News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by marcellus23 on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @12:50PM (#28775311)
I'm gonna drop this HN comment into the bin of "I have an extremely unusual need, but am totally obvlious about it, so this product is objectively bad for not catering to it"

Normal people do not have 20 credit cards. Even people I know who have several cards, often only have a couple they actually use on a daily basis. This is not a real problem.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by franga2000 on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:43PM (#28776681)
"Not catering to it" and "refusing to allow anyone to build a solution, even if they're willing to put in the resources" are very different. On Android, if Google's wallet thing has a limitation I don't like, I can easily use another NFC payment app.

Also, this isn't a missing feature but an arbitrary limitation, so again, Apple doesn't need to "cater to it", just raise an int in the source code from 6 to 20 or whatever.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by marcellus23 on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:11PM (#28777024)
> Also, this isn't a missing feature but an arbitrary limitation, so again, Apple doesn't need to "cater to it", just raise an int in the source code from 6 to 20 or whatever.

No, it's an element of the hardware design.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by cnst on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:16PM (#28777076)
I imagine it might be a hardware limitation? I couldn't find any details about where it comes from. They might be storing private keys in physical hardware; but then why does each card has to have its own private key, why not share all of it together?

It's blatantly absurd to have that much extra security for something that's fundamentally insecure anyways.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by ordx on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:52PM (#28776071)
"640k of memory should be enough for anybody"
Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by ceejayoz on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:02PM (#28776202)
I don't think "number of credit cards in your wallet" is subject to Moore's Law.
Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by cnst on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:11PM (#28777022)
Why not? When you physically had to carry all of them around, it was simply impractical to have 20 different cards.

If you can add all of them to a tiny device, and they all come from just a few banks that provide a unified interface to manage 10 cards at a time, and/or set them all up for auto-pay, then why wouldn't you want to make the most out of all the offers and bonuses?

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by Bayart on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:41PM (#28777400)
The entire system of credit card tie-ins is based on predatory debt practices. It's ingrained in US culture, but a lot of people on HN probably see it as a problem that shouldn't even have to be addressed in the first place. Facilitating the growth of the credit card ecosystem sounds like asking for trouble.
Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by cnst on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:53PM (#28777588)
So, it's Apple's job to tell me how many cards I am allowed to have? And it's okay?
Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by ceejayoz on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:56PM (#28777621)
You can have as many cards as you like.

There are hardware limits on how many you can put in an iPhone, just like there are limits to how many you can stuff into a wallet. Most wallets won't fit 20 cards, either.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by cnst on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @04:51PM (#28778265)
That's the whole purpose of the digital wallet.

I fail to understand how can anyone claim that an 8-card limit in a digital wallet on a 32GB+ device is reasonable, when you can literally store more cards than that even in an average physical wallet.

And, again, Android's NFC and Google Pay have no such limits.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by ceejayoz on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @05:53PM (#28778989)
Apple Pay cards are stored in a special piece of hardware. That the limit went from 8 to 12 in later devices implies it has fairly limited storage space.

Loyalty cards are unlimited. I have dozens of those.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by cnst on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @06:14PM (#28779158)
It's just another over-engineered gimmick from Apple. 12 (10 to third-party at intro?) may be slightly better for an average user than 8 (7 to third-party at intro?), but it still means that you have to delete and re-verify cards all the time, which defeats the whole purpose of the extra security for the data.

In Android Pay and now rebranded as Google Pay all contactless was and is unlimited. You never have to delete any card. You only have to re-verify the cards if you switch devices. That's literally how a digital wallet is meant to be, if you ask me.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by marcellus23 on Thursday October 07, 2021 @09:44AM (#28786152)
> but it still means that you have to delete and re-verify cards all the time

None of your comments seem to show any realization that this is not a problem almost anyone faces. I do not have to delete and re-verify cards all the time — you do.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by cnst on Thursday October 07, 2021 @04:26PM (#28791621)
It's only not a problem for Apple fans because they've learned to accept subpar products with gimmick features and misleading marketing. Plus, the anticonsumer features being sold by Apple as security requirements.

And I don't have to delete any cards either, because for my daily driver I use actual professional devices that run Android instead of the "Pro" gimmicks without Pro features that Apple makes. Apple Pay is useless, so they get what they deserve: $0.00 spend from me because I'm not using it just for one card when I can use all of my cards in Android.

It's mind boggling how people will go to such great lengths to defend such a silly 7-card limit. Or all these suggestions that imply that carrying 20 cards is impractical, when they literally all fit into any Google device of same size as an iPhone. This whole thread and the downvotes are really a travesty. You'd think people on HN would know better than ignore the obvious. But I guess Apple fans are toxic and stubborn regardless of the forum.

Casual reminder that you're not supposed to downvote comments you simply disagree with, but only comments that are incorrect or don't contribute to a healthy discussion. But the Apple fans don't seen to care about such etiquette, and the net score of anyone saying anything that's not positive of Apple appears to be in the negative even here on HN that's supposed to be free of such obvious bias and fanatism.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by cnst on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:10PM (#28775571)
You are aware that 20+ is actually the magical number of accounts that you're supposed to have in your credit file to have the best credit score?

This is not even about credit cards. Debit counts, too. Say you have two bank accounts, an HSA account, one premium card, one business credit card, one everyday card, one… Oops, out of slots already!

It sounds like you're really happy with Apple products, and will simply change your life around them, instead of demanding something better. 6+ cards is probably already the average for many people.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by thereddaikon on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:14PM (#28775621)
Says who? I have great with only one credit card. The key to good credit isn't some esoteric process to game the system. Its having a good and long credit history.
Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by airstrike on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:13PM (#28775614)
But do you really need to add all of those 20 cards to your digital wallet? Just carry the cards with you if you care so much about min-maxing the credit score game.
Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by lapetitejort on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:19PM (#28775699)
If you're actively using you cards (churning [0]) then yes. The point of tap to pay is to prevent carrying all the cards, thus lightening your daily carry.

[0]: https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/what-is-credit-c...

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by FireBeyond on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:06PM (#28776245)
So Apple and other manufacturers should optimize - and components should cost more - for the use case of _churning_, versus more everyday use?

People carrying all those cards to churn or min-max their rewards are already paying with the inconvenience of managing all those accounts.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by cnst on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:24PM (#28777165)
What inconvenience?

All the Chase credits cards show up under a single login; you can pretty much simply login once a month a pay all 9 or 11 of them at once. Or setup auto-pay. Or change the due-date to be the exact same date for all of them, so you only have to login and pay exactly once a month.

I have all 11 of Chase credit cards in Google Pay. If I switch phones, they're already available for verification on the new phone, you don't have to type the whole number anymore. I keep all but 3 to 5 credit cards in a sock drawer; but I can still use any one of them 20 at any time thanks to Google Pay.

When I need to use any one of my 20 cards to make a purchase, simply scroll through and select, based on picture and/or description. If vendor doesn't accept contactless, simply use one of the 5 physical cards I do carry.

The only inconvenience is that it doesn't work on iPhone, and that's one of the reasons I don't use iPhone as a primary phone, because so many things don't work there.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by cnst on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:28PM (#28775788)
Why would anyone want to carry 20 cards?

Why wouldn't you want to add all the cards you have to your wallet? Because your $699 iPhone doesn't support the feature?

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by dagmx on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:13PM (#28775610)
I don't think you're meant to have 20+ credit cards though? I'm struggling to think of anyone I know with 6+ active cards they use for payment.

I'd hazard most people have two or three cards tops.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by cnst on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:23PM (#28775737)
That's the whole point — I can add the ones I rarely use to Android Pay still.

For example, I have 11 Chase credit cards, and all of them are in Google Pay on Android. I almost never use the hotel ones; they simply provide other benefits for the annual fee, like the free hotel night for each annual fee renewal. But sometimes they do run bonus spend promotions, that's where once every year I can simply use those cards through Android/Google Pay on Android without having to worry about finding the physical card that I only use once a year.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by marcellus23 on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:17PM (#28776340)
I think what you're missing is that people, in general, don't do that kind of point chasing.
Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by cnst on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:35PM (#28777325)
But the average is already what the limit on iPhone is.

This means anyone even slightly above average is already out.

Imagine if you weren't allowed to wear tall jeans just because you're above average. That's what Apple does on the technology front.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by jandrewrogers on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @01:37PM (#28775898)
I have the best credit score possible and only 2 credit card accounts. Empirically, there is no relationship between having large numbers of credit cards and having the best credit score.
Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by avianlyric on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @02:29PM (#28776494)
You do realise that the common understanding of a “credit score” is complete bollocks right?

There's no single magic number thats your credit score, other than the one credit reference agencies provide, which no bank worth their salt uses, making that number meaningless.

Banks buy credit files from reference agencies, which contain hundreds of different data points for each individual. Then the bank use their own internal models to calculate credit risk, or identify customers they like. That model will be different at every bank, and for every class of product they sell.

If this wasn’t true, then there would be no differentiation between lenders, other than interest rate. Leaders use their own secret sauce models to help them identify and classify specific groups of individuals that meet their risk appetite. And they won’t just be optimising for repayment or profit, they’ll also be looking to ensure their loan book is highly diverse. Ensuring they’re not overexposed to big events (like, say, a global pandemic), which might disproportionately impact a subset of customers (such as people working in hospitality).

So the idea that 20 cards is some magic number for a good “credit score” is just crap. And grossly underestimates both the diversity and complexity of credit decisioning.

Re:Apple to face EU antitrust charge over NFC chip by cnst on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @03:39PM (#28777363)
Well, yeah, but it's 20 accounts over a period of 7 to 10 years, which represents 2 accounts per year.

That basically represents the idea customer for a bank.