News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by csa on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:57AM (#28839709)
> It is amazing and absurd that the supposed patrilineal links to the sun god remain today

The current emperor is (it seems) the last one in the patrilineal lineage.

I expect strangeness when succession becomes a legit topic. Will adopting his daughter’s spouse be enough? Will they move to just blood line rather than only patrilineal blood line? Will they breed an extramarital son somehow?

It will be an interesting time.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by dustintrex on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:05AM (#28839812)
Not really? Crown Prince Fumihito is the current emperor's brother, and he has a son, Hisahito.

Hisahito's birth was not expected, and there was serious consideration for amending the rules to allow (restore) female succession, but as things stand there's little pressure to change anything.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by csa on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:31AM (#28850475)
Serious question… do you think Hisahito is the crown prince?

While possible, I bet the don’t on Hisahto becoming emperor.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by mistrial9 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:20AM (#28840005)
it is more amazing and absurd that casual observers across the globe know more about how another society should be run, their values and their cultural history
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by westcort on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:09AM (#28840682)
Well, Kishi was certainly a war criminal. And the relationship to the sun god is perhaps a matter of faith to some, but obviously false. Just pointing out the obvious.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by adolph on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @12:38PM (#28841785)
> the relationship to the sun god is perhaps a matter of faith to some, but obviously false

How do you know it's false? Are you in touch with the sun god? How do you know there is only one sun god and you are in touch with the right one?

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by westcort on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @01:43PM (#28842675)
It is too convenient for a ruling family to have the mandate of the one true God. They are flesh and blood with DNA, diseases, and all of the other problems of humanity. But I won’t tell you what to believe. My view is that these are just people, and if they weren’t, where are their magical powers? And if they have no such powers, even if they were divine, would it matter?
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by adolph on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @03:41PM (#28844146)
Ok, you don't know one way or another. I'd agree that a safe assumption is that family members are not descended from a supernatural being. On the other hand, your assertion does not address any specific supporting evidence the family might muster. It would be helpful to support your counterclaim with information specific to Japanese beliefs and practices. For example, you state that the imperial family "are flesh and blood with DNA, diseases, and all of the other problems of humanity," presumably as a counter to the family's claim of supernatural origin. But does that really contradict their claim? For example, in some Christian mythologies the Jesus character was at the same time the son of the central deity as well as being the central deity and at the same time born from a non-supernatural mother. Have the Japanese imperial family claimed that they are not "flesh and blood with DNA, diseases, and all of the other problems of humanity?" Have they claimed "magical powers?" I don't know and you have not established these as claims about which to offer counterclaims. My understanding is that this form of rhetoric is known as "strawman."
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by westcort on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @04:18PM (#28844559)
Their “divine” power comes from belief in such power by the people they rule. Without that, they are the real straw man. And that is what they are, figureheads and cultural tokens. It’s not good for the Japanese people and it is not good for the figureheads themselves. There is one miracle I would fairly attribute to the royal family, though, and that is ending WWII. It was not a supernatural, though, just rarely exercised authority that came from belief. Beyond that, there is no magic involved. I would also argue that the artifacts supposedly from the sun god look about like what you would expect from a good artisan a few thousand years ago. If they were advanced technology, I might give it a second thought. Lacking magic, authority, and power, what is left is a quaint memento of a long-gone past. That is what royal families are—-nothing more.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by adolph on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @07:55PM (#28846581)
Ok, it sounds like you don't have a specific claim on the part of the Japanese imperial family to falsify.

Now there is an additional claim that belief in such power is not good for the Japanese people. Japan as a nation seems to have done pretty well for itself. If belief in a supernatural power is present in a society that seems otherwise well-adapted evolutionarily, what is "not good" about it? Maybe they would do better without it? How would that claim be different from a claim that they might have done worse without it?

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by westcort on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:37PM (#28847607)
Not divine. Not relevant.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by adolph on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @11:53AM (#28853770)
I appreciate not agreeing with a claim of divinity in that it is unfalsible, but to claim something is false without offering evidence is just as much a naked assertion as the original claim.

As to the relevance of the imperial family in Japanese society the fact that they are being discussed is a variety of relevance if only in the same manner as reality television or professional sports. For some reason the story of the Babel fish comes to mind.

https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/35681-now-it-is-such-a-biza...

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by disneygibson on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:24AM (#28840049)
Yeah I really did not like this article. How about the West lets Japan figure out its own proper government and role for the emperor, rather than continuing to insist that our ways are unquestionably superior? The entire mood of this piece is dismissive and arrogant. Poor journalism.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by dustintrex on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:28AM (#28840106)
Are we reading the same article? The West already dictated Japan's form of government, including the role of the Imperial family, after WW2.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by disneygibson on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:37AM (#28840221)
The article is quite negative and assumes that Western ideas are inherently superior, all monarchies are bad, etc. To be expected for a left-wing literature journal, obviously, but that doesn’t make it any less culturally imperialistic.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by westcort on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:11AM (#28840707)
Humanity is moving past the age of monarchies and kings in general and has been for at least 300 years. There is no cultural exceptionalism for this trend.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by disneygibson on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:26AM (#28840886)
No, it isn’t, and the “moving past X toward a democratic future” is an Enlightenment idea rooted in Western culture, largely enforced upon other states via violence, economic sanctions, and colonialism. As the West continues to decline, so will the appeal of its political structures.

This is fairly obvious if you pay attention to Russia, China, India, and other powerful countries. It isn’t 1990 or 1950. The world isn’t trying to reinvent itself in the mold of the West anymore.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by worrycue on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @12:12PM (#28841485)
Ignoring whether anti-monarchy is a western idea or not, monarchy has quite a lot of deficiencies.

Japan itself I would argue has highlighted said deficiencies. Emperor Taishō had various neurological problems. His son Emperor Shōwa (AKA Hirohito) seem alright physically but just wasn’t that good a statesman, in the eyes of some like the British who did not see him as malicious (https://english.kyodonews.net/news/2017/07/758307910564-hiro...) anyway, in that he couldn’t rein in the military and the rest is history.

It’s the luck of the drawn if you have a good leader and if you end up with a bad one it is nigh impossible to replace him without major social upheaval.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by westcort on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @02:36PM (#28843346)
Quantified by global economic productivity, I agree that China and India have seen recent ascendency, but not Russia. China has failed at even developing its own native microchip industry, thus Taiwan has become a political football. We are living in a post-national world where key intermediates come from multiple countries. The Russian Federation is a petro-state that generates less than 3% of global wealth. Sure, they may have temporary disrupted the US political system, but that will run its course. The Republican/Russian cause knows it will ultimately lose because they have embraced the symbol of every other lost cause from the Confederacy to Nazi Germany.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by westcort on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:48AM (#28841189)
You bring up a valid point and it is interesting to hear a perspective in favor of dictators, monarchs, and rule by the divine rights of kings. But look at it another way and the entire global economy runs on money and capitalism, which is inherently democratic by design in that many decisions contribute to the overall direction, rather than a single decision maker. If you think that system is going away, I would find such a view hard to imagine, but would consider it. The late David Graeber certain would have agreed with you that a post-capitalist society might be possible, though it is almost unimaginable at present.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by lbrito on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @12:12PM (#28841486)
>_money and capitalism, which is inherently democratic by design in that many decisions contribute to the overall direction, rather than a single decision maker_

That's an anti historical view. If there's one thing capitalism is definitely not, it's "democratic by design". South America 60s-90s, Europe 1930s etc.

Also absurd to just assume it will win "just because". Even fukuyama gave up on this idea after his "end of history" theory completely flopped.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by westcort on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @02:01PM (#28842930)
I fail to see how any force can negate the power of world economies at this point. Even Germany had to pay back its war debt and had to do so after changing its political system, therefore the power of economies is--historically--far greater than the power of political systems.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @12:15PM (#28841516)
> money and capitalism, which is inherently democratic by design in that many decisions contribute to the overall direction, rather than a single decision maker

No, that's not what “democratic” means. Its true that capitalism is inherently oligarchic rather than monarchic, because of the property you describe above (minus the improper reference to “democratic”) but that's...a far cry from democratic.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by westcort on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @01:59PM (#28842903)
Whether or not capitalism can be classified as oligarchic or democratic, I would argue that capitalism has pervaded the world and is a stronger force at this point than any political system, ruler, or ideology. Redefining terms when it is convenient, without even providing a definition, I might add does not negate the fact that when many contribute that system can be classified as participatory rather then exclusive.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @02:27PM (#28843235)
> Whether or not capitalism can be classified as oligarchic or democratic, I would argue that capitalism has pervaded the world and is a stronger force at this point than any political system, ruler, or ideology.

Liberal capitalism is both a political (politico-economic) system and an ideology. It also peaked in its dominance of the developed “West” (an imprecise term by any geographic interpretation, due to exports and alignments and remnants of colonialism putting Western outposts all over the globw, but there's no really good alternative, either) a bit over 100 years ago, the modern politico-economic system that pervades the developed West is a hybrid of socialism and capitalism (“the modern mixed economy”) derived through a process of proletarian reaction against capitalism very similar to the early stages of motion away from feudalism toward capitalism through bourgeois reaction against feudalism (though much faster).

State capitalism is also a significant politico-economic system and ideology, though a different one than liberal capitalism, and arguably still on the upswing (state capitalist regimes, without any exceptions I am aware of, all borrow the rhetoric of class-participatory socialism, but have practical rule by a self-selected cadre that exercises power through, among other key levers, exclusive control of the means of production.)

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by westcort on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @04:49PM (#28844886)
Got it, so more a more exclusive control of capitalism is the big distinction unshackling Japan from colonialist structures. Groundbreaking.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by westcort on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:18AM (#28840788)
Journalists can draw contrasts. We are all humans and just drawing comparisons across monarchies, which until recently existed in every culture and country. In an age of global pandemics, the world is a single neighborhood. Drawing contrasts does not suggest any course of action.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by MomoXenosaga on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:42AM (#28840304)
Which leads to the imperialism that they claim to hate. Ironic isn't it?
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by westcort on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:09AM (#28840684)
How?