News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by armchairhacker on Thursday October 14, 2021 @07:48PM (#28871853)
I don't get the argument against having less children. It would be different if the human race was really dying out. But it seems like most of our problems are caused by overpopulation.

If the future generations only have 3.5 billion people, 1 billion, 10 million, I don't see how we'd be worse off. Fields like production, retail, maintenance, etc. would have less workers, but also proportionally less demand. Fields like research and academia would also have less people, probably leading to less discoveries, but how much? and how much would it matter? We lose resistance to extinction if there's a deadly disease that kills almost 100% of the population, but we gain resistance from transmissible diseases.

And I know there are tons of people who still really want to have kids. And smart / talented / skeptical people who want to have kids.

Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by kongolongo on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:05PM (#28872015)
>But it seems like most of our problems are caused by overpopulation.

That's too broad of a generalization and not true globally, some countries problems are exactly because of underpopulation. The problem isn't homogeneous throughout the world. It's highly dependent on what populations you're talking about and their circumstances.

>Fields like production, retail, maintenance, etc. would have less workers, but also proportionally less demand.

In some developed countries where recently the birthrates hover very slightly to sometimes below replacement rates can lead to a whole hosts of problems. For example take into account age proportionality as a result of extremely low birthrates in Japan, an ever increasing older and retired population does not have enough younger labor to produce good/services for basic societal function. There's also problems of gender imbalances like in India or China also causing massive issues in the coming generations.

Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by sbierwagen on Thursday October 14, 2021 @07:57PM (#28871946)
>10 million

A world population that small certainly wouldn't sustain semiconductor manufacturing, even if you concentrated them in one region.

Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by bpodgursky on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:01PM (#28871988)
lol a world population that small probably couldn't sustain iron smelting. Have fun digging for grubs and shivering through the winter huddled around the campfire.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by sbierwagen on Friday October 15, 2021 @05:14PM (#28883200)
Iron mining has been done at small scale for thousands of years.

A population of 10 million is the population of England circa 1812. Machine tools, glass optics. Electricity should be possible. Powered flight, if you had hydrocarbons.

Oil would be a problem. All the easy deposits are tapped. A successor civilization would have a hard time progressing past steam power.

A lot depends on how we crash to 10 million. If all the wells are shut down cleanly, thoroughly documented, then the people blink out existence, then the 10 million could live quite a white just on today's reserves. If we end up at 10 million after decades or centuries of warfare, then there won't be any oil left. (Plus the sea would be a lot higher, and many oil deposits would be in places where summer temperatures would be fatal for humans) Liquid fuels can be made from steam cracking of coal hydrocarbons, but they're expensive.

No nuclear power, no turbines, none of the exotic metals that require electron-beam vacuum furnaces. No pharmaceuticals, no long supply lines, limited manufacturing specialization or economies of scale. Fasteners would be expensive again. Fabric would be expensive. Probably the number one most important thing to get working again is production of artificial fertilizers. Without that you're stuck with organic agriculture and 1 out of 2 people working in the fields.

And somehow I get ten sentences into this comment before remembering about a book I read that made the exact same point about fertilizer: https://www.amazon.com/Knowledge-Rebuild-Civilization-Afterm...

Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by beaconstudios on Thursday October 14, 2021 @07:56PM (#28871934)
as people get older, they become infirm and require support; not just directly (relatives or nursing homes looking after their basic needs) but financially. Society is a pyramid, and when a pyramid narrows at the base, it becomes unstable.

Also, our problems (presumably the myriad environmental ones) aren't caused by overpopulation, they're caused by rampant corporate polluting in service to individualistic consumer culture.

Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by arvinsim on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:01PM (#28871984)
Agreed. Overpopulation is an outdated boogeyman. Climate change IMO is the more pressing concern.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by mathematically on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:06PM (#28872033)
What do you suppose is the root cause of global warming?
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by TheSpiceIsLife on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:50PM (#28872429)
A build up of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere.

What are you getting at?

If everything were electric and nuclear, green hydrogen, whatever, we wouldn’t have this particular problem, so it can’t be population alone.

Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by mathematically on Thursday October 14, 2021 @09:04PM (#28872568)
You're correct so I'll explain what I was trying to get at.

At the moment, focusing on dwindling birth rates is nonsensical because the world population is projected to be 10B people by 2050. So the issue isn't lack of people, it's the inability of various nations to properly coordinate a response to an existential crisis (global warming and increasing volume of CO2 in the atmosphere: https://climate.nasa.gov/climate_resources/24/graphic-the-re...). Dwindling birth rates in Britain should be the last thing anyone is worried about if their real concern is not having enough people in the future. I mean if they're really concerned about lack of Brits then I guess it makes sense, but globally, on a planetary scale, worrying about local birth rates is not really something to be concerned about.

Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by arvinsim on Thursday October 14, 2021 @10:09PM (#28873253)
Of course it is a concern. No nation survives with an indefinite dwindling population. If nations turn to immigration as a way to bolster their population, it cones with its own set of problems.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by rsj_hn on Thursday October 14, 2021 @10:12PM (#28873284)
Why would it be indefinite? People less likely to have kids exit the gene pool, and a smaller population of those more likely to have kids survive. In the smaller population land is cheaper, less crowded, there are more natural resources per person, and population grows again, from the lower level. Unless you try to short-circuit that adjustment process by keeping the human/land ratio where it is and importing people to keep land more expensive. And then you have to deal with all the costs of ethnic conflict.

China, with a population of 500 million, would be a much more pleasant place to live. China with a population of 500 million Han and 800 million-strong hodge-podge of other groups constantly resenting each other and together resenting the Han? Not so nice.

Things are never monotonically increasing or decreasing forever, and there is no reason to prevent population from adjusting up or down in order to reach better conditions for a given environment. Nor do we need to set public policy to focus solely on maximizing total GDP and real estate values.

Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by mathematically on Thursday October 14, 2021 @11:13PM (#28873760)
My point is if you're concerned about an existential crisis then worrying about the birth rate in one specific country doesn't really make any logical sense. Global warming is a global problem and nationalistic thinking is not how this problem is going to get solved. Getting atmospheric CO2 concentration down to a safe level is going to require transnational cooperation and coordination. Countries with sensible immigration policies and support programs are going to fare better than the ones that lock up their borders (as is now being evidenced in Britain with their empty gas stations and store shelves because there aren't enough truck drivers to deliver fuel and food to all those gas stations and stores: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/after-brexit-thousands-fo...).
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by hammyhavoc on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:51PM (#28872441)
Prioritizing profit before planet and people.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by mathematically on Thursday October 14, 2021 @09:05PM (#28872574)
That's definitely part of the problem.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by arvinsim on Thursday October 14, 2021 @10:07PM (#28873233)
Modern capitalism driven by profit that doesn't account for externalities.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by stormbrew on Thursday October 14, 2021 @07:54PM (#28871922)
A somewhat unstated reason why decreasing birth rates are considered alarming is because our entire economic system is built around growth that's only really possible if both the labor pool and/or the consumer pool grow. The only two ways that can happen are if we make new workers and consumers (birth, immigration) or we make people who weren't previously workers or consumers into those (this happened post-WWII when women entered the workforce in larger numbers and was probably part of why economic growth was so strong for so long after the war).

Fundamentally, if the number of people participating in the economy shrinks, the economy will shrink, and our late capitalist system is extremely ill equipped to deal with that.

Now there's also a powerful movement against immigration, that is also aggressively for increasing birth rates to fend off an imagined conspiracy to "replace" them, which makes this a particularly thorny problem for the political class.

Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by pyuser583 on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:32PM (#28872275)
There’s no reason our economic system requires population growth. There are certainly examples where shrinking populations corresponded with higher growth: Ireland had a shrinking population and growing economy from 1850 to 1960.

The issue is a population that has a massive number of elderly to care for while having few young people to do it.

Ireland had no problem having tons of kids who left the country upon reaching adulthood, even though the total population was shrinking.

Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by stormbrew on Thursday October 14, 2021 @10:14PM (#28873299)
Capitalism is a global system (at least at this point). Certainly you can have pockets that experience abnormal growth[1] because no country is a closed system. If businesses in one country have new markets open to them outside their borders that's just another way of adding to their economy.

And definitely an aging non-working population can be a downward drag on a capitalist economy as well. Even though they live longer, they are still to some extent "exiting the economy" since they usually live off fixed incomes and don't contribute to the labor pool.

In aggregate, though, you still need growth to make capital investment make sense. There may be other ways to achieve it than population growth overall, especially in small niches, but if you lose that source of growth it should have ramifications on the economy, even if they're counteracted.

[1] Do you have a source on the ireland thing? I'm not really finding anything. And which Ireland for that matter? There are effectively at least three polities called that in that period. All with very different access to markets, political situations, etc.

Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by Swizec on Thursday October 14, 2021 @07:53PM (#28871913)
> I don't get the argument against having less children.

The [current] economic model presupposes infinite growth. You can't have infinite growth with a declining population.

Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by sokoloff on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:00PM (#28871970)
You can’t have infinite growth on a finite planet, either.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by gruez on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:05PM (#28872018)
colonize other planets then?
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by mathematically on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:20PM (#28872160)
Technology for doing so does not exist. Before we can terraform other planets we'll have to learn how to terraform this one. Global warming is actually a great challenge and overcoming it would mean developing the technology that would help colonize other planets, e.g. https://www.nasa.gov/feature/ames/myco-architecture.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by pyuser583 on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:34PM (#28872293)
How would that help? If half the population of earth (randomly chosen) moved to an inhabitant planet in another solar system, wouldn’t the reduction in population shrink the economy?
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by gruez on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:36PM (#28872315)
Presumably there would be trade between the planets. Did european colonization of the americas shrink population in europe?
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by pyuser583 on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:44PM (#28872384)
Parts of it. Ireland’s population shrunk consistently from 1800 to 1960, mostly due to expatriation. Economy mostly grew. The economics are complicated - they were part of then British Imperial economy, which good or bad depending on specifics (corn laws, famines, etc).
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by sokoloff on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:13PM (#28872101)
I hope we do eventually and specifically outside this solar system, which has a clock that’s shorter than the heat death master clock.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by arvinsim on Thursday October 14, 2021 @07:58PM (#28871957)
True. Even if we do find a solution to replace the current economic model, the transition would be messy with a high chance of violence.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by pupppet on Thursday October 14, 2021 @07:55PM (#28871925)
Capitalism demands an ever increasing number of mouths to feed.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by gruez on Thursday October 14, 2021 @07:59PM (#28871960)
How does capitalism (ie. "private means of production") translate to "ever increasing number of mouths to feed"?
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by rackjack on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:14PM (#28872114)
If we interpret "ever increasing number of mouths to feed" as "more people", we can imagine the following:

I sell a product. The more people buy my product, the more money I make. The more people there are, the more people will buy my product. The more people there are, the larger the labor pool I can choose from. The larger the labor pool I can choose from, the more the workers' wages get depressed, so my profit margins get bigger. So the more people there are, the more money I make.

Obviously this is highly reductionist. Also, I don't think saying capitalism "demands" increased population growth is quite right. We can certainly imagine individual businesses who would not like population growth (e.g. mom-and-pop stores who know that increased local population increases the likelihood of a Walmart being erected and putting them out of business). But on the whole, I think the presence of capitalism trends towards increasing population.

Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by gruez on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:43PM (#28872373)
>The more people there are, the larger the labor pool I can choose from. The larger the labor pool I can choose from, the more the workers' wages get depressed, so my profit margins get bigger.

This this true? It presumes a bigger labor pool competing for the same amount of available jobs, which isn't true. As the economy grows, there are also more consumers who demand more products, which requires more workers/jobs.

Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by pupppet on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:14PM (#28872123)
Companies must grow, simple as that.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by pyuser583 on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:35PM (#28872306)
And one of the fastest ways to grow is accomplish more with fewer employees.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by pupppet on Thursday October 14, 2021 @09:00PM (#28872535)
And where do the employees who get laid off work? That solution doesn’t scale.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by pyuser583 on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:36PM (#28872312)
Capitalism has almost universally correlated with lower population growth.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by pupppet on Thursday October 14, 2021 @09:06PM (#28872585)
…taking advantage of growth elsewhere.
Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by pyuser583 on Saturday October 16, 2021 @10:26PM (#28893437)
Why does an increase in GDP per person require more people?

If GDP per person is rising, even if the number of people is shrinking, why can’t the total GDP rise as the population shrinks?

Especially if the population decline is caused by people focusing on work and having fewer children?

Re:In Britain, childlessness seems likely to return to 1920s... by stormbrew on Thursday October 14, 2021 @10:21PM (#28873355)
Capitalism can be correlated with almost anything that happens because capitalism is pervasive.