News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by gaoshan on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:42PM (#28832819)
I genuinely miss the office. Being in a different space for work (one that was pretty gorgeous), in a nice part of downtown, able to tap people on the shoulder for quick questions rather than having to ping them over chat, more spontaneous collaboration (right before we went remote again I overheard two people discussing an area I have some expertise in and was able to interject and provide useful insight), extra productivity (I do better when I'm around others working, worse when I am alone), the occasional happy hour, the occasional lunch with others, the not horrible drive where I can jam tunes or listen to podcasts and have some time to myself.

Not being able to do all of that has brought me lower and lower as the months go by. Made a similar comment on reddit and got downvoted into oblivion but this is really how I feel and it really does impact me negatively. I'm sure I'm not the only one, though it does feel like I might be in the minority.

Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by zmmmmm on Monday October 11, 2021 @05:50PM (#28833505)
I get a lot of what you say but this one drives me bonkers:

> able to tap people on the shoulder for quick questions rather than having to ping them over chat

My work requires so much focus, having people randomly tap me on the shoulder to ask a question they could just drop in chat is debilitating.

I'm curious you phrase "having to ping them over chat" negatively? I would say the same sentence almost totally in reverse:

"Now I no longer have to interrupt people to ask them a question, I can just ping them over chat for a reply when they are ready"

Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by distrill on Monday October 11, 2021 @07:18PM (#28834185)
Even for something quick, I will type up a question and then go over it a few times, make some edits, probably provide some links for context. It just feels like a bigger deal than just asking someone next to you.

In person they can cut me off when they start to get it, or I can tell from their face that I need to keep going with more context, it's just more more collaborative.

In chat I'll either end up having to answer a ton of follow up questions for detail, or I'll drown the question in context.

Yes, I can get better at asking questions. But tbh most of this complexity stems from me trying to ask questions well to begin with. IDK, pinging someone over chat seems like more of an intrusion than just asking a question.

Also, I won't, like, ask someone to take off their headphones for this. I'll ask them at lunch, or when we're grabbing coffee / snacks. Over chat there's no coffee break, it's all "headphone" time, from my perspective.

Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by Draiken on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @07:01AM (#28838274)
But the act of tapping someone in the shoulder and break their concentration already does all the harm IMO.

Once you've done that, headphones on or off is redundant.

In my experience, 99% of these disturbances could be avoided with a bit more effort on the side of the person interrupting. So what generally happens is that the person concentrating loses his focus - very likely getting out of the zone - and helps them with something that they could've done themselves.

For me it really seems selfish the majority of the time. Urgent matters, things that really block you and you absolutely can't figure out, sure. Almost anything else can wait a bit for a response.

Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by distrill on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:25PM (#28847180)
What? I'll wait for coffee or lunch. There are natural places throughout a work day to ask someone a question without interrupting their work time. I specifically noted this too.

I'm not advocating for instant response, I'm saying that there are no natural breaks in a remote environment for us to have casual conversations.

Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by Draiken on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @12:58PM (#28854605)
Yeah, fair point. But what's stopping you from simply asking for some face-to-face time and scheduling it?

Sometimes the best solution is to have a discussion and it's a lot easier to do compared to writing. On those cases I just ask "can we have a meeting to discuss X?" and we schedule something.

This gets you the help you the same results, without any interruption.

Sure they could just pretend to not see your message and ignore it leaving you in a tough spot, but that's a problem with the person, not remote work IMO.

Generally speaking, even if you're focused, you'll stop to have lunch, grab a snack, etc. And you then answer questions, setup a time to meet, etc.

Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by kwhitefoot on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @06:41AM (#28838159)
> In person they can cut me off when they start to get it,

the problem is that you have already interrupted their flow. Getting back into that takes valuable time.

Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by distrill on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:26PM (#28847184)
I'll wait for coffee or lunch. There are natural places throughout a work day to ask someone a question without interrupting their work time. I specifically said that I wouldn't interrupt someone's flow.
Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by gaoshan on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:01PM (#28833594)
Our work is very collaborative and being able to get quick feedback on some issue is nice.

Having to ping them over chat is annoying because while it may result in a quick answer it may also just disappear into the ether (or the chat app fails to deliver, the person steps away but you don't know this, etc.).

Again, our work is collaborative and if someone wants to be left alone they throw on headphones in which case everyone knows to just ping them over chat so they can respond whenever is convenient for them.

Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by justrudd on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:24PM (#28833777)
If I may, what industry do you work in that needs this level of collaboration and such a quick turnaround on it?

I agree with you that it can be nice. But in thinking back on my career, I’ve never been in an industry that needed it (beyond dealing with operational events).

Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by loganfrederick on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:43PM (#28833936)
For me the right middle ground was the collaborative coffee break. Different team members or even departments spend ten minutes walking or lounging in the kitchen, and that's where comradery and spontaneous ideas and collaboration can happen, without it disrupting the big chunks of flow in the day. This I do miss working from home.
Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by tikhonj on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:22PM (#28833758)
It sounds like you're saying that work can't be collaborative without people interrupting each other with no warning, but that isn't my experience at all—my experience has been that the most collaborative work happens when people are intentional about how and when they communicate, which seems easier to encourage in a remote setting.
Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by QuercusMax on Monday October 11, 2021 @07:18PM (#28834192)
When I'm sitting in close proximity to other humans, I can often tell what they are doing. People can give signals that they are currently occupied; this could be things like putting on headphones, etc. It's pretty easy to tell when someone is doing focused work vs. talking to a desk mate, etc.
Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by patcon on Monday October 11, 2021 @10:21PM (#28835378)
I hear what you're saying.

However, i loved being tapped and then helping people. it was my very favourite distraction, and assuming i was actually helping them with work, I felt zero guilt about losing my focus. it's very personality specific, I suppose * shrug *

Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by baud147258 on Monday October 11, 2021 @07:05PM (#28834111)
in the office, even if the person I want to ask a question is next to me, I'd usually ping them beforehand and wait for their answer, it feels more polite this way.
Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by stevage on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:05PM (#28833633)
Absolutely, that was the worst part of office working. I've worked from home for 5 years now and love that part.
Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by mdekkers on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @12:00AM (#28835895)
> able to tap people on the shoulder for quick questions rather than having to ping them over chat

The ability for me to switch of chat/email and just get stuff done, without people tapping on my shoulder or standing next to me because they want something is one of the key reasons why I have been working from home for the past 10 years. I’ll come to the office for a week or two every 8 weeks or so, and that’s it. My productivity takes an insane nosedive in the office, simply because open-plan, interruptions and distractions.

Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by Leherenn on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @05:18AM (#28837714)
I am ok with people switching off for a while, but then you really need to catch up, otherwise it's really painful for people working with you.

I've had colleagues who would maybe quickly look at their mail/chat once a day (usually early in the morning before most people arrived). Latency is high, but that's manageable. But the most annoying is that maybe you would get an answer, maybe not. So you would need to ping them several times over several media, hoping one catches their attention. In meetings you regularly have to re-state/explain stuff because it was sent in a email and they didn't read it, while everyone else is up to date.

A common example: assign them a MR. Gitlab is too noisy (by default), so they redirect every mail from Gitlab to the trash and don't get a notification. You ping them on chat about the MR, wait a couple of days, no review. So you re-ping them. This time a review happens, maybe the next day. There are some comments, so you fix/answer them. Of course they don't know that you did (and don't check), so you need to re-ping them and wait. Depending on how insistent you are, even a small MR can take a week or two. The end result (which might be what they want ultimately) is that you avoid collaborating with them as much as possible because of how painful it is.

Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by tmm on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:41PM (#28833910)
For those of you who miss the office, what does your life look like outside it? Do you have an active social circle? Do you have regular, sustained, positive interaction with your neighbors (i.e. do you do more than say hello in passing)? Kids who do sports? A long commute or a short one? A house or an apartment? Do you do your own housework or do you hire it out? When you're in the office, where do you work (e.g. private office, cubicle, open plan)?

Prior to working from home (since late 2018), my social circle was limited to the office. After nine years in the same neighborhood, I knew two neighbors (three before the ones next door moved away) and only one who I knew well enough to ask to pet-sit. Work and commuting consumed all of my time. I had a boat I visited once a month (mostly to make sure it still floated), hobbies that sat unnoticed for weeks or months at a time, and a house and garden that were decaying around me; all because I never had time for them. I paid a housekeeper to clean and a lawn service to cut the grass. I never liked the commute, but I did enjoy the office. Lunch with coworkers, happy hour at the bar next to the office, hanging out in the cafeteria or someone's office were all enjoyable activities.

I would never trade a single benefit of working from home to get them back. Double my salary and a short commute (or a chauffeur) might tempt me back for a while (if only because I could then pay people to do a lot of the projects I'd otherwise put off), but it wouldn't keep me.

Work from home has allowed me to:

- not be distracted if I don't want to be. No one is on a speakerphone; there aren't conversations in the hallway; if the espresso machine makes noise, it's because I'm using it. Even having a private office with a solid, lockable door didn't insulate me from office noise the way working from home does (yes, there are more dogs barking, children playing, and lawns being mowed ... but unless I'm in a meeting those noises aren't distracting the way people talking is)

- meet many of my neighbors (helps that they're mostly all working from home too)

- spend more time at the marina. Used to be, I could only do that on weekends

- work on my house. Used to be, I was too tired when I got home, so again limited to weekends

- take a break from work during the day and still be productive on something else (housework, hobbies, etc). Before, taking a break from work meant a visit to the cafeteria or a chat with a coworker. Weeding a garden, washing my car, folding clothes, organizing my tools; all of these are fantastic activities for thinking up solutions to work problems

- go racing every Wednesday night. Before, if I wanted to be at the dock at 5:00, I'd have to leave the office by 3:00. That really wasn't possible. Now I leave my house at 4:45 to be there on time. This, by far has been the biggest impact ... new friends at 36, who knew!

- reclaim two hours of my life from commuting ... sure I could have moved closer to the office, but I tried that once and my next job just took me that much farther from home

- reclaim my evenings because I'm not exhausted from commuting

- work on my schedule. Aside from meetings, I can mostly work when I know I'll be most productive ... either early in the morning or late in the evening. And noone cares if I take a nap at 2:00 every day

Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by felipellrocha on Monday October 11, 2021 @10:27PM (#28835435)
I had all of that prior to covid, and and i still miss the office. It was another environment in which I could meet interesting people and bring them into my life.

You might want to consider whether being at home was the thing that made you wander, or if just being in an unfamiliar state of being forced you to wander. I would reckon it's the latter because I can attribute my varied life to the fact that I'm an immigrant, and the immigration forcing me to think outside of the box to do all those things.

Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by teirce on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @02:36AM (#28836750)
You haven't gotten any responses here, so I'll bite.

> Do you have an active social circle? Do you have regular, sustained, positive interaction with your neighbors (i.e. do you do more than say hello in passing)? Kids who do sports? A long commute or a short one? A house or an apartment? Do you do your own housework or do you hire it out? When you're in the office, where do you work (e.g. private office, cubicle, open plan)?

I live in the US (bay area), so my responses will be based on that.

A lot of us were forced to work remote for the last year and a half, which is a bit different than (I presume what you did was) deciding to work from home permanently. There are also pandemic-induced factors that might help people to miss the office more than they might in normal WFH circumstances.

> Social circle / neighbors

COVID kind of killed in-person socialization for a year for the cautious, so social circles and activities aren't as relevant here nor as easy to maintain (compared to a 'normal' WFH timeline). I had a couple groups that did online video calls and catchups / games, but all of those engagements slowly tapered off.

It's also a time where it is incredibly difficult to meet new people, as most are either content with their current circle or are not open to engaging with new people due to COVID. This also applies to my neighbors in my apartment building - nobody seems to want to socialize (I've tried a bit).

> Distractions

I think I'm unique in this one in that I have difficulty maintaining focus for a few reasons, but the office isn't one of them. Once I have some headphones on I'm usually fine.

> Marina and [insert other hobby]

A lot of my hobbies I have were/are typically done at home. I like to read, play games, and sometimes watch tv or twitch or what not, with whatever else is my flavor hobby at the time. None of these are good at getting me out of my apartment, though it is nice to take a book somewhere and sit for a bit now that places are open more around me.

> Commute / evenings / scheduling

My commute is hellish. It's the one thing I don't miss about the office. I agree with you here. The only good thing was it being a good time for winding down after work, which still have to do anyway before I have the energy for another activity.

---

I find a lot of the people who are satisfied with WFH fall into one or more of the following categories: people who live with others (partners, family), those who have kids[0], some own homes / larger living spaces. Partners and family keep you company. Kids can keep you busy. A larger space is easier to be in for a long amount of time.

I'm someone who lives alone, in around 600-700sqft apartment, in a city where I only know a handful of people (who were in/out of town much of last year), was told to stay inside / social distance until early 2021, with nearly everything around me closed for a long time.

I've spent a year and a half sometimes going weeks without seeing someone I know, and it has been very isolating and quite hellish. And I would even consider myself an introvert. My friends in the area happen to all be couples that are quite happy to spend time together. Things have been getting better the last six months or so, but 2020 was bad. (This point is a bit thin since in a 'normal' non-pandemic world, a lot of this wouldn't be the case. But 'free' socialization is one reason why I miss the office now.)

Seeing other people you work with face-to-face is nice. It lets you take breaks / walks together, grab coffee, lunch, or generally just BS for 5-10 minutes when you both need a bit. That's aside from the working bits where proximity can help. I miss pairing with other developers on my team.

Office perks were nice. My company provided meals, snacks, drinks, etc. There was also a well-equipped gym that was free, better than I can get in my area, and certainly better than what fits in my apartment. And the space is obviously much larger than my apartment.

Working on a schedule helped provide some structure to day-to-day (for me). I miss going into the office because it provided some structure for me that I didn't have to do myself.

I don't have the space to distance work from leisure in my apartment, which can make it difficult to focus. My home is full of many things that are more interesting than what I am working on, so the psychology is against me. Going into the office provided an easy separation here.

So those are the reasons why I miss the office. That was longer than I thought it would be. Sorry for the wall of text there.

---

I will admit that some of these are things I could address myself with moderate - large effort. I could be more proactive with friends and neighbors. I could be more disciplined with my schedule. I could try to find better outdoor hobbies. But honestly right now I am just trying to make it by however I can, so some of those seem daunting. I think that's a lot of folks right now.

In hindsight, I should have packed all of my stuff in a storage unit and went to go bunk with some family for a year and work from there. In extra-extra hindsight, if you had told me in 2019 that this would happen, I would have kept living with my roommate instead of striking it out on my own in the fall.

[0] I feel for the parents who relied on daycare / school as a 'break' from their kids and now have had to manage it themselves. I've also had that sympathy worn quite thin from all of the 'WFH must be great if you're single with no kids!' comments I've been seeing for a year. Frankly I'd kill for a spouse and some kids to provide any interaction or structure to a normal day.

Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by hansor on Monday October 11, 2021 @05:35PM (#28833385)
Amen! You are not alone. :)
Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by xtat on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:20AM (#28838800)
Yes please don't randomly tap people on the shoulder and ask quick questions.
Re:Is going to the office a broken way of working? by tezzer on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:04PM (#28833623)
I'm with you, 100%