News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by cletus on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:21PM (#28831945)
This seems to be an unpopular opinion on HN but I just don't trust humans to manage fission power in the long term at scale.

First, there are the issues of storage and disposal of enrichment byproducts, specifically depleted Uranium Hexaflouride ("DUJF" or UF6).

Second, there's what to do with old fuel rods. Proponents argue this is a solved problem and it can be stored for the long term in geologically stable storage facilities. This is just one political change away from becoming a huge problem.

Neither really scales up to 100x or even 10x current fission energy production.

Third, there's long-term maintenance of a plant. Arguments about the relative safety of fission point to deaths caused by coal. Coal is really the worst fossil fuel. LNG is better. But regardless of the numbers, the failure modes are just much, much worse for nuclear. 35 years later, the Chernobyl Absolute Exclusion Zone still stands at 1000 square miles. Parts of this zone will likely remain uninhabitable for centuries.

I just don't trust governments or corporations for the long term inspection, maintenance and management of fission power plants in the long term.

Lastly, the politics are against fission. This seems unlikely to change anytime soon.

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by opwieurposiu on Monday October 11, 2021 @05:58PM (#28833576)
Used fuel from thermal reactors can be processed into fuel for fast reactors. The fast reactor burns up all the transuranium elements so that the waste ends up with only the short lived fission products. These short lived products decay to background in 300 years or so, so the amount of time it needs to be stored is much more manageable.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integral_fast_reactor#Advantag...

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by cletus on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:15PM (#28833711)
So if we can process nuclear waste in fast reactors like this, why haven't we done so with existing nuclear waste? Scale? Cost? Something else?
Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by opwieurposiu on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:54PM (#28834032)
The cost issue: Storing spent fuel is pretty cheap because it is not very voluminous. The USA has produced about 85k tons of spent fuel, which would fit into a single football stadium. This means the cheapest thing to do is just kick the can down the road.

The proliferation issue: Waste burners require processing of spent fuel, which some states believe is a weapons proliferation risk.

The sodium issue: Liquid sodium requires very careful construction of the steam generators and piping to keep it from contacting air or water. This is a sort-of solved problem in that all the sodium cooled reactors have experienced sodium leaks from time to time, but those leaks have been fixed without significant radioactive release. This is an issue that improves with operator experience.

The russians do have one waste burning fast reactor running, the BN-800. If they can do it, so can we. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BN-800_reactor

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by r00fus on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:39PM (#28834680)
French also reprocess. In fact, other countries pay them to reprocess their fuel.

The US doesn't do this ostensibly due to proliferation risk [1] however, I am of the opinion that was due purely due to pressure from the coal lobby.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_reprocessing#History

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by LargoLasskhyfv on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:49PM (#28833988)
Probably because all (usable) waste (the fuel rods) needs to be disassembled (reprocessed) to enable usage somewhere else. With new casings. Which then needs to be disassembled too, after the contents are 'sucked empty'.
Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by himinlomax on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @05:31AM (#28837800)
Because the plants to do so were not built or were dismantled (SuperPhénix) due to anti-nuclear activists.
Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:24PM (#28831981)
It may not be popular, because it is just not very logical or pragmatic. Setting aside the vagaries of politics, as those will eventually change the same way pendulum swings, the simple reality is that we simply won't be able to dig around for coal, gas and oil for that much longer. Something has got to give.
Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by estaseuropano on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:45PM (#28832203)
The op gives clear and sound reasons which you dismiss as illogical without any actual argument. Your answer also misses the obvious point of renewables.

I fully agree with the op, no way nuclear is long-term safe and if we poured the trillions that have been poured into nuclear into renewables the world already would be a lot nicer. But renewables are much harder to monopolize so the big players never really wanted to support them.

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:58PM (#28832345)
"But renewables are much harder to monopolize so the big players never really wanted to support them."

Compared to nuclear power? Yeah. Almost by default getting nuclear power up and running requires government intervention and this is where it hurts. There is no privatization money to skim ( unlike renewables ). It is monopolized, but it is monopolized the way government monopolizes things ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly ).

"if we poured the trillions that have been poured into nuclear into renewables the world already would be a lot nicer. "

It is possible ( I was wrong before ), but I would like you to consider the following:

Solar panels require rare earths. They are called rare not for shits and giggles. What do you think will happen when entire Earth starts looking for them. Consider scalability issues and all of a sudden, digging for oil looks better. We have an interesting view of the coming attractions with Tesla ( https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-25/musk-says... ) and some of the tall tales of him supporting a coup to get the resources he needed.

Similar list of issues run for other renewables with possible exception of geothermal, so I think 'a lot nicer' may be a bit of exaggeration. It is going to sound really cynical, but to me it sounds like pockets where the money reside will change.

That is it. With nuclear -- some of that money will dry up. Hence, partially, the cry out against it.

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by ZeroGravitas on Monday October 11, 2021 @05:33PM (#28833357)
Rare earths aren't rare. Nor are they earths. It's just an old name
Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Monday October 11, 2021 @05:39PM (#28833415)
I suppose we can play a semantic game, but it does not change the actual result does it? They could be called Albino Chickens for all I care.

Rare earths are rare on the market right now, because China managed to monopolize the market. To make it more amusing, extraction of those materials is not exactly easy on the environment, which makes it less likely that Western countries will allow it in their backyard.

With that out of the way what about my argument is wrong?

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Monday October 11, 2021 @07:56PM (#28834447)
It is a lot of information to digest, but I appreciate it. Lemme dig through it.

Some questions do pop up though along the lines of 'everything shortage'.

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by ZeroGravitas on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:11PM (#28833675)
> solar panels require rare earths.

They don't require them, and most common ones don't even use them.

We already covered Rare Earths not being rare, but since they're not really a big limiter on renewable energy anyway, it doesn't really matter.

So, to a rough approximation, everything is wrong with your argument.

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by philipkglass on Monday October 11, 2021 @07:37PM (#28834307)
With that out of the way what about my argument is wrong?

Solar panels do not use rare earth elements. The only element that's fairly rare and commonly used in solar panels is silver, which is used in conductive pastes for cell contacts.

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by TedDoesntTalk on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:42PM (#28832165)
Bill Gates new nuclear power plant design is being built in Wyoming.

These things are small and cheap.

“ The project features a 345 megawatt sodium-cooled fast reactor with molten salt-based energy storage that could boost the system's power output to 500 MW during peak power demand. TerraPower said last year that the plants would cost about $1 billion.”

https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/utility-small-nuclea...

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by cletus on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:47PM (#28832228)
I, for one, welcome newer and better reactor designs.

This doesn't solve the significant issues of fuel enrichment and waste storage and disposal however and we need a much better story for those before fission power has any kind of future (IMHO).

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by linuxhansl on Monday October 11, 2021 @05:17PM (#28833194)
Fair points. (I hope nobody downvoted you)

I somewhat disagree on your general point, though. Pellet reactor (mostly?) solve the spent fuel issue. Also, I believe that due to unreasonable negative opinion we're behind a few decades where we could be in terms of research.

And as I said in my earlier comment, it is exactly this lack of public support that had (and has) us running old timer nuclear plants (like Chernobyl, Fukushima, and most of the currently operated plants in the US, the EU, and elsewhere).

But I agree 100% that the problems you cite need to solved, and these solutions have to be communicated.

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by q1w2 on Monday October 11, 2021 @05:53PM (#28833523)
I don't think any of the GP's arguments hold up.

> there are the issues of storage and disposal of enrichment byproducts

Omega Tau did an in depth analysis of all the storage issues, including the byproducts and how they are managed.

https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/omegataupodcast/omegatau-3...

These are solved problems.

> what to do with old fuel rods

...same as above. The quantity here is far far smaller than most people imagine and it's a very manageable amount - even if scaled 100x. We're talking about 1 barrel per reactor per year.

> there's long-term maintenance of a plant

Modern Gen III plants are build such that any failure in the control systems, causes the reactor to turn off via a, usually, gravity system - so no power needed to turn off the reaction. They are essentially constantly being told to stay on.

Accidents as we've seen in the past are not possible with Gen III reactors. ...the failure modes are just much, much worse for nuclear

More relevant though is that the success condition for LNG/Coal/Oil/etc plants is Global Climate Change. THAT is the critical issue.

Also, the notion that nuclear storage facilities are somehow massive liabilities when the nations of the world currently already have literally tens of thousands of nuclear bombs/missiles, seems odd. There is a far far greater likelihood of Climate Change triggered nuclear war than nuclear waste misuse.

The real problem with nuclear is public ignorance. What I find a remarkable contradiction is how anti-nuclear advocates claim we need to convince the public that Climate Change is real, but then throw up their hands as hopeless when there's a suggestion that nuclear misinformation should be combated.

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by LargoLasskhyfv on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:44PM (#28833941)
Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by Apocryphon on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:31PM (#28832046)
Doesn’t thorium address some of these issues?
Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by cletus on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:49PM (#28832242)
Thorium is complicated. I'd suggest [1] [2] as a good primer on this issue.

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2IqcRl849R0

[2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=baQelfQAH54

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by moonfern on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:36PM (#28832758)
The Gobi Molten salt reactor is finished and testing has begun. China thinks that in 2030 commercial thorium reactors will be available.
Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by GrumpyNl on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:34PM (#28832079)
"Second, there's what to do with old fuel rods. Proponents argue this is a solved problem and it can be stored for the long term in geologically stable storage facilities." With space travel becoming cheaper and cheaper, cant we deposit that on the moon for example?
Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by adt2bt on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:41PM (#28832154)
The general concern there is a rocket malfunction spewing spent fuel rods over a large terrestrial area before it gets the chance to reach the moon.
Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by blaze33 on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:02PM (#28832385)
Yes. Also, given the huge volume of radioactive waste (eg. like 10s of thousands cubic meters just in France) it would require thousands of rocket launches for such an endeavour.

Launch failure rates at best nearing 1%, space don't look like our best option here.

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by orwin on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:43PM (#28832823)
From edf:

"Ces déchets sont constitués, principalement, des matières non valorisables récupérées après le traitement du combustible usé. Les matières sont incorporées dans du verre en fusion, lui-même coulé dans un conteneur en acier. Les conteneurs contiennent 400 kg de verre pour 11 kg de déchets. Les conteneurs, en raison de la chaleur qu’ils dégagent, doivent être entreposés pour être refroidis pendant au moins une cinquantaine d’années avant d’être définitivement stockés. Le volume total de ces déchets équivaudra à 6 700 m³ à l'issue de 40 années d’exploitation du parc nucléaire français. Les déchets à vie longue représentent 10 % du volume total des déchets et concentrent 99,9 % de la radioactivité."[0]

So 6300 cubic meter over 40 years of operations. [edit] counting the glass to make them manipulable.

[0] https://www.edf.fr/sites/default/files/contrib/groupe-edf/pr...

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by t0m4 on Monday October 11, 2021 @07:15PM (#28834173)
It seems that’s quiet the same proportion of nuclear core meltdown. But yes the fallouts could be way worse and it’s actually a bad idea but in 100 years, who knows ?
Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by LargoLasskhyfv on Monday October 11, 2021 @07:40PM (#28834328)
Sorry. Can't do that. Public opinion would go mad because of that:

Space: 1999 is a British science-fiction television programme that ran for two series from 1975 to 1977.[1] In the opening episode, set in the year 1999, nuclear waste stored on the Moon's far side explodes, knocking the Moon out of orbit and sending it, as well as the 311 inhabitants of Moonbase Alpha, hurtling uncontrollably into space.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space%3A_1999

Seriously!1!!

Re:Led by France, 10 EU countries call on Brussels to label ... by Tabular-Iceberg on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @02:36AM (#28836749)
Ignoring rocket reliability, projects that try to protect the environment by wasting more energy are just counterproductive.