News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by dymk on Friday October 08, 2021 @12:15PM (#28800929)
Perhaps in certain subreddits that's true, but on Reddit, it's easy to find both far right and far left echo chambers. And it's easy to find centrist communities. It's also easy to find communities where people don't talk about politics at all, and just discuss their favorite TV show or 3D printing filament without bringing anything else up.

That's not the case on these other "free-speech" reddit clones - they're exclusivly far-right extremist content.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by uabstraction on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:13PM (#28801558)
It's a mistake to think echo chambers are a phenomenon which only take place on the political extremes. Reddit itself is an echo chamber of tepid liberal orthodoxy and American exceptionalism, moderated by a former member of the Atlantic Council. A fish doesn't recognize the water it swims in.

Redditors might call a place like Hexbear an echo chamber for instance, but it wasn't the members of Hexbear who chose to isolate themselves. Reddit made that decision by banning them.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by noobermin on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:01PM (#28802164)
While this is true, I feel like there really is a difference between modern online communities and the ones that existed in the older era, before the so-called web 2.0 era. You can't escape bias at all, that should be any person's educated perspective, but there is a difference in degree that is sharper both on reddit and facebook groups and the like.

Ironically, twitter (which does skew left wing at least in some places), while having its host of issues, has a much lower degree of echo chamber-ness because there are no groups, everyone is thrown in a pot together. It does have the cancel mobs and all that but an echo chamber it is not, which at least proves "echo chamber" isn't the default final state of any social media platform.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by xtracto on Friday October 08, 2021 @12:27PM (#28801101)
> it's easy to find both far right and far left echo chambers

Could you point to 3 "far right echo chamber" active-ish (more than 50,000 subscribers) non-banned subreddits?

For "far-left" I'd say: r/politics r/LateStageCapitalism and r/socialism

EDIT: I knew this post was going to get heat. I consider myself a "leftist" (and by US standards I would be maybe consider a communist) but my point was that there is active censorship of right/far-right discourse in Reddit. Even in my pro-socialist/anti-capitalist view I like reading and seeing the other side's point of view. Main reason being that I think we should be open to other views to see the things to improve in our ideas.

I would invite people to engage in the conversation instead of having a knee-jerk reaction.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hhmc on Friday October 08, 2021 @12:35PM (#28801204)
- r/conspriacy

- r/politicalcompassmemes (basically all the popular 'meme' subreddits are far-right breeding ground)

- any of the "fight porn"/"justice served" have incredibly right-leaning commentariat

These are all things that regular hit r/all

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by postsantum on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:17PM (#28801614)
>> justice served

Moderators for popular subreddit r/JusticeServed on Reddit — one of the most visited websites on the internet with an estimated 12 billion page views per month — said Monday that due to new site policies they are no longer allowed to permit posts, comments, or any other content that shows a person of color as the aggressor

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hairofadog on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:20PM (#28801642)
Do you have a link to where they said that?
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by postsantum on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:32PM (#28801774)
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hairofadog on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:22PM (#28802400)
First, that's from more than a year ago. Second, I looked into it because it sounded literally unbelievable, and indeed it appears to be some sort of trolling and/or conservative fever dream. That exact phrasing shows up in various other places, for example [^0], [^1], and there are threads here and there explaining the frequent trolling of u/automoderator [^2], [^3].

[^0]: https://www.reddit.com/r/copypasta/comments/hndjv0/we_can_no...

[^1]: https://web.archive.org/web/20210123191934/https://www.reddi...

[^2]: https://www.reddit.com/r/Conservative/comments/hmlqrt/commen...

[^3]: https://www.reddit.com/r/SubredditDrama/comments/hn5h3s/rjus...

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by syshum on Friday October 08, 2021 @12:59PM (#28801394)
/r/conspiracy is NOT far right, FAR FAR FAR from it

it is 1990 Democrat, which today sadly is "right" given that "left" has taken an extreme left turn...

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by xtracto on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:14PM (#28801567)
r/conspiracy is a sad story. I loved the subreddit from years ago, where crazy and even stupid conspiracies were discussed. Nowadays it's all related to "antivax" crap.
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by shkkmo on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:04PM (#28802209)
> my point was that there is active censorship of right/far-right discourse in Reddit.

Politically biased rule enforcement is a bit different than having a community that invariably has to frame every unrelated thing in terms of a certain political ideology.

While your overall points are good, you derail a more more original comment into the standard partisan censorship discussion that happens over and over on HN.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by dymk on Friday October 08, 2021 @12:31PM (#28801153)
r/the_doland (banned) r/CringeAnarchy (banned) r/Greatawakening (banned) The myriad of r/incel communities and their clones that Reddit plays whack-a-mole with
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by dtjb on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:16PM (#28801605)
r/antifa and r/chapotraphouse were also large communities that were banned.

Reddit policy definitely appears to be based on behavior, not ideology.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by syshum on Friday October 08, 2021 @09:24PM (#28806161)
Pointing to a few exceptions does not change the fact there is a clear political bias to reddit Admin action.

This is to be expected given the geographic location of their Admin staff, however to deny this to to pretend that CNN, MSNBC and Fox News are all "unbiased news sources" which everyone knows this to be false as well

While yes, Reddit Admins do take action on behavior, the Admins ideology allows certain groups more "benefit of the doubt" more warnings, more kid gloves than other ideologies do.

Any honest observer can see that in the pattern of Admin action

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:19PM (#28801635)
yeah real great "behavior" they got over there

https://www.reddit.com/r/HermanCainAward/

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by dtjb on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:25PM (#28801688)
I could see some people finding it in bad taste, but since all names are obscured, what specifically is bannable about that community?
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:27PM (#28801713)
ah yes, making fun of people dying is okay as long as you obscure the names!

the same people that like to respond with "700,000+ dead"!

this is the same reason /r/fatpeoplehate got banned is it not?

yes the intent may be to "help through shaming" but it's not usually allowed, guess it's okay because of the political lean.

ironically, shaming the fat people would help the covid thing most of all as it's the #1 morbidity reason for covid.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by nemothekid on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:41PM (#28801896)
>ah yes, making fun of people dying is okay as long as you obscure the names!

Yes. You've made up an imaginary enemy in your head and you are talking down to others based on the imaginary Reddit company in your head.

The reason those other communities were banned were for targeted harassment, doxing of real people, and brigading other subreddits. Reddit has never stated that they were any rules on the "morality" of the content. The communities that are still around have not broken those rules yet.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by syshum on Friday October 08, 2021 @09:28PM (#28806181)
So then what is the defense for a similar subreddit that made fun of people that died after getting the vaccination. They followed the same "rules" you seem to claim here, they did not doxx anyone, they did not harass anyone, they did not brigade other subreddits, most of it was just side by side tweets of a person positing the vaccination announcement followed by a notification they died a few day later...
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:45PM (#28801948)
> Reddit has never stated that they were any rules on the "morality" of the content.

Cool, so both sides don't have rules on morality and the only speech moderation we should be worried about on any site is illegal speech. I agree.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by nemothekid on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:49PM (#28802014)
>the only speech moderation we should be worried about on any site is illegal speech

I never said that. I, for one, am not a free speech absolutist, and I think those that pretend they are, are children of the Facebook era of online discourse. I am iterating once again, that Reddit has clear rules and those rules have largely been executed without political bias. If your favorite subreddit got banned, they were very likely violating those rules.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:59PM (#28802137)
We'll agree to disagree, but Reddit's track record speaks for itself.

It's a liberal echo chamber by design, no amount of gaslighting will change that, anyone can tell from 5 minutes of browsing.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by dtjb on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:32PM (#28801772)
I wasn't active in the community, but I believe r/fatpeoplehate was mostly unsolicited photographs ("creepshots") of overweight people and making fun of them.

It appears r/hermancainaward is 100% based on posts that the deceased willingly shared with the public. I think that's a meaningful difference.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by xtracto on Friday October 08, 2021 @08:22PM (#28805773)
> It appears r/hermancainaward is 100% based on posts that the deceased willingly shared with the public. I think that's a meaningful difference.

Just a minor correction there: The majority of posts from the death people in HCA are from Facebook. I think that normally, people posts would only be shared with their Friends (unless you specifically change it to be public).

In that respect, posters in HCA would be publishing posts that were originally not meant to be public.

As an example, I might write a post in Facebook about me and my wife going on vacation to X place for 1 week. While it is OK for me for my friends to know that, I may not want this information to be public for fear of my house getting robbed while I am gone.

Although I completely agree with the sentiment and main point of HCA (and I actually have enjoyed the schadenfreude of some of the awarded people there), I concede that it is definitely a subreddit that is of quite bad taste and brings the worst of the "pro-vaccine" side of the argument.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by BitwiseFool on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:25PM (#28802427)
I think that r/HermanCainAward is actually quite sinister and designed to normalize and reinforce dehumanization of "the other side". The whole point of the subreddit is to showcase people who've had strong political convictions, then died as a result of them.

You're supposed to feel a sense of comeuppance that these people who don't believe in the vaccine or dismiss the severity Covid died as a result of their beliefs. There is no shortage of mockery involved, either. It is disguised as simple schadenfreude, but I sense the subscribers are actually reveling in the deaths of others.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by iaml on Friday October 08, 2021 @09:10PM (#28806104)
There have been threads there where people say they would prefer that sub wouldn't exist at all, those preventable deaths and misery fading from existence. I don't know whether they do it for laughs or are just burnt out from people choosing to make a point of politicizing not wearing a mask, probably a mix of both. I don't know how to solve that problem either, some of the posts there contain straight up insults towards people who vaxx/wear masks, this feedback cycle of radicalization is self sustaining at this point.
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:36PM (#28801828)
So as long as you obtain the obituary from the public and obscure the name, you're totally fine with making fun of people dying, got it!

So much better people on Reddit. Much compassion, such intelligence. So advanced.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by dtjb on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:45PM (#28801959)
This doesn't seem like a productive conversation. Peace.
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:46PM (#28801971)
Have a nice day!
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by noobermin on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:02PM (#28802185)
r/politics isn't "far-left" although lsc and socialism are. There are also hosts of far-left subreddits that don't really reach r/all
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @12:16PM (#28800953)
My post was exactly what GP was doing here. He couldn't talk about the article posted without bringing in some neo nazi fantasy he had. I simply changed the words he spouted and it fit perfectly with what he is doing.

Reddit bans anything "far right" (whatever that means) that gets popular.

Extremist used to mean terrorist, now it's used for people you don't align with politically.

No one on [Patriots . win] is an extremist, but I'm sure you'd say they were.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by pgeorgi on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:11PM (#28801536)
The good thing about "no one on $site is an extremist" is that there's a pretty clear way to disprove it: find one specimen.

https://patriots.win/p/13zg9agFHB/instead-of-eliminating-hun... promotes some myth about "the government wanting to eliminate 1e6 to 1e9 american workers" and proposes to "eliminate politicians" instead.

Comments by the OP in that thread clarify the direction this is supposed to take, responding to "The swamp in one picture" with "One Drone Strike".

Textbook extremism. (edit to add: or, as hunterb123 asserts, an edge lord. Since I don't know the site or user but hunterb123 apparently does, I'll take them by their word.)

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:17PM (#28801612)
your definition of an extremist is certainly lax isn't it?

I'd designate someone an extremist if they were plotting to do something, not some edgy comment that you'd find anywhere.

There's hundreds of comments on reddit wishing death, that doesn't make those people "extremists".

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by pgeorgi on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:29PM (#28801733)
Ah, the edgelord defense, a Tried and True practice. One issue is that the entire thread is _only_ edgelords in that model. I couldn't find anybody on that page speaking out against the ideas espoused by the poster.

As for "comment that you'd find anywhere", I know a few places where I wouldn't find such comments. Not because oh-the-oppression, but because people don't engage with them in the same way as on that page. It's possible shape a culture and that site seems to have chosen one that is easily being mistaken for extremism, at the very least.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:38PM (#28801856)
On Reddit they have an entire subreddit for making fun of people's death. Reddit is the edgelord's gala.

Anytime a Republican got sick, they'd wish for them to die throughout the front page.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by pgeorgi on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:49PM (#28802007)
So we're not arguing if any service is about free speech and how that pertains to extremism, but only which kind of edgelord is worse? Boring.
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:53PM (#28802073)
So you admit we are comparing two edge lords from opposing sides of the political spectrum. Thank you.

You started this by mis-categorizing an edge lord as an "extremist".

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by pgeorgi on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:55PM (#28802097)
I don't know them, so if you assert that they're an edgelord and not an extremist, I can only imagine that you do know them.

Lacking any other information, and given a relative unimportance of that person to me, I'll take your word on that. Given the time you devote on the defense of that community, it's certainly more important to you than it is to me.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:05PM (#28802222)
If you don't know them how did you assert they were an extremist in your original comment?

An extremist is likened to a terrorist, you need to have evidence other than some edgelord comment, otherwise they are just an edgelord.

Until proven otherwise you should assume they are the same as Reddit edgelords (actually most of them ARE or WERE Reddit edgelords!)

I'm not defending one community in particular, I'm defending everyone's right to be in the community they want without being dehumanized as some sort of monster racist.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by pgeorgi on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:16PM (#28802325)
If it quacks like a duck...
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:20PM (#28802374)
Then it's an armchair wannabe federal agent?

Yes pgeorgi does look and quack like that.

Judge thee but not me!

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by pgeorgi on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:24PM (#28802421)
Depends on the federation: Federal Republic of Germany? I'm paying taxes so I guess one could consider me an agent.

But more than that: I also worked and work for organisations aligned with them in various capacities (currently I'm TA'ing at a state-run university, so while that's multiple hops away I guess it's a start? My fellow citizens often mix up what part is federal and what's state anyway, so it might as well not matter in the context of this conversation.)

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:32PM (#28802527)
Shit, so those people were terrorists.
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by pgeorgi on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:34PM (#28802543)
Sorry, I don't follow. Is that the Chewbacca defense?
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:51PM (#28802702)
Was just a joke. You joked that I guessed right you were a fed, and I joked that you must have been right guessing about the person on Patriots since I guessed right.

The underlying joke is we're all just guessing and judging people based on a razor thin insight that is a brief comment on a forum.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hluska on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:35PM (#28801812)
Bullshit. It’s generally acknowledged by everyone whose IQ exceeds their shoe size, that wishing death upon politicians is extremism. Stop defending this kind of shit - it’s not defensible no matter how much you clutch your pearls and whine about your freedumb.
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @01:41PM (#28801901)
So if I find you one instance where someone wished death on Reddit that has +1 upvote (like this submission) you'll concede that Reddit is an extremist site right?
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by pgeorgi on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:02PM (#28802184)
The "one instance" thing only applies to that "patriots" site because you asserted "No one on [Patriots . win] is an extremist". It also doesn't show that the site is an "extremist site", only that your claim is wrong.

Your statement about reddit is a logical fallacy.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:10PM (#28802264)
No, the supposed qualification to be an "extremist" was asserted by another that it was "wishing death".

I wish to apply that same standard to Reddit and see if it passes the same qualification to be "extremist" (it will).

tldr: I still haven't been shown a post on Patriots that is more extreme than anything I've seen on Reddit.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by pgeorgi on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:15PM (#28802314)
You're moving goal posts: The original statement of yours has been "no one on patriots is an extremist", classifying site users. Now you're at "you'll concede that Reddit is an extremist site right?", classifying the site itself.
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:23PM (#28802401)
No, I have an issue with how you quantify "extremist" that's been the whole point of the entire thread.

You say it's anyone who "wishes death", well that is too loose because that pertains to every community on every site, including Reddit.

Please try again with your definition of "extremist" and I will retest the communities.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by timcederman on Friday October 08, 2021 @12:31PM (#28801149)
> No one on [Patriots . win] is an extremist, but I'm sure you'd say they were.

Seriously?

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:42PM (#28802607)
Yes, "seriously".

How about for fun you try to explain what an extremist is?

We'll go from there.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by dymk on Friday October 08, 2021 @12:20PM (#28801022)
That seems fair game to bring up though, because this is a thread discussing the site as a whole, and not about a TV show. And the pattern of reddit clones hosting exclusively far-right ~~~extremist~~~ (edit: I'll replace this with "leaning") content while reddit itself is far more diverse is an interesting observation.
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @12:24PM (#28801067)
I dunno, go look through any popular subreddit and it's all about "extreme" leftist politics, even /r/funny, etc.

But sure, some fantasy about neo nazis discussing tv shows that I'm sure GP totally saw and didn't just make up is relevant.

I guess my point is, yes, it can happen but it happens on both sides. Mostly, people just want a nice place to hang out amongst their like minded peers, and no that doesn't mean discussing Jews 24/7 believe it or not. GP talks like someone who has never talked with someone on the other "side". We're all people, stop dehumanizing the other political spectrum because you don't understand them.

tldr: the most extreme people on the right probably discuss Soros/Jews as much as the most extreme people on the left discuss Trump/MAGA. That doesn't represent anyone else.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by dtjb on Friday October 08, 2021 @12:35PM (#28801199)
wait, patriots.win isn't extremist but r/funny is?
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @12:36PM (#28801215)
extremist != extreme

extreme is used to denote it's a far swing in the spectrum, extremist alludes to terrorism.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by shkkmo on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:11PM (#28802282)
While "extremist" might have connatations of violence/terrorism, those connotations are not inherent in the meaning of the word. I would argue that it behooves us to push back against such a connotation because it really only serves to delegitimize people who don't have mainstream beliefs by implying that they intend violence without having to justify an actually disprovable statement.
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:14PM (#28802303)
Sure. I don't like the word, most of my argument is infact arguing against the use of the word "extremist". I only used it once in response and I used "extreme" elsewhere which is fine to use when denoting where they are in the spectrum of the political ideology.
Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by shkkmo on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:30PM (#28802500)
You explicitly upgraded the terrorism connotation to being part of the meaning by using it to draw a distinction between the two words categorical referents.

Instead I think you should have directly questioned whether the connotation of violence was part of the point you were responding to.

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by hunterb123 on Friday October 08, 2021 @02:34PM (#28802540)
Okay so would you like the criteria for all site's users to be a "connotation of violence" to meet the extremist threshold?

That is even looser than wishing death and would cover many more communities.

Let's clear things up by a simple question:

How do you define "extremist"?

Re:Ruqqus, an open source Reddit clone, is shutting down the... by shkkmo on Saturday October 09, 2021 @05:48PM (#28813605)
An extremist is one who holds extreme views.

I'm not really sure what you mean by:

> Okay so would you like the criteria for all site's users to be a "connotation of violence" to meet the extremist threshold?