News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When is a URL shortener not a URL shortener? by jarin on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @12:03AM (#2889825)
This doesn't just bug me for URLs that are shorter than the t.co URL, but also when I'm posting a link to a website and I want people to see the full URL.

e.g. It is often sufficiently descriptive to tweet "This is a great site: http://actionfiguresridingkittens.tumbly.mil

Re:When is a URL shortener not a URL shortener? by Auguste on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @03:21AM (#2890224)
"It is often sufficiently descriptive to tweet "This is a great site: http://actionfiguresridingkittens.tumbly.mil

You disappointed me when I clicked that link and found it didn't exist.

Re:When is a URL shortener not a URL shortener? by ceejayoz on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @12:21AM (#2889884)
Twitter has implemented a decent solution for that, which most clients (including the website) respect - it includes a display_url parameter along with the shortened URL in tweets fetched via the API.
Re:When is a URL shortener not a URL shortener? by v21 on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @07:10AM (#2890702)
But the displayed URL is truncated with an ellipsis at the end. The OPs URL is likely long enough to trigger that. Sometimes a long URL is all you want to share, but that is now impossible to do. A tweet saying "http://hotchickswithstubbedtoesmakingsexfaces.com/ exists" is a decent tweet, but a tweet saying "http://hotchickswit... exists" isn't as good. And sure, you can mouseover to see the full link, but that's balls.
Re:When is a URL shortener not a URL shortener? by frankdenbow on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @09:52AM (#2891125)
Agreed. I find short urls to be irritating when I want to share a link. REST makes it so links can be descriptive without visiting the link. I remember sending a link to a friend by DM and having them think it was spam since Twitter shortened it.
Re:When is a URL shortener not a URL shortener? by mmahemoff on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @09:14AM (#2890988)
There's no preview for this, so you find out too late.

I think a proper short URL looks neater too: "http://t.co/x812ks1 A site about action figures" "http://action.figures.com/rid... A site about action figures"

The short URL may not look pretty, but at least regular Twitter users will quickly learn to process it as "some URL". The longer abbreviated one breaks that convention and by including some actual meaning, it gets in the way.