News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Photos from NASA's Perseverance rover indicate ancient fl... by tsimionescu on Sunday October 10, 2021 @03:30PM (#28821229)
First of all, never listen to Elon Musk on scientific topics, he has no training and often spouts nonsense which he later may decide was a joke.

Second of all, nuking obviously (1) produces far too little energy for terraforming, and (2) produces large amounts of dust and radioactive fallout. It's also very doubtful that melting Mars's poles would do much to help with the habitability of Mars - it will still be extremely cold, extremely lacking in Oxygen, extremely lacking in atmospheric pressure, and extremely radioactive on the surface.

We also don't know how much water is left on Mars after the atmosphere was washed away - water may have frozen, but a good amount may have simply boiled away in the low pressure and been long carried away by the solar winds. Until we know for sure, boiling away more water would be extremely irresponsible.

Also, given humanity's current total energy output, there is simply no way to terraform Mars. If in the future we will discover some way of using orders of magnitude more energy, we could visit this, but given current scientific knowledge, any energy used to start terraforming Mars is as wasted as trying to terraform the Sun.

Re:Photos from NASA's Perseverance rover indicate ancient fl... by rowanG077 on Sunday October 10, 2021 @11:09PM (#28824228)
Huh. Musk has a physics degree and just started doing a PhD when he dropped out to do business. I mean he is no Hawkings but to say he has no scientific training is just plain wrong.
Re:Photos from NASA's Perseverance rover indicate ancient fl... by tsimionescu on Sunday October 10, 2021 @11:37PM (#28824393)
He has a bachelor's degree in physics (which he got at the same time as a degree in economics). This does not qualify as training, in my book, to discuss complex processes such as terraforming. He has never practiced in the field, and dropped put of that PhD after 2 days.

He is a businessman with an undergraduate degree in physics. It is literally true that he has some training, but less so than any junior engineer working in the field for a year or two.

Re:Photos from NASA's Perseverance rover indicate ancient fl... by rowanG077 on Monday October 11, 2021 @08:46AM (#28827710)
Well you can think that but that doesn't make it true. Considering someone who is qualified to do a Physics PhD at Stanford as someone who has no scientific training is really quite ridiculous. A Physics bachelor is 3 years of full-time scientific training. And I'd imagine it's not easy getting into a Stanford PhD program.

Not that I disagree that Musk is selling bullshit a lot of the time. But that is completely separate from his academic career.

Re:Photos from NASA's Perseverance rover indicate ancient fl... by tsimionescu on Monday October 11, 2021 @02:45PM (#28831504)
He was accepted there ~25 years ago. And 3 or 4 years of a bachelor's degree don't mean much - hundreds of thousands of people get such degrees each year all over the world. And by and large, they are nowhere near qualified in discussing any realistic possibility of something like terraforming.

Also, money opens many doors even in the top universities in the USA, so being accepted for a PhD you don't even start is not an iron-tight guarantee of that much (if he had finished his PhD, I would not say this).

Re:Photos from NASA's Perseverance rover indicate ancient fl... by rowanG077 on Monday October 11, 2021 @04:00PM (#28832363)
I was not objecting to your claim that Musk is not qualified to make an assessment about terraforming. I was objecting to your claim that Musk has no scientific training.
Re:Photos from NASA's Perseverance rover indicate ancient fl... by whoknowswhat11 on Sunday October 10, 2021 @04:01PM (#28821510)
I think a lot of the folks who have claimed musk is wrong on the science (ie, pro hydrogen, anti nuke etc folks) are surprisingly poorly informed.

They have nuclear designs which are 98% fusion. The radioactive fallout for these is much more limited.

For example, atomic lake (which was terraformed with nuclear bombs), has radiation levels of 9 µSv vs 3 from background per week

What's even weirder about the "pro-science" folks - they don't seem to understand radiation exposure ranges in space. Surface of mars is going to have radiation levels on the order of 20 uSv per HOUR - we are talking RADS/year (not mili rads).

That said, impactors or nuclear power on the surface are likely more feasible.

Re:Photos from NASA's Perseverance rover indicate ancient fl... by magicalist on Sunday October 10, 2021 @04:44PM (#28821807)
> They have nuclear designs which are 98% fusion. The radioactive fallout for these is much more limited.

> For example, atomic lake (which was terraformed with nuclear bombs), has radiation levels of 9 µSv vs 3 from background per week

It's kind of weird to take an authoritative stance with that example. "atomic lake" was from an underground detonation of a moderate-yield fission device 50 years ago and largely just moved dirt around while still sending up detectable radioactive waste. OK, you can go near the lake now without ill effect but you've accomplished...what exactly?

So scale it up to what is actually needed to vaporize a meaningful amount of the ice caps and look at how effective that would be at making a dent in the Martian atmosphere and the GP has a very good point. It's not a workable idea.

Re:Photos from NASA's Perseverance rover indicate ancient fl... by tsimionescu on Sunday October 10, 2021 @11:42PM (#28824416)
> Surface of mars is going to have radiation levels on the order of 20 uSv per HOUR - we are talking RADS/year (not mili rads).

Sure, but there is a difference between solar radiation coming from a clear source that you can shield against, versus potentially coating the planet in fine radioactive dust that would get into every nook and cranny it finds. Radiation from the sky is bad, but radiation inside our lungs is many times more deadly.

To be fair, martian dust is already extremely toxic, so mixing in radioactive fallout may not significantly increase the need for scrubbing everything down.

Re:Photos from NASA's Perseverance rover indicate ancient fl... by mensetmanusman on Sunday October 10, 2021 @04:20PM (#28821615)
?????

“ (2) produces large amounts of dust…”

The purpose would be to produce dust to spark a warming feedback loop…

Re:Photos from NASA's Perseverance rover indicate ancient fl... by tsimionescu on Sunday October 10, 2021 @04:49PM (#28821845)
Dust cools, it doesn't help with warming. Also, martian dust is extremely erosive, dust storms are already a major problem for the prospect of above-surfave structures (such as sun panels). Kicking up massive amounts of dust for who knows how long into the atmosphere may well backfire.
Re:Photos from NASA's Perseverance rover indicate ancient fl... by _Microft on Sunday October 10, 2021 @04:38PM (#28821760)
We would want something that lets light through but traps the heat, meaning that it needs to be intransparent for infrared radiation. That‘s basically greenhouse gases. Carbon dioxide and water vapor fit the bill.
Re:Photos from NASA's Perseverance rover indicate ancient fl... by dragonwriter on Sunday October 10, 2021 @11:39PM (#28824406)
> The purpose would be to produce dust to spark a warming feedback loop…

That's like spiking Earth’s atmosphere with greenhouse gases to promote global cooling.