News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by tpmx on Monday October 11, 2021 @01:51PM (#28830963)
Probably/unfortunately not really a Starlink competitor, right?

They don't specify the "cruising" altitude, but I assume it's ~10 kilometers at most, probably less?

Airbus would need quite a few of these in order to build a global internet connectivity service then.

Edit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_Zephyr says ~20 km.

Starlink sats (will) operate at ~540-570 km:

https://spaceflightnow.com/2021/04/29/spacex-launches-60-mor...

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by tomxor on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:28PM (#28831313)
[EDIT] remove redundant info

> Airbus would need quite a few of these in order to build a global internet connectivity service then.

Yes it would require more units, but with a much smaller cost per unit for build, launch and maintenance. That's where it will start to get interesting: Which will have the lowest cost per GB, per user, per square km of coverage etc?

I suspect even if it's cheaper it would still remain less global, since having massive swarms of these would probably be even more of a logistical nightmare than starlink. i.e they would supplement other technology... which is pretty much what Airbus is quoted suggesting in the article.

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by caconym_ on Monday October 11, 2021 @10:24PM (#28835404)
> with a much smaller cost per unit for build, launch and maintenance

Somebody further down in the comments estimates $250k in launch costs for each Starlink satellite^[1]. Elsewhere, I found a claim that SpaceX execs said in 2019 that the per-satellite cost was "well below" $500k^[2]. So let's say $400k per satellite including manufacturing and launch, just to pick a number.

Once it's in orbit, you need to pay for operations, but not maintenance (except on your ground-based infrastructure). And multiple factors (e.g. cheaper launch) stand to bring that price down.

Realistically, how much do we expect one Starlink satellite's worth of telecom UAS to cost on an ongoing basis, including the maintenance and operations costs that don't apply to Starlink? Where is the analysis? OP's article makes the "cheaper" claim with (AFAICT) absolutely nothing to back it up, and the fact is that full size aircraft are not cheap.

The service density flexibility and possibility for additional radio bands Starlink can't provide might be a good argument for this system to exist, but all this talk of it being cheaper seems very vague and presumptuous. What am I missing?

^[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28832257

^[2] https://www.teslarati.com/spacex-starlink-satellite-launch-s...

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by tomxor on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:54AM (#28839672)
> OP's article makes the "cheaper" claim with (AFAICT) absolutely nothing to back it up, and the fact is that full size aircraft are not cheap.

It's not a full sized aircraft. 1 small autonomous plane is cheaper than 1 small satellite in general - in almost all respects. The article didn't claim anything beyond this:

> The unmanned glider [...] is cheaper and more environmentally friendly than a satellite.

This is fairly obvious and uninteresting, what is interesting is cost per GB/user/km2, in other words the end result, which is hard for anyone to say with much certainty at this point even with a thorough analysis because nether business has reached scale yet.

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by caconym_ on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @01:13PM (#28842299)
> It's not a full sized aircraft. 1 small autonomous plane is cheaper than 1 small satellite in general - in almost all respects. The article didn't claim anything beyond this:

From the picture in the article I'm not sure what else to call it other than "full size". Wiki claims it has a ~90 foot wingspan^[1]. Wiki also claims it has an 11 lb payload capacity, so one imagines a practical version of this concept would need to be be substantially larger in order to carry a useful telecom payload.

(A Starlink satellite is a couch-sized slab weighing over 500 lbs, and one can only assume how much of that is telecom equipment, but it's probably a lot more than 11 lbs. So it seems plausible that you'd need on the order of 10 aircraft of this size, or a single much larger and much more expensive aircraft, to equal the throughput of a single Starlink satellite. None of that sounds cheap.)

Being a UAS doesn't necessarily make it cheaper, either. The MQ-1 Predator, a borderline obsolete ~1500 lb airframe pushed by a ~100 hp air-cooled Rotax, seems to cost governments on the order of 10 million dollars to procure. I'm sure there's a lot of pork in there, but it seems far from obvious that relatively exotic UASs like this one can be procured and pressed into production use for, say, two orders of magnitude less than that.

> This is fairly obvious and uninteresting, what is interesting is cost per GB/user/km2, in other words the end result, which is hard for anyone to say with much certainty at this point even with a thorough analysis because nether business has reached scale yet.

Starlink is already a service you can buy and use, subject to whatever "beta" rollout scheme they're using. They still have a long way to go to realize their scale ambitions, but I think their economics are far more settled than other schemes (like this one).

I do agree that cost per user is the interesting number here, but--as above--it seems far from obvious that this UAS scheme can even be competitive with Starlink, let alone cheaper in any reasonable sense.

^[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_Zephyr

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by Tepix on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:15PM (#28831191)
These planes can compete with Starlink in certain scenarios, for example you can launch them in the event of floods that knock out the regular telecommunications infrastructure.
Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by tpmx on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:32PM (#28831364)
With Starlink soon having ~global coverage, why bother transporting, launching and servicing these aircraft for a one time thing? I don't see the benefit. Will also be really hard to reach low prices for end user terminals with this approach.

Very high quality visual/signals surveillance seems like a much more obvious market fit.

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by btilly on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:53PM (#28831609)
First, Starlink has limited bandwidth per square mile. Therefore it cannot conceivably provide telecommunications for densely populated areas.

Second, all you have to do is make these aircraft compatible with cell phones. So your target population already has "end user terminals" literally in hand.

Third, this is not a one-time need. Local disasters happen fairly regularly, and sometimes can be predicted in advance. (For example hurricanes.) There is real value to an instant telecommunications network that can be deployed on short notice.

Now I don't claim that this is actually economically viable. But it is not exactly crazy, either.

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by tpmx on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:03PM (#28831733)
Pretty good points. Starlink can't do 2G/3G/4G/5G with mobile phones on the ground, ~550+ km away, of course.

They should probably look into partnering with e.g. Ericsson Response (https://www.ericsson.com/en/about-us/sustainability-and-corp...).

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by kbenson on Monday October 11, 2021 @05:44PM (#28833471)
> Very high quality visual/signals surveillance seems like a much more obvious market fit.

Oh, yeah, there are already companies the provide complete surveillance of cities or large areas of cities so that even if a crime scene is discovered hours or days later, they can just go back to that time and track vehicle movement to and from the crime scene to wherever it ends up as long as it's in the same (large) area.

Reducing the cost of the equipment that does the recording of the area will only make it more accessible to more police departments, for better or worse.

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by Tepix on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @07:58AM (#28917138)
For starters, all network participants need an expensive, large and power hungry Starlink antenna. An airplane could work with smaller devices as endpoints, such as phones.
Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by Gravityloss on Monday October 11, 2021 @06:04PM (#28833625)
You wouldn't need that many. The line of sight area has 300 km radius. There's even a precedent. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratovision
Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by rlt on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:17PM (#28832553)
They would have the advantage of variable density based on demand, i.e. more of them over population centers and none over oceans, whereas LEO satellite constellations are pretty uniformly distributed because they're orbiting.

It's sort of in between a stationary cell tower and LEO satellite constellation.

But then you have to worry about them failing and hitting those population centers, whereas satellites deorbit slowly and usually burn up completely.

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by Ottolay on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:27PM (#28831309)
The U2 operated at over 20km, so maybe the altitude is higher.

I suspect the greater issue is vehicle cost, lifetime, and safety. A starlink satellite is much smaller (and as result cheaper) and is rumored to have a 5+ year lifetime. Also, at end of life it burns up in the atmosphere. No worry about pushing the life on a component and having it crash and kill someone as a result.

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by runarberg on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:01PM (#28831710)
I’m a bit puzzled by the economy here. Is creating, lunching and orbiting a satellite really cheaper then flying an airplane? Is it really cheaper to have a decommissioned satellite totally burn up in the atmosphere then reusing parts of an airplane to fix another, recycle unusable parts and put the rest in a landfill?

The economics here just seem wrong.

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by ethbr0 on Monday October 11, 2021 @03:50PM (#28832257)
USD2021$15M per Falcon 9 launch (re-used, assuming first launch was paid for by a customer) [0]

60 Starlink satellites per Falcon 9 launch [1]

= + USD2021$250,000 in launch costs per satellite (+ manufacturing / ops costs)

[0] https://www.elonx.net/how-much-does-it-cost-to-launch-a-reus...

[1] https://space4peace.org/starlink-gears-up-to-launch-nearly-1...

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by Ottolay on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:09PM (#28832459)
As a reference a new Cessna 172 is $432,000 [1] and that is not a high tech aircraft.

[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/erictegler/2021/04/28/prices-fo...

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by runarberg on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:37PM (#28832770)
This feels like comparing potatoes and pineapples.

A new Cessna vs a used Falcon 9 launch hardly seems like a fair comparison. The cost of the rocket is written off as externalized. The actual satellites are not factored in at all. Really what we are comparing here is the cost of an operation vs the cost of an airplane. The economics still seem dubious.

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by sfblah on Monday October 11, 2021 @07:26PM (#28834241)
And a Cessna 172 has to be human safe.
Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by runarberg on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:02PM (#28834497)
Indeed, and the $432,000 is the price on the consumer market. A mass order of Zephyrs by, say, the British Government is sure to land a much smaller price tag per unit then a lone hobby pilot can expect when buying a single airplane.
Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by rlt on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:33PM (#28832727)
On top of this, if Starship is successful ("fully and rapidly reusable") it could bring the launch cost down another order of magnitude.

And because Starlink is building thousands of satellites it has economies of scale that no previous satellite/spacecraft had.

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by Breza on Monday October 18, 2021 @11:51AM (#28906806)
If Airbus is successful, you'd have to compare SpaceX's scale to a similarly massive manufacturing operation of solar-powered aircraft. And you could theoretically make money from multiple sources since the aircraft could carry multiple pieces of equipment. You could make money from being an ISP and from selling imaging services.
Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by elif on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:54PM (#28831624)
Glide based efficiency crafts absolutely need thick atmosphere. They don't have supersonic jets.
Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by Ottolay on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:24PM (#28832635)
The U2 was subsonic. Also, un-powered gliders can get up to impressive altitudes.

https://www.airbus.com/newsroom/press-releases/en/2018/09/ai...

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by JackFr on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:51PM (#28832912)
> The unmanned glider, which is powered by two small propellers,

I’m confused by the article and the above comment. Isn’t a glider by definition unpowered?

Re:Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks witho... by Ottolay on Monday October 11, 2021 @07:28PM (#28834251)
Checkout [1]. Easier to say "motor glider" or "powered glider" than "powered airplane with glider like configuration".

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_glider