Re:Finland lobbied EU to declare nuclear power sustainable
by fsckboy on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @02:31PM
(#28843291)
you are focusing on pollution in terms of sustainability, but perhaps fission is unsustainable because it relies on "fuels" which can run out? there is only a finite supply of uranium.
Re:Finland lobbied EU to declare nuclear power sustainable
by slaymaker1907 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @02:53PM
(#28843586)
This is only if you define sustainable == infinite which is ridiculous. Sure solar power/wind power might be present long after humanity is gone, but that doesn't mean we can continue maintaining solar/wind power plants indefinitely, these things take resources to produce. On the other hand, if we define sustainable as being can we do this thing for a 1000 years without modification, modern nuclear power starts to look a lot more sustainable.
Re:Finland lobbied EU to declare nuclear power sustainable
by konspence on Thursday October 14, 2021 @01:54AM
(#28860922)
I see your point, but eventually the solar panels produce the energy to produce more solar panels. Including the mining
IIRC there is a formal guidance for what is classified as renewable. Things like oil, while originating from biological matter, obviously being considered 'not', while tree mass, plant mass, being considered so. Believe the guidance was whether the carbon emitted in its production has been or could be absorbed within a lifetime, via the means with which it was produced.
I have reservations with nuclear but I imagine it would fit within those guidelines easily.
Re:Finland lobbied EU to declare nuclear power sustainable
by smileysteve on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @04:47PM
(#28844864)
This seems a bit reaching; especially considering breeding reactors; and the amount of fuel contained in a small volume;
Lithium is not in great supply comparatively; Photovoltaics depend on p/n junctions and silicon. Wind turbines depend on rare earth magnets.
Re:Finland lobbied EU to declare nuclear power sustainable
by ashtonkem on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:07PM
(#28847431)
We’ll need to move the planet due to the warming of the sun before we’ll run out of fissible fuel.
Re:Finland lobbied EU to declare nuclear power sustainable
by jjk166 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @07:46PM
(#28846507)
Between waste reprocessing, breeder reactors, and seawater extraction, uranium could power our civilization for billions of years. Uranium would leach into the ocean from the crust faster than we'd need to extract it.
Re:Finland lobbied EU to declare nuclear power sustainable
by 3np on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @02:53PM
(#28843576)
Right, but that time-horizon is orders of magnitudes compared to fossils, no?
Re:Finland lobbied EU to declare nuclear power sustainable
by Ekaros on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @03:24PM
(#28843946)
And accepting something comparable to coal leaves a lot of time to sort things out. We are talking about hundreds of years. Not only tens.
Re:Finland lobbied EU to declare nuclear power sustainable
by trenchgun on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @03:54PM
(#28844285)
At least thousands of years with breeders.
Re:Finland lobbied EU to declare nuclear power sustainable
by blitzar on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @04:50AM
(#28849806)
The sun is not infinite, when it runs out of fuel it will be gone too.
Re:Finland lobbied EU to declare nuclear power sustainable
by whiddershins on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @02:50PM
(#28843544)
How finite though? I mean, everything uses materials.
Well, isn't it? Am I missing something or is nuclear about as sustainable as it gets? The perfect baseload to cover us when solar or wind is out. Almost no CO2 produced, much lower deaths/GWh produced, plentiful fuel supplies?