Range, performance, comfort, features are all miles ahead in the Tesla. Price may be the only factor they're competitive, but the sales numbers don't lie. Nissan has sold 500k Leafs in the last 10 years. Tesla sold 440k Model 3s in 2020 alone.
Also, the EV aspect of Teslas is not the only thing that attracts buyers. I know many here on HN don't realize this, but people love the OTA updates that make your car better over time. Tesla takes a software company approach to cars. I don't have faith in any of the existing manufacturers pulling that off. It's a completely different business model that none of incumbents show any proficiency in.
That said, highlighting the Leaf, e-Golf and Bolt only make the legacy makers look worse in my opinion. I mean, how many times have you heard any of those vehicles be spoken about as "an object of desire". Most people view them as a "good thing" the same way as they view a colonoscopy as a good thing: a wise thing to get but certainly not something you're excited about having.
So far in my experience the only legacy automaker that is putting out truly compelling electric vehicles is Ford with the F-150 Lightning and the Mustang Mach-E.
Tesla's stealth advantage in the USA is their reliable charger network, if they open it up they might enable their competitors more than they think, especially after the car shortage ending makes buying from a dealer less painful.
I think it’s more likely that the market is flooded with mediocre EVs just as it’s currently flooded with mediocre gas vehicles. 2022 and 2023 have things like the f150, Honda Civic, Toyota Camry, and Ford Explorer coming out in EV variants.
I disagree. It was never an object of desire in the same way Tesla's are, but it was desired in the sense that many made the decision to buy a Prius primarily for social signalling reasons - it became almost cliché that a Prius meant "look how environmentally conscious I am!" This was famously parodied it what was my favorite South Park episode of all time, "Smug Alert".
The Prius is a pinnacle of practicality. Great gas mileage, reliable as hell, cheap to repair, and it’s a hatchback.
Traditional manufacturers didn't make great EVs because they couldn't make much money with them.
Another thing...Porsche already has a desirable EV. Benz EQS is not that bad either.
That's probably why the markets are betting the way they are.
And the Bolt is great. Just make sure not to park within 50 feet of anybody else [1].
[1] https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1133604_gm-asks-chevy-b...
I recently was looking at purchasing a used Leaf Plus (the new gen) but I was utterly shocked to discover threads on the Leaf subreddit discouraging people from taking long roadtrips on the Leaf because the battery overheats and will reduce the charging speeds. You cannot just go from charge > drive > charge and expect the same speeds. I was about to move from NJ to California and driving across the country :/
Now I am forced to look at the Volt as that is all I can afford. I don't even like this car but I want to get onto at least a semi zero emission platform.
The Teslas have tons of problems, (random build quality, poor parts availability, high insurance caused by the above). Someone who wants a reasonably priced EV that they can use under all circumstances as a regular car don't have many options right now.
Tesla nairled the excitement factor that nobody else has
When I tried to buy my Leaf, the sales guy tried to get me to buy another model, and a month after buying the car, I was getting spam for a Pathfinder (monster SUV).
I also see a lot of WV e-Golfs on the road, and Chevy Bolts. I don't know how reliable they are (Chevy have battery problems), but I think there definitely is competition.