News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by ch33zer on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:12PM (#28831160)
Do people decide to go to work for a company based on the language they'll be working in? Seems like something that should be very far down the priority list?
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by capableweb on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:21PM (#28831243)
Yeah, I currently do. I only work with companies who can ensure I get to write and maintain Clojure/ClojureScript projects, or any other lisp-like languages.

Just like I'm sure many people would reject jobs that would force you to write assembly code now when we have higher abstraction languages, I reject jobs that are requiring me to work with inferior languages and ecosystems like Rust, Go or JavaScript. It's simply not worth the frustration anymore.

In the beginning of my career I didn't have the flexibility to choose what languages to work with though, but nowadays I am that lucky.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by waffletower on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:40PM (#28831449)
I haven chosen to work for companies where a significant amount of my development output will, in theory, be in Clojure. I do work on private projects where Clojure is less ideal, and avail myself of the breadth available to the python ecosystem for example, but when there the multitudinous shortcomings do not take long to manifest.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by rastapasta42 on Monday October 11, 2021 @07:50PM (#28834399)
> python ecosystem for example, but when there the multitudinous shortcomings do not take long to manifest.

What type of shortcomings? Can you provide some examples?

(The question is coming from someone who wrote a Scheme interpreter in the past, but have been using Python for the last 8 years and haven't touched Lisp in long time).

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by Keyframe on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:26PM (#28831300)
How are mentioned three inferior to Clojure and Clojurescript? What if you need performance or a bit less of maximalism in the community... Or even a community at all and libraries and support?
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by capableweb on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:09PM (#28831801)
> How are mentioned three inferior to Clojure and Clojurescript?

They are not lisps :)

> What if you need performance

Choose a lisp that gives you performance. Clojure gets you about 80% on the way there, for the rest you can use Common Lisp if you really require performance. I've found that Clojure usually does the trick if you optimize it a bit.

> Or even a community at all

Clojure does have a community, not sure what you mean? There are forums, chats, Q&A sites, blogs, people on Twitter.

> libraries and support?

Plenty of battle-tested libraries with stable APIs, and loads of companies that offer Clojure support (not to mention the great public community that can also help with most if not all questions).

Have you actually used Clojure in any capacity? These points seems to be coming from someone who haven't actually tried to get involved.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by trenchgun on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:18PM (#28833735)
Do you ever miss static typing?
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by capableweb on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @04:48AM (#28837502)
I did, in the beginning. But then I learned better ways of achieving the same guarantees, other methodologies to "prove" (not as in "formal proofs") that my program works as it should. Once Clojure.Spec appeared it was a no-brainer to start using it, and now I want Clojure.Spec in all languages, much rather than static typing.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by closeparen on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:29PM (#28831332)
Go and Lisp have polar opposite philosophies; it makes sense that some developers who like one will be eager to avoid the other.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by waffletower on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:42PM (#28831473)
Clojure has a very strong software community, and find it to be near an ideal size. Tooling is in flux at the moment in the community, and so it has begun to show some of the lack of uniformity that is easy to find in larger ecosystems like python, java, and Appleland etc.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by boppo1 on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:05PM (#28832421)
Is lisp really that good? I'm a novice 'tutorials and duct tape' programmer and I've been eyeing SICP lately as a way to hopefully gain confidence in knowing wtf I'm doing.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by caleb-allen on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:12PM (#28832492)
The heart of it is that you can manipulate the AST as you use it - the structure of the language is itself data which can be acted upon. It makes for good metaprogramming which some people really like.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by vindarel on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:04PM (#28833620)
It's way better than Python (type warnings, speed, expressivity, stability, ease of deployment…). You won't build a web app as fast though. But if you plan to build a software that lasts and is easy to maintain, I'd recommend to give it a try.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by ithrow on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:11PM (#28832482)
It won't give you any magic wand if that's what you expect but SICP is highly recommended.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by ballpark on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:31PM (#28831349)
I also choose to work for companies that use Clojure/Clojurescript. I'm not debating about languages that are better or not, but I get annoyed working in most others.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by c0balt on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:32PM (#28831356)
It may be true that for most high level development a high level programming language will suffice but don't just write off any other languges, because you don't like their ecosystem and/ or design. Languges like C++ or Rust are in no way competing with Clojure since their aims and target market are vastly different. Nobody should write a kernel in clojure, but maybe in rust (Redox) or C++ (Linux).
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by capableweb on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:54PM (#28831618)
Please note I said "Clojure/ClojureScript projects, or any other lisp-like languages". I'm in no way limiting myself to just Clojure, any lisp-like language will do, say Common Lisp if performance is needed, ulisp if it has to run on a microcontroller, Babashka/Fennel/Janet if fast startup time is required and so on.

As long as it's s-expressions and interactive development oriented, I'm probably fine with it.

But for the last 4-5 years, I have literally not found a single use case where I'm forced to use C++ or Rust since multiple other (lisp-like) languages has the same target market and the ergonomics are just so much better.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by cjaybo on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:33PM (#28832064)
> I have literally not found a single use case where I'm forced to use C++ or Rust

I use C++ to write realtime audio processing applications, especially DAW plug-ins. This is hardly C++'s primary market, but AFAIK there are no lisp-like langauges that can compete with C++ here. I'd be happy to learn something new if this isn't the case!

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by capableweb on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:49PM (#28832876)
Common Lisp performance can be about the same as C++, so performance considerations won't stop you there at least. Common. You can also call C and C++ functions from Common Lisp, so the ecosystem shouldn't stop you either.

It would help if you outlined what's missing from for example Common Lisp in order for it to compete with C++, then maybe I'll be able to give more helpful suggestions that will help you.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by widdershins on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:24PM (#28833780)
The reason people use C/C++ for audio is because a kind of 'soft realtime' performance is required. The thread producing audio cannot block for an unbounded amount of time, ever. If you are late to produce an audio buffer, a nasty audible glitch will be the result. This means no file access, no waiting for mutexes, and certainly no garbage-collection pauses.

This is why managed languages like Lisps are rarely (if ever) used for the DSP in audio applications. I am an audio programmer who loves all things lispy, so believe me, I wish this weren't the case.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by gaze on Monday October 11, 2021 @09:33PM (#28835049)
Fast is unimportant -- latency and determinism are paramount. It's true that GC'ed languages have been used in realtime applications but it's always an uphill battle. There are also low-latency GCs that are being rolled out. I think there's patent issues there but whatever. Might as well just do resource management at compile time.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by tialaramex on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:54PM (#28832308)
I don't understand why you gave the example of C++ (Linux)

Linux is written in C, and, perhaps someday, Rust.

Linus doesn't like C++ and has explicitly objected to, among other things, its enthusiasm for implicit allocation. Rust's implicit allocation all lives in libraries and so the Rust for Linux project ripped that out.

[dead]
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by metagame on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:22PM (#28831954)
I can answer this one! It manages to have significantly less elegant syntax and behavior than both C and Common Lisp, while also having drastically lower performance than both. Alongside that, it's incredibly difficult to port to new systems for little reason other than that the creator decided to make it so. Its package management is also significantly worse than Common Lisp's.

All of this without even getting into Rob Pike (the man largely responsible for its origin, if you're not familiar) saying explicitly it was for people who weren't capable of understanding a better language:

«The key point here is our programmers are Googlers, they’re not researchers. They’re typically, fairly young, fresh out of school, probably learned Java, maybe learned C or C++, probably learned Python. They’re not capable of understanding a brilliant language but we want to use them to build good software. So, the language that we give them has to be easy for them to understand and easy to adopt.»

Rob Pike, 2014.

Go is a fine language, but let's not pretend, here. Rob Pike certainly doesn't.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by to11mtm on Monday October 11, 2021 @05:04PM (#28833070)
There's some truth to this.

As a C# developer, I get to deal with a lot more:

- Bikeshedding over LINQ

- Going back and optimizing LINQ

- Helping Developers understand someone else's LINQ, Reflection/Attribute Abuse

- Helping developers understand new syntax in each version of the language.

A large part of Go's philosophy is to more or less take away all of those tools from the Developer and try to force a style of code that is somewhat monotonous, verbose (in a way very different from Java), yet 'readable' by a developer with minimal experience.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by kaba0 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @05:18AM (#28837719)
Assembly is just as readable/simple, in that every single line is easy to comprehend. Yet good luck getting the big picture of an assembly program.

The same is more or less true of Go. Abstractions can be bad, but in the majority of cases it is the only tool we have against complexity, and a method with an annotation may be thousands time more readable/understandable than the reimplementation of a given identical functionality for the thousands time.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by capableweb on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:17PM (#28831905)
I guess taste is like assholes, everyone has one :)

Go is inferior (to me) because it doesn't have s-expressions, and it doesn't offer interactive development (who in the world wants to re-compile/re-run a whole program/tests on each change?).

Once you've got the taste for interactive development it's really hard to go back to anything else. Ask any Smalltalk developer what they think of other languages.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by eointierney on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:13PM (#28832495)
Where are we at with the "language hierarchy" at the moment? It's been a while since I've seen this game played.

So my move.

1. Common Lisp (well obviously) 2. Racket (gotta make some noise) 3. Haskell (controversial, I know) 4. Rust (trendy and deservedly) 5. APL (terseness) 6. Prolog (made me think differently) 7. Fortran (come a long way) 8. Forth (brevity) 9. Ada (correctness) 10. Lean (I really like Lean) . . C . . C++ . . Python . Perl . Shell . . ECMAscript

Is there anyone I haven't offended? Do let me know :)

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by xkriva11 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:01AM (#28839111)
The Smalltalk mentioned above :-)
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by igouy on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @01:26PM (#28842463)
To quote out of context — "… historically focused more on creative and didactic experimentation than software engineering and industrial use…".

"A Critical Analysis of String APIs: the Case of Pharo" https://hal.inria.fr/hal-01651250/document

----

For CRUD stuff, PHP & Notepad will probably be OK.

For other stuff, local type inference does make a difference.

So does the widespread availability of free-as-in-beer source code libraries.

[dead]
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by capableweb on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:15PM (#28831880)
No, what language you like is often not based on objective set of criteria. It's mostly personal preference and emotions involved.

For example, the reason I like lisps is because they usually offer interactive development, something most non-lisps don't offer. That makes any non-lisps inferior to me.

For the future, you could do with less snark. I never said what I think is objective, and I'm pretty sure most of us know that what languages you like is very much subjective. The sarcasm in your comment just make this thread less interesting, not more.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by kaba0 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @05:15AM (#28837698)
> That makes any non-lisps inferior to me

You didn’t write that though, so I get how some could misunderstand you here.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by capableweb on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @05:19AM (#28849996)
This thread got started with the question:

> Do people decide to go to work for a company based on the language they'll be working in?

So it's expected that the responses will be highly subjective, since the subject itself ("which language you prefer to work with?") is very subjective. Then people write about their experiences which is again, subjective.

Or, I misunderstood the entire point of this thread, and if so, I'm sorry.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by tombert on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:06PM (#28831764)
I seek out companies using niche languages not because I necessarily care about that specific language, but because I find that companies that are willing to work with niche tech tend to be more fun to work for. Typically if you're a Haskell or F# developer, then you probably are at least a little interested in theory and mathematics. Since I'm also interested in theory and math, there's a selection bias of "folks I am extremely likely to get along with".

With a more mainstream language like Java, you're not necessarily going to select for that trait. This isn't to knock Java engineers, since I know a ton of Java engineers much smarter than me, but that fact that Java (JavaScript/Python/C#/any-other-mainstream-language) is popular means that a lot of people learn it because there's a lot of jobs in it and/or it pays well. There's nothing wrong with using a language that makes you money obviously, and there's nothing wrong with liking Java, but as a perpetual-geek I am certainly less drawn to "Java Shops".

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by jes on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:14PM (#28831184)
At 62, I'd probably work for free for a company that used Common Lisp and had half a clue.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by diskzero on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:37PM (#28832108)
I'll bite! Drop me a note. Let's find out if I have a clue.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by ballpark on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @12:39PM (#28841795)
I hope that you'll pay him. If you don't it will be an indication of lack of clues
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by diskzero on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @01:48PM (#28842718)
But of course. I realize the use of "probably work for free" should not be taken literally. It does show that he(?) places value on other aspects of work rather than making a high salary performing joyless tasks

I have been in the fortunate position of being able to provide employment to others (and myself) in several companies. I don't exploit people, I offer wages as competitive as possible, I hire people from non-traditional backgrounds and mentor employees who probably would not get the attention of other large tech companies.

I am not a saint and admit I may be clueless about some things. Providing a workplace that is safe, free of discrimination, rewards people for hard work and supports those who are in need of help are areas I think I do have a clue about.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by jes on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @05:43PM (#28845447)
Hello -- I did just send an email. I would enjoy a relaxed discussion.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by emidln on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:40PM (#28832140)
Why? The things people often list above language are table stakes. I wouldn't give up a high salary to work in Clojure for a low salary, but that's not a choice you have to make. I wouldn't give up interesting problems, fully paid insurance, a good team, 4+ weeks of vacation, etc but again I don't have to give up any of those to work in Clojure. The choice isn't some ideologically pure Clojure startup scraping by versus proper pay + benefits at a large enterprise.

If you're doing application development, it's nice to have a language that truly cares about backwards compatibility and interoperability with a common platform. It means I can focus on solving problems and not incidental complexity. I can easily hack Clojure from the comfort of a pom.xml if necessary.

I'm not working in Clojure right now because I found interesting work outside of application development, but when I was last looking in 2018, I could get roughly all of the things I wanted from a job and still hack Clojure from a CIDER REPL in Emacs all day.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by askonomm on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:22PM (#28831260)
Yes, people want to work with technologies they enjoy, therefore doing work they enjoy.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by jlg23 on Monday October 11, 2021 @05:03PM (#28833059)
Yes, I do. Just because I know how to speak/write some language I don't have to love it. And I rather do something I enjoy than dragging myself to work every day. Increased productivity is just a corollary. (I'll still accept a java gig, but the salary must make up for the daily misery).
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by cletus on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:09PM (#28831807)
They certainly can decide where not to work based on this. Many years ago I had a conversation with IMDB and ran for the hills when I found out the used Perl.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by weavie on Monday October 11, 2021 @05:20PM (#28833229)
Yup, I applied to and worked for one of the companies on this list purely because they were using Common Lisp.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by Barrin92 on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:07PM (#28831778)
fairly high up the list for me. If there were more/any F# jobs around here I'd happily apply. Come to like the language a lot.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by waynesonfire on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:31PM (#28831351)
yes. in fact, startups use this property to their advantage in recruiting by adopting a niche technology stack to hire talented engineers that want to solve problems using that tech stack.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by vegai_ on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @07:29AM (#28838457)
I once did the opposite: I thought that technology details don't matter if the company is good in other ways. Did the mature thing, so to speak.

I was wrong and the company was the worst professional experience of my ~20 year career. Now I vet my future employers' tech stack before signing any papers. It doesn't have to perfect (that's what I often come there to improve) but it has to be not shit, and they have to accept that fundamental problems need to be fixed.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Monday October 11, 2021 @07:11PM (#28834150)
Tangentially. Every job posting is about "5+ years experience in language x, y, and z"

So it's very hard to land a job in a language I don't know. It's all pretty stupid, for the most part any software engineer can pick up any new language pretty quickly when working 9 hours a day on it. The language is the easy part of comp sci.

I'd love to take a job in Android or web development but I just don't have experience so I don't get interviews.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by EamonnMR on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:07PM (#28831782)
I may have passed up on an opportunity because a company used Perforce instead of Git at some point, though memories that old are unreliable at best.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by outworlder on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:45PM (#28832202)
> Seems like something that should be very far down the priority list?

Not entirely. It's a proxy - and a window - on the company culture.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by AtlasBarfed on Monday October 11, 2021 @05:43PM (#28833454)
When you start a job, you are a noob from the perspective of processes, frameworks, paradigms, and current codebase.

You're most susceptible to intellectual bullying in this stage. It's really what makes switching jobs the worst part in programming: you look like an idiot no matter what the first week or two, and are completely at the mercy of your manager and team culture to sink or swim.

Add a new language as ammunition to be intellectually bullied? No thanks.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by joshmn on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:16PM (#28833716)
I do. I’m trying to transition out of development and into management. The last thing I want to do is leave behind the place I’ve called home for the last 10 years, abandoning all the headaches from the language’s subtleties in the process. I’m proficient in enough and have contributed (reasonably) to production-level systems in many, but that doesn’t mean I enjoyed them as much as I do my mainstay.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by cheeze on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:41PM (#28832159)
Functional fanatics are totally the kind of people who seek out teams or spaces for a specific language.

I stay away from those people, not going to lie.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by alfiedotwtf on Monday October 11, 2021 @05:31PM (#28833342)
It's my only priority...

Every place I've worked at, I only applied after asking a) what language do they use b) is it technically cool.

Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by brundolf on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:56PM (#28832329)
I think there's a little-discussed connection between dev happiness and motivation/productivity. I for one am much more driven when I feel good about the thing I'm producing, and the language it's written in has a big impact on that.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by yissp on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:49PM (#28832245)
If I was offered a job with great pay, benefits, and company culture, but all of my programming would need to be done in brainfuck, I'd probably turn it down.
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by eointierney on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:16PM (#28832539)
Eh, surely you'd just build a brainfuck transpiler in lisp and coast
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by klyrs on Monday October 11, 2021 @11:03PM (#28835623)
(parody) Ugh, nobody would want to touch that unreadable machine-generated crap...
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by MrBuddyCasino on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:24PM (#28831275)
What programming languages do you know? Do you prefer any one of them?
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by gmadsen on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:10PM (#28831810)
many companies require certain expertise in a specific language
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by beepbooptheory on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:42PM (#28832172)
just seems like a promising avenue to one day actually getting a job!
Re:Companies that use Lisp extensively by AtNightWeCode on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:45PM (#28831505)
No, it is a warning sign if Lisp, VB6, Cobol or similar is used. ;)

Edit: Just to clarify, the comment was a joke but yes, devs for sure reject jobs at prominent workplaces because of tech. I myself know a highly attractive workplace that want me to join but I won't because I don't believe in their tech stack.