesn't help either.

I scare people when im enthused about something. Its a bitch.

Re:Willingness to look stupid by joeberon on Thursday October 21, 2021 @10:03AM (#28944537)
> Non technical people only have the patience to learn / listen to very basic concepts.

What a stupidly arrogant comment. Have you not heard of philosophy, for example?

Re:Willingness to look stupid by amusedcyclist on Thursday October 21, 2021 @11:24PM (#28953405)
Yeah but we generally don't work with philosophers, we work with sales people and marketers. I respect their skill but they generally aren't the types to be interested in learning new things
Re:Willingness to look stupid by davidivadavid on Thursday October 21, 2021 @11:57AM (#28946396)
Or any non-STEM field...
Re:Willingness to look stupid by seoulmetro on Thursday October 21, 2021 @08:00PM (#28952331)
>"my questions are not really stupid, I'm just so smart that others don't realise"

Sounds like this was the point of the blog post. He also drops that he was "very good" at Overwatch and "#1 in the world". Usually the people who want to tell others about this in public are not very good.

The ones who are very good are the ones who only tell you after you've tried teaching them. Since bad players in games often can't tell what good players look like, or how they play.

Re:Willingness to look stupid by kevinmgranger on Thursday October 21, 2021 @10:10AM (#28944645)
I think this interaction is an example of what "the customer is always right" is supposed to mean. Sure, the salesperson should verify that the person isn't using mistaken terminology, but past that, why not just help them? Or why didn't the salesperson take the initiative to ask them for the reason, instead of continuing to insist they were mistaken?
Re:Willingness to look stupid by mbauman on Thursday October 21, 2021 @10:49AM (#28945281)
But they did help him. I don't see this as a huge indictment on the rep here — they _do_ deal with people who are very ignorant of tech everyday. Maybe it took a while to convince them, but I think that's just as likely a failing of communication.

> I eventually asked them to humor me and just bring out the boxes for the various laptop models so I could see the boxes, which they did, despite clearly thinking that my decision making process made no sense