News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I'm sorry by avsteele on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @11:00PM (#28781324)
I am not versed in all the details here, but it is clear there is a diverge of expectations between MS and some of the repo owners. This is just part of business. Legal agreements and projects are complicated. Not everything is going to be spelled out. In a good business relationship you acknowledge this and work in good faith to resolve differences when they occur.

However, top comments make clear there is a dire need for professional communications training among these programmers. There is entirely too much emotion on display here. Stuff like this:

   While I appreciate that this must have been hard to write, this is a total non-apology and just about meets the incredibly low expectations I and others had for the .NET Foundation's public statement.
.. and the other comments like it, are not productive. There is a difference in expectations, so resolve it by making offers to MS for proposed changes. Ultimately there is a negotiated settlement or you walk. That's it. Don't bring emotions into it.
Re:I'm sorry by RedShift1 on Thursday October 07, 2021 @12:31AM (#28781943)
I don't see anything wrong with that quote. Can it be expressed more "softly"? Sure. But that person is expressing his opinion and I don't see any problem with that. You could also argue it lays the foundation for further escalation but that's on whoever chooses to engage in it IMO.

There seems to be a more general trend going on, some think themselves or others must be protected from "harshness" (even though I consider the above quote to be only a mild example - see the rest of the internet...). For example Linus Torvalds gets a lot of flak for his opinions on some pieces of code he doesn't like but every time I read those emails, I feel like people are blowing it way out of proportion. I'm sure it's not fun to be on the receiving end but his arguments are typically sound and likes to write a lot to really drive his point home. I'd rather be told I'm working on a dead end than a "nice comforting letter" explaining how my patch can't be accepted _right now_ because of x and y with wording that could be interpreted as "it could be accepted later" just to be friendly even though the code is structurally bad and needs to go back to the drawing board. It would give hope where there is none and I think that is worse than "no your code sucks because of x y and z".

I think in this case here it was ok for disappointment to be expressed.

Re:I'm sorry by indigochill on Thursday October 07, 2021 @03:41AM (#28783344)
I'd say the key thing wrong with it is that it's not actionable. It doesn't express what the commenter would like to see changed. It's just general vague disapproval.

Harsh or soft, criticism should always be actionable. The way you describe Torvalds' feedback, that's actionable, when someone is told what makes their code unacceptable, so they can correct course and try again.

EDIT: I should edit to add, the post that the quote is from -does- in fact then go on to point out what it finds unacceptable. But I'm commenting just on the quote.

Re:I'm sorry by chrisseaton on Thursday October 07, 2021 @06:30AM (#28784493)
> his arguments are typically sound

Telling someone to kill themselves is not a sound argument under any circumstances.

Re:I'm sorry by samhw on Thursday October 07, 2021 @08:35AM (#28785412)
What if that person is Hitler? What if you work at Dignitas? What if you're Linus Torvalds, working at Dignitas, and the person is Hitler, and Hitler wants to merge a particularly bad pull request to add an NPM leftpad dependency to page_alloc?
Re:I'm sorry by chrisseaton on Thursday October 07, 2021 @08:37AM (#28785432)
These aren't sensible suggestions worth debating.

But yes I think it's literally absolutely always wrong to tell anyone to kill themselves, no matter how evil they are. Personal abuse is always wrong.

Re:I'm sorry by samhw on Thursday October 07, 2021 @08:53AM (#28785575)
If it wasn't sufficiently clear from my scenario where Hitler wants to merge an NPM dependency into the Linux kernel while Linus Torvalds is treating him at a euthanasia clinic, I was joking.

In the scope of any realistically possible pull request discussion, yes, you're undoubtedly right.

Re:I'm sorry by pizza234 on Thursday October 07, 2021 @04:11AM (#28783497)
(Rationally) making a point, expressing emotions, and being offensive/insulting are entirely separate things.

There are a few misconceptions at play:

  1. that expressing negative emotions implies being offensive

  2. that being offensive strengthens an argument
In my experience, being able to separate the offensive part, which is certainly difficult, leads to much more productive outcomes, without losing argumentative strength - besides, being also (considered) more professional.

> some think themselves or others must be protected from "harshness"

In the above perspective, harshness is simply improductive in any context - being firm and persuasive is always a better choice. It's just very difficult :^)

> I'd rather be told I'm working on a dead end than a "nice comforting letter" explaining how my patch can't be accepted _right now_ because of x and y with wording that could be interpreted as "it could be accepted later"

This is a dichotomy between an arguably harsh approach and a false/polite one. There are other different approaches (besides, I think that there's nothing offensive/harsh in being told that one is working on a dead end).

> I don't see anything wrong with that quote. Can it be expressed more "softly"? Sure. But that person is expressing his opinion and I don't see any problem with that.

Being considerate towards other people leads to a much more productive collaboration. This vision:

> You could also argue it lays the foundation for further escalation but that's on whoever chooses to engage in it IMO.

is indeed non-collaborative - essentially, not being interested at all about the other person. The point is then just venting frustration rather than communicating (in general, not the specific case).

I doubt that anybody can hold a lead/management position with this attitude (without being considered at least an unpleasant manager).

> For example Linus Torvalds gets a lot of flak for his opinions on some pieces of code he doesn't like but every time I read those emails, I feel like people are blowing it way out of proportion. I'm sure it's not fun to be on the receiving end but his arguments are typically sound and likes to write a lot to really drive his point home.

This argument actually proves the point. Torvals made a public apology:

  http://lkml.iu.edu/hypermail/linux/kernel/1809.2/00117.html
so definitely there is something (to say the least) inappropriate with that attitude. There are indications that he went to therapy specifically because of that:

  https://twitter.com/lexnfx/status/1409185767348310020
All in all, I definitely support (in a more verbose way :^)) the argument:

> top comments make clear there is a dire need for professional communications training among these programmers

Re:I'm sorry by rocqua on Thursday October 07, 2021 @04:39AM (#28783701)
> making a point, expressing emotions, and being offensive/insulting are entirely separate things.

Whilst true, what often happens is that people emotionally express disapproval. This then often includes harsh judgement not just of someones work, but of their person as well. At that point it becomes insulting. Even when not moving on to harshly judging a person, totally destroying someone's work is likely to put them on the defensive. For the purposes of keeping up conversation, it can be equivalent to being insulting.

Consider remarks like.

"This code is riddled with bugs and lacks insights form the last 10 years. Whomever wrote it must be willfully ignorant or a total moron with their head in the sand".

It reads like a statement made from emotion, it technically only includes "making a point" but it goes so far as too become insulting. Even if you drop the second sentence it can still be insulting.

Re:I'm sorry by judahmeek on Thursday October 07, 2021 @12:57AM (#28782166)
> You could also argue it lays the foundation for further escalation but that's on whoever chooses to engage in it IMO.

This sounds like victim-blaming. I can imagine neo-nazis using this type of statement to defend someone who yelled the N-word in a black neighborhood.

The truth is that inflammatory language, which GP's quote was, is rarely constructive.

Re:I'm sorry by xunn0026 on Thursday October 07, 2021 @01:53AM (#28782618)
Excuse me? The post is a non-apology. It starts with a minor PR while in fact it turns out to be about the whole organizational structure which was a surprise to people that joined it?! This is a fundamental problem, not a minor PR and how the process for merging that is.

As for emotions and business you are also quite wrong. Emotions will give you some pretty good hints about reality. Ignoring those and trying to be 'productive' is a sure way of being tricked all the way to the bank. There's a reason emotions exist and to lobotomise yourself won't make you a better business person.

Re:I'm sorry by fsloth on Thursday October 07, 2021 @03:03AM (#28783119)
"There's a reason emotions exist and to lobotomise yourself won't make you a better business person."

This. If the other party has identified you as a mark for their scheme, non-emotional professional haggling will result in the worst case in profit for the hostile party, and even at best will be a total waste of time for you and exhausting.

I.e. it's "Excuse me sir I notice an acidic liquid flowing from your direction. I would appreciate if you could either maneuver yourself or stop the said liquid flow as the volume of fluid gets in contact with my countenance." v.s. "Stop peeing on my face you **hole!"

You should not aggravate situations beyond reasonable bounds, should not become a sosiopathic professional victim and so on - but for a person of healthy psychological state, your emotions definetly are a valuable guide.

Re:I'm sorry by ChrisMarshallNY on Thursday October 07, 2021 @03:41AM (#28783339)
I find it fairly important to be “human,” in my interactions; professional, or otherwise.

That said, I’m also responsible for keeping the tenor of my communication constructive.

There will be mistakes (on my part, and on the part of others), as well as miscommunications, but they can be kept to a minimum, and addressed on a case-by-case basis.

I’m a big believer in sincere, appropriate, apologies. They have been enormously effective, in my own career.

I won’t apologize for breathing your oxygen, but I also won’t avoid taking responsibility and accountability for what’s mine.

When we weasel out of responsibility, we also surrender agency and power. If it’s our fault, it is also our bailiwick. An apology may seem like a weakness, but it can actually be the opposite.

Re:I'm sorry by BigRedDog1669 on Thursday October 07, 2021 @08:16AM (#28785241)
I agree the part about the low expectations of the foundation isn't constructive, but I feel like some open display of emotion is necessary after a person openly refuses to have an honest discussion. In the PR she repeatedly ignores the maintainer to push her changes. Then in the 'apology' she doesn't really apologize and isn't really straightforward about what really happened. In the PR the maintainers were pretty reasonable in their communication and it didn't really change the directors approach. I feel like when communicating with someone who repeatedly works in bad faith at some point all you can do is walk away. This emotional poster is doing that but before doing so making sure it is clear to others that this is not okay. I think that's better than saying "I repectfully disagree" because that makes it seem like it's just a slight misunderstanding rather than someone working in bad faith.
Re:I'm sorry by acoard on Thursday October 07, 2021 @11:51AM (#28787932)
Wanted to support your point on emotions with a quote from my favourite philosopher, David Hume:

"We speak not strictly and philosophically when we talk of the combat of passion and of reason. Reason is, and ought only to be the slave of the passions, and can never pretend to any other office than to serve and obey them."[0]

[0] https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Page%3ATreatise_of_Human_Natu...

Re:I'm sorry by RNCTX on Thursday October 07, 2021 @07:42AM (#28784983)
> There is a difference in expectations, so resolve it by making offers to MS for proposed changes.

Here's some more rude commentary for you: you are showing your hand, and it's a very poor / weak one.

You seemingly operate under the assumption that corporate-speak is some sort of invisibility cloak that gives the denizens of said corporations free reign to exploit whoever they like, and those exploited should politely ask for their soylent green in return.

Well, if I were giving my humanities-grad opinion to those developers in terms of dealing with people like you, I'd tell them to immediately recognize and refuse to deal with people like you, and more specifically to tell you that "if you want me to participate in your HR-speak, you can pay me a salary, until then the discourse is not on your terms. Maybe you should tell your boss to send someone else."

Re:I'm sorry by gatlin on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @11:45PM (#28781585)
I think more highly of people who are honest about their emotions and express them, instead of pretending that the motivating force behind almost all of our personal behavior isn't "relevant." Emotional ≠ unproductive.
Re:I'm sorry by judahmeek on Thursday October 07, 2021 @12:50AM (#28782105)
It's not a question of whether they express their emotion, but how they express it.

It's possible to express anger without burning bridges.

Re:I'm sorry by emodendroket on Thursday October 07, 2021 @03:34AM (#28783306)
I don't. The essence of civilization is suppressing animal instincts in service of a higher goal.
Re:I'm sorry by vcmak on Thursday October 07, 2021 @04:23AM (#28783566)
I've been around long enough to know that the higher goal is to line the pockets of those who establish and enforce the "polite" interaction rules. They give orders to the workers (in the broadest sense, workers can be productive professors) and skim off a percentage of the output.
Re:I'm sorry by emodendroket on Thursday October 07, 2021 @01:05PM (#28789179)
OK, sure, that's the order we live under, and it's not ideal. But better than running around foraging all day, and if you wish to change it it's better to save the rage for situations where it's called for.
Re:I'm sorry by psysharp on Thursday October 07, 2021 @04:17AM (#28783530)
No, it's abstractions of animal instincts, and that difference is huge.
Re:I'm sorry by emodendroket on Thursday October 07, 2021 @01:04PM (#28789163)
I don't think so. A lot of those instincts, such as killing, are pretty strongly proscribed.
Re:I'm sorry by jsiepkes on Thursday October 07, 2021 @08:28AM (#28785350)
> I am not versed in all the details here

You should probably read the conversation in the PR: https://github.com/reactiveui/splat/pull/778

> there is a dire need for professional communications training among these programmers.

Maybe, but probably not why you think.

Once you've read the PR's conversation you'll see this isn't about someone just merging a PR which wasn't approved. This about someone submitting a PR, a maintainer asking for discussion before merging it, ignoring the maintainer and just merge the PR, the maintainer asking why it wasn't discussed and then making a snide remark to the maintainer.

So I agree that the "Sorry for merging a PR" isn't going to cut it here. The merging of the PR was the least of the problem. It's a hollow corporate-style apology where someone is allowed to be called out for. It's like saying: "Sorry I hurt your toe" after you pushed someone of a cliff.

Re:I'm sorry by drfxyjhdyfrhgc on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @11:12PM (#28781413)
Did you look at the Contribution License Agreement? It appears that the issue at hand was in fact "spelled out". Repo owners aren't unreasonable to interpret this action as bad faith. I would agree that their message would be better communicated with a more amicable tone.
Re:I'm sorry by RNCTX on Thursday October 07, 2021 @08:22AM (#28785292)
I don't see why you think people should respond in an amicable tone to an employee of a corporation blatantly attempting to seize ownership of assets which currently do not belong to them.
Re:I'm sorry by cies on Thursday October 07, 2021 @03:21AM (#28783244)
It says: "owned or managed".

It does not say "owned AND managed".

MSFT has been in the business of using legal to make money. This is not the Apache Foundation. This is a non-profit arm of MSFT.

Re:I'm sorry by dclowd9901 on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @11:16PM (#28781432)
> I would agree that their message would be better communicated with a more amicable tone.

This was entirely GP's point.

Re:I'm sorry by drfxyjhdyfrhgc on Thursday October 07, 2021 @12:35AM (#28781977)
Yes, I agreed with his point and disagreed with his characterization of the situation.