News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by _moof on Sunday October 03, 2021 @08:34PM (#28741822)
Facebook might be a factor in the division we see today in America but don't kid yourself: we were pretty f*in' divided during the Bush years—the Supreme Court had to decide that election, and the 9/11 unity lasted about a day and a half—and the GOP stopped at nothing to go after Clinton.

This has been going on since the 1980s. Facebook may be an accelerant, but it didn't start this fire—not by a long shot.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by dragonwriter on Sunday October 03, 2021 @08:42PM (#28741855)
> we were pretty f*in' divided during the Bush years, and the GOP stopped at nothing to go after Clinton.

Its quite weird, because the exact same narrative of unprecedented polarization has been used under Clinton (during the bipartisan neoliberal policy consensus), Bush, Obama, and Trump (with Biden, its at least usually acknowledged as a continuation of that under Trump, not new), with most major voices just seemingly forgetting the unbroken succession of preceding instances of the same narrative, pretending whatever is currently happening came recently, out of the blue without warning.

I think you can justify the claim that there was a real increase in political tribalism resulting from the resolution of the long post-WWII set of political realignments that was particularly evident from about the 1994 midterms and the Contract With America through today. (With some signs as far back as the 1980s as the lines of the new alignment started to become clear and the parties really accelerated movement toward their new polarity, where previously major ideological divides weren't aligned with the major partisan divide, so that ideological factions, to succeed, had to work across party lines.) But that's not as sexy a narrative as “suddenly we woke up in this election cycle with divisiveness that just came out of nowhere”.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by TedDoesntTalk on Sunday October 03, 2021 @09:18PM (#28742022)
> that's not as sexy a narrative as “suddenly we woke up in this election cycle with divisiveness that just came out of nowhere”

Because a lot of people want to believe that the time in which they live is more special and more different than the ones that came before.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by jacquesm on Sunday October 03, 2021 @11:31PM (#28742739)
Swift Boat Veterans for Truth was a turning point, things got really ugly after that.
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by Karrot_Kream on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:27PM (#28742368)
I think it's pretty obvious to anyone familiar with US history that the seeds of these "culture wars" started in the '60s with the hippie movement. While I wasn't old enough, I know several older liberals who talked about Reagan the way many younger liberals talk about Trump (and probably worse!), and older conservatives who talked about Carter similarly to how younger conservatives talk about Obama. Reagan was known as the Teflon President because none of the gaffes he made could ever stick to him and he remained quite popular throughout his rule.

The problem is, the internet, the web, and now social media has accelerated this divisiveness to a whole new point. As the GP says, it's an accelerant. Like a small cooking fire can turn nasty with the addition of gas, the acceleration of the culture wars thanks to the winner-take-all outcomes of today mean that everything is getting more heated _faster_.

EDIT: While I know it's faux pas, I am curious where/why the downvotes are coming (from) simply because this seems fairly non-controversial, and also because it started out with a few upvotes first.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by dragonwriter on Monday October 04, 2021 @04:33AM (#28744420)
> The US can barely afford to school its children, purchase its homes, or enact reasonable public health measures without bankrupting people.

I think its pretty obvious to anyone whose knowledge of US history extends earlier than the 1960s that it did not start there (and, also, that the existence of the culture war and partisan polarization, while not unrelated, are quite distinct.)

> The problem is, the internet, the web, and now social media has accelerated this divisiveness to a whole new point

No, its not, as looking at US history anytime outside of a partisan realignment will show. Partisan polarization is a feature of the divide between the major parties in the two-party system aligning with the major ideological divides in the country, which they tend to do in a normal stable political alignment, but not during a period of partisan realignment.

The relatively low level of partisan divisiveness (despite the often quite high level of ideological divisiveness, seen in overlapping things like the Civil Rights Movement, the Anti-War Movement, the youth counterculture/“hippie” movement, etc.) in the (roughly) WWII to 1990s period isn't due to some kind of weird temporary absence of technology needed for partisan division, it is due to the long and overlapping partisan realignments spurred by (mainly) the New Deal Coalition and parties settling out their positions on civil rights. These things meant that on the politically salient ideological issues, the divide between the parties was not aligned with the major cleavages; “liberal Republicans” were farther left on the key ideological issues of the day than “conservative Democrats”, and the opposing ideological factions were present in both parties.

That political realignments had largely settled out by the mid-1990s, with Clinton and the remaining “conservative” Democrats who hadn't defected to the Republicans solidly to the left of what was acceptable for Republicans, and vice versa, which enabled ideological division to translate more directly into partisan division.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by Karrot_Kream on Monday October 04, 2021 @02:03PM (#28750201)
> Partisan polarization is a feature of the divide between the major parties in the two-party system aligning with the major ideological divides in the country, which they tend to do in a normal stable political alignment, but not during a period of partisan realignment.

A feature? I'm not aware of any document written by the American founders that calls this a "feature" of the system. An emergent property of FPTP perhaps but not a feature. I'd call it a mistake to attribute more to FPTP than its intuitive appeal; the American founders invented FPTP off-the-cuff.

> The relatively low level of partisan divisiveness (despite the often quite high level of ideological divisiveness, seen in overlapping things like the Civil Rights Movement, the Anti-War Movement, the youth counterculture/“hippie” movement, etc.) in the (roughly) WWII to 1990s period isn't due to some kind of weird temporary absence of technology needed for partisan division, it is due to the long and overlapping partisan realignments spurred by (mainly) the New Deal Coalition and parties settling out their positions on civil rights. These things meant that on the politically salient ideological issues, the divide between the parties was not aligned with the major cleavages; “liberal Republicans” were farther left on the key ideological issues of the day than “conservative Democrats”, and the opposing ideological factions were present in both parties.

Right but what _caused_ this political realignment? I mean sure, you can say that the ideologies were extant and during the Civil Rights Movement (and that this divide itself traces itself back to the Reconstruction period and before that into the founding of the US itself) the New Deal Coalition began unraveling and formed the seeds of today's divide, but I submit a large part of what exacerbated that divide was technology. FDR was a popular president and helped cement the New Deal coalition largely because of his use of radio. Likewise Goldwater and early televangelists received a lot of their support from the rise of TV. Social media is just the continuation of this ongoing technological trend.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by LudvigVanHassen on Monday October 04, 2021 @02:30AM (#28743698)
No idea. This sholdn't be downvoted.
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by buitreVirtual on Sunday October 03, 2021 @08:45PM (#28741868)
Facebook is more than a factor. It is central to the problem as the largest social media corporation. Its amplification of psychopathic content to maximize the sickest forms of engagement for profit has people effectively living in a destructive cult. Remember when first came the tea party with their death panels talk, then birtherism, then Trump, QAnon and coup attempts?
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by _moof on Sunday October 03, 2021 @08:47PM (#28741878)
To put my position more simply: fixing (or ending) Facebook is necessary, but it won't be sufficient.
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by avalys on Sunday October 03, 2021 @08:53PM (#28741902)
The tea party and birtherism predate all of Facebook’s content ranking algorithms - so I would say you’ve proved the GP’s point.
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by eropple on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:31PM (#28742397)
They do not, however, predate opportunistic actors begging for shares of their content on the platform, and of the platform's users happily doing so. I know; my dad was one of them.

There's a difference of kind to mass broadcast on a platform one incidentally scrolls (and thus receives incidental exposure from) versus, say, chain emails. The latter have a lot lower impact and require way more activation energy to push onward than a one-click Share.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by buitreVirtual on Sunday October 03, 2021 @09:19PM (#28742029)
All that garbage was circulating and being amplified in early Facebook and for many years later, even today, generating engagement and profit regardless of algorithms. They just made it worse over time. Why do you also dismiss the rest of the list?
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by aviraldg on Sunday October 03, 2021 @08:31PM (#28741809)
Please stop assuming everyone shares your values and beliefs. Personally, I think that while there is some mismanagement at Facebook (that can be fixed) most of the issues brought up can probably be expected from anyone in this problem space at this scale. Facebook has allowed me to discover a lot of opportunities and connect with some long lost friends, so I would say the cost is worth it.
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by thomasjudge on Sunday October 03, 2021 @08:42PM (#28741858)
I do agree with this part of the statement from the company: "If any research had identified an exact solution to these complex challenges, the tech industry, governments, and society would have solved them a long time ago." The social costs of social media are complex, and solutions are not obvious. Unfortunately it's likely that if the companies can't meaningfully address these problems on their own, congress will attempt to, and the results of that the companies may not find to their liking.
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by bjt on Sunday October 03, 2021 @11:27PM (#28742700)
If you're trying to optimize for engagement AND avoid rewarding divisive content or misinformation, then yeah, that's complex and maybe impossible.

But as Haugen points out in her 60 Minutes interview, they don't _have_ to optimize for engagement above all else. They have tools to drive down divisiveness and disinformation. They just choose to leave them turned off most of the time.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by _3u10 on Monday October 04, 2021 @12:06AM (#28742943)
wouldn’t turning down divisiveness require picking a unified POV?

What if the unified POV is not the one she wants, would she still support it?

People seemed pretty upset that FB was used to unify a majority for Trump, I mean that’s when all the complaints really started.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by manquer on Monday October 04, 2021 @12:47AM (#28743201)
There is no need for any unified Point of View. From UX changes ( stop showing like/view counts) there are a ton of things a platform can do if they don't want to optimize for engagement, it will be financially damaging to do so, their revenue and stock price will drop no company will do it, but it not a hard problem technically.

Optimizing for engagement inevitably leads to toxic and unhealthy ecosystem sooner or later.

Issues with facebook and the right wing becoming more extreme long before Trump became mainstream ( perhaps it was always there). There was lot of concern noise during the early Tea Party movement in 2010s. There was a lot of toxic content when Obama became president.

Facebook started as tool to rate looks of female students in Harvard , I don't think there was ever a time when Facebook was not toxic.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by _3u10 on Monday October 04, 2021 @08:20PM (#28754082)
The ecosystem seems pretty healthy... are users leaving?

It seems that there is a subset of the populace whose opinions you disagree with and want FB to stop serving those users. If female users didn't want to be rated, why would they post photos and encourage people to 'like' them? It seems FB/IG has found a set of users who want to rate photos and a set of users who want to upload photos to be rated. How is this 'toxic'?

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by manquer on Monday October 04, 2021 @09:31PM (#28754517)
healthy in the context emotionally/ mentally for the user.

It is toxic when said users are teenagers and pre-teens, that is the whole point of all the Instagram / Facebook public discourse recently .

At that age as a society we have decided they cannot take certain decisions on their own, which is why Sex, Alcohol, Marriage , Content with Rating PG/R, admission to certain venues, etc are all regulated.

Why should Social Media be different ?

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by runarberg on Sunday October 03, 2021 @09:31PM (#28742084)
idk. If you found out that your product is harmful, I would expect you to stop producing it. This is the case for every other consumer products except maybe cigarettes and alcohol. For example, if they find out a car is not safe, they pull it of the market at the very least, sometimes they even issue a recall. Why do we not hold social media products to the same standards?
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by meowtimemania on Sunday October 03, 2021 @09:57PM (#28742226)
But cars aren’t safe, many people die from cars every year.
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by runarberg on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:04PM (#28742258)
Cars and Social Media is pretty hard to compare, but I’ll give it a shot:

The equivalent here is not that a company produces cars, and that cars are dangerous. The equivalence is more in the line of a specific car manufacturer makes a car which they know is more dangerous to a subset of their customers, but still continue to push it to them.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by nradov on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:40PM (#28742437)
Nissan knows that the Versa is more dangerous to their customers than, let's say, a Mercedes S500. Should Nissan then stop pushing the Versa in order to protect customers?
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by echelon on Sunday October 03, 2021 @11:31PM (#28742735)
I'm sure this argument is along the lines of what Facebook employees must tell each other so they can sleep at night.

But let's be clear, Nissan is making a car that is as safe as they can make it for consumers at a certain price point. Safer than riding a small motorbike. Safer than crossing a road. Or many other alternatives. They're enabling and empowering consumers that can't afford better cars to have some measure of mobility and safety.

Facebook, on the other hand, designs features to manipulate emotions and harm consumers. Make them feel bad, stay engaged, worry more, buy more. They ran the numbers. As long as the increase in suicide count is under a certain threshold, it's not a big deal for them.

There's a big fucking difference between the two.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by wintermutestwin on Sunday October 03, 2021 @09:36PM (#28742108)
>allowed me to discover a lot of opportunities and connect with some long lost friends, so I would say the cost is worth it.

This value that they are providing should not necessitate the wholesale pillaging of user data. My data is worth way more to me than a simple weblog service. These thieves are trading trinkets for land and the natives just don't realize how valuable their land actually is. (hint - it is worth way more than FB charges their advertisers)

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by otterley on Monday October 04, 2021 @02:18AM (#28743631)
Facebook was awesome in the first few years, when the feed was merely a chronological timeline of your friends’ status updates and photos. Then, they started putting crap in the News Feed that users didn’t explicitly subscribe to, down-ranked updates by actual friends, and made it far too easy for people to amplify garbage via the Share button.

The problem is not that Facebook exists; it’s that they wrested control from their users and assigned it to themselves and their advertisers.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by dylan604 on Sunday October 03, 2021 @08:41PM (#28741852)
>The next best step is to pledge to not hire ex-Facebookers.

So, if this is the rule, then there's no reason for FB employee to quit as they'll never find another job.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by sbarre on Sunday October 03, 2021 @08:46PM (#28741874)
Yeah that rule doesn't feel very well thought through. :-/
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by psyc on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:02PM (#28742240)
> pledge to not hire ex-Facebookers

I agree that Facebook is a plague, but this divisive, realpolitik, tough-guy power-play nastiness really nauseates me.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by _3u10 on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:04PM (#28742254)
It’s not even realpolitik. Talent is talent, if 90% of the market isn’t competing it provides financial edge for those willing to break the cartel.

The chances of it working are near zero because there’s always some asshole capitalist like myself to f it up.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by yumraj on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:59PM (#28742534)
> The next best step is to pledge to not hire ex-Facebookers.

I actually agree with that, and not because of any personal agenda against FB, but because I don’t want the corrupted, unethical mindset of FB to permeate my organization. I just cannot trust ex-FB employees to make ethical decisions.

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by echelon on Sunday October 03, 2021 @11:32PM (#28742750)
Exactly my thinking. FB staff make a choice to stay. That speaks volumes.
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by snuser on Sunday October 03, 2021 @08:22PM (#28741751)
I'm not sure why you're being downvoted, one of the only powers a lot of have is being able to pick who wins by working for them
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by donw on Sunday October 03, 2021 @08:27PM (#28741780)
Likely because reality is out of fashion at present.
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday October 03, 2021 @08:41PM (#28741850)
I don't think refusing to take their money will harm them much. Boycotting them is not likely to do something. Media scandals don't stick either

Maybe make a bot that goes to Facebook and click on all ads costing them money?

Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by haney on Sunday October 03, 2021 @08:53PM (#28741903)
That bot would likely make Facebook money and cost advertisers money
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday October 03, 2021 @09:04PM (#28741959)
Don't advertisers assess their return on investment, if there are more clicks coming from facebook but less purchases, surely that should set off some alarm bells and loose facebook customers?
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by _3u10 on Sunday October 03, 2021 @09:06PM (#28741964)
FB before it was regulated was pretty awesome. Some of us like the idea of democratized society.
Re:Facebook whistleblower says she wants to fix company, not... by ldehaan on Monday October 04, 2021 @12:22AM (#28743026)
Its telling about HN that this isn't the top comment, or that I've seen this post a million times on here.

I quit Facebook 6 years ago, and Twitter a few months ago, didn't have any other "social media" websites. Not missing a thing. Nobody cared. Still talk to all the same people. So there's that little nugget of knowledge if you're reading this and wondering if it was hard to quit.

"Social media" never: Got me a job Got me a raise Made me a friend Helped me find X Helped me Changed my mind Made me happy