1. https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/08/18/more-americ...
There's no simple answers here.
These are not remotely equivalent things, and I bristle every time I hear someone suggest it.
I hope you keep in mind that this puts you into a somewhat privileged position given that numerous people need to maintain accounts with Facebook for their job, their educational institutions, their landlord, or something else they cannot avoid. In quite a lot of countries on earth Facebook services (or their national analogues) are essentially equivalent to 'the internet'.
Maybe. If I quit Facebook, I can't messenger my loved ones anymore and my Oculus is now a lovely brick someone bought me for Christmas.
At a certain scale, the power dynamics start to look very similar. Governments still generally maintain a monopoly on violence, that's a big difference.
Generally. I think we can consider "Deported because your employer has no further use for you" a mostly-government-but-kind-of-weird-hand-in-glove-with-corporate-power blended category.
That's a HUGE difference. You are describing inconveniences but you still have a choice to give up your Oculus etc if you want.
You don't have the choice to "ignore" the government the same way.
Synchronously, without video, using an interrupting device. And after that, bifurcated across about a half-dozen messaging services.
Facebook is the first system I've seen that actually has 100% of my friends and family reachable using a common protocol supporting text, audio, and video messaging. If I were to leave, I'd lose touch with about half the people I correspond with regularly. It's a hard sell.
Corporations cannot solve every kind of problem, and some form of government is inevitable, necessary and desirable.
Taking away people's ability to discuss the issue on FB and Twitter effectively stifled hope for a timely independent investigation of the origins of the virus. This was done on the basis of really shitty science, from people with extreme conflict of interest.
The fact that Facebook deleted millions of lab leak related posts is obscene, and seeing people defend it is just so, so disheartening. What the fuck.
If you need reminding, sensible opinion was that masks didn't work. If you need reminding, sensible opinion was that a lab leak was impossible. If you need reminding, sensible opinion was that a vaccine wouldn't come for years. On and on.
Sense is inherently subjective. You are subject to the same flaws of logic and reasoning as anyone else. People believe that everyone else is an irrational fool, and their view is correct (and yes, this is the only thing that has changed recently...as people have become more exposed to people who aren't like them, they have retreated into their shell).
Btw, you should also consider whether your own view here has any "sense". Part of living in a society with other people is the right to disagree with others (isn't it odd that you use this right when considering the views of others but don't believe they have the same right? That their views just make no sense and can be ignored...irony).
It is unfortunate that fewer and fewer people today understand the principles on which their freedom is built.
The actual epistemic logic is more complex but, for the purposes of this discussion, the point is that you can define these things as things that reasonable people can disagree about because: there is no clear evidence, and people will weigh that evidence differently. It makes no sense to say that these things should be removed from the internet because they are "irrational"...Galileo was regarded as "irrational" too, the nature of new information is that it breaks down existing systems of thought.
To be clear too, believing in rational universalism is an example of irrational thinking. No "rationalist" philosopher ever believed in universalism. Theories like logical positivism were explicitly non-universal in regarding some things as unknowable. The only real application of universalism has, typically, been in German fascist political philosophy with ideas like the Volk...it is in an inherently political/cultural concept...again, the irony of this is a bit much but the precise reason why these theories exist is because they are people who think that we just need to shut discussion down.
Unless you're saying other people are so stupid we need to control their content so they can make the right choices?
At that moment, let's just keep everyone in a jail cell so they don't hurt themselves.
Who is the arbiter of truth? The government? You?
This is a flawed model. At some point, there is so much information that nobody can conceivably consume it all. A better mental model for this dynamic is that of pollution: can you fight pollution by making more "stuff", or at some point does it make sense to try and clean out the junk?
> Unless you're saying other people are so stupid we need to control their content so they can make the right choices?
Yes, to some degree. I think we need to be cautious here, and I acknowledge that there are a lot of examples of how this can go wrong.
But yes, yes indeed. If people were smarter, propaganda would not work. Alas propaganda works, and it works frighteningly well. There are also plenty of examples of this in both the modern world and in History.
> At that moment, let's just keep everyone in a jail cell so they don't hurt themselves.
Now you're being a little hysterical.
> Who is the arbiter of truth? The government? You?
This might shock you, but no, and we don't need an "arbiter". Getting to the "truth" is to a large extent a decentralized process that should involve many people and communities. I would suggest that a good place to start is with the scientific consensus. For everything else, it certainly becomes a lot more complicated.
Right, a "decentralized process". Which is entirely at odds with having authority figures censoring all unpopular opinions and dissent. You say we don't need an arbiter yet you argue in favor of creating one, intentionally or not.
It's a failure of the imagination to not see the difference.
Okay, so you think you know better and the government knows better. We're done here. You're the useful idiot (not an insult, a historical term) for the powers who want to censor.
The propaganda is this event, you are the person they convinced. You are advocating censorship on their behalf for them. You are going against you and your people's inalienable rights of freedom of speech.
I support your freedom to speak this nonsense, you should support other people's speech, but you prefer to be a tool.
Shame on you.
If you cannot recognize that difference, then may I politely suggest that you ponder the idea of "intellectual laziness".
Are they though? All 3 of these groups have been pushing for only their narrative to be heard. Any other voice is misinformation at best and disinformation at worst.
No, and in my experience this is not how things were presented. It _is_ misinformation to suggest that that is the likeliest explanation or to imply that we have a good reason to think so.
At a higher level, there's also the question of context, and the question of what the appropriate forum for such discussion is, and what is productive or non-productive geopolitically.
But it's not misinformation to float the idea and explore the possibility.
Tell that to the fact checkers and the social media companies that display the fact checks.
(a) the Hunter Biden laptop is likely a Russian ploy
(b) the Hunter Biden laptop was verified independently by journalists and colleagues
Which of the following represents misinformation:
(a) it is very curious that a global pandemic originated in the same location as a biosafety level 4 lab
(b) it was impossible that the virus originated from a lab and in fact it is xenophobic and racist to imply the virus originated in a lab
In both stories, Big Tech + Government + The Press all took swift and unified action towards the "approved" narrative.
However, the second point falls very very close to my area of expertise (biochem), so I'll humour you.
> (a) it is very curious that a global pandemic originated in the same location as a biosafety level 4 lab
The above statement actually contains no information: it is a bad faith / rhetorical statement. There are high security labs all around the world, particularly where there are people... so the odds that any event happens fairly close to one are fairly high.
> (b) it was impossible that the virus originated from a lab and in fact it is xenophobic and racist to imply the virus originated in a lab
This here conflates different issues in a disingenuous way. My expert opinion is that it is more likely to have emerged outside of a lab, but yes, it is also possible that the virus originated in a lab. The second part of your sentence is hysterically incorrect.
Not everything is about “controlling” you, not everything is a “fake narrative”, the world isn’t out to censor you, and no, not every form of censorship is bad. Yes censorship is a slippery slope, but so is intellectual laziness.