News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paddle announces iOS IAP alternative that avoids Apple's ... by Danieru on Thursday October 07, 2021 @06:50AM (#28784613)
Apple would be playing with fire if they attempt that interpretation. It would detooth the ruling, and could force the judges hand to impose stricter or more vague requirements. The judge certainly not have an issue with the api design...
Re:Paddle announces iOS IAP alternative that avoids Apple's ... by CubsFan1060 on Thursday October 07, 2021 @07:01AM (#28784692)
The judge outright said this was ok:

“In such a hypothetical world, developers could potentially avoid the commission while benefitting from Apple’s innovation and intellectual property free of charge. The Court presumes that in such circumstances that Apple may rely on imposing and utilizing a contractual right to audit developers annual accounting to ensure compliance with its commissions, among other methods. Of course, any alternatives to IAP (including the foregoing) would seemingly impose both increased monetary and time costs to both Apple and the developers.”

Re:Paddle announces iOS IAP alternative that avoids Apple's ... by Danieru on Thursday October 07, 2021 @07:12AM (#28784758)
Wow, that's insane. She really did give a toothless ruling.

Thanks for correcting me.

Re:Paddle announces iOS IAP alternative that avoids Apple's ... by worrycue on Thursday October 07, 2021 @07:22AM (#28784830)
It’s less that it’s toothless and more that Apple won the case - she ruled 9/10 counts in Apple’s favour.
Re:Paddle announces iOS IAP alternative that avoids Apple's ... by FDSGSG on Thursday October 07, 2021 @07:19AM (#28784807)
It's not insane, there's simply no reason for why Apple shouldn't get their cut.
Re:Paddle announces iOS IAP alternative that avoids Apple's ... by Aeolun on Thursday October 07, 2021 @07:36AM (#28784934)
Microsoft doesn’t get a cut from Windows apps. Why should Apple?
Re:Paddle announces iOS IAP alternative that avoids Apple's ... by CubsFan1060 on Thursday October 07, 2021 @07:49AM (#28785030)
Why are you comparing iOS to Windows? MacOS to Windows, or iOS to Android make more sense.

A more fair comparison would be andorid. Or the Windows Phone, where Microsoft took 20%: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Phone

Re:Paddle announces iOS IAP alternative that avoids Apple's ... by Aeolun on Thursday October 07, 2021 @07:52AM (#28785051)
I’m comparing a small general purpose computer to a big one. How is that an invalid comparison?

Just because everyone does the same thing on a mobile phone doesn’t make it any more sensible.

Re:Paddle announces iOS IAP alternative that avoids Apple's ... by CubsFan1060 on Thursday October 07, 2021 @08:10AM (#28785202)
Because it's a cherry picked example that ignores a lot of factors.

I could easily make the statement "Microsoft gets a cut of everything purchased on Xbox, why shouldn't Apple?"

To which I suspect your response would be waving your hands around something that is ill defied (General Purpose Computing), and then trying to define it to fit your narrative.

Re:Paddle announces iOS IAP alternative that avoids Apple's ... by roflc0ptic on Thursday October 07, 2021 @08:41AM (#28785468)
A more cogent and principled response would be that there is an effective duopoly in the phones market, and this creates incentives for and actually realized anti competitive practices on the part of both google and apple. Apple both builds a market and regulates that market in its own favor, and consumers don't have an especially plausible alternative to participating.
Re:Paddle announces iOS IAP alternative that avoids Apple's ... by GeekyBear on Thursday October 07, 2021 @08:36AM (#28785424)
Microsoft chose to create Windows as an open platform where they didn't get a cut of application sales.

Microsoft chose to create XBox as a platform where developers who didn't pay them a cut could not sell software.

Microsoft attempted to convert Windows into a platform where developers who didn't pay them a cut could not sell software with Windows RT, but it failed in the marketplace.

Re:Paddle announces iOS IAP alternative that avoids Apple's ... by threeseed on Thursday October 07, 2021 @08:07AM (#28785168)
Microsoft is definitely the anomaly.

Sony, Microsoft, Nintendo, Google, Valve, Epic etc all take their cut.

Re:Paddle announces iOS IAP alternative that avoids Apple's ... by Aeolun on Thursday October 07, 2021 @08:21PM (#28793977)
I was feeling sort of confused by me feeling like Valve and Epic were not supposed to be in that list.

But it’s because I have a choice. I can choose to use Valve, or Epic, or nothing at all.

Hell, I can even choose never to use the Nintendo store, and just purchase plain cardridges.

The same is not true for the others, but especially not for Apple.

Re:Paddle announces iOS IAP alternative that avoids Apple's ... by FDSGSG on Saturday October 09, 2021 @11:14AM (#28810552)
>Hell, I can even choose never to use the Nintendo store, and just purchase plain cardridges.

Do you really think that Nintendo doesn't get their cut on plain cartridges?

Re:Paddle announces iOS IAP alternative that avoids Apple's ... by wayneftw on Thursday October 07, 2021 @10:59AM (#28787180)
...and the fact that everybody is doing it makes it good and right, right?
Re:Paddle announces iOS IAP alternative that avoids Apple's ... by Danieru on Thursday October 07, 2021 @08:14AM (#28785225)
Hey FDSGSG I see you used my comment to implement your reply. As you no doubt know my API usage policy is 30% of your gross.

Note, you cannot deduct the 30% your electric utility charges you, nor the 30% your PC monitor maker charges you, nor the 30% your desk maker charges, you'll have to figure out how to finance your development out of the other -40%.

If this is not acceptable obviously you could have written your reply to my comment under any other comment. There are many other comments you could freely leave your reply to me under. You choose to use my comment to base your reply to no doubt because that's the only one I read. Still of course, I do not have a monopoly on replies to me under all posts on the internet. Replies under my comment are of course not a monopoly because you can freely reply to me anywhere else. For example, you could have replied to my post on your grandma's Facebook.