The Level 3 automation systems that Tesla and Uber built rely on two factors too, but they invert them, expecting disengaged humans to snap to alertness at super-human speed, which is just not how our brains work. So of course the second factor only exists as a legal cover to reduce their liability, which is all these players care about as far as safety is concerned.
Though just speculation and no source.
The thing about automotive radar, and this isn't just Tesla, is that stationary objects are normally excluded. Otherwise the system brakes for things like overhead signs that have high radar reflectivity. Stopped cars, concrete barriers, etc are all basically invisible to most automotive radar.
Tesla also isn't the only manufacturer taking the vision approach. Subaru, for example, was doing vision-only emergency braking in 2016.
I believe most automotive radars in the last few years are FMCW exactly to accommodate adaptive cruise control.
The goal is to cut costs and keep shipping during the chip shortage. Ignore the excuses.
Tesla doesn’t have a lot of any of those things.
So it's like a small animal with one eye closed.
This is the most ridiculous line of reasoning I've heard in a long time. Wow.
Cars do not need that skill.
> Or listen to a faraway sound and know that its getting closer at an alarming or not-alarming rate?
I'm sure the car has multiple microphones, it just needs the brains to process the input.
> Or feel the road getting harsher and understand that the GPS is incorrect?
Again, I am sure the car has multiple G sensors, accelerometers and gyroscopes. It just needs the smarts to process the input.
As a driver, I can certainly sense my car smelling funny if something goes wrong :)
https://www.barrons.com/articles/lidar-is-the-future-of-auto...
In a Tesla AEB should be an entirely self-contained ("dumber") system. Its only job should be to look for any ground-level object ahead and brake. It should do this using simpler but more reliable ("dumber") techniques like forward bumper-level radar or camera parallax, not NN/deep learning/object recognition/AI.
To use an analogy, AEB should be like two-factor authentication. If your "second" factor is the same as your first, then it isn't two-factor. In this case AutoPilot is the "first" and "second" factor i.e. it is AEB and in control of the vehicle.
So Tesla's vehicles absolutely have AEB, when AutoPilot is disabled, because it is offering a "second opinion" relative to the driver. So IIHS's ratings are correct in that instance. But as soon as AutoPilot is enabled it is no longer a "second" opinion and therefore may as well not exist.
Unfortunately Tesla aren't alone in making this mistake. We're seeing other vehicle manufacturers stepping into the vehicle automation space double-dipping their auto-drive systems into AEB. It is a bad practice regardless of who, AEB should be its own system with its own simpler/dumber logic that protects people from auto-drive mistakes, not compounds them.