[1] https://fishshell.com/docs/current/design.html#configurabili...
That said fish is quite configurable¹, it just have pleasant (well maybe not to you) default that you can change.
1- The ssettings are mostly listed there https://fishshell.com/docs/current/interactive.html
I think these projects are extremely opinionated and they will inevitably drive a lot of users away. Both fish and GNOME strive to provide "good" defaults out of the box but those defaults will never appeal to everyone. I ended up liking fish but I still despise GNOME and everything related to it.
I ended up back on zsh. It's a real shame, because fish adds quite a lot in terms of improved subshell syntax and intelligent string manipulation.
Seems like someone should have been able to disable the suggestions using a plugin or something, given that IIRC fish has a plugin interface. But as far as I can tell no such thing exists.
For scripts, you can still use bash or zsh or python or whatever you want.
I prefer to keep my utilities scripting and interactive shell the same. That way I don't have to keep two sets of gotchas in my head, and don't accidentally use the wrong syntax in one place or the other sometimes leading to confusing misbehaviours.
While I don't mix bash/zsh/sh/... I will consider python/node/other if I need specific things that they do well or I'm making something more than a simple tool or automation (for which bash is either underkill or just thoroughly unsuited). They are sufficiently different that I'm not going to cause myself the sort of mix-up I might with flipping between shell scripting syntaxes.
I'll admit that I haven't really dug into scripting with elvish, because I quickly abandoned it again.
My main reason for leaving elvish again was the good syntax completion in fish. Yes, you can create your own completions in elvish and they'll probably be just as good, but that takes time and I ultimately decided not to bother with it.
It is actually the other way round, with bash being an incremental improvement over zsh. Starting from v3, bash has adopted many features that zsh had had for a long time.
Both, bash and zsh, are incremental improvements over the Korn shell.
On the other hand, fish shell feels like a bash rethought and optimized for interactive use. It's now my daily driver on all of my Linux and Windows machines (msys2 port). After using it only for interactive sessions, I also started to write my utilities in fish, which is a breath of fresh air compared to both bash and zsh.
The only place where I still use bash is when I need to write a script that needs to be shared with others, everything else is now fish.