Re:Quickemu: Quickly create and run optimised Win-10,11/macO...
by amarshall on Friday October 08, 2021 @07:39AM
(#28798091)
No one but Apple owns a copy of macOS. They own a license to use it according to the terms of that license.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Quickemu: Quickly create and run optimised Win-10,11/macO...
by account42 on Friday October 08, 2021 @09:23AM
(#28798970)
As with all information, society as a whole "owns" macOS - Apple only has been granted a temporary monopoly of this information in order to encourage them to create more.
Re:Quickemu: Quickly create and run optimised Win-10,11/macO...
by amarshall on Friday October 08, 2021 @11:10AM
(#28800171)
Practically, what’s the difference until their copyright expires?
Re:Quickemu: Quickly create and run optimised Win-10,11/macO...
by ncmncm on Saturday October 09, 2021 @12:38AM
(#28807103)
Innumerable court cases have turned on what are often negligible practical differences. Apple is said, legally, to "hold" copyright. Saying they "own" it would mean they have all sorts of rights and powers around it that we as a society choose not to grant to them.
That is not to say that numerous judges have not, on their own initiative, elected to grant holders many such powers. Judges can be just as confused as anyone, and more than some, and so exceed their statutory authority. Congress, moreso. But there is still a difference.
Re:Quickemu: Quickly create and run optimised Win-10,11/macO...
by Mordisquitos on Friday October 08, 2021 @08:37AM
(#28798498)
Which is another argument against using the term "stealing". At no point does the user deprive Apple of the ownership of macOS.
Re:Quickemu: Quickly create and run optimised Win-10,11/macO...
by amarshall on Friday October 08, 2021 @11:17AM
(#28800232)
Sure, and I didn’t argue for or against the use of that term. The legal definition of theft varies by jurisdiction, but is not necessarily limited to physical objects (e.g. services). I have no idea whether it’s appropriate in this case (I’m not a lawyer), but feels more like copyright infringement.
Re:Quickemu: Quickly create and run optimised Win-10,11/macO...
by JasonFruit on Friday October 08, 2021 @08:43AM
(#28798551)
Control is a part of ownership. If you don't control how something is used and by whom, you don't really own it. So either using it in unauthorized ways is in a manner theft, or Apple's "ownership" is not real ownership. I'm not sure what the solution is, but IP is a tricky concept no matter your position.
Re:Quickemu: Quickly create and run optimised Win-10,11/macO...
by CTDOCodebases on Friday October 08, 2021 @09:09AM
(#28798831)
It sounds like Apple don’t even own it then if they can’t prevent people from pirating it.
Re:Quickemu: Quickly create and run optimised Win-10,11/macO...
by amarshall on Friday October 08, 2021 @11:20AM
(#28800259)
It has nothing to do with actually preventing all infringement, but instead seeking enforcement in at least some cases. If a copyright owner is aware of substantial infringement and chooses not to pursue (or license) they may lose their copyright through genericization or other means.
(Caveat: I’m not a lawyer, but I learned broadly the above from an IP lawyer.)
Re:Quickemu: Quickly create and run optimised Win-10,11/macO...
by ben_w on Friday October 08, 2021 @10:13AM
(#28799494)
I can’t prevent someone from robbing me, just make it harder for them to do so and have legal recourse if they do it anyway.
This still counts as “having control”.
Re:Quickemu: Quickly create and run optimised Win-10,11/macO...
by tinus_hn on Friday October 08, 2021 @11:18AM
(#28800241)
Actually I own several dvds that contain legitimate copies of Mac OS X (back when it came on dvds)
Re:Quickemu: Quickly create and run optimised Win-10,11/macO...
by amarshall on Friday October 08, 2021 @12:32PM
(#28801160)
You may own the physical disc, but to use the software on it you need to accept the license terms.
Re:Quickemu: Quickly create and run optimised Win-10,11/macO...
by tinus_hn on Friday October 08, 2021 @03:29PM
(#28803142)
Because to do that, I have to make another copy into the memory of my computer.
Re:Quickemu: Quickly create and run optimised Win-10,11/macO...
by Tomte on Friday October 08, 2021 @08:47AM
(#28798588)
Not according to German law.